The Blue Chip Cookies-Milford , Ohio Menu

4.7

(50+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Cookie Cakes and Other Specialty Items Blue Chip Bundles Create Your Own Assortment "À La Carte"-Pick Your Flavors Gluten Sensitive Cookies Choose Your Packaging Add a personal note/card

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- The Chipster (alias Cookie Sandwich)
  The Best Sandwich you will ever have, The Chipster. We put delicious vanilla buttercream icing in between two chocolate chip cookies!
  $4.85
- Cookie Cake-Round, 15-16 Servings.
  The 13 Inch customized cookie cake-approximately 15 servings. Be sure to tell us what you want for your message on the cake. Include name. Do this in the INSTRUCTIONS for the product. Examples: Happy Birthday Donna, or Congratulations, or Happy Holiday We can put simple symbols also as shown. We have chocolate chip and sugar on hand. Please allow 30 minutes to decorate to specifications and ideally give us 2 days lead time. If you want another cookie flavor, please email us at orders@bluechipcookies.com by Monday of each week.
  $33.00
- Sugar Iced (2 Cookies)
  Our sugar cookie with buttercream icing spread across the top! Delicious.
  $4.85
- Chocolate Chip (2 Cookies)
  The big kahuna, the grand slam, the most wonderful chocolate chip cookie you will ever taste. Baked with our signature dough and secret ingredients, this cookie is the one to stand the test of time. Yummy to the last bite. Voted best cookie in over 10 cities.
  $4.35
- Cookies & Cream, aka OMG (2 Cookies)
  Our sugar dough with Oreo cookie bits popping out all over!
  $4.35
- Peanut Butter (2 Cookies)
  Our signature dough is married with premium creamy-smooth peanut butter for that rich peanut-buttery goodness.
  $4.35
- Sugar with Season Sprinkles (2 Cookies)
  Favorite amongst our younger fans and those who are young at heart, our sugar cookies are coated with seasonal sprinkles for that perfect treat. Holiday Sprinkles, Red, Green and White.
  $4.35
- Cinnamon Delight (Snickerdoodle) (2 Cookies)
  Our sugar cookie is infused with cinnamon and spice that has a profile that’s light and airy with great flavor. A favorite for many!
  $4.25
- Chocolate Chip M&M (2 Cookies)
  A colorful chocolate chip cookie combined with the famous Mars candy. Each cookie is baked with seasonal M&M's throughout the year.
  $4.35
- White Chocolate Macadamia, alias Mac! (2 Cookies)
  What Blue Chip Cookies is known for across the country. ”The first bakery to introduce the White Chocolate Chip Macadamia to the public!
  $4.35
Cookie Cakes and Other Specialty Items
We have a nice variety of cookie cakes for any celebration: 7-inch, 13- inch, and 1/2 sheets. Try to order at least 1 day in advance, also give us at least 30 minutes to decorate the cake, if same day, without being rushed. We typically have all sizes on hand. Please select your icing colors, then type in the message you want on the cake and other info you want us to know in "Special Instructions." Make sure you let us know what message you want on the cookie cake. We can make cakes with advance notice in other flavors including Gluten Sensitive (no gluten flour added.)
- Cookie Cake-Round, 15-16 Servings.
  The 13 Inch customized cookie cake-approximately 15 servings. Be sure to tell us what you want for your message on the cake. Include name. Do this in the INSTRUCTIONS for the product. Examples: Happy Birthday Donna, or Congratulations, or Happy Holiday We can put simple symbols also as shown. We have chocolate chip and sugar on hand. Please allow 30 minutes to decorate to specifications and ideally give us 2 days lead time. If you want another cookie flavor, please email us at orders@bluechipcookies.com by Monday of each week.
  $33.00
- Cookie Cake-1/2 Sheet, 28 to 30 Servings.
  The 1/2 sheet customized cookie cake-28 to 30 servings. Tell us what you want as your message on the cake. We can do simple symbols, also. 1/2 sheets are not always available, so order 3 days ahead of time.
  $57.00
- Deep Dish Cookie Cake-Small-5 Servings
  Personal Size Cookie Cake, Deep Dish-Serves 4-5 for a mini celebration. We decorate the border and can put small phrase on the cake or a simple symbol. Put your request in "Special Instructions." Available in Chocolate Chip only.
  $15.00
- Blue Chip Baby Cakes-2 Servings.
  Introducing These adorable Valentine "baby cakes. " A 5 oz mini cake that serve 2 people. We plan to carry these on a regular basis.
  $6.50
- The Blue Chip Cookie Monster
  Scoop of vanilla or fudge frosting sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies. Monster is completed with a dip in sprinkles and frosting eyes. We put it in a small white 4 x 4 x 4 box.
  $6.50
- Buttercream Icing-4 ounces or buttercream to ice your cake!
  Add more icing to your cakes!
  $4.35
Blue Chip Bundles
We have created a unique bundle of cookies with your gift box included! Great for Birthdays, Client Thank You, Employee Appreciation, Holiday, Mother's Day, Father's Day and Special Monday Days.
- Premium Bundle-14 Cookies-You Pick 7th Flavor
  Premium Portfolio: Chocolate Chip (2), Cinnamon Delight (2), Oatmeal Raisin (2), Peanut Butter (2), Sugar Cookie of the Month (2), White Chocolate Chip (2), You Pick the 7th flavor.
  $28.50
- Seasonal Favorites-14 Cookies-You Pick 7th Flavor
  Seasonal Favorites: Blue Chip Joy (2), Chocolate Chip (2), Cookies and Cream-OMG (2), Choco-Mint (2), Confetti Cake (2), White Chocolate Macadamia (2), Triple Chocolate (2) and you pick the 7th flavor.
  $28.50
- Buttercream Icing-4 ounces or buttercream to ice your own cookies.
  Smooth and creamy buttercream icing, perfect for adding a sweet and rich touch to your favorite gluten-sensitive cookies.
  $4.35
Create Your Own Assortment
Create Your Own Assortment of 8 Cookies or 14 Cookies. Each flavor is equal to 2 cookies. 8 Cookies-4 Flavors 14 Cookies-7 Flavors
- MyWay-14 Cookies, Pick 7 Flavors
  ### Menu Description Assorted gift box of 14 cookies. Choose from options like Thank You Box, Happy Birthday Box, etc. Pick 7 flavors including options with chocolates, nuts, berries, citrus, sugar, and peanut butter.
  $30.00
- Buttercream Icing-4 ounces or buttercream to ice your own cookies.
  Enjoy spreading or dipping your cookie into our buttercream icing on the side.
  $4.35
"À La Carte"-Pick Your Flavors
Blue Chip Cookies has over 50+ flavors that we offer through the year. Every day we have available typically over 30 flavors to our customers. To ensure excellence in freshness, the cookies are baked to perfection, cool on our racks, and then we seal them as soon as possible "airtight" 2 cookies, the same flavor, into our proprietary bags. We label each one on the back with ingredients. We freeze the cookies immediately so we can offer this many flavors all the time. Please order one hour ahead if you want your cookies delivered at room temperature. Directions for serving are enclosed. If for future date, simply put them in your freezer and take out 1 hour prior to event.
- Choc-Mint (2 Cookies)
  Brown Sugar Cookie of the Month for March. A refreshingly decadent twist on a classic! Featuring half semi-sweet chocolate chips for a deep, velvety bite and half Guittard mint chips for a superb, melt-in-your-mouth minty finish. You will be in MINT condition after one bite!
  $4.35
- Sugar Minty Scout (Sugar Cookie of the Month)
  Sugar Minty Scout – This dreamy sugar cookie is dressed in a dazzling coat of crushed Girl Scout Thin Mints, bringing together the magic of buttery sweetness and the cool, chocolatey mint crunch of childhood adventures. In Honor of Girl Scout Day on March 12th.
  $4.35
- Almond Toffee Chip (2 Cookies)
  A savory blend of almonds, mixed with toffee brickle, and semi-sweet chocolate chips.
  $4.35
- Berries & Cream (2 Cookies)
  Dried berries rolled together with decadent white chocolate chips for that earthy-sweet goodness! Owners favorite!
  $4.35
- Black and White (2 Cookies)
  White chocolate chips mixed with our signature oban-infused dough that offers a sweet and delightful profile.
  $4.35
- Blue Chip Joy, aka JOY (2 Cookies)
  A marriage of almonds, coconut, and semi-sweet chocolate chips comes together for a whimsical delight.
  $4.35
- Blue Chip Royale (2 Cookies)
  Slivered almonds meet with white chocolate, and toffee bits that offer a tasty treat fit for a king or queen.
  $4.35
- The Chipster (alias Cookie Sandwich)
  The Best Sandwich you will ever have, The Chipster. We put delicious vanilla buttercream icing in between two chocolate chip cookies!
  $4.85
- Chocolate Chip (2 Cookies)
  The big kahuna, the grand slam, the most wonderful chocolate chip cookie you will ever taste. Baked with our signature dough and secret ingredients, this cookie is the one to stand the test of time. Yummy to the last bite. Voted best cookie in over 10 cities.
  $4.35
- Chocolate Chip Macadamia (2 Cookies)
  Semi-sweet chocolates with macadamia nuts shipped from the big island! Aloha!
  $4.35
- Chocolate Chip M&M (2 Cookies)
  A colorful chocolate chip cookie combined with the famous Mars candy. Each cookie is baked with seasonal M&M's throughout the year.
  $4.35
- Chocolate Chip Pecan (2 Cookies)
  Our famous chocolate chip cookie with pecan pieces mixed through the dough! On the menu now because of so many requests.
  $4.35
- Chocolate Chip Walnut (2 Cookies)
  Our famous chocolate chip cookies baked with walnuts for a crispy, crunchy, nutty delight. What makes a good thing better? More good things.
  $4.35
- Cinnamon Delight (Snickerdoodle) (2 Cookies)
  Our sugar cookie is infused with cinnamon and spice that has a profile that’s light and airy with great flavor. A favorite for many!
  $4.25
- Confetti Cake, aka Birthday Cake Cookie
  Our Confetti Cake is a version of our sugar cookie! First we mix beautiful sprinkles in the dough versus roll them in dough and add a special Birthday Cake extract that makes the cookie taste like a mini cake!
  $4.25
- Cookies & Cream, aka OMG (2 Cookies)
  Our sugar dough with Oreo cookie bits popping out all over!
  $4.35
- Lemon Delight (2 Cookies)
  Our sugar cookie dough infused with lemon extract, light and airy!
  $4.35
- Milk Chocolate Chip (2 Cookies)
  Chocolate Chip cookie made with Guittard Mlk Chocolate.
  $4.35
- Oatmeal Raisin (2 Cookies)
  A favorite of many, our oatmeal raisin is made with raisins, oats and macaroon coconut.
  $4.35
- Peanut Butter (2 Cookies)
  Our signature dough is married with premium creamy-smooth peanut butter for that rich peanut-buttery goodness.
  $4.35
- Peanut Butter Fudge (2 cookies)
  Our peanut butter with chocolate fudge buttercream icing spread across the top! Delicious.
  $4.85
- Peanut Butter Surprise (2 Cookies)
  Milk Chocolate in a peanut butter cookie!
  $4.35
- Pumpkin Spice
  Sugar cookie dough with pumpkin pie spice and pumpkin puree.
  $4.35
- Sugar Old Fashioned (2 Cookies)
  Our classic Sugar Cookie, rolled in more sugar!
  $4.35
- Sugar with Season Sprinkles (2 Cookies)
  Favorite amongst our younger fans and those who are young at heart, our sugar cookies are coated with seasonal sprinkles for that perfect treat. Holiday Sprinkles, Red, Green and White.
  $4.35
- Sugar Iced (2 Cookies)
  Our sugar cookie with buttercream icing spread across the top! Delicious.
  $4.85
- Sugar Iced Spinkles(2 Cookies)
  Sugar Iced with Seasonal Sprinkles.
  $4.85
- Sugar M&M (2 Cookies)
  Our classic sugar cookies with seasonal M&Ms. Great cookie for the individual or kid that loves classic sugar with a festive milk chocolate candy to make it fun to eat and look at. This cookie brings the kid out in all of us. Delicious!
  $4.35
- Triple Chocolate, alias Brookie(2 Cookies)
  Semi-sweet, milk, and oban chocolates combined in a cookie that tastes like a brownie. Contains two cookies per pack.
  $4.35
- White Chocolate (2 Cookies)
  Delicious Guittard White Chocolate in brown sugar cookie dough! We just substitute the semi-sweet for white chocolate. Creamy and scrumptious.
  $4.35
- White Chocolate Macadamia, alias Mac! (2 Cookies)
  What Blue Chip Cookies is known for across the country. ”The first bakery to introduce the White Chocolate Chip Macadamia to the public!
  $4.35
- Buttercream Icing-4 ounces or buttercream to ice your own cookies.
  Enjoy spreading or dipping your cookie into our buttercream icing on the side.
  $4.35
Gluten Sensitive Cookies
We have finally created a Gluten Sensitive Sugar Cookie line up includes Sugar Plain, Cookies and Cream, Sugar Iced and Sugar M&M. Please note, however we bake in our current facility that has gluten in it and we prepare gluten products in same ovens. So if highly sensitive to gluten, just like tree nuts, we recommend you go to nut free bakeries or gluten free bakeries.
- Snickerdoodle-Gluten Sensitive
  Sugar cookie made with gluten-free flour, infused and rolled with a cinnamon and sugar mix.
  $5.00
- Sugar Cookie-Gluten Free-Sensitive (2 Cookies)
  We simple substituted our wheat flour for gluten free flour and we have an incredible sugar cookie. We roll our cookie scoop in sugar and bake to perfection. *Please note we cannot claim Gluten Free because we bake in our Milford facility where gluten is present.
  $5.00
- Peanut Butter Gluten Sensitive
  Rich peanut butter cookies made with gluten-sensitive ingredients.
  $5.00
- Buttercream Icing-4 ounces or buttercream to ice your own cookies.
  Smooth and creamy buttercream icing, perfect for adding a sweet and rich touch to your favorite gluten-sensitive cookies.
  $4.35
Choose Your Packaging
Choose from our various packing options. We bundle our cookies in a simple no fuss bag. If you purchase a dozen or more we will upgrade you automatically to a blue reusable gift bag. If you would like a gift box, choose from our selection below for $2.50, which holds up to 7 flavors.
- Happy Birthday
  This box holds nicely 6-16 cookies, 3 to 8 flavors.
  $2.50
- Thank You
  This box holds nicely 6-16 cookies, 3 to 8 flavors.
  $2.50
- Signature Blue Chip
  This box holds nicely 6-16 cookies, 3 to 8 flavors.
  $2.00
- Happy Day or Thinking of You.
  This box holds nicely 6-16 cookies, 3 to 8 flavors.
  $2.50
- Sweet Day
  This box holds nicely 6-16 cookies, 3 to 8 flavors.
  $2.50
- Thinking of You
  This box holds nicely 6-16 cookies, 3 to 8 flavors.
  $2.50
- Celebrate
  This box holds nicely 6-16 cookies, 3 to 8 flavors.
  $2.50
Add a personal note/card
Want to add a personal note? Just type it is the special instructions. We will match a card to your note.
- Handwritten Note
  Type in your personal note, and one of our associates will handwrite it for you on a notecard and insert it in your order.
  $2.00