The NY Slice Menu

4.6
(700+ Reviews)
$Pizza
  • Starters

    Ya startin' wit me?
    • Breadstix

      Dese are da best! Think I'm kiddin' youse? Try me. (4) per order, served with a side of marinara or cheese sauce.
      $4.99
      Breadstix
    • Italian Sausage Stix

      Italian sausage and mozzarella stuffed breadsticks
      $5.89
    • Roni Stix

      Pepperoni stuffed breadsticks with mozzarella
      $5.89
    • Pizza-dias

      Our version of a quesadilla, instead with mozzarella cheese in pizza dough with a side of marinara
      $8.99
    • Gahlic Knots

      Dese are those knot things everyone talks about.... however, we hit em up wit a lit'l parmesan and oregano on top (6) per order
      $4.99
  • Calzones & Strombolis

    Da big guys - Dey carry da weight around here!
    • Calzone

      Ya gonna score wit dis one! Like a football cut in half! A big, golden pizza dough turnover filled wit’ ricotta and Mozzarella cheeses and any other fillings you want.
      $9.99
      Calzone
    • Stromboli

      It’s not ‘zakly a sandwich, not ‘zakly a calzone. But a chunk of heaven, nonetheless! Full of pepperoni, sausage, gooey mozzarella and any other fillings you want!
      $7.99
      Stromboli
  • Slices

    Dere ain't nuttin- lika nice awthentic New Yawk Slice. Capiche? Starts as cheese, toppings additional
    • Da Big Slice

      Da authentic New York thin crust slice. Fold it in half and eat it like a true blue New Yawker. Build your custom slice with your choice of toppings.
      $3.89
      Da Big Slice
  • 16"

    Traditional thin crust brick oven pies cut into 8 slices. Think you can get better pizza somewhere else? Fuhgedabowdit!
    • 16" Pizza

      This’ll take you back to Brooklyn, da Bronx or wherever it was you got lost in da city and had the best pizza you ever had--up until now.
      $17.99
      16" Pizza
    • 16" Bada BBQ

      Grilled chicken tossed in BBQ sauce, topped with ricotta and painted with our house-made ranch
      $21.99
      16" Bada BBQ
    • 16" Bet Da Ranch

      Grilled Parmesan chicken, banana peppers, and bacon painted with our house-made ranch
      $21.99
    • 16" Big Greek

      Roma tomatoes, mozzarella and feta cheese, fresh spinach, roasted red peppers, red onion, garlic, black olives and oregano.
      $21.99
    • 16" Big Islander

      Mozzarella, ham, smoked bacon, pineapple and BBQ sauce
      $21.99
      16" Big Islander
    • 16" Big Meat Yorker

      Pepperoni, sliced Italian sausage, salami and bacon. Made with our house-made marinara pizza sauce.
      $21.99
      16" Big Meat Yorker
    • 16" Buffalo Chicken

      Grilled chicken tossed in Buffalo sauce, topped with ricotta then painted with our house-made ranch.
      $21.99
      16" Buffalo Chicken
    • 16" Da Big Spicy

      Grilled or breaded chicken tossed in Buffalo sauce, topped with Jalapeno, onion, banana peppers and tomatoes painted with our house-made ranch
      $21.99
    • 16" Da Gardener

      $21.99
    • 16" Formaggi

      Fresh mozzarella, feta, provolone, ricotta and pecorino romano. Made with our house-made marinara pizza sauce.
      $21.99
      16" Formaggi
    • 16" Margherita

      This’ll take you back to Brooklyn, da Bronx or wherever it was you got lost in da city and had the best pizza you ever had--up until now.
      $21.99
      16" Margherita
    • 16" Da Bianca

      Ricotta, Olive Oil and Garlic
      $21.99
  • 20"

    Dis is it! Authentic brick-oven, New York thin crust. BadaBing - BadaBoom! Starts as cheese, toppings additional
    • 20" Pizza

      This’ll take you back to Brooklyn, da Bronx or wherever it was you got lost in da city and had the best pizza you ever had--up until now.
      $19.99
      20" Pizza
    • 20" Bada BBQ

      Grilled chicken tossed in BBQ sauce, topped with ricotta and painted with our house-made ranch
      $26.99
      20" Bada BBQ
    • 20" Bet Da Ranch

      Grilled Parmesan chicken and bacon painted with our house-made ranch
      $26.99
    • 20" Big Islander

      Mozzarella, ham, smoked bacon, pineapple and BBQ sauce
      $26.99
      20" Big Islander
    • 20" Big Meat Yorker

      Pepperoni, sliced Italian sausage, salami and bacon. Made with our house-made marinara pizza sauce.
      $26.99
      20" Big Meat Yorker
    • 20" Buffalo Chicken

      Grilled chicken tossed in Buffalo sauce, topped with ricotta and then painted with our house-made ranch.
      $26.99
      20" Buffalo Chicken
    • 20" Da Big Greek

      Roma tomatoes, mozzarella and feta cheese, fresh spinach, red onion, garlic, black olives and oregano
      $26.99
    • 20" Da Big Spicy

      Grilled or breaded chicken tossed in Buffalo sauce, topped with Jalapeno, onion, banana peppers and tomatoes painted with our house-made ranch
      $26.99
    • 20" Da Gardener

      $26.99
    • 20" Formaggi

      Fresh mozzarella, feta, provolone, ricotta and pecorino romano. Made with our house-made marinara pizza sauce.
      $26.99
      20" Formaggi
    • 20" Margherita

      Imported Roma tomatoes, fresh Mozzarella & basil pesto, extra virgin olive oil, Italian sea salt and cracked black pepper.
      $26.99
      20" Margherita
    • 20" Da Bianca

      Ricotta, Olive oil and garlic
      $26.99
  • Drinks

    • 12 oz Mugs Root Beer

      $1.89
    • 12 oz Diet

      $1.89
    • 12 oz Dr Pepper

      $1.89
    • 12 oz Pepsi

      $1.89
    • 16.9 oz Water

      $1.89
    • 12 oz Mountain Dew

      $1.89
    • 12 oz Starry

      $1.89
    • 12 oz Orange Crush

      $1.89
  • Desserts

    • Cannoli

      $4.59

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Dairy Queen
Dairy Queen
3.7
(566 Reviews)
Ice cream shop
SmockTown Brewery LLC
SmockTown Brewery LLC
4.6
(161 Reviews)
Brewery, Bar, Restaurant
Dashboard Food Truck & Catering
Dashboard Food Truck & Catering
5.0
(91 Reviews)
Restaurant
Coffeehouse Five
Coffeehouse Five
4.7
(488 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Breakfast, Lunch
Mrs. Curl Ice Cream Shop
Mrs. Curl Ice Cream Shop
4.6
(1,814 Reviews)
Ice cream shop, Restaurant
The Suds
The Suds
4.5
(372 Reviews)
American
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza
4.5
(2,061 Reviews)
Pizza
Egg Roll Number 1
Egg Roll Number 1
4.4
(553 Reviews)
Chinese, Asian, Restaurant
Roscoe's Tacos
Roscoe's Tacos
4.5
(1,568 Reviews)
Tex-Mex, Mexican
Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza
3.5
(782 Reviews)
Pizza

+1 317-887-1009

1201 Greenwood Park E Dr, Greenwood, IN 46142


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms