The Bay Restaurant Menu

342 E Silver Spring Dr, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217
  • Appetizers

    • Buffalo Cauliflower Bites (V)

      Zesty battered cauliflower served with celery, carrots & choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressings
      $10.50
    • Artichoke Dip (V, GF)

      A delicious blend of artichoke, basil & cheeses served with corn chips
      $10.95
    • Hummus Platter (V, VG, GF)

      Chickpea hummus served with cucumbers, celery, carrots, and corn chips
      $10.00
    • Basil Mozzarella Sticks (V)

      Mozzarella cheese & fresh basil wrapped in a wonton skin & served with pizza sauce | 4 per order
      $11.00
    • Roasted Veggies (V, GF)

      Roasted vegetables served with red pepper sauce
      $11.00
    • Chips & Dip (V)

      Fried-to-order potato chips & housemade onion dip
      $10.75
    • Crispy Chicken Tenders

      Four crispy breaded chicken tenders with your choice of ranch, bay buffalo, BBQ, or honey mustard
      $14.75
    • New England Salmon Cakes

      A tasty spin on the traditional crab cake served with a rémoulade | 4 per order
      $14.00
    • Chicken Wings

      10 Wings spun in your choice of BBQ, or Bay Buffalo sauce. Served with celery, carrots & choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressings
      $16.25
    • Bay Brussels Sprouts

      Crispy fried Brussels sprouts, mandarin oranges, roasted pepitas, sunflower and sesame seeds, drizzled with a white balsamic and orange gastrique
      $9.50
  • Salads

    • Cobb (GF)

      Romaine with cherry tomatoes, grilled chicken, Granny Smith apples, candied walnuts, sliced avocado, blue cheese crumbles & boiled egg, served with choice of dressing
      $15.00
    • Oriental Chicken

      Grilled chicken breast, romaine, red & green cabbage, carrots, mandarin oranges, red peppers, nuts, ramen & sunflower seeds, served with choice of dressing
      $15.25
    • Grilled Chicken Caesar

      Grilled chicken breast, Parmesan cheese, herbed croutons & house-made Caesar dressing
      $15.50
    • Salmon* (GF)

      Salmon filet, spinach, roasted beets, grapefruit & mandarin oranges, served with horseradish dressing
      $15.00
    • Southwest

      Southwestern spiced chicken, romaine, black beans, tomatoes, corn, red onion, tortilla strips, red onion, & cheddar-jack cheese. Recommended with Southwest dressing or choice of dressing
      $16.25
    • Crispy Buffalo Chicken

      Romaine, crispy chicken tenders, buffalo sauce, tomatoes, blue cheese crumbles, celery, red onions, and choice of dressing
      $15.25
    • Strawberry (GF)

      Spinach, strawberry, Granny Smith apples, mandarin oranges, walnuts, mint, goat cheese and choice of dressing.
      $13.50
    • Asparagus And Sweet Pea

      Romaine, seasoned sweet peas and asparagus, sliced cucumber, cherry tomato, goat cheese, and a dollop of homemade olive tapenade
      $14.00
  • Sandwiches

    • Milwaukee Cheesesteak

      Toasted Turano hoagie bun loaded with grilled red peppers, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, chopped steak, garlic mayo, topped with smoky provolone cheese
      $15.50
    • Memphis Style Pulled Pork

      Pulled pork smoked for 15 hours topped with creamy coleslaw, BBQ sauce & pickled onions, served on a toasted brioche bun
      $13.00
    • Buffalo Chicken

      Crispy breaded chicken breast with lettuce, celery, Swiss cheese, Bay Buffalo Sauce & ranch dressing, served on a toasted brioche bun
      $15.95
    • Cubano

      Thin sliced ham, smoked pulled pork, Swiss cheese, pickle, and house mustard on a Breadsmith hoagie roll
      $15.00
  • Pizzas

    • Supreme

      Pepperoni, sausage, black olives, red peppers, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, cheddar-jack cheese blend & house-made pizza sauce
      $20.00
    • Margherita(V)

      A thin layer of garlic oil, our housemade pizza sauce topped with tomatoes, basil & fresh mozzarella
      $19.00
    • Sausage & Pepperoni

      Sausage, pepperoni, cheddar-jack cheese blend & house-made pizza sauce
      $19.00
    • BBQ Chicken

      Chicken, BBQ sauce, bacon, red onion, cheddar-jack cheese blend & cilantro
      $19.00
  • Friday Fish Fry

    • Cod

      Cod available | Three hand-battered cod filets, tartar sauce & coleslaw, served with rye bread, lemon & choice of fries, baked potato, or chips
      $17.95
    • Perch

      Baked available | Three hand breaded cornmeal perch filets, tartar sauce & coleslaw, served with rye bread, lemon & choice of fries, baked potato, or chips
      $17.95
  • Pasta & More

    • Classic Italian Lasagna

      Layers of lean ground beef, Italian sausage, Parmesan/Romano cheese blend, mozzarella, pasta & house-made tomato sauce. Served with Garlic Bread
      $14.50
    • Chicken Pesto Caprese

      Cavatappi pasta, chicken, basil pesto, cherry tomatoes, garlic cream sauce, fresh mozzarella, topped with balsamic glaze. Served with Garlic Bread
      $17.00
    • The Mustache Twirler Chicken Pasta

      Cavatappi pasta with red peppers, green peppers, cashews, onions, andouille sausage, black olives & chicken in a zesty Cajun cream sauce. Served with Garlic Bread
      $15.00
    • Cedar-Planked Salmon* (GF)

      Roasted salmon filet served with seasonal roasted veggies, rice & verde sauce
      $23.00
    • Tofu Peanut Satay (V, VG)

      Sautéed marinated tofu, pea pods, roasted red peppers, & peanut sauce served over Basmati rice
      $14.00
    • Lemon Pepper Dill

      Cavatappi, seasoned sweet peas and asparagus, red onion, parmesan, chopped bacon, topped with goat cheese
      $14.50
  • BBQ Saturdays

    • Hickory Smoked BBQ Ribs Saturday Only

      Dry-rubbed Baby back pork ribs smoked in-house for over 7 hours, finished with Kansas City-style BBQ sauce. Served with: corn bread and choice of two sides: mac-n-cheese, coleslaw, baked potato, fries or chips
      $20.50
    • BBQ Rib, Pulled Pork And Rib Tip Combo Saturday Only

      A quarter rack of baby back pork ribs, pulled pork, and lemon pepper smoked wings with Kansas City-style BBQ sauce | Served with: corn bread and choice of two sides: mac-n-cheese, coleslaw, baked potato, fries or chips
      $28.50
  • Burgers and Chicken

    • Standard Topping

      Lettuce, tomato, & onion
      $13.95
    • Bay Stack

      Cheddar cheese, deep-fried sliced onion rings & creamy onion dip
      $15.95
    • Bay

      Topped with a fried egg, bacon & Bay Buffalo sauce
      $15.00
    • Mushroom And Swiss

      Swiss cheese, sautéed mushrooms & garlic mayo
      $15.95
    • The American

      American cheese, onion, bacon & garlic mayo
      $15.95
    • Impossible Plant Based Burger

      Love meat? Eat meat. Impossible™ delivers all the flavor, aroma & beefiness of meat from cows | Add cheese $0.75 | Additional Topping $2 | GF without bun
      $15.00
    • Roasted Poblano And Black Bean Burger

      ROASTED POBLANO AND BLACK BEAN BURGER Oven roasted poblano peppers, black beans & wild rice with chilies, cumin, crimini mushrooms, roasted corn, roasted red peppers, & caramelized onions, topped with mayo. GF without bun
      $13.75
    • The Big Game Barbeque Burger

      1/2 pound burger patty made with equal parts boar, bison, elk, and wagyu beef, topped with two slices of house-smoked brisket, cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce, bacon, and sauteed onion
      $20.00
    • Olive & Goat Cheese

      Olive tapenade, goat cheese, spring greens, and tomato
      $15.95
  • Desserts

    • Caramel Apple Deep Dish Pie

      Buttery caramel and toffee-studded custard hug fresh Granny Smith apples piled high in a melt-in-the-mouth shortbread crust
      $7.00
    • Snickers Peanut Butter Pie

      Peanut butter graham cracker crust filled with layers of chocolate ganache and peanut butter mouse topped with whipped cream rosettes and tiny peanut butter cups
      $7.00
    • Turtle Cheesecake

      Chocolate chips, pecans, and caramel…the ever-popular flavor combination nesting on caramel cheesecake with a chocolate cookie crumb crust
      $8.00
    • Flourless Chocolate Cake

      Rich flourless chocolate cake served with whipped cream & fresh berries | GF
      $7.00
  • Entree

    • Grilled Cheese

      $6.95
    • Hot Buttered Pasta

      $6.95
    • Mac And Cheese

      $7.95
    • Cheese Pizza

      $7.95
    • Mini Corn Dogs

      $7.95
    • Noodles With Red Sauce And Mozzarella

      $7.95
    • Pepperoni Pizza

      $8.95
    • Sausage Pizza

      $8.95
    • Salmon

      $8.95
    • Crispy Chicken Tenders

      $8.95
  • Sides

    • Chips

    • French Fries

    • Mandarin Oranges

    • Carrots And Celery

    • Granny Smith Apple Slices

  • Lunch Sandwiches

    • Grilled Cheese

      Aged cheddar and Muenster cheese toasted to perfection. Make it a BAY DELUXE by adding crisp bacon & tomato +$2
      $10.00
    • B.L.A.T

      Bacon, lettuce, avocado, tomato, and garlic mayo, served on toasted Breadsmith bread
      $13.00
    • Bearded Brunch Sandwich

      Thinly sliced ham, American cheese, garlic mayo, and egg over hard, served on toasted Breadsmith bread
      $12.00
  • Ales

    • Bell’s Two Hearted 7% (IPA)

      $6.75
    • Blue Moon 5.4% (Wheat)

      $5.75
    • Dog Fish Head IPA 6.0%

      $6.50
    • Fat Tire 5.2% (Amber)

      $6.25
    • Lagunitas IPA 6.2%

      $5.95
    • Lakefront IPA 6.9%

      $5.95
    • Louie’s Demise 4.8% (Amber)

      $5.95
    • Spotted Cow 4.8% (Farmhouse)

      $6.50
  • Porter

    • Edmund Fitzgerald 5.8%

      $5.95
  • Stout

    • Guinness 4.2%

      $7.25
  • Hefeweizen

    • Hacker Pschorr 5.5%

      $6.25
  • Lagers

    • Bud Light

      4.2%
      $5.00
    • Coors Light

      4.2%
      $5.00
    • Corona

      4.6%
      $5.75
    • Hamm's

      4.6%
      $4.00
    • High Life

      4.6%
      $5.00
    • Miller 64

      3.0%
      $5.00
    • Pabst Tall Boy

      4.74%
      $4.75
    • Riverwest Stein

      5.6% (Amber)
      $5.95
  • BEER ON TAP

    • Stella Artois

      5.0%
      $7.25
    • Third Space Happy Place

      5.3% APA
      $6.75
    • Third Space Upward Spiral

      6.5% (IPA)
      $6.75
    • Deschutes Black Butte Porter

      5.5%
      $6.75
    • Allagash White

      5.2% Belgian-Style wheat
      $7.25
  • NA, Cider, Seltzers

    • Woodchuck Granny Smith Cider

      5.0%
      $6.50
    • Heineken Zero

      Non- alcoholic
      $5.25
    • White Claw Hard Seltzer

      5.0% (110 calories)
      $5.50
  • White

    • Sauvignon Blanc – 2019 Peter Yealands (Marlborough)

      Stone fruit, guava with fresh, aromatic herbal notes. The palate has fruit that is balanced with a long, crisp, mineral finish
      $11.00
    • Chardonnay – 2018 William Hill (Napa)

      Ripe tree fruit, baked apple, supported by layers of caramel, brown spice, and slightly toasted oak. The wine has a silky feel with moderate sweetness
      $11.00
    • Pinot Grigio – 2018 Three Thieves (California)

      Rich pineapple, citrus, green apple & hints of creamy vanilla and spice. The wine has a full-bodied palate & crisp finish
      $10.00
    • Riesling – 2016 Chateau St. Michelle (Columbia Valley,WA)

      Crisp apple aromas and flavors, some mineral notes, light acidity and a great balance of sweet & dry
      $10.00
    • Ménage À Trois Prosecco (Italy)

      Refreshing citrus and bright green apple flavors with a crisp, clean finish
      $9.00
  • Rose

    • 2019 Bieler Père & Fils (France)

      Classic Provence rosé with a delicate balance of floral, herbal and wild red fruit
      $11.00
  • Red

    • Malbec – 2017 Doña Paula (Mendoza)

      Aromas of black fruit, violets and spices, with some mineral and graphite notes. Great balance and freshness with soft tannins and good concentration and structure
      $12.00
    • Pinot Noir – 2018 Angeline (California)

      A wealth of aromas including cranberries, maraschino cherries & orange zest
      $11.00
    • Cabernet – 2016 Joel Gott (California)

      Flavors of red fruit, black cherry, and blackberry. Hints of vanilla, clove & a touch of baking spice to support the fruit
      $12.00
    • Red Blend – 2017 Ted Red (California)

      Flavors of bing cherries, crushed black berries, and ripe fig
      $11.00
  • Chardonnay

    • 2016 William Hill (Napa)

      Ripe tree fruit, baked apple, supported by layers of caramel, brown spice, and slight toasted oak. Silky feel with moderate sweetness
      $11.00
    • 2015 Buena Vista (North Coast)

      Ripe tree fruit, sour lemon, supported by layers of pineapple, and slight toasted oak. Silky feel with some sweetness
      $30.00
  • Pinot Grigio

    • 2016 Three Thieves (California)

      Rich pineapple, citrus, and green apple with hints of creamy vanilla and spice. Full-bodied palate and crisp finish
      $10.00
  • Sauvignon Blanc

    • 2016 Whitehaven (Marlborough)

      Citrus aromas with peach, gooseberry, and ripe tropical fruits
      $30.00
    • 2018 Peter Yealands (Marlborough)

      Stone fruit and guava with fresh, aromatic herbal notes. Balanced with a long, crisp, mineral finish
      $11.00
    • 2019 Ponga (Marlborough)

      Ripe citrus and tropical fruit with white peach and grapefruit. Bright aromas are accented with chalky, mineral tone finish
      $30.00
  • Reisling

    • 2016 Chateau St. Michelle (Columbia Valley, WA)

      Crisp apple aromas and flavors with some mineral notes, light acidity, and a balance of sweet and dry
      $10.00
    • 2018 Clean Slate (Mosel, Germany)

      Mineral notes with a hint of spiciness and fresh, peach flavors. Clean, fresh flavor
      $24.00
  • Prosecco

    • Ménage À Trois (Italy)

      Delicate bubbles releasing a seductive floral fragrance. Refreshing citrus and bright green apple flavors. Crisp, clean finish
      $9.00
  • Rosé

    • 2017 Bieler Pere And Fils (France)

      Classic Provence Rosé with a delicate balance of floral, herbal, and wild red fruit
      $11.00
  • Reds/Red Blends

    • 2015 Hey Mambo (California)

      A blend of Zinfandel, Merlot, Barbera, Petite Sirah, Ruby Cabernet, and Grenache with cherry and vanilla bean notes
      $11.00
    • 2013 Double Decker (California)

      A blend of Cabernet Sauvignon, Petite Syrah, and Barbera with flavors of blackberry, black cherry, and plum. Robust, yet smooth finish
      $25.00
  • Cabernet

    • 2016 Joel Gott (California)

      Flavors of red fruit, black cherry, and blackberry. Hints of vanilla, clove, a touch of baking spice to support the fruit
      $12.00
  • Malbec

    • 2017 Punto Final (Mendoza)

      A deep concentration of ruby red color with notes of blackberry, blueberry, and cassis flavors. Full structure, with firm tannins, complete the finish
      $30.00
    • 2017 Dona Paula (Mendoza)

      Intense violet color with aromas of black fruit, violets, and spices. Some mineral and graphite notes. Soft tannins and persistent finish
      $30.00
  • Pinot Noir

    • 2016 Imagery (Sonoma)

      Firm structure of tannins and bright acidity with ripe black cherry and tea flavors. Good concentration and medium body
      $30.00
    • 2016 Angeline (California)

      Aromas of cranberries, maraschino cherries, and orange zest
      $11.00
  • House Cocktails

    • Wisconsin Old Fashioned

      Muddled cherry & orange in demerara syrup with choice of brandy/bourbon/whiskey & Angostura bitters, sweet or sour | (*Pitcher available for $25.00)
      $10.00
    • Grapefruit Martini

      Absolut Grapefruit, St. Germain, lemon juice, grapefruit juice & simple syrup
      $11.00
    • Moscow Mule

      Stolichnaya Vodka, lime juice, ginger beer & Angostura bitters
      $9.00
    • Dark & Stormy

      Gosling’s Dark Rum, lime juice, ginger beer & Angostura bitter
      $9.00
    • Cosmopolitan

      Stolichnaya Vodka, triple sec, lime juice, simple syrup & cranberry juice
      $10.00
  • Cocktail Of The Month List – 2022

    • January: Mochatini

      Vanilla vodka, Kahlua, crème de cacoa
    • February: Peanut Butter Cup Martini

      Skrewball PB whiskey, Godiva chocolate liqueur, half & half | with a peanut butter cup
    • April: Purple Rain (“Lavender Lemon Drop”)

      Absolut Citron, lavender simple syrup, lemon juice, creme de violette, with sugar rim
    • May: Blue Duke

      Absolut Citron, Blue Curacao, simple syrup, lemon juice , and a splash of cranberry juice
    • June: Aperol Mist

      Aperol, lemon juice, seasonal wheat beer and a lemon wedge
    • July: Electric Iced Tea (“Blue Long Island”)

      Vodka, gin, rum, tequila, blue Curacao, sour mix, and Sierra Mist
    • August: Brandy Slush

      A Cheryl McMahon secret family recipe of brandy slushy mix, and Sierra Mist
    • September: Summer’s End

      Vodka, Malibu, triple sec, and pineapple juice
    • October: Witches Brew (“Orange Cosmo”)

      Absolut Mandarin, orange juice, triple sec, simple syrup, lemon juice, and black sugar rim
    • November: Caramel Apple Mimosa

      Cinnamon sugar, caramel, Stoli Karamel, apple cider and Prosecco
    • December: Eggnog Martini

      Eggnog , amaretto, vanilla vodka and a dash of nutmeg
  • Vodka

    • Absolut

    • Absolut Citron

    • Absolut Grapefruit

    • Absolut Lime

    • Absolut Mandarin

    • Absolut Pears

    • Absolut Peppar

    • Belvedere

    • Dripping Springs Orange

    • Grey Goose

    • Grey Goose LaPoire

    • Grey Goose Citron

    • Ketel One

    • Pinnacle

    • Rehorst

    • Rehorst Citrus & Honey

    • Stolichnaya

    • Stoli Razberi

    • Stoli Vanil

    • Stoli Salted Karamel

    • Tito’s

    • Blue Ash Farm Cherry Vodka

  • Gin

    • Beefeater

    • Bombay Sapphire

    • Hendrik’s

    • Rehorst

    • Tanqueray

  • Tequila

    • Casa Noble Reposado

    • Casa Pacific Reposado

    • Casamigos Blanco

    • Corzo Anejo

    • Don Julio Blanco

    • Jose Cuervo Gold

    • Lunaluz Blanco

    • Patron Anejo

    • Patron Reposado

    • Patron Silver

  • Rum

    • Appleton Estate

    • Bacardi

    • Bacardi Anejo

    • Bacardi Gold

    • Bacardi Limon

    • Banks

    • Captain Morgan

    • Cruzan Passion Fruit

    • Cruzan Pineapple

    • Gosling’s Dark

    • Malibu

    • Mount Gay

    • Oronoco Plantation O.F.T.D

    • Smith & Cross

  • Brandy

    • Benedictine & Brandy

    • Bavet

    • Korbel

  • Whiskey

    • Basil Hayden’s

    • Buffalo Trace

    • Bulleit Bourbon

    • Bulleit Rye

    • Calumet Farm

    • Canadian Club

    • Crown Royal

    • Jack Daniels

    • Jack Honey

    • Jameson

    • Jim Beam

    • Kessler

    • Knob Creek

    • Knob Creek Smoked Maple

    • Maker’s Mark

    • Michter’s Bourbon

    • Old Forester

    • Seagram’s 7

    • Seagram’s VO Skrewball

    • Straight Edge

    • Slow & Low/Rock & Rye

    • Templeton Rye

    • The Knot

    • Tullamore Dew

    • Woodford Reserve

    • Blue Ash Farm Honey Bourbon

  • Scotch

    • Arran Malt 10 Year

    • Balvenie 17 Year

    • Glenfiddich 12 Year

    • Glenfiddich 15 Year

    • Highland Park 12 Year

    • Highland Park 18 Year

    • Johnny Walker Black

    • Johnny Walker Red

    • Lagavulin 16 Year

    • Laphroaig 10 Year

    • Macallan 10 Year

    • Monkey Shoulder

    • Oban

    • Talisker

  • Gameday Features

    • Absolut Peppar Bloody Mary

      Bloody Mary mix, Absolut Peppar, celery salt, pickle, olive, and choice of small tap chaser.
      $9.50
    • Absolut Moscow Mule

      Absolut vodka, lime juice, ginger beer & Angostura bitters
      $9.00
    • Absolut Pear Mule

      Absolut Pear vodka, apple cider, ginger beer & Angostura bitters
      $9.00
    • Absolut Cider Mule

      Absolut vodka, apple cider, ginger beer & Angostura bitters
      $9.00
    • Absolut Grapefruit Martini

      Absolut Grapefruit, St. Germain, lemon juice, grapefruit juice & simple syrup
      $11.00

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms