Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Surreal Creamery Menu

$$Ice cream shop, Bubble tea store, Dessert shop
538 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10016
Order Online

  • Breaking Batter Ice Cream Cake Jars

    • Make Your Own Ice Cream Cake Jar

      Optional $1 bubble tea with every ice cream cake jar purchase
      $11.50

    • Amour S'More Ice Cream Cake Jar

      Vanilla Cake, Chocolate & Marshmallow Frosting, Earl Grey Vanilla Ice Cream, Hershey's Syrup, Graham Crackers, and Chocolate Chips.
      $11.50

    • Chocolate Meltdown Overload Ice Cream Cake Jar

      Layers of Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Crunch, Chocolate Sprinkles, Crushed Oreos and Chocolate Ice Cream.
      $11.50

    • All Very Strawberry Ice Cream Cake Jar

      Strawberry Cake, Cream Cheese Frosting, Strawberry Ice Cream, and Strawberry Crunch.
      $11.50

    • I Dream Of Taro Ice Cream Cake Jar

      Taro Cake, Taro Ice Cream, and Butter Waffle Cookies.
      $11.50

    • Lala Red Velvet Ice Cream Cake Jar

      Red Velvet Cake, Cream Cheese Frosting, White Chocolate Curls, and Earl Grey Vanilla Ice Cream.
      $11.50

    • Monster Celebration Ice Cream Cake Jar

      Vanilla Cake, Cookies & Cream Frosting, Rainbow Sprinkles, Chocolate Crunch, and Monster Cookie Ice Cream.
      $11.50

  • Breaking Batter Cake Jars

    • Make Your Own Cake Jar

      Create the cake jar of your dreams or select from our signature jars.
      $11.50

    • Monster Celebration Cake Jar

      Vanilla Cake, Cookies & Cream Frosting, Blue Vanilla Frosting, and Rainbow Sprinkles.
      $11.50

    • Amour S'More Cake Jar

      Vanilla Cake, Chocolate & Marshmallow Whipped Frosting, Hershey’s Syrup, Chocolate Chips, and Graham Crackers.
      $11.50

    • Lala Red Velvet Cake Jar

      Red Velvet Cake, Cream Cheese Frosting, and White Chocolate Curls.
      $11.50

    • I Dream Of Taro Cake Jar

      Layers of Taro Cake, Cream Cheese Frosting, and Butter Waffle Cookies.
      $11.50

    • Chocolate Meltdown Overload Cake Jar

      Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Frosting, Chocolate Sprinkles, and Chocolate Crunch.
      $11.50

  • Tres Leches Cake Jars

    • Make Your Own Tres Leches Jar (8oz Mason Jar)

      Layers of delicious cake with whipped Tres Leches Frosting and toppings of your choice.
      $12.00

    • Strawberry Tres Leches (8oz Mason Jar)

      $12.00

    • Dulce De Tres Leches Cake Jar (8oz Mason Jar)

      Vanilla cake soaked in tres leches sauce, topped with whipped tres leches frosting and drizzled with decadent dulce de leche
      $12.00

    • Dulce De Tres Leches Cheesecake Jar (8oz Mason Jar)

      Layered with New York style cheesecake, light and airy tres leches frosting, vanilla cake and decadent dulce de leche drizzle.
      $12.75

    • Strawberry Cheesecake Jar (8oz Mason Jar)

      $12.75

    • Classic Tres Leches Cake Jar (8 Oz Mason Jar)

      $12.00

  • Mason Jar Specials

    • Buy 3 Mason Jars, Get 1 Free

      Buy 3 Mason jar specials, get 1 free!.
      $38.25

    • Nom Nom Cookie

      Blue Vanilla Ice Cream, Chocolate Crunch, Chocolate Syrup, Cookie Crisp, Marshmallows, and Oreos.
      $12.75

    • It's My Birthday

      Strawberry Ice Cream, Fruity Pebbles, Strawberry Sprinkles, and Rainbow Sprinkles.
      $12.75

    • Chocolate Blackout

      Chocolate Ice Cream, Chocolate Crunch, Chocolate Syrup, Cocoa puffs, and Oreos.
      $12.75

    • Earl Grey Everyday

      Earl Grey Ice Cream, Caramel Syrup, Reese's Puffs, and Lady Fingers.
      $12.75

    • Know Your Roots

      Taro Ice Cream, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Chocolate Crunch, Chocolate Syrup, and a Cinnamon Graham cracker.
      $12.75

    • Matcha Made In Heaven

      Matcha Ice Cream, Lucky Charms, and Caramel Syrup.
      $12.75

    • Make Your Own Mason Jar Sundae

      Choose from 8 different Ice Cream flavors and up to 4 toppings
      $12.75

  • Floteas

    • Buy 3 Floateas, Get 1 Free

      Choose 4 floteas: options include Vietnamese iced coffee, Thai milk, matcha, and earl grey varieties paired with complementing ice creams like taro swirl and brown sugar.
      $35.25

    • Matcha Bubble Tea & Taro Ice Cream

      Creamy taro ice cream swirled atop matcha bubble tea with chewy tapioca pearls, garnished with a crisp waffle triangle.
      $11.75

    • Brown Sugar Bubble Tea & Earl Grey Ice Cream

      Swirled Earl Grey ice cream atop brown sugar bubble tea with chewy tapioca pearls, garnished with a crisp graham cracker.
      $11.75

    • Taro Bubble Tea & Matcha With Taro Swirled Ice Cream

      Creamy taro bubble tea with matcha swirled taro ice cream, topped with a waffle crisp and chewy tapioca pearls.
      $11.75

    • Earl Grey Everyday

      Earl grey ice cream, caramel syrup, reese's puffs, and lady fingers.
      $11.75

    • Vietnamese Coffee Bubble Tea & Earl Grey Tea Ice Cream

      Smooth Vietnamese coffee bubble tea topped with creamy Earl Grey tea ice cream, garnished with a mini waffle cookie.
      $11.75

    • Make Your Own Flotea

      Customize your own Bubble Tea & Ice Cream float. Choose from 8 different flavors of Ice Cream and 6 different Milk Tea flavors.
      $11.75

  • Bubble Tea

    • Classic Milk Teas

      $7.25

    • Slushes

      Strawberry, Passionfruit, Mango, and Lychee Slushes
      $7.50

    • Jasmine Fruit Teas

      Jasmine green tea
      $7.25

  • Ice Cream & Milkshakes

    • Make Your Own Milkshake

      Choose from over 8 different Milkshake flavors. Add up to 4 toppings.
      $10.75

    • Make Your Own Ice Cream Cup

      Customize your own Ice Cream cup with 8 different flavors and up to 4 topings.
      $10.75

  • Catering and Gift Packs

    • 6-Pack Breaking Batter Cake Jars

      Pick 6 of our signature cake jars to create a custom gift!
      $62.00

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms