The Penny Pub Menu

79 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  • Appetizers

    • Chicken Tenders

      traditional style
      $10.50
    • Irish Nachos

      waffle fries, mozzarella, bacon, sour cream, and chives
      $13.50
    • Late Night Fries

      waffle fries smothered in mozzarella cheese and Guinness gravy
      $10.50
    • Waffle Fries

      a large portion of fries with choice of dipping sauces
      $8.00
    • Steak Fries

      large portion of steak fries with your choice of dipping sauces
      $7.00
    • Tots

      a large portion of tots with your choice of dipping sauces
      $8.00
    • Buffalo Chicken Tots

      bed of tots topped with mozzarella cheese and buffalo chicken with a ranch and buffalo drizzle
      $13.50
    • Quesadilla

      with salsa and sour cream
      $9.95
    • Buffalo Or Irish Whiskey BBQ Chicken Quesadilla

      breaded chicken dipped in your choice of buffalo or Irish whiskey BBQ sauce with ranch and sour cream
      $12.95
    • Penny Pretzels

      eight pretzel sticks lightly salted with your choice of two dipping sauces
      $10.50
    • TPP Wings

      Choice of Buffalo (Mild, Medium or Hot), Irish Whiskey BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Lemon Pepper, Old Bay, Teriyaki
      $12.00
    • Hotzarella Sticks

      mozzarella sticks tossed in buffalo sauce with ranch for dipping
      $10.50
    • Mozzarella Sticks

      served with marinara sauce
      $10.50
    • Fried Pickles

      fried pickle chips with a horseradish sauce for dipping
      $10.50
    • Chicken Caesar Salad

      grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, rye croutons, and parmesan cheese
      $13.95
    • House Salad

      romaine lettuce, bacon, tomatoes, onions, monterey jack cheese, and croutons
      $10.50
    • Boneless Wings

      choice of wing sauces
      $12.00
    • Homemade Fried Mac & Cheese

      with chipotle ranch for dipping
      $11.50
    • Jalapeno Poppers

      breaded and filled with cream cheese, cheddar, with a side of sour cream
      $10.95
  • Entrees

    • Dublin Dip

      marinated steak, sautéed onions and Irish cheddar on toasted garlic bread with Guinness gravy sauce for dipping, served with fries
      $16.95
    • Penny Reuben

      corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Russian dressing on grilled rye bread, served with fries.
      $14.95
    • The B.E.C

      bacon, egg, and cheese on a brioche bun, served with a side of tots
      $12.94
    • Chipotle Chicken Sandwich

      breaded chicken cutlet, bacon, American cheese, chipotle slaw, and chipotle mayo on Texas toast, served with a side of steak fries
      $14.95
    • The Penny Burger

      half pound certified angus beef burger on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, and red onion, served with fries
      $12.95
    • Grilled Chicken BLT

      with truffle mayonnaise on toasted French bread, served with fries
      $13.95
    • Irish Grilled Cheese

      Irish cheddar and bacon on Texas toast with a side of Guinness gravy
      $11.95
    • Fish & Chips

      beer battered cod and waffle fries with malt vinegar and tartar sauce, served with fries
      $14.95

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Oak Neck Pizzeria & Catering
Oak Neck Pizzeria & Catering
4.0
(130 Reviews)
Pizza
Primi Italian Steakhouse
Primi Italian Steakhouse
4.4
(454 Reviews)
Steak house
Sugar Island Bake Shop
Sugar Island Bake Shop
5.0
(8 Reviews)
Bakery
Summerwind Gourmet Delicatessen & Catering
Summerwind Gourmet Delicatessen & Catering
4.3
(89 Reviews)
Deli, Restaurant
Stuff-A-Bagel
Stuff-A-Bagel
3.5
(247 Reviews)
Bagel shop
Bella Cucina
Bella Cucina
4.5
(153 Reviews)
Pizza, Restaurant
Besito Mexican Restaurant - West Islip NY
Besito Mexican Restaurant - West Islip NY
4.5
(1,085 Reviews)
Mexican, Restaurant, Taco
Atlantis Diner
Atlantis Diner
4.2
(1,217 Reviews)
Diner, Restaurant
SoBol Babylon
SoBol Babylon
4.2
(137 Reviews)
Cafe
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices
4.6
(77 Reviews)
Ice cream shop

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms