Sutton Cafe Menu

$$Diner, American, Sandwich shop

1026 1st Ave., New York, NY 10022

Order Online

Sandwiches
- Fried Egg Sandwich
  $5.25
- Western Egg Sandwich
  $8.95
- Bacon, Lettuce And Tomato Sandwich
  $9.95
- Tuna Fish Salad Sandwich
  No celery.
  $11.95
- Chicken Salad Sandwich
  No celery.
  $11.95
- Egg Salad Sandwich
  $10.95
- Roast Turkey Sandwich
  Carved to order.
  $13.95
- Roast Beef Sandwich
  Carved to order.
  $13.95
- Virginia Ham Sandwich
  $12.45
- Ham And Cheese Sandwich
  $13.95
- Hot Pastrami Sandwich
  $13.95
- Meatloaf Sandwich
  $12.95
- Turkey Meatloaf Sandwich
  $12.95
- Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
  $13.95
- Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
  $13.95
- Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sandwich
  $15.45
- Fried Filet Sandwich
  $12.95
- Individual Tuna Sandwich
  $12.95
- Individual Salmon Sandwich
  $12.95
- S And S Sardines Sandwich
  $12.95
Hot Open Sandwiches
- Hot Open Freshly Sliced Roast Beef Sandwich
  $20.45
- Hot Open Freshly Carved Turkey Sandwich
  Off the bone.
  $20.45
Eggs and Omelets
- 1 Egg Any Style
  $8.75
- 1 Egg Any Style With Ham
  $11.75
- 1 Egg Any Style With Bacon
  $11.75
- 1 Egg Any Style With Sausage
  $11.75
- 1 Egg Any Style With Canadian Bacon
  $12.25
- 1 Egg Any Style With Turkey Bacon
  $12.25
- 1 Egg Any Style With Turkey Sausage
  $12.25
- 2 Eggs Any Style
  $9.95
- 2 Eggs Any Style With Ham
  $12.95
- 2 Eggs Any Style With Bacon
  $12.95
- 2 Eggs Any Style With Sausage
  $12.95
- 2 Eggs Any Style With Canadian Bacon
  $13.45
- 2 Eggs Any Style With Turkey Bacon
  $13.45
- 2 Eggs Any Style With Turkey Sausage
  $13.45
- Corned Beef Hash And Eggs
  Served with french fries or home fries and toast.
  $14.95
- Steak And Eggs
  Served with french fries or home fries and toast.
  $22.95
- Plain Omelet
  Served with french fries or home fries and toast.
  $11.45
- Veggie Omelet
  Served with french fries or home fries and toast.
  $14.45
- Feta Omelet
  $13.45
- Florentine Omelet
  Served with french fries or home fries and toast.
  $14.45
- Greek Omelet
  Served with french fries or home fries and toast.
  $14.45
- Spanish Omelet
  $14.45
- Nova And Onions Omelet
  Served with french fries or home fries and toast.
  $19.95
- Make Your Own Omelet
  $13.45
Griddle Specialties
- Plain Griddle
  $12.95
- Griddle With Ham
  $15.95
- Griddle With Bacon
  $15.95
- Griddle With Sausage
  $15.95
- Griddle With 2 Eggs Any Style
  $15.45
- Griddle With Canadian Bacon
  $16.45
- Griddle With Turkey Bacon
  $16.45
- Griddle With Turkey Sausage
  $16.45
- Griddle With Blueberries
  $15.45
- Lumberjack
  Served with 2 eggs and ham, bacon, or sausage.
  $18.45
- Silver Dollar Pancakes
  Served with butter and syrup.
  $14.45
- Chocolate Chip Pancakes
  Served with butter and syrup.
  $16.45
- Walnut Pancakes
  Served with butter and syrup.
  $16.45
- Belgian Waffle Sundae
  Comes with a scoop of ice cream, syrup, and whipped cream.
  $18.45
Odds and Ends
- Bagel With Cream Cheese
  $4.95
- Bagel With Cream Cheese And Nova
  $15.95
- Bagel Platter
  Comes with cream cheese, nova, lettuce, tomato, onions, and olives.
  $19.45
- Danish
  $3.75
- Turnover
  $3.75
- Pound Cake
  Plain marble or carrot.
  $3.75
- Bagel
  $2.95
- Pita
  $2.95
- English Muffin
  $2.95
- Large English Muffin
  $3.35
- Toast
  $2.75
- Roll
  $2.75
- Homemade Muffin
  $4.15
- Jumbo Cookie
  $4.15
- Hot Cereal
  Oatmeal.
  $7.25
- Hot Cereal With Walnuts
  $8.95
- Hot Cereal With Raisins
  $8.95
- Avocado Toast
  $7.95
Appetizers
- Chicken Fingers
  Served with french fries in a basket.
  $12.95
- Homemade French Fried Onion Rings
  $8.95
- Fried Mozzarella Sticks
  Served with marinara sauce.
  $10.95
- Buffalo Chicken Wings
  $12.95
- Shrimp Tenders
  With homemade marinara sauce, hot or mild.
  $14.95
- Stuffed Grape Leaves
  $9.95
- Homemade Chili
  $7.45
Salads
- Greek Salad
  Lettuce, tomato, green peppers, onions, cucumbers, olives, anchovies, feta cheese, and stuffed grape leaves.
  $15.45
- Grilled Chicken Salad
  Grilled chicken breast on top of mixed greens and tomato.
  $19.45
- Slim-Line Salad
  8 oz. steak or turkey burger with a scoop of cottage cheese, lettuce, and tomato salad.
  $18.45
- Tuna Salad
  On a bed of lettuce, tomato, and cucumbers.
  $15.45
- Chicken Salad
  On a bed of lettuce, tomato, and cucumbers.
  $15.45
- Egg Salad
  On a bed of lettuce, tomato, and cucumbers.
  $15.45
- Cantaloupe And Cottage Salad
  $12.45
- Caesar Salad
  Fresh romaine lettuce with croutons and our special Caesar dressing.
  $13.95
- Chef's Salad
  Julienne of ham, roast beef, turkey, cheese, hard-boiled egg, lettuce, tomato, and cucumbers.
  $20.45
- Health Salad
  Fresh fruit salad, cottage cheese, and jello on a bed of lettuce.
  $18.45
- Turkey Bowl
  Fresh sliced turkey over mixed greens and tomato salad.
  $19.45
- Large Mixed Green Salad
  $13.45
- Tuna Fish Salad Platter
  No celery. Served with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce, and tomato.
  $19.45
- Chicken Salad Platter
  No celery. Served with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce, and tomato.
  $19.45
- Egg Salad Platter
  No celery. Served with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce, and tomato.
  $19.45
- Salad Nicoise
  Chunks of tuna over mixed greens with hard-boiled egg, olives, green beans, tomato, and anchovies.
  $19.45
- Horiatiki Salad
  Tomato, cucumber, onions, and feta cheese with grilled chicken.
  $19.45
- Sutton Cafe Salad
  Mixed greens, tomato, onions, and olives with hamburger or turkey burger.
  $19.45
- Vegetable Plate
  Choice of 2 vegetables with baked potato or baked sweet potato.
  $19.45
Homemade Wraps
- Turkey Club Wrap
  Delicious, fresh roasted turkey with bacon, romaine lettuce, and tomato.
  $15.95
- Turkey Club Wrap With Side
  Delicious, fresh roasted turkey with bacon, romaine lettuce, and tomato.
  $19.45
- Sutton Cafe Wrap
  Thin sliced Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
  $15.95
- Sutton Cafe Wrap With Side
  Thin sliced Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
  $19.45
- Hot Roast Beef Wrap
  Hot roast beef with melted cheese and sautéed mushrooms.
  $15.95
- Hot Roast Beef Wrap With Side
  Hot roast beef with melted cheese and sautéed mushrooms.
  $19.45
- Roast Beef Wrap
  Delicious homemade roast beef with Swiss cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
  $15.95
- Roast Beef Wrap With Side
  Delicious homemade roast beef with Swiss cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
  $19.45
- Chicken Caesar Wrap
  Grilled chicken with Caesar salad.
  $15.95
- Chicken Caesar Wrap With Side
  Grilled chicken with Caesar salad.
  $19.45
- Chicken Salad Wrap
  Our own chicken salad with lettuce and tomato.
  $15.95
- Chicken Salad Wrap With Side
  Our own chicken salad with lettuce and tomato.
  $19.45
- Grilled Chicken Wrap
  Grilled chicken with melted cheese and sautéed onions.
  $15.95
- Grilled Chicken Wrap With Side
  Grilled chicken with melted cheese and sautéed onions.
  $19.45
- Nova Wrap
  Thinly sliced nova with cream cheese, red onions, lettuce, and tomato.
  $18.00
- Nova Wrap With Salad
  Thinly sliced nova with cream cheese, red onions, lettuce, and tomato.
  $22.45
- Tuna Fish Salad Wrap
  Tasty homemade tuna fish with lettuce and tomato.
  $15.95
- Tuna Fish Salad Wrap With Side
  Tasty homemade tuna fish with lettuce and tomato.
  $19.45
- Veggie Wrap
  Eggplant, mushroom, onion, and spinach.
  $15.95
- Veggie Wrap With Side
  Eggplant, mushroom, onion, and spinach.
  $19.45
Triple Decker Clubs
- Turkey Triple Decker Club
  Fresh sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
  $19.45
- Roast Beef Triple Decker Club
  Served with Swiss cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
  $19.45
- Grilled Chicken Triple Decker Club
  Grilled breast of chicken with cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
  $19.45
- Chicken Salad Triple Decker Club
  Chicken salad with bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
  $18.45
- Tuna Salad Triple Decker Club
  Tuna salad with sliced egg, lettuce, and tomato.
  $18.45
- Egg Salad Triple Decker Club
  Egg salad with bacon, lettuce and tomato.
  $18.45
Sutton Cafe Specialties
- House Chicken Breast
  Grilled breast of chicken, topped with sautéed onions and melted cheese on pita.
  $17.45
- Chicken Pita Pizza
  Grilled chicken breast with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on pita.
  $17.45
- First Avenue
  Thin sliced roast beef topped with sautéed mushrooms and melted cheese, garnished with potato salad or French fries.
  $19.45
- Monte Cristo
  Thin sliced turkey with ham and melted Swiss cheese over challah French toast.
  $19.45
- Chicken Salad Melt
  Served with French fries or potato salad.
  $19.45
- Tuna Salad Melt
  Served with French fries or potato salad.
  $19.45
- Open Reuben
  Pastrami or corned beef with sauerkraut, topped with melted Swiss on grilled rye bread, garnished with potato salad or French fries.
  $19.45
- Pastrami Grill
  Grilled hot pastrami on rye with melted cheese.
  $19.45
- Grilled Eggplant
  Grilled eggplant, peppers, red onion and melted mozzarella on a bun with French fries.
  $19.45
- Chicken Nuggets
  Served with French fries in a basket.
  $18.45
- Chicken Fingers
  Served with French fries in a basket.
  $19.45
- Fish And Chips
  Served with French fries in a basket.
  $19.45
- Fried Fish Filet Deluxe
  Served with French fries, lettuce and tomato.
  $19.45
- Open Sliced Steak Sandwich
  Sliced steak on toast, open-faced, with lettuce, tomato, and French fries.
  $24.45
- Sutton Meatloaf
  Served with mashed potatoes, crispy onions, and barbecue gravy, served open-faced on thick egg bread.
  $19.45
- Gyro On Pita
  Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, and tzatziki sauce.
  $12.45
- Gyro Platter
  Served with Greek salad, French fries, and tzatziki sauce.
  $19.45
- Chicken Souvlaki On Pita
  Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and tzatziki sauce.
  $12.45
- Chicken Souvlaki Platter
  Served with Greek salad, French fries, and tzatziki sauce.
  $19.45
1/2 lb. Steak Burgers
- Steak Burger
  $9.75
- Steak Burger Deluxe
  Includes French fries, lettuce, and tomatoes.
  $16.25
- Gardenburger
  $9.75
- Gardenburger Deluxe
  Includes French fries, lettuce, and tomatoes.
  $16.25
- Chili Burger
  $10.75
- Chili Burger Deluxe
  Includes French fries, lettuce, and tomatoes.
  $17.25
- Turkey Burger
  $9.95
- Turkey Burger Deluxe
  Includes French fries, lettuce, and tomatoes.
  $16.45
- Pizza Burger
  $11.50
- Pizza Burger Deluxe
  Includes French fries, lettuce, and tomatoes.
  $18.00
- Steak Cheeseburger
  Includes french fries lettuce and tomatoes.
  $11.25
- Steak Cheeseburger Deluxe
  Includes French fries, lettuce, and tomatoes.
  $17.75
- Greek Burger
  Sautéed spinach, feta cheese, and onion.
  $14.75
- Greek Burger Deluxe
  Includes French fries, lettuce, and tomatoes.
  $21.25
- Cali Burger
  Avocado, bacon, and cheddar cheese.
  $14.75
- Cali Burger Deluxe
  Includes French fries, lettuce, and tomatoes.
  $21.25
- Mex Burger
  Avocado, jalapeño peppers, and cheddar cheese.
  $14.75
- Mex Burger Deluxe
  Includes French fries, lettuce, and tomatoes.
  $21.25
- Rodeo Burger
  Mushrooms, onions, and muenster cheese.
  $14.75
- Rodeo Burger Deluxe
  Includes French fries, lettuce, and tomatoes.
  $21.25
- Italian Burger
  Roasted red peppers, onions, and mozzarella cheese.
  $14.75
- Italian Burger Deluxe
  Includes French fries, lettuce, and tomatoes.
  $21.25
Hot Pressed Paninis
- Eggplant Parmigiana Panini
  Topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce.
  $19.45
- Grilled Chicken Panini
  Sliced chicken breast, mozzarella cheese, basil, and roasted red peppers, sprinkled with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
  $19.45
- Roast Beef And Mozzarella Panini
  Sliced roast beef topped with mozzarella.
  $19.45
- Turkey Panini
  Sliced turkey topped with Swiss cheese and grilled tomato, served with a side of honey Dijon dressing.
  $19.45
- Chicken Parmigiana Panini
  Pan-fried chicken topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce.
  $19.45
- Italian Panini
  Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, balsamic vinaigrette and fresh mozzarella.
  $19.45
- Greek Panini
  Grilled chicken, feta cheese, tomato, and spinach, served with tzatziki sauce.
  $19.45
Mediterranean Specialties
- Pasta With Marinara Sauce
  $16.45
- Pasta With Meat Sauce
  $20.45
- Pasta With Meatballs
  $20.45
- Lasagna
  $20.95
- Vegetarian Lasagna
  $20.95
- Spinach Pie
  $20.95
- Eggplant Parmigiana With A Side Of Pasta
  $20.95
- Chicken Cutlet With A Side Of Pasta
  $22.45
- Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana With A Side Of Pasta
  $24.45
Stuffed Pasta Fiesta
- Imported Cheese Ravioli
  Homemade ravioli stuffed with ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.
  $20.45
- Beef Ravioli
  Homemade ravioli stuffed with sautéed beef and a blend of spices and cheese with homemade marinara sauce.
  $20.45
- Spinach Ravioli
  Homemade ravioli stuffed with spinach, ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.
  $20.45
- Stuffed Rigatoni
  Homemade rigatoni stuffed with ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.
  $20.45
- Stuffed Shells
  Homemade jumbo pasta shells stuffed with ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.
  $20.45
Entrées
- Turkey
  Carved roast turkey breast, served with cranberry sauce, vegetables and potatoes.
  $24.45
- Grilled Chicken Breast And Athenian Style
  Marinated in fresh garlic, lemon and herbs, served with vegetables and potatoes.
  $24.45
- Poached Chicken Breast
  With a balsamic black bean and pepper salsa, served with potatoes or vegetable.
  $24.45
- Chicken Breast Florentine
  Broiled breast of chicken stuffed with imported feta cheese, spinach, and herbs, served with potatoes or vegetable.
  $24.45
- Chicken Kebab
  Chunks of chicken breast sautéed with bell peppers, onions and tomatoes, served over rice.
  $24.45
- Southern Fried Chicken
  Honey dipped Louisiana-style fried chicken, served with vegetables and potatoes.
  $24.45
- Turkey Meatloaf
  Slowly baked turkey meatloaf, served with homemade mushroom gravy, vegetables and potatoes.
  $24.45
- Baked Meatloaf
  Served with mushroom gravy, mixed vegetables and potatoes.
  $24.45
- Broiled Rib Eye Steak
  Topped with garlic flavored sautéed mushrooms, served with vegetables and potatoes.
  $28.45
- Chopped Steak
  Topped with sautéed onions or bacon, served with vegetables and potatoes.
  $24.45
- Broiled Norwegian Salmon
  Served with vegetables and potatoes.
  $25.45
- Poached Norwegian Salmon
  Served with a creamy dill sauce, vegetables and potato.
  $25.45
- Fish Fillet Ala Maison
  Cooked in white wine and garlic, served with vegetables and potatoes.
  $25.45
- Shrimp Primavera
  Gulf shrimp and diced vegetables, sautéed in garlic and herbs, served over pasta or rice.
  $29.45
Stuffed Baked Potato
- Stuffed Baked Potato With Broccoli And Cheese
  Add bacon for an additional charge.
  $12.45
- Stuffed Baked Potato With Garden Salad
  $17.45
- Stuffed Baked Potato With Caesar Salad
  $17.45
Side Orders
- French Fries
  $6.45
- Cheese Fries
  $8.95
- Sweet Potato Fries
  $7.95
- Home Fried Potatoes
  $6.45
- Home Mashed Potatoes
  After 12 pm.
  $6.45
- Rice
  $5.95
- Pasta With Marinara Sauce
  $10.95
- Pasta With Olive Oil And Garlic
  $10.95
- Small Mixed Green Salad
  $7.95
- Caesar Salad
  Fresh romaine lettuce with croutons and our special caesar dressing.
  $7.95
- Sautéed Vegetable
  $9.95
- Side Of Ham
  $8.95
- Side Of Bacon
  $8.95
- Side Of Sausage
  $8.95
- Side Of Canadian Bacon
  $9.95
- Side Of Turkey Bacon
  $9.95
- Side Of Turkey Sausage
  $9.95
- Side Of Corned Beef Hash
  $9.95
- Coleslaw
  $6.45
- Potato Salad
  $6.45
- Cottage Cheese
  $6.25
- Cranberry Sauce
  $5.75
- Tzatziki Sauce
  $6.95
- Marinara Sauce
  $6.95
- Salad Dressing
  $6.95
Desserts
- Jello
  $4.75
- Layer Cake
  $7.25
- Creamy Cheesecake
  $7.25
- Assorted Fruit Pie
  $6.25
- Fruit Pie A La Mode
  $8.25
- Creamy Rice Pudding
  $6.95
- Ice Cream
  $4.95
Fresh Beginnings
- Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
  $5.95
- Tomato Juice
  $4.95
- Apple Juice
  $4.95
- Individual Pineapple
  $4.25
- V-8
  $4.25
- 1/2 Grapefruit
  $4.95
- Fresh Fruit Salad
  $7.25
- Melon
  $6.95
Beverages
- Coffee
  $2.50
- Tea
  $2.50
- Decaffeinated Coffee
  $2.50
- Herbal Tea
  $2.50
- Hot Chocolate
  $2.95
- Hot Chocolate With Milk
  $4.45
- Espresso
  $4.25
- Double Espresso
  $5.50
- Cappuccino
  $6.25
- Milk
  $3.75
- Chocolate Milk
  $3.75
- Iced Cappuccino
  $6.95
- Iced Coffee
  $3.50
- Iced Tea
  $3.50
- Ice Cream Soda
  $7.95
- Fresh Lemonade
  $6.25
- Fountain Soda
  $2.75
- Egg Cream
  $4.75
- Milkshake
  $6.95
- Thick
  $7.95

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Privacy

Terms

Sutton Cafe Menu

Sandwiches

Fried Egg Sandwich

Western Egg Sandwich

Bacon, Lettuce And Tomato Sandwich

Tuna Fish Salad Sandwich

Chicken Salad Sandwich

Egg Salad Sandwich

Roast Turkey Sandwich

Roast Beef Sandwich

Virginia Ham Sandwich

Ham And Cheese Sandwich

Hot Pastrami Sandwich

Meatloaf Sandwich

Turkey Meatloaf Sandwich

Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich

Chicken Cutlet Sandwich

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sandwich

Fried Filet Sandwich

Individual Tuna Sandwich

Individual Salmon Sandwich

S And S Sardines Sandwich

Hot Open Sandwiches

Hot Open Freshly Sliced Roast Beef Sandwich

Hot Open Freshly Carved Turkey Sandwich

Eggs and Omelets

1 Egg Any Style

1 Egg Any Style With Ham

1 Egg Any Style With Bacon

1 Egg Any Style With Sausage

1 Egg Any Style With Canadian Bacon

1 Egg Any Style With Turkey Bacon

1 Egg Any Style With Turkey Sausage

2 Eggs Any Style

2 Eggs Any Style With Ham

2 Eggs Any Style With Bacon

2 Eggs Any Style With Sausage

2 Eggs Any Style With Canadian Bacon

2 Eggs Any Style With Turkey Bacon

2 Eggs Any Style With Turkey Sausage

Corned Beef Hash And Eggs

Steak And Eggs

Plain Omelet

Veggie Omelet

Feta Omelet

Florentine Omelet

Greek Omelet

Spanish Omelet

Nova And Onions Omelet

Make Your Own Omelet

Griddle Specialties

Plain Griddle

Griddle With Ham

Griddle With Bacon

Griddle With Sausage

Griddle With 2 Eggs Any Style

Griddle With Canadian Bacon

Griddle With Turkey Bacon

Griddle With Turkey Sausage

Griddle With Blueberries

Lumberjack

Silver Dollar Pancakes

Chocolate Chip Pancakes

Walnut Pancakes

Belgian Waffle Sundae

Odds and Ends

Bagel With Cream Cheese

Bagel With Cream Cheese And Nova

Bagel Platter

Danish

Turnover

Pound Cake

Bagel

Pita

English Muffin

Large English Muffin

Toast

Roll

Homemade Muffin

Jumbo Cookie