The Jay Street Cafe

Use to come here before it became the ‘cafe’ it is now & enjoyed meeting friends or taking family for great meals-very home town feeling. But, now it’s not like that so much. Met friends for Dinner. The Tempura stringbeans were very oily/greasy; the soy based sauce super salty… we couldn’t eat them. The BBQ plate was not much better. Pulled Pork and cole slaw was OK but Fries were cold & oily. The worst part of this dish is the cornbread! Thin, dry and oily…too inedible. Dinner for two was $100 (two entrees, one app, two beers) which is costly for a disappointing meal. Service was good though :/

Servers tried, there were only 3 working during a lunch rush. The food was bad. Just bad. Corned beef had no flavor except for a bad aftertaste. Same with blt. Both sandwiches were extremely dry. Fries were cold. I can’t really understand how it was all so bad. They were very basic sandwiches. Hard to screw up I thought.

Best burger in town!

This is such a great place!! My wife and I go frequently throughout the year. We love especially when it is warmer and we are able to eat outside. The setting is amazing in a quaint little town setting right across from the Metro-North Kathonah station. The staff is very friendly and they have a very nice assortment of food. You will definitely enjoy this place and the food prices are quite good. Enjoy!!

Jaime is the best

We used to go to this location quite regularly before it became Jay Street Cafe and loved the food ! We gave it another shot the other day. Service was good. I had the falafel burger- and enjoyed every morsel ‼️ my dining companions ordered a burger and pancakes. Pancakes were standard. Burger had a charred exterior with a burnt taste. It was not good/enjoyable. My companion could not eat it. I agree with other reviewers regarding prices. They are a bit high. I plan to return - for now - as I enjoyed the falafel burger very much - despite the price