Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

The Original Goodie Shop Menu

$Bakery
2116 Tremont Ctr, Columbus, OH 43221
Order Online

  • Breads

    • Apple Cinnamon Bread

      $6.95

    • Buttercrust White Bread

      $4.95

  • Sweet Rolls & Coffee Cakes

    • Signature Cinnamon Sticks (1 Dz)

      Our signature item! Cinnamon Sticks are our best selling product. You won't find them anywhere else. We layer our sweet roll dough with korintje cinnamon, and coat them in a buttery brown sugar glaze. Every bite is like the center of a cinnamon roll. These freeze well, so we recommend ordering more than just 1 dozen.
      $10.25

    • Iced Cinnamon Rolls (6 Pan)

      Cinnamon rolls come 6 to a pan with icing on top.
      $6.95

    • All Day Cake

      You will eat this delicious cake all day - until it's gone. All Day Cake is a cream cake in bundt form, baked with a buttery brown sugar glaze and pecans, then coated again in our donut glaze.
      $7.95

    • Fruit Coffee Cake

      Our sweet roll dough with fruit filling and streusel topping. Raspberry, Cherry, Blueberry or Apricot - Based on Availability. Please note your preference and we will try to send you that flavor!
      $9.25

    • Paradise Coffee Cake

      Sweet roll dough baked with sweet cream between layers with a Streusel topping. 8"x8"
      $9.25

  • Scratch-Made Cakes & Cupcakes

    • Assorted Gourmet Cupcakes (1/2 Dz)

      Half dozen gourmet flavored cupcakes. Assortment varies based on availability at the moment.
      $21.00

    • Decorated Cake 7" 2-Layer Round

      Decorated for celebration. Serves 6-10.
      $31.95

    • Sprinkled Cupcakes (1/2 Dz)

      1/2 dozen.
      $16.50

  • Packages

    • Help Us Through This Meeting That Should Have Been An Email (Treats For 12)

      1 surprise hand-drawn inspirational message. 1 dz signature cinnamon sticks, 2 cut brownies, 2 smile face decorated butter cutout cookies, 1 dz assorted tea size cookies. Serves 12.
      $29.95

    • Birthday Box

      Includes a cupcake with candle, 2 cookies to decorate with icing and sprinkles, a smile face cookie, ring cookie, 3 more decorated cookies, 2 buckeyes, and a hand-drawn birthday message.
      $22.95

    • Breakup Box (For 1)

      1 surprise hand-drawn inspirational message, 2 iced heart butter cookies, broken, 2 brownies, 2 icing shots, 2 buckeyes, 2 chicken pot pies (you’ll need comfort food), 1 dog or cat (decorated cutout cookie) for company.
      $23.95

    • Help Me Through This Savage School Week

      1 surprise hand-drawn inspirational message, 2 smile face decorated butter cutout cookie, 2 unicorn decorated butter cutout cookies, 2 brownies, 2 buckeyes, 2 icing shots, 1/2 dz signature cinnamon sticks, 1 monster java beverages.
      $27.95

    • Thank Goodness Karen’s Leaving! (Office Treats For 12)

      1 dz iced butter cookies with goodbye messages, 1 dz signature cinnamon sticks, 1 heart-felt, handwritten note for “karen” from “your co-workers”. Serves for 12.
      $43.25

    • Tea Party (For 4)

      4 assorted crimson cup tea sachets, 4 Russian tea cakes, 4 signature cinnamon sticks, 1 dz assorted tea cookies.
      $28.95

  • Beverages

    • Chilled Soda

      One.
      $3.00

    • Chilled Tea

      One.
      $2.00

    • Chilled Monster Java

      One.
      $3.50

    • Chilled Bottled Water

      One.
      $1.00

    • Coffee: Joe-In-The-Box

      Crimson Cup Coffee brewed fresh into a "Joe-in-the-Box" complete with fixins.
      $19.00

  • Donuts & Goodies

    • Buckeyes (8 Pcs)

      8 hand made buckeyes packaged in a red gift box.
      $9.00

    • Cream Horn

      Flaky pastry dough, handmade at our shop, filled with cream filling and sprinkled with powdered sugar.
      $3.75

    • Chocolate Iced Brownie

      $2.75

    • Muffins Assorted 1/2 Dz

      An assorted 1/2 dozen of muffins we have available today.
      $15.00

    • Cherry Danish

      We make our own Danish dough and fill the center with cherry filling, brush it with honey glaze and drizzle.
      $3.50

    • Cheese Danish

      We make our own Danish dough and fill the center with cream cheese filling, brush it with honey glaze and drizzle.
      $3.50

  • Extras

    • Scratch-Made Doggo Biscuits (1/2 Dz)

      Human grade ingredients.
      $5.00

    • 1 Tub Of Icing (1 Pint)

      $5.75

    • Chicken Pot Pies (4)

      Package of 4 Pot Pies. These come frozen—keep them frozen until ready to eat. Put in 400 degree oven for 30 minutes!
      $15.75

  • Cookies

    • Decorated Cookies (1/2 Dz)

      A half dozen of our iced butter cutout cookies decorated for whatever's in season. Assortment varies on availability at the moment.
      $16.00

    • Smile Face Cookies (1/2 Dz)

      Half dozen of our butter cutout cookies, iced and decorated with a smile.
      $12.00

    • Thumbprint Cookies (1/2 Dz)

      Shortbread-like tea cookies with pecans in the dough. Topped with a dollop of colorful icing.
      $5.25

    • Animal Face Cookies (1/2 Dz)

      An assorted half dozen of our iced butter cutout cookies decorated like animals.
      $16.50

    • Cookie Kit

      Comes with 6 butter cookies, 3 icing shots, 3 sprinkle shots, and 6 children's themed rings.
      $15.00

    • Soft Chocolate Cookie, Iced

      Chocolate cookie with either vanilla or chocolate icing.
      $2.75

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms