14" Whole Pies
- Cheese PizzaWhole milk mozzarella cheese over house-made marinara red sauce.$16.00
- Pepperoni PizzaWhole milk mozzarella cheese & pepperoni slices over house-made marinara red sauce$18.00
- Cypress Hill PizzaPepperoni, Mushroom, Olive$19.00
- Five Cheese PizzaMozzarella, Cheddar, Provolone, Ricotta, Parmesan$20.00
- Hawaiian PizzaCanadian Bacon, Pineapple$19.00
- Margherita PizzaFresh Garlic, Tomatoes, Basil, Fresh Mozz on Red Sauce$20.00
- Spicy Chicken PizzaShredded Mozzarella, Chicken, Onion, Jalapenos, and Chopped Garlic on our House-Made Marinara Red Sauce$20.00
- Pesto PizzaChicken, Red Peppers, Olives, Fresh Basil$21.00
- Buffalo Chicken PizzaRed Onion, Blue Cheese, Chicken, Franks Red Hot, Garlic + Oil Base$21.00
- Brooklyn PizzaSausage, Mushroom, Olive, Red Bell Pepper$21.00
- SFNY Special PizzaCanadian Bacon, Pepperoni, Olives, Red Peppers, Mushrooms$23.00
- BBQ Chicken PizzaChicken, Onion, Pepperoncinis, and Shredded Parmesan on BBQ Base$23.00
- Combination PizzaPepperoni, Sausage, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Olives, Onions$24.00
- Veggie PizzaRed and Green Bell Peppers, Mushrooms, Olives, Onions, Artichoke Hearts on Basil Pesto Base$24.00
- Greek PizzaSpinach, Tomato, Kalamata Olives, Red Onion, and Feta on Garlic + Oil Base$24.00
- Meat Lovers PizzaSausage, Pepperoni, Bacon, Canadian Bacon$22.00
18" Whole Pies
- Cheese PizzaWhole milk mozzarella cheese over house-made marinara red sauce$21.00
- Pepperoni PizzaWhole milk mozzarella cheese & pepperoni slices over house-made marinara red sauce$23.00
- Cypress Hill PizzaPepperoni, Mushroom, Olive$25.00
- Five Cheese PizzaMozzarella, Cheddar, Provolone, Ricotta, Parmesan$25.00
- Hawaiian PizzaCanadian Bacon, Pineapple$25.00
- Margherita PizzaFresh Garlic, Tomatoes, Basil, Fresh Mozz on Red Sauce$26.00
- Spicy Chicken PizzaShredded Mozzarella, Chicken, Onion, Jalapenos, and Chopped Garlic on our House-Made Marinara Red Sauce$26.00
- Pesto PizzaChicken, Red Peppers, Olives, Fresh Basil$27.00
- Buffalo Chicken PizzaRed Onion, Blue Cheese, Chicken, Franks Red Hot, Garlic + Oil Base$27.00
- Brooklyn PizzaSausage, Mushroom, Olive, Red Bell Pepper$27.00
- SFNY Special PizzaCanadian Bacon, Pepperoni, Olives, Red Peppers, Mushrooms$29.00
- BBQ Chicken PizzaChicken, Onion, Pepperoncinis, and Shredded Parmesan on BBQ Base$29.00
- Combination PizzaPepperoni, Sausage, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Olives, Onions$29.00
- Veggie PizzaRed and Green Bell Peppers, Mushrooms, Olives, Onions, Artichoke Hearts on Basil Pesto Base$29.00
- Greek PizzaSpinach, Tomato, Kalamata Olives, Red Onion, and Feta on Garlic + Oil Base$29.00
- Meat Lovers PizzaSausage, Pepperoni, Bacon, Canadian Bacon$28.00
Slices
- Cheese Pizza SliceA simple, classic New York staple - mozzarella and our tomato sauce$3.50
- Pepperoni Pizza SliceOur best selling slice - pepperoni, mozzarella, tomato sauce$3.75
- Vegetarian Pizza SliceMozzarella, piled high with fresh local vegetables$4.25
- Chef's Choice$4.25
Sides
- 3 Breadsticks & Sauce$4.50
- CalzoneOlive Oil, Ricotta, Mozz + 5 toppings of choice w/ one side of Red Sauce$12.00
- Wings6 Wings - BBQ, Buffalo, or Plain – served with carrot and celery sticks and one side of Ranch or Blue Cheese dressing$6.00
- Wings12 Wings - BBQ, Buffalo, or Plain – served with carrot and celery sticks and one side of Ranch or Blue Cheese dressing$10.00
Salads
- Caesar SaladAdd chicken +$3.00$5.50
- Garden SaladAdd chicken +$3.00$5.50
- Spinach SaladAdd chicken +$3.00$5.50
- Family Size SaladChoice of Caesar, Garden, or Spinach – double portion with two side dressings$9.00
Daily Specials
- Any 2 Slices + Soda$9.00
- Slice & Salad$9.00
- Tallboy SpecialCheese slice + PBR/Rainer$5.00
Beverages
- Fountain Soda$2.50
- Canned SodaCoke, Sprite, Diet Coke, Fanta, Ginger Ale, Diet Ginger Ale$2.50
- 2 Liter SodaCoke, Sprite, Diet Coke, Fanta$4.75
- 6 Pack Micro Beer$14.00
- 6 Pack Tall Boys$10.00
- Growler Fill64oz SFNY Growler (Growler Bottle $5)$12.00
Menu Gallery
Menu Gallery
Menus may not be up to date.