The Better Bagel Menu

$Bagel shop
45 Merrick Rd, Amityville, NY 11701
  • Bagels Rolls and Popovers

    • Bagels Nothing On Them

    • WEDNESDAY DOZEN SPECIAL ($8.99)

      ONLY AVAILABLE ON WEDNESDAY * ORDERS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED ANY OTHER DAYS*\n\nThe Wednesday Special is not available on Holidays weeks and Holiday Eves.
      $8.99
    • Bagels With Butter

    • Bagels With Plain Cream Cheese

    • Bagels With Flavored Cream Cheese

    • Mini Bagels **Half Dozen

      $4.99
    • Hero Bread

      with Sesame Seeds
      $1.75
    • Kaiser Roll

      with Poppy Seeds
    • Bagel With Avocado

    • Bagels By Dozen

      Select 13 our of delicious fresh baked bagels!\n*Up to 3 Green Bagels included with Dozen Price - available in 1st, 2nd and 3rd Bagel Selections*
      $18.99
    • FlaBagel (Flat Bagels)

      Flat Bagel\nEverything Seeds, Sesame, EggBacon Asiago, Pumpernickel Sesame, Marble Rye
    • Mini Bagel (Each)

    • Mini Bagels **Dozen

      $9.99
    • Pretzel

      $2.59
  • Cream Cheese, Butter & Lox

    • Vegetable 1/2 LB

      $6.50
    • Cinnamon Raisin 1/2 LB

      $6.50
    • Strawberry 1/2 LB

      $6.50
    • Sriracha Jalapeno 1/2 LB

      $6.50
    • Olive 1/2LB

      $6.50
    • Scallion 1/2 LB

      $6.50
    • Scallion & Bacon 1/2 LB

      $6.50
    • Lox Spread 1/2LB

      $7.49
    • Sliced Nova Lox 1/4 LB

      $11.50
    • Butter 1/2 LB

      $4.29
    • Plain 1/2 LB

      $5.59
  • Avocado Toasts ***NEW***

    • Egg & Bacon Avocado Toast

      Seasoned and Smashed Avocado on Thick Cut Whole Wheat Toast, with 1 egg any style and crispy bacon
      $8.99
    • Smashed Avocado Toast

      Seasoned and Smashed Avocado on Thick Cut Whole Wheat Toast
      $6.99
    • Everything Seeds & Sriracha Avocado Toast

      Seasoned and Smashed Avocado on Thick Cut Whole Wheat Toast, with 1 egg any style, toasted everything seeds & Sriracha
    • Pico De Gallo And Chorizo Sausage Avocado Toast

      Our smashed and seasoned avocado on thick cut whole wheat toast. topped with Pico de Gallo and Chorizo Sausage
      $8.99
    • Nova Lox, Capers, Bermuda Onion

      Nova Lox, Capers, Bermuda Onion, Seasoned and Smashed Avocado on Thick Cut Whole Wheat Toast\nOne Egg Any Style
  • Breakfast - Classic Eggs Sandwiches & Sides

    • Two Eggs Only

      Eggs Only - No Meat, No Cheese
    • EC Sandwich

      Egg and Cheese
    • BE Sandwich

      Bacon and Eggs
    • SE Sandwich

      Sausage and Egg
    • HE Sandwich

      Ham and Egg
    • TE Sandwich

      Turkey and Egg
    • TBE Sandwich (Turkey Bacon & Egg)

      Turkey Bacon & Egg
    • BEC Sandwich

      Bacon Egg and Cheese
    • SEC Sandwich

      Sausage Egg and Cheese
    • HEC Sandwich

      Ham Egg and Cheese
    • TEC Sandwich

      Turkey Egg and Cheese
    • TBEC Sandwich (TurkeyBacon Egg & Cheese)

      TurkeyBacon Egg and Cheese
    • French Toast Bites

      French Toast Bites, Topped with Powdered Sugar\nSyrup on the Side
      $6.99
    • Side Of Bacon (4 Slices)

      4 Slices
      $4.25
    • Side Of Sliced Avocado

      Sliced Half Avocado
      $2.25
    • Side Of HashBrown

      $1.99
    • Kitchen Sink Breakfast Hero

      BIG Omelet with Turkey, Chicken, Bacon, Ham, Chorizo Sausage, Peppers, Onions, American Cheese on a 12in Hero. \n\n*Sorry no changes or substitutions on this*
      $9.49
    • Bacon Sandwich (6 Slices, No Eggs)

      6 Slices of our delicious Boars Head Crispy Bacon
    • Side Of Breakfast Potatoes

      Only Available Saturdays and Sundays
    • Gyro Egg Sandwich **NEW

      Grilled gryo meat with two eggs any style, melted havarti dill cheese and tzatziki sauce on a roll or your choice of bagel
  • Breakfast - Quesadilla

    • Quesadilla - Bacon Egg Cheese

      Served with our own made Roasted Salsa and Sour Cream\n\n*No Substituions*
      $7.99
    • Quesadilla - Mexicalli Style

      Scrambled Eggs, Chorizo Sausage, Grilled Peppers and Onions, Cheddar and Jack Cheese. Served with our homemade Roasted Salsa and Sour Cream\n\n*No Substituions*
      $8.99
  • Breakfast - Omelets

    • Create Your Own Omelet

    • Outwest Omelet

      Red and green peppers, red onions, grilled ham.
      $7.29
    • No Guilt Omelet

      Three egg whites, diced tomato, baby spinach, Alpine Lace cheese.
      $7.29
    • Cowboy Breakfast

      Sausage, ham, bacon, American cheese, sauteed button mushrooms.
      $8.99
  • Breakfast - Speciality Egg Sandwiches, Heros and Wraps

    • Sunrise Sandwich

      Three egg whites, avocado, bacon, Cheddar cheese, dash of hot sauce on a multigrain bagel.
      $7.99
    • Southampton Hobo Sandwich

      Two eggs, bacon, Pepper Jack cheese, hashbrown on a choice of roll or bagel.
    • Hungry Man Hero Plus Sandwich

      Three eggs any style, grilled ham, sausage and bacon, American cheese, on a hero.
    • Breakfast Reuben Sandwich

      Grilled pastrami with melted Swiss, fried eggs, Reuben sauce on a marble rye bagel.
      $8.99
    • Breakfast BLT Sandwich

      Two eggs, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
    • Breakfast Burrito

      Three scrambled eggs with diced chorizo sausage, avocado, Cheddar cheese, pico de gallo and hot sauce on a plain wrap.
      $8.49
    • Power Protein Wrap

      Three egg whites, baby spinach, grilled turkey, sliced tomato, peppers and Alpine Lace in a whole wheat wrap.
      $7.99
    • Healthy Start Plus Sandwich

      Three egg whites, sliced tomato, grilled turkey on a choice of bagel or roll.
    • Grecian Omlete Wrap

      Three scrambled eggs, baby spinach, Kalamata olives and Feta cheese on a Wrap
      $7.99
    • Kitchen Sink Hero

      BIG Omelet with Turkey, Chicken, Bacon, Ham, Chorizo Sausage, Peppers, Onions, American Cheese on a 12in Hero. \n\n*Sorry no changes or substitutions on this*
      $9.99
    • Brunchwich Sandwich **NEW

      Two Eggs, Hashbrown, Shaved Rib Eye Steak, Melted Cheddar Cheese with a Sriracha Mayo.\nWe recommended Over Medium Eggs with this sandwich : )\n\nSorry no ingredient substitutions.
    • Gyro Egg Sandwich **NEW

      Grilled gryo meat with two eggs any style, melted havarti dill cheese and tzatziki sauce on a roll or your choice of bagel
    • Green Eggs & Ham

      Egg Whites, Fresh Spinach, Ham and Cheddar on a Spinach Bagel
      $7.99
  • Muffins

    • Muffin

      $3.29
    • Mini Muffin Packages

      9 of our Fresh Baked Mini Muffins Packaged
      $4.99
    • Muffin Toasted W/ Butter

      $3.99
  • Bakery, Fruit & Dessert

    • Crumb Cake

      $2.89
    • Plain Pound Cake

      $2.50
    • Marble Pound Cake

      $2.50
    • Black & White Cookie

      $2.50
    • Pacakage Of Baked Brownies

      $4.89
    • Package Of Hahns Crumb Cake

      $4.99
    • Tates Cookies

      $4.99
    • M&M Large Cookie

      $2.39
    • Rainbow Sprinkle Large Cookie

      $2.39
    • Fruit Bowl 32oz

      $8.99
    • Strawberries & Cream Parfait

      $3.99
    • Granola Yogurt Parfait

    • Linzer Tart Cookie

      $2.49
    • Muffins

      $2.99
    • Rice Pudding

      Topped with Cinnamon Sugar (Individual Portion)
      $3.99
    • Christina's Cookies

      3 chocolate chip cookies baked fresh by Christina : )
  • Philly Cheesesteaks

    • Philly Cheesesteak

      Our Philly Cheesesteaks are made with 100% Roasted Rib Eye.
  • Lunch - Build Your Own Sandwich or Wrap

    • Egg Salad Sandwich

    • Tuna Salad Sandwich

    • Chicken Salad Sandwich

    • Veggie Tuna Sandwich

    • Country Chicken Sandwich

      Chicken Salad with Grapes Apples and Craisins
    • BLT

      6 Slices of Crispy Bacon on Bread of your Choice\nWith Lettuce and Tomato
    • Boars Head Oven Gold Turkey Sandwich

    • Boars Head Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich

    • Boars Head Cracked Pepper Turkey Sandwich

    • Boars Head Roast Beef Sandwich

    • Boars Head Salami Sandwich

    • Boars Head Pastrami Sandwich

    • Breaded Chicken Cutlet

    • Grilled Chicken Cutlet

    • Everything Seeded Chicken Cutlet *New

      Everything Seeded Breaded Chicken Cutlet
    • Grilled Cheese

    • Boars Head Deluxe Ham

    • Loaded Egg Salad ***NEW

      Egg Salad with Scallions and Bacon
  • Lunch - Specialty Wraps

    • Blue Ribbon Wrap

      Breaded chicken cutlet, savory ham, Havarti Dill cheese, lettuce and tomato with a dash of hot sauce.
      $9.99
    • Chicken Caesar Wrap

      Grilled chicken, chopped Romaine, shaved Parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing.
      $9.49
    • Strawberry Wrap

      *Boars head is temporarily not carrying honey turkey. Oven Gold Turkey will be used in place of honey turkey temporarily**\n\nHoney maple turkey, fresh sliced strawberries, Alpine Lace Swiss, lettuce and balsamic dressing.
      $9.99
    • Hummus Chicken Wrap

      Grilled chicken, hummus, Pepper Jack cheese, Corn, black beans, red onion, Romaine leaves, tomato and ranch dressing.
      $9.99
    • Chicken Bruschetta Wrap

      Marinated grilled chicken, fresh Mozzarella, balsamic tomato bruschetta, chopped Romaine lettuce.
      $9.99
    • Trendy Traveler Wrap

      Sliced avocado, tomato, green leaf lettuce, cucumber slices, red onion, hummus.
      $8.49
    • Italian Veggie Wrap

      Baby spinach, breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella, tomato bruschetta, grilled zucchini, grilled red pepper and grilled carrot.
      $9.49
    • Greek Chicken Wrap

      Marinated Grilled Chicken, Cherry Tomato, Cucumbers, Romaine Lettuce, Havarti Dill Cheese, and Cucumber Dill Sauce
      $9.99
    • Beef Gyro

      on grilled warm pita, lettuce, tomato, onion and our housemade tzatziki sauce
      $9.99
    • NEW** Italia Uno Sandwich

      Mortadella, Cappy Ham, Fresh Burrata, Chopped Pistacios, Pasticio Basil Pesto on Fresh Ciabatta Bread\n\n**No Changes No Substitutions**
      $11.99
  • Lunch - Speciality Sandwiches

    • BLT Sandwich

    • BLT Plus Sandwich

      Crispy bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing.
    • Tuscan Sandwich

      Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato on ciabatta roll.
      $9.49
    • Super Reuben Sandwich

      Grilled pastrami, melted Swiss, sauerkraut and Russian dressing on thick cut grilled rye bread served with a side of coleslaw and pickle.
      $10.99
    • The Supreme Everything Seeded Chicken Sandwich

      Hot Everything Seeded Chicken Cutlet with a smear of plain cream cheese, crispy bacon, lettuce and tomato on your choice of bread
    • Chipolte Chicken Salad Sandwich

      Chicken Salad, Chipolte Mayo, Grapes, Apples, Asiago Cheese, ciabatta roll
      $8.99
    • BBQ Bacon Chicken Sandwich

      Warm Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Crispy Bacon, Melted Cheddar with BBQ Sauce L&T
      $10.99
    • Texas Long Horn

      Grilled Boars Head Roast Beef, Colby Jack cheese, house made horseradish steak sauce, on a toasted roll.
    • Beef Gyro

      on grilled warm pita, lettuce, tomato, onion and our housemade tzatziki sauce
      $9.99
    • NEW** Italia Uno

      Mortadella, Cappy Ham, Fresh Burrata, Chopped Pistacios, Pasticio Basil Pesto on Fresh Ciabatta\n\n**No Changes No Substitutions**
      $11.99
  • Lunch - Specialty Heros

    • Turkey BLT Hero

      Oven Gold Turkey, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing.
      $10.49
    • Midwest Turkey BLT Hero

      Cracked Peppermill turkey, Pepper Jack cheese, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing.
      $10.49
    • Contemporary Italian

      Breaded eggplant, tomato bruschetta, cappy ham, sopressata, Provolone, lettuce.
      $10.99
    • French Dip Hero

      Hot roast beef, melted Mozzarella and Swiss cheese, on a toasted garlic hero with a side of au jus dipping sauce.
      $13.99
    • Italia Uno

      Mortadella, Cappy Ham, Fresh Burrata, Chopped Pistacios, Pasticio Basil Pesto on Fresh Ciabatta Bread\n\n**No Changes No Substitutions**
      $11.99
  • Chopped Salad Bar

    • Nutty Chicken Salad

      Mixed greens, grapes, apples, Bleu cheese, grilled chicken, walnut dressing.\n\n*Due to a shortage and price increase of lettuce and greens this week there is a temporary price increase on our chopped salads*
      $10.99
    • Garden Salad

      Mixed Greens, Tomato, carrot, cucumber, red onion, balsamic vinaigrette.\n\n*Due to a shortage and price increase of lettuce and greens this week there is a temporary price increase on our chopped salads*
      $9.49
    • Classic Caesar Salad

      Chopped Romaine, shaved Parmesan cheese, house made croutons, red onion, Caesar dressing.
      $9.99
    • Greek Salad

      Tomato, red onion, Cucumbers, Kalamata olives, peppers, Feta cheese, Greek vinaigrette.\n\n*Due to a shortage and price increase of lettuce and greens this week there is a temporary price increase on our chopped salads*
      $9.99
    • Santa Fe Salad

      Romaine Lettuce Blackened Chicken, Black beans, corn, avocado, tomato, red onion, cucumber, avocado ranch dressing.
      $10.99
    • Create Your Own Salad

      Up to 5 Choppings mixed in\n\n\n*Due to a shortage and price increase of lettuce and greens this week there is a temporary price increase on our chopped salads*
      $10.99
    • Chef Salad

      Romaine Lettuce, Cucumber, Tomato, Carrot, Hard Boiled Egg, Roast Beef, Turkey, Ham, Swiss and American Cheese\n\n*Due to a shortage and price increase of lettuce and greens this week there is a temporary price increase on our chopped salads*
      $12.99
  • Salads by the Half LB

    • Tuna Salad 1/2 LB

      $6.59
    • Egg Salad 1/2 LB

      $4.99
    • Chicken Salad 1/2 LB

      $6.59
    • Country Chicken Salad 1/2 LB

      $6.59
    • Veggie Tuna Salad 1/2 LB

      $6.59
    • Potato Salad 1/2 LB

      $4.59
    • Macaroni Salad 1/2 LB

      $4.59
    • Coleslaw 1/2 LB

      $4.59
    • Greek Penne Pasta Salad (1/2 LB)

      Penne Pasta, Fresh Spinach, Feta, Peppers, Red Onion, Fresh Dill, Greek Vinaigrette\n(No Substitutions)
      $4.59
    • Buffalo Chicken Salad 1/2 LB

      $5.99
    • Mediterranean Chick Pea Salad 1/2LB

      Chick Peas, Fresh Dill , Feta, Peppers, Red Onion, Red Wine Vinegrette\n(No Substitutions)
      $4.59
    • Bow Tie Pasta Salad 1/2 LB

      Seared Buttery Mushrooms, Broccoli Florets, Light Garlic and Oil and Lots of Fresh Parsley
      $4.49
    • Kale, Broccoli Slaw And Quinoa 1/2 LB

      A slaw of Broccoli Kale and Quinoa, shredded cabbage and carrot, chick peas and kernel corn tossed with a honey apple cider vinaigrette
      $4.59
    • Loaded Egg Salad ***NEW

      Creamy Egg Salad with Bacon and Scallions
      $5.29
    • Pistacio Basil Pesto Pasta

      Cellentani Pasta tossed with Pistachio Basil Pesto, Shaved Parm and Arugula
      $4.79
    • Summer Orzo Salad LB

      Orzo, fresh spinach, peas, scallions, fresh parsley, dill, feta cheese with a Lemon Vinaigrette
      $4.50
  • Cold Cuts & Cheese (Boars Head)

    • Boars Head Deluxe Ham

      $6.50
    • Oven Gold Turkey

      $6.25
    • Roast Beef

      $8.99
    • Boars Head Peppermill Turkey

      $6.50
    • Salami

      $6.50
    • Honey Maple Turkey

      $6.50
    • Yellow American

      $5.25
    • Swiss

      $5.99
    • Cheddar

      $5.59
    • Muenster

      $5.59
    • Provolone

      $5.59
    • Asiago

      $5.59
    • Mozzarella

      $5.75
    • Alpine Lace Swiss

      $5.59
    • White American

      $5.25
  • Chips and Snacks

    • Wise Chips (2.75oz)

      $2.79
    • Sour Patch Kids (16oz Package)

      $3.99
    • DeepRiver 2oz Bag

      $2.99
    • Wise Chips (Large Bag)

      $5.29
    • HALS Chips & Popcorn (Large Bag)

      $3.29
    • HALS Chips And Popcorn (Single Serve 2oz)

      $1.89
    • NorthFork Potato Chip (Large)

      $3.99
    • NorthFork Potato Chips (Small)

      $2.99
  • ZUMI Fresh Juices and Waters

    • Zumi Infused Water

      Filter Water with Cucumber Lemon Strawberries Mint
      $2.99
  • Grocery Items (Milk, Eggs, Juice, Paper Towels)

    • Half Gallon Of Milk

      $3.99
    • Breakstones Butter

      $5.99
    • Boars Head Bacon

      $9.99
    • Tropicana OJ (46oz)

      46oz
      $6.49
    • Paper Towels

      210 Sheets
      $2.99
    • Toilet Paper (Max 2 Rolls Per Customer Per Day)

      Commercial Grade - Sorry not the soft kind :)\n\nMax 2 rolls per customer per day
      $1.99
    • Package Of Romaine Lettuce

      3 Per Pack
      $3.99
    • Dozen Eggs

      Carton of Eggs (Dozen)
      $6.29
    • Arizona Arnold Palmer (Gallon)

      Gallon
      $4.99
    • Whipped Cream Cheese (8oz)

      The Better Bagel uses Real Philadelphia Cream Cheese.
      $5.59
    • Cherry Tomatoes (Pint)

      $3.99
    • Red Onion (Whole Onion)

      $1.49
    • Everything Seed Topping (Toasted)

      Great for topping salads, sandwiches, etc
      $2.99
    • Everything Seeds (For Cooking)

      Great for making everything crusted chicken, pork, etc
      $2.99
  • Beverages and Coffee

    • Box Of Joe

      Includes 12 cups, milk, half & half, and sweeteners. Tea option includes variety of tea bags.
      $22.99
    • Fountain Iced Tea

      Our deli fountain Ice Tea \n*There is an option for our Lemonades - please order using the option if you want Lemonade*
    • Tropicana

      Due to limited supply from vendors we are limited to NO Pulp and Apple Juice only
      $2.75
    • Arizona

      20 oz.
      $2.89
    • Chocolate Milks

      Choose Brand and Flavor
      $2.59
    • Gatorade 20oz

      20 oz.
      $2.59
    • Hot Coffee

      HAZELNUT CREAMER IS OUT OF STOCK\n\nToasted Coconut *Sold Out*
    • Iced Coffee

      Our iced coffee is Cold Brewed Daily : )\n\n**HAZELNUT CREAMER IS OUT OF STOCK**
    • Poland Spring Water

    • Snapple

      20 oz.
      $2.89
    • Soda

      20 oz.
      $2.89
    • V-8

      $2.59
    • Vitamin Water

      20 oz.
      $2.75
    • Hot Tea

    • Joe Tea

      $2.89
    • Boylan Soda Pop (Bottle)

      20 oz.
      $1.99
    • Boylan Soda Pop (4 Pack)

      $6.99
    • Fresh Squeezed Lemonade

      Fresh Squeezed Daily! You have to try it!
    • Celsius

      12 oz Can
      $2.99
  • SOUPS

    • Today's Soup Wednesday 1/29

      Choose Soup Selections and Size\nSoups are available 10:30am to 3:30pm Daily

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Giacomo Jacks
Giacomo Jacks
4.3
(78 Reviews)
Seafood
Liam's Landing
Liam's Landing
4.6
(129 Reviews)
Restaurant
Toomey's Tavern
Toomey's Tavern
4.4
(414 Reviews)
Bar, Restaurant
Luigi's Italian Deli
Luigi's Italian Deli
4.8
(79 Reviews)
Deli
The Peninsula Cafe
The Peninsula Cafe
5.0
(3 Reviews)
Bar & grill
Philly Pretzel Factory
Philly Pretzel Factory
4.2
(72 Reviews)
Bakery
Lazy Lobster
Lazy Lobster
Restaurant
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
4.3
(210 Reviews)
Juice shop, Breakfast, Cafe
Mercato Kitchen & Cocktails
Mercato Kitchen & Cocktails
4.5
(516 Reviews)
Italian

ยฉ 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms