Sydney's Sweet Shoppe Menu

4.7

(125+ Reviews)

10" Whole Pies (REG)Half Pies 10" Gluten Free Pies 10" Sugar Free Pies 10" Vegan Pies 5" Mini Pies Sugar Free 5" Mini Pies Vegan 5" Mini Pies Mix & Match 4 Pack (REGULAR)Mix & Match 4 Pack (GLUTEN FREE)Mix & Match 4 Pack (VEGAN)Cakes Cheesecakes Pie Add-Ons Greeting Cards by Jon Reis

10" Whole Pies (REG)
All 10" pies feature our signature flaky and tender crust
- 10" Dutch Apple
  Traditional Apple pie with an added buttery richness of a crunchy crumb topping
  $35.00
- 10" Cherry
  Old-fashioned tart cherry pie topped with a lattice crust DISCLAIMER: Although every care has been taken to remove all cherry pits from our cherries, some may still remain. This product may occasionally contain a cherry pit and we therefore cannot be held liable for any found within the product when purchased.
  $35.00
- 10" Mixed Berry
  The perfect summer blend of the freshest blackberries, blueberries, and raspberries baked with a top crust
  $35.00
- 10" Blueberry
  Fresh juicy blueberries bursting with flavor baked into our signature flaky crust
  $35.00
- 10" Double Crust Apple
  Our traditional Apple pie baked with a double crust
  $35.00
- 10" Chocolate Cream
  Rich chocolate cream filling, layered with whipped topping and garnished with chocolate shavings
  $32.00
- 10" Banana Cream
  Rich banana cream filling poured over a bed of fresh bananas, layered with whipped cream, and dusted with graham cracker crumbs
  $32.00
- 10" Coconut Cream
  Rich coconut cream filling layered with whipped topping and garnished with freshly toasted coconut
  $32.00
- 10" Lemon
  The perfect balance of sweet and tangy lemon that melts in your mouth! Topped with whipped cream.
  $34.00
- 10" Pecan
  Soft and smooth filling topped with crunchy pecans.
  $32.00
- 10" Bourbon Chocolate Pecan
  A creamy, chocolate-bourbon filling topped with a delightful crunch of toasted pecans.
  $35.00
- 10" Sweet Potato
  Lush sweet potato paired with the perfect balance of creamy filling and fall spices
  $35.00
- 10" Caramel Apple
  Our signature Dutch Apple Pie drizzled in homemade caramel sauce! Serve this warm with Vanilla ice cream to enjoy even more.
  $40.00
- 10" Lemon Meringue
  Our Lemon Pie but better! Now featuring Italian Meringue. (We recommend eating this pie within 48 hours of purchase)
  $36.00
- 10" Key Lime (FROZEN)
  Graham cracker crust filled with a smooth, tart, lime filling. Pie is frozen when purchased! Serving suggestion: To serve from the freezer, let the pie sit at room temperature until it’s easy to cut into, up to 15 minutes if needed. Enjoy!
  $34.00
- 10" Peanut Butter Bliss (FROZEN)
  This creamy and delicious whipped peanut butter filling has a Graham cracker crust and is drizzled with hot fudge & topped with whipped cream & Reese’s peanut butter cup crumbles. (Pie is frozen when purchased) Serving suggestion: To serve from the freezer, let the pie sit at room temperature until it’s easy to cut into (about 15 minutes depending on how warm your kitchen is). Enjoy!
  $34.00
- 10" Oreo Cheesecake Pie (FROZEN)
  Oreo cookie crust filled with rich and creamy cheesecake loaded with Oreo bits. Topped with whipped cream and Oreo crumbles.
  $34.00
- 10" Vanilla Almond Cream
  Rich vanilla cream filling lightly sweetened with almond flavor, topped with whipped cream and toasted almond shavings. Best when enjoyed within 2-3 days of purchase.
  $32.00
- 10" Blueberry Sour Cream
  This delectable treat features a graham cracker crust, creamy sour cream filling, and fresh blueberry compote. (keep refrigerated and eat within 3 days oaf purchase).
  $32.00
Half Pies
Don’t want to commit to the full pie? Take home one of our Half Pies. Can feed 3-4 people.
- Dutch Apple Half Pie
  $19.50
- Cherry Half Pie
  Old-fashioned tart cherry pie topped with a lattice crust
  $19.50
- Blueberry Half Pie
  $19.50
- Mixed Berry Half Pie
  $19.50
- Double Crust Apple Half Pie
  $19.50
- Chocolate Cream Half Pie
  $18.00
- Banana Half Pie
  $18.00
- Coconut Cream Half Pie
  $18.00
- Lemon Half Pie
  $19.00
- Pecan Half Pie
  $18.00
- Sweet Potato Half Pie
  $19.00
- Peanut Butter Bliss Half Pie
  $19.00
- Key Lime Half Pie
  $19.00
- Oreo Cheesecake Half Pie
  $19.00
- Vanilla Almond Cream Half Pie
  $18.00
- Blueberry Sour Cream Half Pie
  $18.00
10" Gluten Free Pies
Pies are certified Gluten-Free with a Gluten-Free crust. Ingredients: Cornstarch, White Rice Flour, Brown Rice Flour, Milk Powder, Tapioca Flour, Potato Starch, Xanthan Gum, Cream (dairy), Vinegar, Salt, Water. (contains dairy)
- 10" GF Dutch Apple
  $40.00
- 10" GF Cherry
  $40.00
- 10" GF Double Crust Apple
  $40.00
- 10" GF Mixed Berry
  $40.00
- 10" GF Blueberry
  $40.00
- 10" GF Chocolate Cream
  $37.00
- 10" GF Banana Cream
  $37.00
- 10" GF Coconut Cream
  $37.00
- 10" GF Vanilla Almond Cream
  $37.00
- 10" GF Pecan
  $37.00
- 10" GF Blueberry Sour Cream
  $37.00
- 10" GF Key Lime
  $39.00
- 10" GF Peanut Butter Bliss
  $39.00
- 10" GF Lemon
  $39.00
- 10" GF Lemon Meringue
  $41.00
- 10" GF Caramel Apple
  $45.00
10" Sugar Free Pies
Pies are sweetened naturally with monk fruit extract.
- 10" SF Dutch Apple
  $42.00
- 10" SF Double Crust Apple
  $42.00
- 10" SF Cherry
  $42.00
- 10" SF Mixed Berry
  $42.00
- 10" SF Blueberry
  $42.00
- 10" SF Lemon
  $41.00
10" Vegan Pies
Pies are made vegan-friendly with vegan butter.
- 10" VG Dutch Apple
  $40.00
- 10" VG Cherry
  $40.00
- 10" VG Mixed Berry
  $40.00
- 10" VG Blueberry
  $40.00
- 10" VG Double Crust Apple
  $40.00
5" Mini Pies
Need the perfect-sized gift? Look no further than an individual 5″ mini pie!
- 5" Dutch Apple
  $9.00
- 5" Cherry
  $9.00
- 5" Mixed Berry
  $9.00
- 5" Blueberry
  $9.00
- 5" Double Crust Apple
  $9.00
- 5" Chocolate Cream
  $9.00
- 5" Banana Cream
  $9.00
- 5" Coconut Cream
  $9.00
- 5" Vanilla Almond Cream
  $9.00
- 5" Lemon
  $9.00
- 5" Pecan
  $9.00
- 5" Oreo Cheesecake Pie (Frozen)
  $9.00
- 5" Lemon Meringue
  $9.00
- 5" Peanut Butter Bliss (Frozen)
  $9.00
- 5" Blueberry Sour Cream
  $9.00
- 5" Sweet Potato
  $9.00
- 5" Key Lime (Frozen)
  $9.00
Sugar Free 5" Mini Pies
In need of a small dessert with no sugar? Look no further than our Sugar-Free 5" Mini Pies!
- SF 5" Dutch Apple
  $11.00
- SF 5" Cherry
  $11.00
- SF 5" Lemon
  $11.00
Vegan 5" Mini Pies
- VG 5" Dutch Apple
  $10.00
- VG 5" Cherry
  $10.00
- VG 5" Double Crust Apple
  $10.00
Mix & Match 4 Pack (REGULAR)
Choose your favorites to create a custom 4-pack in our 5" Mini size.
- Mix & Match 4 Pack (REG)
  $34.00
Mix & Match 4 Pack (GLUTEN FREE)
Choose your GF favorites to create a custom 4-pack in our 5" Mini size.
- Mix & Match 4 Pack (GLUTEN FREE)
  $42.00
Mix & Match 4 Pack (VEGAN)
Choose your VG favorites to create a custom 4-pack in our 5" Mini size.
- Mix & Match 4 Pack (VEGAN)
  $38.00
Cakes
- Carrot Cake (LARGE)
  Perfectly moist and delicious, made with lots of freshly grated carrots, and topped with the most heavenly cream cheese frosting and chopped walnuts.
  $40.00
- 8 x 8 Texas Sheet Cake
  $25.00
- 8 x 8 Carrot Cake
  $25.00
Cheesecakes
- Sour Cream Cheesecake
  Creamy and ultra-smooth classic cheesecake dessert topped with sour cream. Paired with a buttery graham cracker crust, no one can deny its simple decadence.
  $55.00
Pie Add-Ons
- Birthday Topper - Gold
  Make any pie a birthday pie! Place in the center of the pie just before serving.
  $4.50
- 8 oz. Caramel (freezes well)
  To-Go container of our housemade caramel sauce
  $5.00
- Vanilla Ice Cream Scoop
  scoop of vanilla ice cream (served on the side)
  $1.50
Greeting Cards by Jon Reis
All custom cards are curated by local artist, Jon Reis. (4x6 size) Available for pickup in-store only.
- Javelina Birthday Card
  $10.00
- Desert Landscape Card
  $10.00
- Hummingbird Card
  $10.00
- "Howl"dy Card
  $10.00