The Mustard Seed Cafe Menu

4.6

(575+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Lite Bites Mustard Seed Samplers Sandwich Combos & More Quiche Me Fresh Made Salads Soups On Sides Drinks Desserts

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Pick 3
  Any whole sandwich plus your choice of 2 sides ( Limited to one slice of quiche and one soup)
  $20.34
- Chicken Salad Sandwich
  our signature chicken salad on a croissant or your favorite bread.
  $13.76
- Quiche and Side
  Pick one of the freshly baked cranberry chicken, chicken fajita (don't forget the sour cream), spinach, tomato bacon spinach or delicious tomato pie. Select a salad, soup or fruit cup.
  $14.93
- Pick 4
  Any half sandwich plus your choice of 3 sides ( Limited to two slices of quiche and one soup)
  $20.34
- Sweet Tea
  $4.27
- Caramel Cake
  Delicious homemade caramel icing on yellow cake
  $7.78
- Really Cheezy Grilled Cheese
  Your choice of 5 slices of American, provolone or Swiss or just an all-American grilled cheese. Add bacon for an additional cost.
  $10.72
- Slice of quiche
  $7.13
- Unsweet Tea
  $4.27
- Chocolate Cake
  Delicious triple-layered chocolate cake
  $7.78
- Fruit cup
  Mixed fruit topped with Craisins, almonds, and raspberry drizzle
  $4.66
- Grilled Chicken Asiago
  Grilled chicken topped with bacon, Asiago cheese, ranch dressing, lettuce & tomato served on ciabatta
  $15.73
Lite Bites
- Avocado Toast
  2 slices of toast with avocado spread with everything bagel seasoning and red pepper flakes. Add bacon for additional cost
  $7.13
- Ham & Cheese Croissant
  Ham & cheese croissant with choice of American, provolone, or Swiss cheese.
  $8.95
- Cheese Danish
  Delicate, Flaky Pastry Filled with Rich, Creamy Cheese
  $3.88
Mustard Seed Samplers
When you are really hungry! Gluten-free disclaimer:-Please keep in mind that items prepared without gluten products are made in a facility that handles many other wheat products. .
- Pick 4 Salad Sampler
  Select 4 of your favorite salads.
  $16.16
- Pick 3
  Any whole sandwich plus your choice of 2 sides ( Limited to one slice of quiche and one soup)
  $20.34
- Pick 4
  Any half sandwich plus your choice of 3 sides ( Limited to two slices of quiche and one soup)
  $20.34
Sandwich Combos & More
All sandwiches are prepared with premium boar's head deli meats. Combos come with one choice: salad (club salad and very berry spinach excluded); soup, fruit cup or potato salad, pasta salad. Bread choices: croissant, ciabatta, wheat, hoagie, sourdough, marble rye, gluten-free available for an additional cost. Gluten-free disclaimer:-Please keep in mind that items prepared without gluten products are made in a facility that handles many other wheat products. .
- Chicken Salad Sandwich
  our signature chicken salad on a croissant or your favorite bread.
  $13.76
- Really Cheezy Grilled Cheese
  Your choice of 5 slices of American, provolone or Swiss or just an all-American grilled cheese. Add bacon for an additional cost.
  $10.72
- Connie's Bacon, Ham, Cheese & Caramel Apple
  Dressed with lettuce and tomato. Served on grilled sourdough.
  $16.39
- Grilled Chicken Asiago
  Grilled chicken topped with bacon, Asiago cheese, ranch dressing, lettuce & tomato served on ciabatta
  $15.73
- The TBC
  Smoked turkey, bacon & provolone cheese with mayo, lettuce & tomato served on ciabatta bread.
  $15.00
- Chicken Caesar Wrap
  grilled chicken strips, Romain lettuce with Caesar dressing
  $12.98
- Ms Reuben
  Choice of corned beef sauerkraut & Swiss cheese smothered in our house-made dressing.
  $16.39
- MSBLT
  Bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo served on wheat. Extra bacon for an additional cost.
  $12.98
- Mustard Seed Wrap
  Choice of chicken or turkey dressed with your choice of dressing. Add lettuce and tomato
  $12.98
- The Cuban
  Pulled pork topped with ham, swiss & American cheese, with mayo, mustard & pickles, grilled to perfection on sourdough.
  $16.39
- Julie's Club
  Smoked ham, turkey, bacon, cheese (American, provolone or swiss), lettuce, tomato and mayo in between three slices of toasted wheat.
  $16.39
- Hot Ham and Cheese
  Ham with your choice of cheese on your choice of bread
  $13.97
- Veggie Reuben
  spinach, with sauerkraut, homemade dressing on rye
  $10.53
- Turkey Rueben
  smoked turkey with our housemate dressing, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese
  $16.39
- Pimento Cheese
  Creamy Cheddar cheese & pimento with a kick of spices served on sourdough.
  $12.28
- Old time Hoagie
  Your choice: mesquite chicken; smoked ham or smoked turkey. Your choice of dressing. Ask her lettuce or tomato
  $14.28
- Veggie Wrap
  Mixed veggies smothered in our house dressing (poppy seed).
  $9.99
- Tuna Salad Sandwich
  Our Cherished family recipe served on your choice of bread or croissant
  $13.76
- Georgie
  Boar’s head roast beef with horseradish and onion cheese, served on an onion sauce
  $18.18
- Micah's Smash
  Micah's smash-smoked turkey, provolone bacon & mayo on a hoagie roll smashed. 'Panini' style.
  $15.00
- Jared Smash
  Jared smash-smoked ham, provolone, bacon & honey mustard on a hoagie roll smashed 'Panini' style.
  $15.00
Quiche Me
Gluten-free disclaimer:-Please keep in mind that items prepared without gluten products are made in a facility that handles many other wheat products. .
- Quiche and Side
  Pick one of the freshly baked cranberry chicken, chicken fajita (don't forget the sour cream), spinach, tomato bacon spinach or delicious tomato pie. Select a salad, soup or fruit cup.
  $14.93
Fresh Made Salads
Made just like you like it. Gluten-free disclaimer:-Please keep in mind that items prepared without gluten products are made in a facility that handles many other wheat products. .
- Very Berry Spinach Salad
  Fresh blueberries, strawberries, candied pecans, topped with goat cheese. Served with citrus berry vinaigrette. Sorry, not available as a side. Add chicken, tuna scoop or grilled chicken for an additional cost.
  $14.88
- Green Apple Salad
  Fresh greens with cran-raisins, candied pecans, goat cheese, grannie smith apple slices, and topped with your favorite mustard seed dressing. Not available as a side. Add grilled chicken for an additional cost.
  $14.88
- Market Street Caesar
  Fresh romaine with fresh parmesan cheese topped with house-made croutons, dressing. Add grilled chicken for an additional cost.
  $10.90
- Club Salad
  Organic spring mix greens topped with smoked ham, turkey, bacon and Cheddar cheese, grape Toma toes topped with our house-made croutons, dressing. Sorry, not available as a side.
  $15.19
- BLT Salad
  Arcadian spring mix with tomatoes, crumbled bacon, and cheddar cheese. your choice of dressing
  $11.50
- Italian Fusilli Pasta
  Diced grilled chicken with a delicious mix of spinach and fusilli pasta, celery, diced black olives and pimentos, dusted with parmesan cheese a dash of Italian dressing. Add grilled chicken for an additional cost.
  $12.59
- Kitchen Sink
  A blend of kale, edamame, carrots, grape tomatoes, sunflower seeds, blueberries, cranberries & crushed cashews marinated in pomegranate dressing.
  $13.89
- Arcadian Spring Mix
  Leafy organic spring greens topped with organic carrot slices, cran-raisins, almond slivers, cheese & seasonal fruit. Add scoop of chicken salad, tuna salad, or grilled chicken for an.
  $10.90
Soups On
Gluten-free disclaimer:-Please keep in mind that items prepared without gluten products are made in a facility that handles many other wheat products. .
- Tomato Basil
  Made everyday.
  $6.17
- Chili
  Made everyday.
  $6.17
Sides
Gluten-free disclaimer:-Please keep in mind that items prepared without gluten products are made in a facility that handles many other wheat products. Quiches do contain milk and egg.
- Slice of quiche
  $7.13
- Side Mac and cheese
  The perfect comfort side dish.
  $7.78
- Side Pasta Salad
  Our side pasta salad is a harmonious blend of Italian flavors and parmesan cheese, typically tossed together to create a refreshing side dish.
  $7.00
- Fruit cup
  Mixed fruit topped with Craisins, almonds, and raspberry drizzle
  $4.66
- Potato Salad Scoop
  Potato salad typically includes boiled potatoes mixed with a mayo-based dressing, often complemented by ingredients like onions, herbs, and spices.
  $4.22
Drinks
- Soda
  Coke Products
  $4.27
- Unsweet Tea
  $4.27
- Sweet Tea
  $4.27
- Lemonade
  Refreshing citrus beverage.
  $4.27
Desserts
Slice of cake
- Coconut Cake
  Delicious buttercream layered cake with coconut flakes
  $7.78
- Caramel Cake
  Delicious homemade caramel icing on yellow cake
  $7.78
- Chocolate Cake
  Delicious triple-layered chocolate cake
  $7.78