The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Pickerington Menu

4.2
(1,475+ Reviews)
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Fish & Chips

      Traditional British style, hand-battered & fried Cold Water Atlantic Haddock. Served with steak fries, a side garnish of coleslaw & tartar sauce
      $21.50
    • Shrimp & Fish Platter

      Jumbo shrimp hand-battered and fried with our traditional british style fish served with steak fries, tartar and cocktail sauce and a side garnish of coleslaw.
      $25.00
    • Chicken Tender Basket

      Fresh chicken tenders hand-battered and fried. served with bbq or honey mustard for dipping. we recommend a side of onion rings - but the choice is yours
      $17.00
    • Philly Cheese Steak

      Shaved tender sirloin, sautéed onions, peppers and mushrooms topped with white american cheese.
      $19.75
    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Fried chicken tenders dipped in buffalo sauce, shredded cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion and blue cheese dressing wrapped up in a soft flour tortilla.
      $17.00
    • Carrot Cake

      An old family recipe made in-house and topped with cream cheese icing. Each piece sliced to order
      $9.50
    • Spicy Chicken Quesadilla

      A crispy tortilla stuffed with blackened chicken, house made salsa, monterey jack and cheddar cheese.
      $17.00
    • Jumbo Pretzel

      Buttered and salted then baked. Served with warm beer cheese sauce for dipping.
      $16.00
    • Loaded Skins

      Potato skins topped with bacon, cheese, and scallions. Served with a side of sour cream.
      $15.50
    • Fried Pickles

      Dill pickle spears, hand-battered and fried. Served with our house made ranch.
      $13.00
    • French Dip

      Shaved tender sirloin topped with sautéed onions and melted swiss cheese on a hoagie, served with hot au jus.
      $19.75
    • Kid Chicken Tenders

      $8.00
  • Starters (3Pd)

    • Fried Mushrooms

      Fresh button mushrooms battered & deep fried, served with a horseradish dipping sauce
      $14.00
    • Loaded Skins

      Potato skins topped with bacon, cheese, and scallions. Served with a side of sour cream.
      $15.50
    • Fried Pickles

      Dill pickle spears, hand-battered and fried. Served with our house made ranch.
      $13.00
    • Southwest Eggroll

      Crispy fried egg rolls stuffed with chicken, queso cheese, peppers, onions, and black beans. Served with our Southwest Ranch.
      $11.00
    • Cheese Curds

      Deep fried Wisconsin cheese curds served with marinara sauce.
      $14.00
    • Spinach & Artichoke Dip

      Garlic sauteéd spinach and artichoke hearts blended with parmesan, Swiss, and American cheeses. Topped with tomatoes and shredded parmesan and served with fresh corn tortilla chips.
      $14.00
    • Coconut Shrimp

      Hand dipped in our famous batter, rolled in coconut, and fried to order. Served with a Thai Chili sauce for dipping.
      $11.00
    • Potstickers

      Traditional Asian dumplings stuffed with pork and shredded cabbage. Topped with scallions and served with Thai Chili sauce.
      $13.50
    • Zucchini Fries

      Strips of zucchini breaded and fried to perfection. Served with our house made ranch.
      $8.00
    • Edamame

      Pan seared and sprinkled with kosher salt - a light snacking favorite!
      $6.00
    • Peel and Eat Shrimp

      One pound of warm peel and eat shrimp cooked in a garlic cajun butter sauce
      $17.00
    • Gaylords Saucy Shrimp

      Half pound of fried shrimp tossed in your choice of sauce. Served over a bed of lettuce and topped with scallions.
      $14.00
    • Loaded Nachos

      Smothered with our black bean dip, salsa, jalapeños, melted cheese, and scallions. Served with a side of sour cream
      $15.00
    • Jumbo Pretzel

      Buttered and salted then baked. Served with warm beer cheese sauce for dipping.
      $16.00
    • Potato Cake Appetizer

      Fried potato pancakes served with a side of sour cream.
      $12.00
  • Wings (3Pd)

    • 6 Bone-Out Wings

      Juicy boneless chicken wings - grilled, breaded, or fried and tossed in your choice of sauce.
      $10.00
    • 10 Bone-In Wings

      A classic - fried & tossed in a choice of sauce
      $19.00
    • 12 Bone-Out Wings

      Juicy boneless chicken wings - grilled, breaded, or fried and tossed in your choice of sauce.
      $15.50
  • Soups & Salads (3Pd)

    • Chicken Cobb

      Large bed of chopped romaine topped with tomato, diced egg, feta cheese, bacon & marinated onion. Served with freshly grilled chicken & choice of dressing
      $19.00
    • Wedge Salad

      An iceberg wedge covered in blue cheese dressing and topped with bacon, tomato, egg, and fresh red onion.
      $14.00
    • Half House Salad

      Mixed greens topped with bacon, tomato, blue cheese crumbles, fresh red onion, and croutons. Served with your choice of dressing.
      $10.00
    • Half Caesar Salad

      Chopped romaine tossed with parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing.
      $9.00
    • Full Spinach Salad

      Baby spinach topped with mushrooms, bacon, chopped egg & fresh red onion. Served with choice of dressing on the side
      $14.00
    • Full Caesar Salad

      Chopped romaine tossed with parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing.
      $13.00
    • Half Spinach Salad

      Baby spinach topped with mushrooms, bacon, chopped eggs, and fresh red onion. Served with your choice of dressing.
      $10.00
    • Soup of the Day

      Just ask your friendly neighborhood Old Bag of Nails server what's cooking today!
      $9.00
    • Full House Salad

      Mixed greens topped with bacon, tomato, blue cheese crumbles, fresh red onion, and croutons. Served with your choice of dressing.
      $14.00
    • French Onion

      Just like you'd imagine... nice & cheesy!
      $10.00
    • New England Clam Chowder

      Our secret recipe... and gluten free!
      $9.00
  • Hand Helds (3Pd)

    • Chicken Tender Basket

      Fresh chicken tenders hand-battered and fried. served with bbq or honey mustard for dipping. we recommend a side of onion rings - but the choice is yours
      $17.00
    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Fried chicken tenders dipped in buffalo sauce, shredded cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion and blue cheese dressing wrapped up in a soft flour tortilla.
      $17.00
    • Spicy Chicken Quesadilla

      A crispy tortilla stuffed with blackened chicken, house made salsa, monterey jack and cheddar cheese.
      $17.00
    • Blackened Shrimp Melt

      Blackened shrimp with provolone and cheddar cheeses on sourdough bread.
      $18.00
    • Philly Cheese Steak

      Shaved tender sirloin, sautéed onions, peppers and mushrooms topped with white american cheese.
      $19.75
    • French Dip

      Shaved tender sirloin topped with sautéed onions and melted swiss cheese on a hoagie, served with hot au jus.
      $19.75
  • Burgers & Reubens (3Pd)

    • Bernadette Burger

      Our 8oz burger cooked to order. Fully customizable with your choice of toppings!
      $17.00
    • Gaylord Burger

      An old time favorite - cheddar, bacon & BBQ sauce!
      $18.50
    • Bernie Chicken Sandwich

      Like the Bernadette Burger... but chicken! Order fried, grilled, or blackened with your choice of cheese and toppings.
      $17.00
    • Cowboy Burger

      For the spice chasers - pepper jack cheese, fried jalapeños & topped with our homemade cajun mayo. Ask for a blackened burger if you're really getting wild!
      $18.00
    • Sesame Ginger Chicken Sandwich

      Grilled chicken breast tossed in sesame ginger sauce and topped with feta cheese, house made pickled onions, and fresh spinach.
      $18.00
    • New England Reuben

      Our famous golden fried fish with melted swiss, coleslaw and 1000 island between two slices of grilled marble rye.
      $19.00
    • Rustic Burger

      A classic is back - blue cheese, bacon, and onion straws. Try it with your burger blackened for a little more kick!
      $18.50
  • Seafood & Steak (3Pd)

    • Fish & Chips

      Traditional British style, hand-battered & fried Cold Water Atlantic Haddock. Served with steak fries, a side garnish of coleslaw & tartar sauce
      $21.50
    • Shrimp & Fish Platter

      Jumbo shrimp hand-battered and fried with our traditional british style fish served with steak fries, tartar and cocktail sauce and a side garnish of coleslaw.
      $25.00
    • Atlantic Salmon

      Char-grilled or blackened, served with wild rice, a choice of side and dill cream sauce. please indicate meat temp. consuming undercooked meat or seafood may increase your risk of food borne illness.
      $25.00
    • Fish Tacos

      Our white fish, blackened or deep-fried, served inside three soft flour taco shells topped with a spicy shredded lettuce slaw and garnished with salsa. served with sour cream on the side and a side of tortilla chips.
      $18.50
    • Lobster Rolls

      Two traditional New England rolls stuffed with lobster, mayo, and a drizzle of butter. Served with a pickle spear and choice of one side.
      $28.00
    • Mussels & Jumbo Shrimp

      Over a pound of mussels with shrimp steamed in white wine, butter, and spices. Served with two slices of garlic bread for dipping.
      $21.00
    • Shrimp Po'Boy

      Crispy fried shrimp tossed with shredded lettuce, tomato, onion, and cajun mayo stuffed into a fresh hoagie roll.
      $18.00
    • Crab Cake Dinner

      Twin crab cakes served with lightly dressed salad greens and topped with a cajun remoulade.
      $21.00
    • Lobster Chips

      Kettle chips topped with warm lobster, beer cheese and scallions.
      $26.00
    • Oscar Haddock

      Grilled Haddock topped with crab meat and a lobster cream sauce.
      $23.00
    • Fish Sandwich

      Our Cold Water Atlantic Haddock hand-battered & fried Traditional or Eddie Style, blackened or pan seared, served with lettuce, tomato, onion on a hoagie roll & a side of steak or thin fries
      $18.50
    • Shrimp & Chips

      Jumbo shrimp, hand-battered and fried, served with steak fries, a side garnished of coleslaw and cocktail sauce.
      $20.00
  • Sides (3Pd)

    • Onion Ring Side

      $5.99
    • Steak Fries

      $5.99
    • French Fries

      $5.99
    • Coleslaw

      $3.99
    • Sweet Potato Fries

      $5.99
    • Fried Corn

      $5.99
    • Kabob Veggies

      $5.99
    • Garlic Bread

      $5.99
    • Applesauce

      $3.99
    • Kettle Chips

      $3.99
    • Tortilla Chips

      $5.99
    • Wild Rice

      $5.99
    • Tots

      $5.99
    • Potato Cakes

      $5.99
    • Fruit Cup

      $3.99
  • Desserts (3Pd)

    • Fried Snickers

      $11.00
    • Bread Pudding

      Steve says it's the best he's ever had, and that's good enough for us! Our homemade bourbon sauce is really something special.
      $10.00
    • Carrot Cake

      An old family recipe made in-house and topped with cream cheese icing. Each piece sliced to order
      $9.50
    • Chocolate Cake

      Chocolate cake, chocolate icing, chocolate chips, chocolate syrup... a chocolate lover's dream dessert!
      $10.50
  • Kids Menu (3Pd)

    • Kid Chicken Tenders

      $8.00
    • Kid Cheeseburger

      $8.00
    • Kid Mac & Cheese

      $8.00
    • Kid Grilled Cheese

      $8.00
    • Kid Mini Corn Dogs

      $8.00
    • Kid Fish & Chips

      $9.50
    • Kid Shrimp & Chips

      $9.50

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Reunion Asian Kitchen
Reunion Asian Kitchen
4.5
(45 Reviews)
Chinese
Pizzeria New York
Pizzeria New York
4.2
(304 Reviews)
Pizza
Finnegan's Wake
Finnegan's Wake
4.5
(213 Reviews)
Bar
Rule 3
Rule 3
4.2
(2,050 Reviews)
American, Restaurant, Sports bar
Pizza Cottage
Pizza Cottage
4.4
(1,223 Reviews)
Pizza, Family, Restaurant
Bella Lao Food
Bella Lao Food
4.4
(20 Reviews)
Asian fusion, Laotian
Domino's Pizza
Domino's Pizza
3.3
(261 Reviews)
Chicken wings, Pizza
Starbucks
Starbucks
3.3
(60 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Cafe, Coffee store
Kroger Bakery
Kroger Bakery
5.0
(1 Reviews)
Bagel shop, Dessert shop, Donut shop
Kroger Deli
Kroger Deli
4.5
(2 Reviews)
Deli, Sandwich shop

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms