The Old Mill Pottery House Café Menu

3341 Old Mill St, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863
  • LUNCH FEATURES AND COMBINATIONS

    • LUNCH SHRIMP & GRITS

      Seasoned shrimp sautéed with celery and bell peppers. Served on Old Mill’s creamy cheddar cheese grits and topped with crumbled bacon, green onions and parmesan cheese
      $13.99
    • LUNCH FRIED CATFISH

      Delta catfish filets hand tossed in our own Old Mill’s popcorn breading and fried to a golden brown, served with fresh cucumber dill sauce & steak fries
      $13.99
    • LUNCH GRILLED SALMON

      Grilled salmon served over a bed of rice with fresh cucumber dill sauce & steamed broccoli
      $15.99
    • LUNCH CHICKEN BREAST

      Grilled, natural, cage free chicken breast served over a bed of rice with steamed broccoli. Basted in Old Mill’s BBQ or teriyaki sauce available upon request
      $13.99
    • POTTERY HOUSE CAFÉ BROWN

      Hot sliced turkey on toasted sourdough bread topped with sliced tomatoes, creamy bacon & cheddar cheese sauce, applewood smoked sliced bacon and parmesan cheese. Served with mashed potatoes
      $13.99
    • LUNCH PRALINE PORK CHOP

      A grilled bone-in pork chop topped with warm Old Forge’s French toast moonshine sauce and chopped pecans. Served with mashed potatoes
      $13.99
    • SOUP & HALF CHICKEN SALAD SANDWICH

      Bowl of soup with a half of a chicken salad sandwich
      $10.99
    • GRILLED TRIPLE CHEESE SANDWICH & SOUP

      A grilled cheese sandwich made with American, cheddar & provolone cheese on sourdough bread
      $11.49
    • SOUP & 1/2 OLD MILL’S TRIPLE DECKER CLUB SANDWICH

      We are sorry but there are no substitutions on the 1/2 Club Sandwich
      $11.99
    • SOUP & PIMENTO CHEESE SANDWICH

      Bowl of soup with fresh pimiento cheese served on our bakery fresh toasted olive bread
      $12.49
  • STARTERS

    • FRIED GREEN TOMATOES

      Made with our Old Mill’s fried green tomato breading & served with our original Old Mill’s avocado ranch dressing
      $10.49
    • LOADED POTATO CHIPS

      House fried crispy potato chips topped with melted cheddar jack cheese, chopped bacon, scallions and sour cream. Served with our avocado ranch dressing for dipping
      $11.99
    • FRIED PICKLES

      Spicy dill pickle chips lightly breaded in our green tomato breading, served with our tangy “Come Back” dipping sauce
      $10.99
    • CHICKEN LIVERS

      Lightly breaded, deep fried and topped with caramelized onions. Served with our tangy “Come Back” dipping sauce
      $9.49
    • BLACK BEAN SPRING ROLLS

      Black beans, cheese and seasoning wrapped in an egg roll and deep fried. Served with our original Old Mill’s chipotle ranch dressing
      $11.49
    • BACON & CHEDDAR DIP

      A creamy blend of cheeses including Sweetwater Valley Farm’s sharp cheddar cheese mixed with applewood smoked bacon and served with fresh fried pork rinds
      $11.99
    • SPINACH ARTICHOKE DIP

      A creamy blend of spinach and artichoke hearts served with stone ground corn tortilla chips
      $10.99
    • GRILLED SALMON CAKES

      Fresh salmon mixed with cracker crumbs and seasonings. Served with our tangy “Come Back” sauce and cucumber dill sauce
      $10.99
    • PIMIENTO CHEESE GRIT CAKE

      Our stone ground yellow grits mixed with our house made pimiento cheese. Grilled and topped with bourbon glazed pork belly & chowchow
      $10.99
  • THE MILLERS SELECTION

    • SHRIMP & GRITS

      Seasoned shrimp sautéed with celery, onion and bell peppers. Served on Old Mill’s creamy cheddar cheese grits and topped with bacon, green onions and parmesan cheese
      $18.99
    • CHICKEN GUMBO & GRITS

      Chicken breast cooked with tomatoes, okra and creole seasoning served on Old Mill’s creamy cheddar cheese grits. Served with an Old Mill’s jalapeno hoe cake
      $13.99
    • FRIED CATFISH FILLETS

      Delta catfish hand tossed in our own Old Mill’s popcorn breading and fried to a golden brown. Served with a fresh cucumber dill sauce, steak fries and coleslaw
      $17.49
    • BREADED CHICKEN TENDERS

      Hand breaded with the Old Mill’s chicken breading, served with honey mustard dressing, coleslaw & steak fries
      $15.99
    • FRIED CHICKEN LIVERS

      Hand breaded with the Old Mill’s chicken breading & topped with grilled onions. Served with our tangy “Come Back” sauce, coleslaw & mashed potatoes
      $13.99
  • CAFE SPECIALS

    • OLD MILL’S CHOPPED STEAK

      10 oz. grilled black angus ground beef topped with sautéed mushrooms & onions. Served with mashed potatoes and cinnamon apples
      $16.99
    • OPEN FACED ROAST BEEF

      Tender, thinly sliced hot roast beef on sourdough bread, topped with brown gravy. Served with mashed potatoes and cinnamon apples
      $13.99
    • DISTILLER’S FETTUCCINE & MEATBALLS

      Meatballs made with Dudash Farm’s ground sausage. Marinated in tomato moonshine sauce and served over fettuccine noodles. Topped with parmesan cheese
      $15.99
    • BEEF SHORT RIBS

      Tender, slow cooked, marinated beef short ribs. Served over Old Mill’s cheddar cheese grits and topped with seasoned carrots
      $15.99
    • GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST

      Two grilled, natural cage free chicken breasts served over a bed of rice. Served with steamed broccoli
      $17.99
    • OLE FORGE’S PECAN FRIED CHICKEN

      Two chicken breasts lightly breaded in a pecan breading and fried. Topped with Old Forge’s French toast moonshine sauce and chopped pecans. Served with a baked sweet potato
      $19.99
    • BUTTERMILK CHICKEN MELT

      Two fried chicken breasts topped with sautéed mushrooms and melted Sweetwater Valley Farm’s buttermilk cheese. Served with steamed broccoli
      $19.99
    • CAFE CHICKEN FLORENTINE

      Two grilled chicken breasts topped with sautéed spinach, red onions, grape tomatoes, our creamy spinach artichoke cheese sauce and parmesan
      $20.99
  • HEARTY SOUPS

    • TOMATO BASIL SOUP

      $6.49
    • HOMEMADE CHILI

      $6.49
    • FRENCH ONION SOUP

      $6.49
    • SOUP OF THE DAY

      $6.49
    • LOADED BAKED POTATO SOUP

      $6.49
  • GARDEN FRESH SALADS

    • CHICKEN SALAD & FRUIT

      Our famous chicken salad served with fresh fruit and a slice of cinnamon raisin pecan bread
      $13.99
    • CHICKEN SALAD & CAFE WEDGE

      Our famous chicken salad served with a wedge of iceberg lettuce topped with raspberry walnut vinaigrette, dried cranberries, sliced apples, walnuts and blue cheese crumbles. Served with a slice of cinnamon raisin pecan bread
      $14.99
    • BAKER’S GRILLED CHICKEN SALAD

      A crisp iceberg blend topped with cheddar jack cheese, tomatoes, bacon bits, mushrooms, broccoli, red onions, and hard boiled egg. Served with fresh baked bread
      $16.49
    • CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD

      Fresh romaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese and topped with Pottery House croutons and grilled chicken breast. Served with fresh baked bread
      $16.49
    • HOUSE SALAD

      A crisp iceberg blend topped with carrots, red cabbage, tomatoes, parmesan cheese, red onion and house croutons
      $6.99
    • HOUSE CAESAR SALAD

      Fresh romaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese and topped with house croutons
      $6.99
    • BABY WEDGE

      Wedge of iceberg lettuce topped with bacon bits, tomatoes, red onion and blue cheese dressing
      $8.99
    • SOUTHWEST STEAK SALAD

      A crisp iceberg blend topped with black bean & corn salsa, red onion, tomatoes, avocado, feta cheese, fried tortilla strips and grilled cajun seasoned sirloin steak. Served with chipotle ranch dressing
      $17.99
    • AUTUMN HARVEST SALAD

      A blend of leafy greens, cabbage and carrots topped with dried cranberries, feta cheese, walnuts, maple roasted sweet potatoes and chopped bacon. Served with a sorghum bourbon vinaigrette dressing and cinnamon raisin pecan bread
      $13.99
    • STRAWBERRY SPINACH SALAD

      Fresh baby spinach topped with strawberries, mandarin oranges, toasted almonds & blue cheese crumbles. Served with raspberry walnut vinaigrette and cinnamon raisin pecan bread
      $14.99
  • POTTERY HOUSE SIGNATURE SANDWICHES

    • FRIED GREEN TOMATO BLT

      Fried green tomatoes breaded with our Old Mill’s fried green tomato breading, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce & avocado bacon spread. Served on toasted sourdough bread with steak fries
      $12.99
    • OUR ORIGINAL CHICKEN REUBEN

      Shaved rotisserie chicken breast, creamy coleslaw, 1000 island dressing and melted swiss cheese on grilled onion rye bread served with home made potato chips
      $11.99
    • CAFÉ GARDEN MELT

      Spinach, mushrooms, red peppers, cream cheese & mayo, topped with melted gruyere, swiss & cheddar cheeses on grilled onion rye bread with tomatoes & red onion. Served with steak fries
      $11.99
    • CHICKEN QUESADILLA WRAP

      Diced southwest chicken breast, roasted red peppers, caramelized onions & cheddar jack cheese grilled in an herb tortilla. Served with salsa, chipotle ranch and steak fries
      $12.99
    • CLASSIC CHICKEN CLUB

      Grilled chicken breast topped with cheddar cheese, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomatoes & red onion. Served on grilled kaiser roll with steak fries
      $14.99
    • RIBEYE STEAK SANDWICH

      Grilled Black Angus ribeye served on a hoagie with lettuce, tomato & red onions. Served with steak fries
      $21.99
  • BLACK ANGUS BURGERS

    • SMOKEHOUSE BURGER

      Basted in BBQ sauce, topped with sautéed onions, applewood smoked bacon & cheddar cheese. Served on a grilled corn meal dusted kaiser roll with lettuce & tomato
      $15.49
    • POTTERY MELT BURGER

      Topped with sautéed onions and melted Swiss cheese. Served on our bakery fresh, grilled onion rye bread
      $14.49
    • THE SOUTHERN

      Topped with a bourbon glaze, pimiento cheese, sautéed onions and applewood smoked bacon. Served on an Old Forge’s spent grain bun with lettuce & tomato
      $16.99
  • HOMEMADE DESSERTS

    • COCONUT CREAM PIE

    • CHOCOLATE PECAN PIE

    • CARROT CAKE

    • CHOCOLATE CAKE

    • KEY LIME PIE

    • PEANUT BUTTER PIE

    • HOT CHOCOLATE PIE

    • LEMONADE PIE

  • ARTISAN BREADS

    • SOURDOUGH

    • HONEY WHEAT

    • MULTIGRAIN

    • CINNAMON RAISIN PECAN

    • GREEN OLIVE

    • ONION RYE

    • SOURDOUGH BREAD BOWL

  • SIDES

    • STEAK FRIES

      $4.49
    • HOMEMADE POTATO CHIPS

      $4.49
    • MASHED POTATOES

      $4.49
    • PASTA SALAD

      $4.49
    • CINNAMON APPLES

      $4.49
    • STEAMED BROCCOLI

      $4.49
    • COLESLAW

      $4.49
    • CHEDDAR CHEESE GRITS

      $4.49
    • JALAPEÑO CORN PUDDING

      $4.49
    • FRESH FRUIT CUP

      $4.49
    • BAKED POTATO

      $4.49
    • GARDEN RICE

      $4.49
    • VEGETABLE OF THE DAY

      $4.49
    • BAKED SWEET POTATO

      $4.49
  • FROM THE GRILL

    • HAND CUT BLACK ANGUS, CHOICE RIBEYE

      $28.99

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms