The Pewter Spoon Cafe Menu

4.7

(250+ Reviews)

$Cafe, Restaurant

Retail Baked Goods Breakfast Sandwiches & Scrambles Greens & Panini Drinks

Retail
- Nabali Extra Virgin Olive Oil Bottle
  We think it's more important than ever to be conscious of our consumption and to practice spending with more intentionality. We decided years ago to carry select products from Canaan Palestine, a company based out of the West Bank in Palestine. Canaan works with small family farms and provides a fair trade relationship to those Palestinians whose livelihoods are in constant risk due to the ongoing occupation and land encroachment. By buying their products for your loved ones, not only do you get to share Palestinian food and culture, but you are help small family farms across Palestine in their goal of preserving Palestinian culture and nurturing the land beneath their feet.Product of Palestine.
  $36.00
- Maftoul (250g)
  We think it's more important than ever to be conscious of our consumption and to practice spending with more intentionality. We decided years ago to carry select products from Canaan Palestine, a company based out of the West Bank in Palestine. Canaan works with small family farms and provides a fair trade relationship to those Palestinians whose livelihoods are in constant risk due to the ongoing occupation and land encroachment. By buying their products for your loved ones, not only do you get to share Palestinian food and culture, but you help small family farms across Palestine in their goal of preserving Palestinian culture and nurturing the land beneath their feet.Product of Palestine.
  $12.00
- Bag of Coffee (12oz.)
  Brazil Coopfam
  $15.50
  Mexico Decaf de Agua
  $18.50
  Deep Disco
  $17.50
  Guatemala Guaya’b
  $16.50
  Leftist Blend
  $17.00
  Stargazer Blend
  $17.50
  Midwinter
  $16.50
  Peru Sol Y Cafe
  $17.50
  Mexico Triunfo Verde
  $19.00
  Kenya Kabnegtuny
  $20.00
  Mt.Pleasant
  $20.50
  Ethiopia YCFCU Halo Bariti
  $20.50
- Loose Tea (2oz.)
  English Breakfast Black Tea
  $15.00
  Rooibos Ocean of Wisdom
  $15.00
  Matcha Green Tea Powder
  $13.00
  Earl Grey Black Tea
  $16.00
  Velvet Cacao Pu-Erh
  $14.50
- Gimme Tote Bag
  A Gimme! Coffee tote bag celebrating the Ithaca water that is part of every cup of coffee we brew. (After it's filtered and softened and tested by our Education team, of course!) Screen printed in upstate New York on an undyed organic cotton tote bag, this tote is sturdy, spacious, and a symbol of where we brew. FeaturesTote is 100% Organic Certified cotton, GOTS certified, and made in a Fair Trade Certified factory. Screen Printed in Ithaca
  $13.00
- PS card
  $7.00
- Spoon Travel Mug
  $30.00
- 87 Albany St. Tee
  Pre-shrunk cotton, polyester, rayon tri-blend soft material.
  Indigo, Small
  $22.00
  Indigo, Medium
  $22.00
  Indigo, X-Large
  $22.00
  Green, Small
  $22.00
  blue, Large
  $22.00
  Green, X-Large
  $22.00
- EcoJarz Reusable Cold Cup
  Lids fit on any regular-mouth jar.
  JUST 16oz Jar
  $3.00
  JUST 24oz Jar
  $4.25
  JUST Lid
  $8.00
  JUST Straw
  $4.50
  Jar, Lid, & Straw
  $15.50
- Klean Kanteen 16oz Thermos
  The first and last thermos you'll ever need for camping, around town, worksites, office.FeaturesIntegrated double-wall construction 7oz cupTwist and pour cap with 360° pour-through designClimate Lock™ double-wall vacuum insulation keeps contents hot or cold for hoursTK Closure™ internal thread design which provides cutting edge thermal performance for both hot and cold beveragesElectropolished 18/8 food-grade stainless steel interior doesn't retain or impart flavors100% plastic freeChip-resistant Klean Coat™ finishLeakproof16ozTofu with dark brown Gimme! logos on both sides
  $30.00
- Fellow Carter Move Mug (12 oz.)
  Limited edition artist series mug18/8 food-grade stainless steelBPA free plastic lidInner ceramic coating12 oz
  $35.00
Baked Goods
- Ciabatta Loaf
  Baked by Patisserie in Skaneateles. Delivered Tuesdays, Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays.
  $5.00
- Ginger-Molasses Cookie
  $2.00
- Walnut Chocolate Chip Scone
  $3.00
- French Toast Bread Pudding
  $3.50
- Berry Jam Oat Bar
  $2.75
Breakfast Sandwiches & Scrambles
- SPECIAL: Chester Egg Sandwich
  Fried egg on toasted ciabatta with roasted potato, sriracha aioli, arugula, and cheddar cheese
  $9.50
- Classic Egg Sandwich
  Fried local egg, local butter, NY cheddar on toasted ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich option!
  $7.00
- Gus Egg Sandwich
  Fried egg with garlic aioli, roasted red onion, arugula, and Swiss cheese on toasted ciabatta.
  $9.00
- Southwestern Egg Sandwich
  Fried local egg, chipotle aioli, bacon/vegetarian sausage, NY cheddar on toasted ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich option!
  Bacon (2)
  $9.00
  Vegetarian Sausage (contains gluten) (1)
  $9.00
  NO MEAT
  $8.00
- Build Your Own EGG SANDWICH
  Ciabatta
  $5.75
  Wheat Bread
  $5.75
  Gluten-Free Bread
  $7.25
- Alpine Egg Scramble
  Three local eggs, sautéed mushrooms, arugula, NY Swiss in a wrap or bowl. Bowls served with slice of toasted ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Scramble option!
  $9.00
- Build Your Own Egg Scramble
  $3.50
- Bonnie Toast
  Toasted ciabatta with cream cheese, tomato, and arugula
  $6.00
- Clyde Toast
  Toasted ciabatta with hummus, cucumbers, and za’atar thyme spice blend
  $6.00
- NO EGG Toast
  To add an egg, please see Build Your Own Egg Sandwich item.
  Ciabatta
  $3.25
  Whole Wheat Bread
  $3.25
  Gluten-Free Bread
  $3.75
Greens & Panini
- SPECIAL: Hugo Greens
  Pears, red onions, toasted almonds, gorgonzola and cranberry-balsamic served as a wrap or salad.
  $12.50
- SPECIAL: Archie Panini
  Toasted ciabatta with Kalamata olive tapenade, roasted red peppers, arugula and havarti cheese
  $10.50
- Russell Greens
  Greens, gorgonzola, roasted sweet potato, quinoa, toasted almonds, craisins with balsamic dressing as a wrap or salad.
  $12.50
- Curried Chicken Salad Greens
  Spring mix, curried chicken salad with raisins, pecans, celery, homemade balsamic dressing as a wrap or salad. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
  $12.00
- Positano Greens
  Spring mix, homemade croutons, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, homemade hummus, Italian dressing as a wrap or salad. Vegan. Shaved parmesan optional. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
  $12.00
- Build Your Own Greens
  $7.00
- Caprese Panini
  Pesto aioli (contains dairy), tomato, fresh mozzarella, balsamic dressing on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
  $11.50
- Flora Panini
  Baked apples, Brie, garlic aioli, roasted red onions, and arugula on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
  $12.00
- Millersburg Grilled Cheese
  Local butter, hot pepper jam, NY cheddar cheese, and arugula on ciabatta bread. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
  $9.00
- Pesto Chicken Panini
  Chicken, pesto aioli (contains dairy), tomato, roasted red onion, arugula, NY provolone. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
  $13.00
- Chipotle Chicken Panini
  Chicken, bacon, chipotle aioli, NY cheddar on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
  $12.50
- Mushroom Panini
  Sautéed mushrooms, roasted red onions, garlic aioli, arugula, NY swiss on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
  $12.00
- Build Your Own PANINI
  Ciabatta
  $6.00
  Wheat Bread
  $4.00
  Gluten-Free Bread
  $7.50
Drinks
- SEASONAL: Maple-Pecan Latte
  Hot, 12oz.
  $5.50
  Hot, 16oz.
  $6.00
  Iced, 16oz.
  $6.00
  Iced, 20oz.
  $6.50
- Drip Coffee
  Your choice of our house blend, Deep Disco, or our featured brew of the week. All coffees roasted by the folks at Gimme! Coffee in Ithaca.
  8oz
  $2.75
  12oz
  $3.00
  16oz
  $3.25
- Cafe Au Lait
  Drip coffee with steamed milk.
  12oz
  $3.50
  16oz
  $3.75
- Cold Brew
  Cold-brewed coffee using Stargazer Blend from Gimme! Coffee.
  16oz
  $3.75
  20oz
  $4.25
- Espresso
  Double shot of Leftist Espresso Blend by Gimme! Coffee in Ithaca. Hints of dark chocolate, cherry, sweet toffee.
  $3.00
- Americano
  Double shot of espresso with hot water. 12oz. size only.
  Hot, 12oz
  $3.50
  Iced, 16oz
  $3.75
- Macchiato
  Double shot of espresso just slightly marked with steamed milk. *PLEASE NOTE: Our macchiatos are served in the traditional Italian style. Not to be confused with the large milky drink made by a big coffee franchise ;)
  $3.75
- Cortado
  Double shot of espresso with steamed milk. 4.5oz. size only.
  $3.75
- Cappuccino
  Double shot of espresso with steamed milk. 8oz. size only. For a larger drink with the same coffee to milk ratio, try a large latte with an extra shot of espresso.
  $4.00
- Latte
  Double shot of espresso with steamed milk.
  Hot, 12oz
  $4.50
  Hot, 16oz
  $5.00
  Iced, 16oz
  $5.00
  Iced, 20oz
  $5.50
- Mocha Latte
  Double shot of espresso with homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) and steamed milk.
  Hot, 12oz
  $5.00
  Hot, 16oz
  $5.50
  Iced, 16oz
  $5.50
  Iced, 20oz
  $6.00
- Hot Tea
  Hot loose-leaf teas from Samovar Tea Lounge in San Francisco
  English Breakfast - Black
  $3.00
  Earl Grey - Black
  $3.00
  California Persian - Black
  $3.00
  Jasmine - Green
  $3.00
  Spearmint Sage - Herbal
  $3.00
  Rooibos Ocean of Wisdom - Herbal
  $3.00
  Chamomile - Herbal
  $3.00
  Four Seasons - Oolong
  $3.00
- Black Iced Tea
  Unsweetened English Breakfast
  16oz
  $2.50
  20oz
  $3.00
- Chai Latte
  Homemade sweetened chai concentrate made with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, star anise, cardamom, and caffeinated black tea, with steamed milk.
  Hot, 12oz
  $4.50
  Hot, 16oz
  $5.00
  Iced, 16oz
  $5.00
  Iced, 20oz
  $5.50
- Matcha Latte
  Lightly sweetened matcha green tea powder with steamed milk.
  Hot, 12oz
  $5.00
  Hot, 16oz
  $5.50
  Iced, 16oz
  $5.50
  Iced, 20oz
  $6.00
- London Fog
  Hot Earl Grey tea with vanilla syrup and steamed milk. Topped lightly with cinnamon.
  12oz
  $4.50
  16oz
  $5.00
- Lemon-Lime Palestina Soda
  A refreshing lemon-lime soda made with cane sugar. Drink Palestina brand donates portion to proceed to charities. 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸 free Palestine
  $2.50
- Milk (8oz)
  $2.00
- Chocolate Milk (8oz)
  Homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) with milk.
  $2.25
- Water Bottle
  $2.25
- Steamer
  Steamed milk with your choice of organic flavor shot. Lightly topped with cinnamon!
  8oz
  $2.50
  12oz
  $3.00
  16oz
  $3.50
- Hot Chocolate
  Homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) with steamed milk.
  8oz
  $2.75
  12oz
  $3.25
  16oz
  $3.75
- Rosé
  $9.00
- Sauvignon Blanc
  Tropical citrus and grapefruit notes with a balanced minerality. 12.5%
  $9.00
- Prosecco
  10.5% ABV. Italy
  $9.00
- Malbec
  Plum, vanilla, blackberry. 13.5%. Argentina
  $9.00
- Dry Rosé Cider
  $8.00
- Sublimated Dreams NEDIPA
  $8.00
- Wolffer Dry White Cider
  Floral, Fruity, Crisp. Long Island.
  $8.00
- True Devotion Hazy Pale Ale
  Limited release from local Grow Brewery with notes of lime and berry undertones of floral bouquet.
  $7.00
- Sloop Sauer Peach
  Berliner weisse style ale with peaches. Sweet, sour and everything in between.
  $4.00
- Rothaus-Brau Amber Lager
  A full-bodied amber lager with mild notes oh hop and rich malty finish. German.
  $4.00
- Haus Effect Pale Lager
  $6.00
- 64oz. Beverage Jug
  Cold Brew
  $16.00
  Half-Caf Cold Brew
  $16.00
  Decaf Cold Brew
  $16.00
  English Breakfast Tea
  $13.00
  California Persian Black Tea
  $16.00
  Jasmine Green Tea
  $16.00
  Jasmine Green Tea Lemonade
  $18.00
- Pot of Coffee
  At least one hour notice required. Coffee pots must be returned by next day.
  Regular
  $12.00
  Decaf
  $12.00