This sandwich's game is strong, kinda like the guy we named it after. Smoked brisket, pulled pork, cheese sauce, fries and our famous St. Louis sweet BBQ sauce all served on a hoagie. You may need to tap out for this one, but we have faith in you.
Hoosier Daddy
An Indiana favorite made specially for the Circle City. Fried pork tenderloin with mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle. Served on a Sugarfire signature bun.
Big Muddy
This bad boy of the brisket sandwich world is served with brisket (of course), smoked sausage, horseradish sauce, BBQ sauce, lettuce, pickles. The perfect sandwich for someone who likes a lot of sandwich.
PBLT
The "P" stands for "Pretty Darn Delicious" or "Pimento Cheese." Depends who you ask. Check out the most plentiful BLT you've ever had with pimento cheese, house bacon, lettuce, tomato, on toasted bread.
Brisket Cheesesteak
This is cheesesteak our style. This Philly-inspired sandwich with an east-coast attitude is served with brisket with onions, peppers, and cheese on a hoagie roll.
The Carolina
This simple and sumptuous sandwich is served with a choice of your favorite meat and coleslaw. We top it with a drizzle of our eastern-inspired Mustard Barbecue Sauce for the mid-south tang you're looking for.
Combo Plate
If you're just looking for something simple and straightforward, this is for you. Our specialty barbecue plate with your choice of any 2 smoked meats and 2 sides. This one comes with a fountain soda to wash down with your fav 'cue sauce.
Chicken Biscuit
Our tender chicken breast marinated in buttermilk, pickle juice, and nunya. Slow smoked, breaded and fried, then tossed in house hot sauce and served on a house biscuit and slathered in honey butter. Mmmm...
The Meat Daddy
This plate of all plates is not for the faint of heart. Take a look at a 4-bone rib, jalapeno cheddar sausage link, & 4oz each of brisket, pulled pork, turkey. Plus 2 sides and a fountain drink to top it all off. Bone appetit!
3 Meat Combo
This predecessor to the meat daddy is plenty for most. On this one, select 3 of your favorite smoked meats, and add 2 sides and a refreshing fountain beverage. Nap time not included.
Smoked Portobello Sandwich
Don't tell anyone, but we snuck something on here for our veggie-friendly friends. This is a double-decker smoked portabella sandwich with special sauce, lettuce, balsamic onions, pickles, and American cheese.
Main Plates
Pulled Pork
Pulled Pork Plate Grab a 6oz. or 8oz. helping of our famous pulled pork and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
Brisket
BrisketBrisket PlateGrab a 6oz. or 8oz. helping of our famous smoked brisket and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
Baby Back Ribs (1/2 Or Full-Rack)
Baby Back Ribs (1/2 or Full-Rack)Grab a 1/2-rack (6-bone) or full-rack (12-bone) helping of our famous house-smoked ribs and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
Sausage
Jalapeño-Cheddar Sausage LinkThis house recipe of jalapeño and cheddar mixed straight into a perfectly wrapped sausage link is the perfect pairing for the rest of your meal. Keep a tall glass of cold fountain soda nearby. We didn't hold anything back on this spicy link of all links.
Turkey
Turkey PlateGrab a 6oz. or 8oz. helping of our famous smoked turkey and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
Double Burger
Double BurgerThis double-pattied burger is served with one side. Grass fed beef blended daily from our proprietary mix of chuck, brisket and boneless short rib, hand-patted and griddle seared, seasoned only in sea salt and fresh cracked pepper then served on a real butter toasted bun. Add lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, and house condiments at your request.
Single Burger
This solo-pattied single is grass fed beef blended daily from our proprietary mix of chuck, brisket and boneless short rib, hand-patted and griddle seared, seasoned only in sea salt and fresh cracked pepper then served on a real butter toasted bun. Add lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, and house condiments at your request.
Baked Bean Burger
Yes, beans can be baked too in Colorado. Vegetarian baked beans mixed with polenta, sun-dried tomatoes, green pepper, onion, garlic, and parsley topped with cheddar, mixed baby kale, roasted red pepper, pickled red onion, Carolina mustard sauce
Smoked Salmon Plate
Grab a 5oz. helping of our famous smoked salmon and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
Smoked Salmon (Salmon Only)
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of salmon by its lonesome in 5oz portions. This one doesn't come with any sides.
Smoked Salmon Sandwich
We serve smoked salmon in a 5oz. portion on a freshly baked bun. This plate comes with one of your favorite sides. Top with one of our tasty barbecue sauces to round it out.
Baby Back Ribs (1/3 Rack)
Looking for something lighter? Grab a 1/3-rack (4-bone) of our famous house-smoked ribs and pair it with your favorite side and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
Turkey (Meat Only)
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of turkey by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 1/2lb., or 1lb
Turkey Sandwich
We serve turkey in 6oz. or 8oz. portions on a freshly baked bun. This plate comes with one of your favorite sides. Top with one of our tasty barbecue sauces to round it out.
Brisket (Meat Only)
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of brisket by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 1/2lb., or 1lb.
Brisket Sandwich
We serve brisket in 6oz. or 8oz. portions on a freshly baked bun. This plate comes with one of your favorite sides. Top with one of our tasty barbecue sauces to round it out.
Sauce
White BBQ
Adventurous 'cue eaters will love our Alabama-style white sauce, which gets a kick from just the right amount of horseradish and vinegar. Fantastic on brisket or right out of the bottle. Yum.
Sugarfire 47
There's something special about this sweet, complex sauce. Something indescribable. It's an enigma, just like its name. No one knows what the 47 stands for, not even us.
Honey Badger
In the wild, honey badgers are known for being tenacious. This sweet, tangy sauce will grab you and won't let go until you've poured it over everything in sight.
Coffee BBQ
We love coffee almost as much as we love barbecue. Add a kick to anything with this rich, roasted sauce. Wake up and smell the smoker.
St. Louie Sweet
This perfectly balanced sauce brings just the right amount of sugar to pulled pork, brisket, or a full rack of ribs. Lick your fingers after you're finished. You don't want to leave a drop of this behind.
Carolina Mustard
For folks who like a little more tang in their sauce, our classic Carolina sauce combines yellow mustard and vinegar for a double dose of flavor.
Texas Hot
The temperature is always climbing in the Lone Star State, and so is the heat in this sauce. Our peppery, smooth sauce brings a deep Texas flavor to anything you put it on.
Starters
Pork Belly Hush Puppies
This starter or side can be shared or kept to yourself. House-made hushpuppies, breaded and stuffed with pork belly and served with a jalapeño jelly for dipping. Once you make these part of your Sugarfire schedule, it'll be hard to leave them out.
Smoked Fried Artichokes
They start fresh and then wind up house-smoked. These artichokes are served alongside a zesty lemon aioli for dipping capabilities. Perfect for sharing before the meal, or keeping to yourself on the side.
Sides
House French Fries
This hot, hand-cut potato delight is prepared with love daily. Our french fries are the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
Baked Beans
This hot, spicy, side is prepared with love daily. Our tangy baked beans are the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
Coleslaw
This cool cabbage treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayo-based coleslaw is the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
Potato Salad
This cool potato treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayo-based potato salad is the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
Shakes & Floats
Ice Cream Soda Floats
Scoops of local, handmade ice cream in a glass, topped with local soda, or "pop" if that's where you are. These floaty delights are served in varieties of purple cow, root beer, or orange. Or, just ask us for some ice cream and top it with your favorite soft drink!
Pie Shakes
It might just be exactly what it sounds like. A full piece of pie blended directly into one of our housemade milk shakes. Choose your pie and choose your shake flavor and see them come together in holy moo-trimony right in front of your eyes.
Housemade Milk Shakes
Choose your favorite classic flavor from our selection of chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry. Topped with whipped cream and other fun stuff! Our housemade shakes are always made with fresh ice cream. Brain freeze insurance not necessarily included.