The Pickled Herring Menu

96 U.S. 9 & Rt 520 Marlboro Plaza, Englishtown, NJ 07726
  • * SHISSEL OF SOUP

    • * Add Kreplach (Side Order - No Soup)

      $2.25
    • * Add Matzo Ball (Side Order - No Soup)

      $2.25
    • * Chicken Noodle

    • * Home Style Chicken Noodle with Vegetables

    • * Mushroom & Barley

    • * Split Pea

  • * START WITH A "NOSH"

    • * Chopped Liver Appetizer

      $9.25
    • * Frank on a Bun

      $4.75
    • * Homemade Knish

      $5.50
    • * One Slice Derma

      $4.95
    • * One Stuffed Beef Cabbage

      $8.95
    • * One Stuffed Chicken Cabbage

      $8.95
    • * Pickled Herring in Cream Sauce

      $8.25
    • * Square Potato Knish

      $4.25
  • * THE "BIG" SALAD

    • * Arizona Salad

      Romaine lettuce, black beans, corn, avocado & cheddar cheese. Served in a tortilla shell with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
      $18.95
    • * Buffalo Chicken Salad

      Buffalo chicken, lettuce, tomato, bacon & avocado. Served with bleu cheese dressing.
      $17.95
    • * Caesar Salad

      Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese & homemade croutons. Served with homemade caesar dressing.
      $16.95
    • * Chef Salad

      Choice of three meats, one cheese, iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion & hard boiled eggs.
      $19.95
    • * Seared Tuna Salad

      Seared sesame tuna, mixed greens, cucumbers, carrots, red peppers, scallions and frizzled onions.
      $19.95
    • * Steak Salad

      Sliced London broil, mixed greens, grilled vegetables and caramelized onions. Served with horseradish aioli dressing.
      $19.95
    • * Summer Salad

      Mixed greens, craisins, mandarin orange slices & candied walnuts served with raspberry vinaigrette dressing.
      $17.95
    • * Trifecta Salad Plate

      Any three scoops of salad served with lettuce, tomato, onion, potato salad & cole slaw.
      $16.95
    • Sloppy Joe Salad

      $19.95
    • The Big Salad No Protein

      $12.95
  • * FROM THE CARVING BOARD

    • * B.L.T Sandwich

      $10.95
    • * Chicken Salad Sandwich

      $11.95
    • * Chopped Liver Sandwich

      $14.95
    • * Deli Duo

      $22.95
    • * Egg Salad Sandwich

      $9.95
    • * Empire Turkey Sandwich

      $16.95
    • * Fresh Roasted Frame Turkey Sandwich

      $15.95
    • * Hebrew National Bologna Sandwich

      $14.95
    • * Hebrew National Hard Salami Sandwich

      $16.95
    • * Hebrew National Salami Sandwich

      $14.95
    • * Hot Brisket Sandwich

      $15.95
    • * Hot Corned Beef Sandwich

      $15.95
    • * Hot Pastrami Sandwich

      $15.95
    • * Knishwich

      Corned beef, pastrami or brisket served between a square knish.
      $18.95
    • * Roast Beef Sandwich

      $15.95
    • * Tongue Sandwich

      $16.95
    • * Tuna Salad Sandwich

      $11.40
    • * Turkey Breast Sandwich

      $15.95
    • * Veggie Tuna Salad Sandwich

      $11.95
    • * Whitefish Salad Sandwich

      $13.95
  • * OVERSTUFFED COMBO SANDWICHES

    • * Corned Beef & Pastrami Combo

      $18.95
    • * Create Your Own Combo

      $18.95
    • * Roast Beef & Turkey Combo

      $18.95
    • * Tongue & Turkey Combo

      $19.95
    • * Turkey, Pastrami, Swiss, Coleslaw & Russian

      $19.95
  • * TRIPLE DECKERS

    • * Corned Beef & Pastrami Triple

      $18.95
    • * Create Your Own Triple

      $18.95
    • * Roast Beef & Turkey Triple

      $18.95
    • * Turkey, Tongue & Pastrami Triple

      $20.95
  • * JUST JOES

    • * Healthy Joe

      Fresh roasted turkey, marinated bell peppers and portobello mushroom served on three layers of thin rye bread dressed with honey mustard.
      $18.95
    • * Sloppy Joe

      Corned beef, roast beef and turkey served on three layers of rye bread with cole slaw and russian dressing.
      $18.95
    • * Smokey Joe

      Nova salmon, sable, whitefish salad, cream cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion served on three layers of thin rye bread.
      $21.95
  • * HANDCRAFTED BURGERS

    • * Bacon Cheeseburger

      $17.50
    • * Brooklyn Burger

      Served with sautéed onions, sautéed mushrooms and cheddar cheese.
      $17.95
    • * California Burger

      Choice of beef or turkey burger, jack cheese, avocado and tomato.
      $17.95
    • * Cheeseburger

      $15.95
    • * Classic Burger

      $14.95
    • * Classic Turkey Burger

      $14.95
    • * Pastrami Burger

      Classic burger topped with pastrami.
      $18.50
  • * CLUB SANDWICHES

    • * Club Sandwich

      Your choice of turkey, roast beef or chicken salad served with bacon, lettuce and tomato.
      $15.95
  • * PERFECT PLATTER FOR TWO

    • * Perfect Platter for Two

      Sliced pastrami, corned beef, roast beef, turkey and tongue. Served on rye bread with french fries and your choice of cole slaw or health salad.
      $45.95
  • * SIGNATURE SANDWICHES

    • * Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

      Grilled or breaded chicken cutlet, tomato and buffalo sauce. Served with bleu cheese dressing on a tuscan roll.
      $14.95
    • * California Grilled Veggie Sandwich

      Portobello mushroom, sliced grilled vegetables and balsamic glaze served on a tuscan roll.
      $16.95
    • * French Dip

      Thinly sliced roast beef and provolone served with au jus on a warm club roll.
      $16.95
    • * New York Sliced Steak Sandwich

      Sliced London broil, frizzled onions, tomato, mixed greens and horseradish aioli served on a Tuscan roll.
      $16.95
    • * Southwest Chicken Sandwich

      Blackened chicken, avocado, jack cheese and honey mustard served on a multigrain roll.
      $15.95
    • * The Best Turkey Sandwich

      Fresh roasted turkey, homemade cranberry chutney and mixed greens served on raisin walnut bread.
      $16.95
    • * The Classic Reuben

      Hot corned beef or pastrami, swiss cheese, sauerkraut and Russian dressing on grilled rye bread. Served with French fries.
      $19.95
    • * Tuna Melt

      Tuna salad and american cheese served open face on rye bread.
      $14.95
    • Deli Wrap

      $18.95
    • Grilled Chicken Portobello Wrap

      $15.95
    • London Broil Wrap

      $17.95
  • * SMOKED TO PERFECTION

    • * Bagel All The Way

      Nova salmon, cream cheese, onion, cucumber and tomato. Pick one bagel choice and one cream cheese choice.
      $19.95
    • * Baked Salmon Platter

      Pick one bagel choice and one cream cheese choice.
      $25.95
    • * Fish Platter for Two

      Choice of any three: nova salmon, smoked whitefish, whitefish salad, baked salmon, sable or pickled herring in cream sauce. Served with two bagels, cream cheese, cole slaw, potato salad, lettuce tomato and onion.
      $45.95
    • * Nova Lox Platter

      Pick one bagel choice and one cream cheese choice.
      $25.95
    • * Sable Platter

      Pick one bagel choice and one cream cheese choice.
      $26.95
    • * Smoked Whitefish Platter

      Pick one bagel choice and one cream cheese choice.
      $20.95
  • * HOT OPEN SANDWICHES

    • * Hot Open Brisket

      $19.95
    • * Hot Open Fresh Roasted Turkey

      $19.95
    • * Hot Open Roast Beef

      $19.95
  • * SECRET FAMILY RECIPES

    • * 1/2 Roasted Chicken

      $20.95
    • * Beef Chopped Steak with Onions

      $20.95
    • * Beef Stuffed Cabbage Dinner

      $21.95
    • * Brisket Dinner with Gravy

      $24.95
    • * Chicken Cutlets

      $21.95
    • * Chicken Fingers Dinner (Adult)

      $21.95
    • * Chicken In-A-Pot (No Sides)

      $22.95
    • * Chicken Pot Pie Dinner

      $20.95
    • * Chicken Stuffed Cabbage Dinner

      $21.95
    • * Cornflake Crumb Baked Chicken

      $22.95
    • * Flanken In-A-Pot (No Sides)

      $25.95
    • * Fresh Roasted Turkey Dinner with Gravy

      $20.95
    • * Fried Chicken

      $22.95
    • * Honey Roast Chicken

      $22.95
    • * Romanian Tenderloin Steak with Mushrooms & Onions

      $32.95
    • * Salmon

      $22.95
    • * Sliced Beef London Broil with Mushrooms & Onions

      $25.95
    • * Sweet & Sour Meatballs

      $21.95
    • * Turkey Chopped Steak with Onions

      $20.95
    • * Turkey London Broil with Onions

      $22.95
    • * Two Specials (Knockwurst)

      $19.95
    • Meat Loaf

      $21.95
  • * CAN'T RESIST SIDES

    • * Baked Beans

      $4.95
    • * Baked Potato

      $4.95
    • * Choice of Salad

      $4.95
    • * Egg Roll

      $5.25
    • * Extra Half Sour Pickles

    • * Extra Sour Pickles

    • * Fries

      $7.95
    • * Homemade Fries

      $7.95
    • * Kasha Varnishkas

      $7.95
    • * Mac & Cheese

      $8.95
    • * Mashed Potatoes

      $6.95
    • * Onion Rings

      $7.95
    • * Potato Pancake

      $4.95
    • * Stuffed Derma (Kishka)

      $4.95
    • * Sweet Baked Potato

      $4.95
    • * Sweet Mashed Potato

      $6.95
    • * Sweet Noodle Kugel

      $8.95
    • * Sweet Potato Fries

      $7.95
    • * Toasted Barley & Mushroom

      $7.95
    • * Vegetable of the Day

      $7.95
  • * "EGG" CEPTIONAL OMELETTES

    • * Cheese Omelette

      $10.95
    • * Corned Beef Omelette

      $15.95
    • * Lox, Eggs & Onion Omelette

      $16.95
    • * Pastrami Omelette

      $15.95
    • * Salami & Egg Omelette

      $14.95
    • * Three Eggs Any Style

      $9.95
    • * Vegetable Omelette

      $13.95
  • * KIDS

    • * Chicken Fingers with Fries (Kids)

      $9.95
    • * Grilled Cheese with Fries (Kids)

      $7.95
    • * Hot Dog with Fries (Kids)

      $7.95
    • * Jr. Burger with Fries (Kids)

      $9.95
    • * Mac & Cheese (Kids)

      $7.95
  • * A LITTLE SOMETHING SWEET

    • * 7 Layer Cake Slice

      $5.95
    • * Assorted Rugelach

      $7.95
    • * Black & White Cookie

      $4.95
    • * Chinese Cookie

      $3.95
    • * Chocolate Chip Cookie

      $3.95
    • * Cigar Pastry

      $4.95
    • * Humentashen

      $4.95
    • * Linzer Tart

      $4.95
    • * Slice of Cake

      $5.95
    • * Sprinkle Cookie

      $3.95
  • * BEVERAGES

    • * Bottle of Water

      $1.50
    • * Can of Soda

      $2.50
    • * Dr Brown's Soda

      $3.25
    • * Juice

      $3.95
    • * Snapple

      $3.25
    • * Stewart's Soda

      $3.25

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Edible Arrangements
Edible Arrangements
3.0
(55 Reviews)
Dessert shop, Juice shop
House Of Biryanis (HOB)
House Of Biryanis (HOB)
4.6
(59 Reviews)
Indian, Biryani
Mixed Greens & Grill Manalapan
Mixed Greens & Grill Manalapan
3.9
(195 Reviews)
Salad shop, Juice shop, Sandwich shop
Latin Bites Restaurant & Food Trucks
Latin Bites Restaurant & Food Trucks
3.4
(257 Reviews)
Cuban, Latin American, Puerto Rican
Latin Bites Restaurant & Food Trucks
Latin Bites Restaurant & Food Trucks
3.4
(259 Reviews)
Cuban, Latin American, Puerto Rican
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard
4.4
(164 Reviews)
Ice cream shop, Dessert, Dessert shop
Mom's Golden Griddle
Mom's Golden Griddle
4.2
(506 Reviews)
Restaurant, Diner
Soda King
Soda King
3.3
(6 Reviews)
Restaurant
Barbara's Hand Made Cookie Pies
Barbara's Hand Made Cookie Pies
4.9
(29 Reviews)
Bakery

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms