Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar Menu

Smoked fresh catch. Served with house-made crostinis.

Fresh calamari and banana peppers cooked light and crispy. Served with a side of chilled marinara.

Crispy fried green tomatoes topped with corn pico, balsamic reduction, and goat cheese.

Tender chunks of Florida gator tail, fries, or blackened.

Gulf grouper, fried, or blackened, and served with our house-made tartar sauce.

Gulf shrimp tossed in our house-made Buffalo sauce.

Crispy hand battered shrimp rolled in fresh coconut.

Legendary Bahamian Mamashaw's very own recipe.

Crispy Brussels sprouts, balsamic reduction, Azar sausage, bacon, caramelized onions and goat cheese crumbles. Add protein for an additional charge. Gluten-free available.

5 pieces. Fresh scallops topped with lemon, tarragon and smoked Gouda cream. Gluten-free available.

5 eggs topped with smoked Buffalo bacon crumble.

Seared tuna, seaweed salad, corn pico, avocado, and topped with cucumber wasabi.

Served hot or cold.

6 gulf oysters topped with butter, garlic, red peppers, Parmesan, and Romano.

6 gulf oysters topped with bacon, cheddar, and jalapenos.

Spring mix, marinated tomatoes, pickled onions, shredded cheese, and croutons. Add protein for an additional charge.

Halved romaine, croutons, cherry tomatoes, and Parmesan. Add protein for an additional charge.

Halved romaine, pressed egg, smoked bacon, cherry tomatoes, blue cheese crumbles, balsamic reduction, and bleu cheese dressing. Add protein for an additional charge.

Spring mix, candid walnuts, roasted beets, goat cheese, marinated tomatoes, topped with balsamic reduction, and drizzled with honey. Add protein for an additional charge. Gluten-free available.

Choice of shrimp or Mahi in 2 flour tortillas with spring mix, marinated tomatoes, corn pico, shredded cheese, pickled onions, and house-made taco sauce.

2/3 lb. double-smashed patty, American cheese, spring mix, marinated tomatoes, pickled onion, pickles and house-made burger sauce.

Gluf shrimp, smoked bacon, Azar sausage, and onion over cheese grits. Gluten-free available.

Creamy Maryland style with hints of tangy mustard, and zesty lemon, and topped with corn pico.

Fresh caught snapper, scored, breaded, and lightly fried.

Fresh blackened grouper served over bacon, Azar sausage, onions, and cheese grits. Gluten-free available.

Fresh ahi tuna, mildy hot poke sauce, and sticky rice.

Blackned gulf shrimp, capellini pasta tossed in garlic, white wine, and butter sauce.

White meat chicken strips and blackened or fried.

Fresh gulf chrimp, gulf select oysters, cold water scallops, fresh, and house-made stuffed deviled crab.

Freshly shucked.

Choose 2 of any seafood options. Comes with 2 sides.

Choose 3 of any seafood options. Comes with 2 sides.

Gluten-free available.

Gluten-free available.

Gluten-free available.

Gluten-free available.

4 layers of double chocolate heaven made locally by TC Bakery.

3 eggs, Azar sausage or bacon, biscuit, sausage gravy, and cheese grits.

Crispy potatoes, bacon, Azar sausage, corn pico, cheddar cheese, scrambled eggs, and bang bang sauce drizzle.

Whipped cream, mixed berry jam, and maple syrup. Served with 2 scrambled eggs.

Gulf shrimp, smoked bacon, Azar sausage, and onions over cheese grits. Gluten-free available.

Fresh blackened grouper served over bacon, Azar sausage, onions, and cheese grits. Gluten-free available.

Halved biscuit topped with fried green tomatoes, eggs, Maryland style Crab Cake, and hollandaise.

Sauteed shrimp, sausage, red peppers, onion, cheddar cheese, scrambled eggs, topped with house-made taco sauce, and hollandaise.

Baked omelette with sauteed shrimp, crab meat, red onion, tomato, and cream cheese. Gluten-free available.

Dipped in vanilla custard, grilled to perfection, and topped with whipped cream. Served with 2 scrambled eggs.