Sweet Tooth Fairy Menu

Get six of our most popular flavors decorated as pretty roses for someone you love! 2 each Red Velvet, VaNIElla Squared, and Double Fudge.

Want to include a nice note with your delivery? Choose a Baby, Birthday, Thank You, or Generic card, and then write your message into the notes for this order. We'll hand-write your message in a folded greeting card (no more than 20 words, please!).

You will receive six of our seasonal flavors plus one Cookie Dough, one Red Velvet, one Oreo (R) Cookies and Cream, one Reese's (R) Peanut Butter, two Fairy Fetti. Please note that large orders (over 2 dozen treats) may not be handled same-day via DoorDash. Please call the store directly to schedule large orders in advance. Note: Picture may not indicate flavors available at this time.

Get an assortment of six of our yummiest deluxe seasonal filled cupcakes delivered to your door! This month's filled cupcakes include Raspberry Cheesecake, Nutella Crepe, Lemon Delight, and Double Chocolate Raspberry. (Substitutions may apply.)

An assortment of our everyday and seasonal bars. Currently this includes the Caramel Chocolate Oat Bar, Chocolate Chocolate Chip Brownie, and Rasberry Cheescake Brownie. Substitutions may apply. Please indicate in the notes if you'd like a different mix.

One dozen of our delicious jumbo cookies! This assortment includes our Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter Explosion, and Fairy Fetti Delight cookies, plus additional cookies from our monthly and seasonal favorites. Please indicate in the notes if you'd like a different mix of the above flavors.

Six of our delicious chocolate chocolate chip cookies frosted with yummy Signature Vanilla frosting.

Six of our super popular round signature sugar cookies frosted with yummy Signature Vanilla frosting.

The Sweet Tooth Fairy's signature treat, now delivered straight to your door! You'll receive an assortment of our six most popular flavors in a plastic cup. Want them to be even cuter!? Choose gift box packaging!

Decorate your own masterpieces with this family fun activity! A dozen shaped sugar cookies, frosting, and sprinkles to make and enjoy together. You'll get 12 cookies, sprinkle mixes, and 2 tubs of frosting. Choose Signature Vanilla if you want them to taste like the ones we frost in our store!

Always wanted to create your own cupcakes?? Get a dozen unfrosted cupcakes, frosting, and sprinkles to experiment with at home. Choose your cakes (2) and frostings (2). You'll get 6 of each selected cupcake flavor and 1 tub of each selected frosting, plus assorted sprinkles. Please note that requests for other frosting colors may not be possible with quick deliveries! If you would like a different color than what is in the list here, please give your order additional time (1 hour or more) and we will try to accommodate if we can! If we aren't able to color the frosting, we will send the natural colored frosting in the flavor you selected.