The Crazy Baker Cafe

High prices

Great elairs

Great original delicious baked goods, breads, a must try!!!

Best Bakery in town!

I heard a lot of good things about this place thought I’d give it a try, so glad I did I called and asked if they had strawberry shortcake they said they would have it ready for me in a couple of minutes it was decorated so pretty with lots of strawberries and it tasted amazing the whip cream was to die for.I’m very picky so this place hands down has my business. Definitely recommend.

Amazing bakery and even better customer service! This place dropped what they were doing to fill a last minute same day order for my wife’s baby shower! We went through a woman on marketplace at first who ended up scamming us basically and when the owner heard what happened he didn’t hesitate to help. I called 6 other bakery’s who all said they couldn’t help, I’m so grateful for John and crew at “The Crazy Baker Cafe” they saved my wife’s baby shower and had very reasonable pricing.

Preordered a cake.. on pickup day, it was never done, even though order was confirmed. Then the cake was rushed and made on the spot.. when I got to the restaurant and presented the cake, it looked like the leaning tower of Pisa..see pics.. it was like the whipped cream topping was too warm because it was sliding off the cake. It looked disgusting and it did not taste any better.. To say I was embarrassed, is an understatement! Never again will I order anything from this bakery! Go elsewhere, you’d be better off!

Probably the only good thing in Toms River! Love the people and all they make is great quality. Gotta try Corissant Sandwiches!!!