Southernmost Sandy’s Cafe Menu

4.4

(100+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Baskets Burrito Beverage Common Tacos Burgers Breakfast Starters Coffee Breakfast Sandwich Sides Sandwich Tostones

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Cuban Mix
  Ham, pork, salami, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, mustard and mayo. Served with French Fries on the side.
  $13.50
- Breakfast Special Platter
  Two eggs, your choice of meat, your choice of side, choice of pancakes or Belgium waffle and some seasonal fruit.
  $13.25
- Chicken Tacos
  3 tacos served with red sauce, guacamole and spicy watermelon on the side. Peppers, onions, cilantro and chihuahua cheese inside of each taco
  $13.50
- Iced Cafe con Leche
  16 oz cup
  $4.95
- Bacon Egg & Cheese
  Served with hash browns and slice of seasonal fruit
  $9.00
- Cheese Bread
  Soft, Latin-American style bread, typically filled with a blend of cheeses.
  $3.50
- Large Con Leche
  16 oz
  $4.75
- Key West Breakfast
  Two eggs choice of bacon, ham, sausage, choice of grits, fries or hash brown,
  $10.00
- Skirt Steak Tacos
  3 tacos served with red sauce, guacamole and spicy watermelon on the side. Onions, cilantro, chihuahua cheese and chimichurry inside of each taco.
  $14.50
- Steak Egg & Cheese
  Served with hash browns and slice of seasonal fruit
  $10.00
Baskets
- Chicken Tenders
  Served with fries and honey mustard
  $15.50
- Chicken Wings
  Chicken wings served with a selection of sauces including BBQ, hot, mild, or mole.
  $12.95
- Hot Dog
  Jumbo Hot dog with your choice of toppings
  $9.00
- Shrimp & Chips
  Fried shrimp paired with crispy potato chips, typically served in a basket.
  $18.50
- Snapper Fish & Chips
  Served with fries and tartar sauce.
  $18.50
Burrito
- California Burrito
  12" flour tortilla filled with Arrechera Steak, Curly Fries, Pico de Gallo, Guacamole, Chihuahua Cheese, Chimichurry, Homemade Roasted Garlic Aioli. Served with a small side of French fries red sauce and homemade habanero sauce on the side
  $18.00
Beverage
- Apple Juice
  Freshly squeezed apple nectar, packed with the tart and sweet essence of ripe apples.
  $2.99
- Bottled Water
  Pure and refreshing bottled water.
  $2.50
- Can Soda
  Crisp, Chilled Can of Refreshing Soda - Perfect Thirst Quencher
  $2.75
- Orange Juice
  Classic citrus refreshment.
  $2.99
Common
- Happy hour Chicken wings
  Chicken wings prepared for happy hour, typically marinated and cooked to achieve a balance of flavors that complement a festive atmosphere.
  $7.00
- Happy hour Conch fritters
  Conch fritters are made by deep-frying a batter mixed with conch meat, typically including onions, bell peppers, and a blend of spices, served with a dipping sauce.
  $8.00
- Happy hour Egg plant chips
  Thinly sliced eggplant, fried until crisp, typically accompanied by a selection of Latin dips.
  $6.00
- Happy hour Pretzel bites
  Bite-sized pretzels, typically served with a tangy mustard dip.
  $6.00
Tacos
- Chicken Tacos
  3 tacos served with red sauce, guacamole and spicy watermelon on the side. Peppers, onions, cilantro and chihuahua cheese inside of each taco
  $13.50
- Cuban Pork Tacos
  3 tacos served with red sauce, guacamole and spicy watermelon on the side. Cuban Roasted pork, mojo onions, cilantro and cotija cheese inside of each taco
  $13.50
- Fried Mahi Tacos
  3 tacos served with red sauce, guacamole and spicy watermelon on the side. lettuce, pickled onion, cilantro, chipotle aioli and cotija cheese inside of each taco
  $17.50
- Fried Shrimp Tacos
  3 tacos served with red sauce, guacamole and spicy watermelon on the side. Key west pink shrimp with pico de gallo, cotija cheese and cilantro inside of each taco.
  $18.50
- Lobster Tacos
  3 tacos served with red sauce, guacamole and spicy watermelon on the side. fried lobster, cilantro, cotija cheese and spicy lime slaw inside of each tac
  $19.50
- Skirt Steak Tacos
  3 tacos served with red sauce, guacamole and spicy watermelon on the side. Onions, cilantro, chihuahua cheese and chimichurry inside of each taco.
  $14.50
- Vegetarian tacos
  Corn tortillas filled with a mix of seasonal vegetables, typically includes beans, cheese, and a variety of salsas, garnished with avocado and cilantro.
  $11.50
Burgers
- Black & Blue Burger
  1/2 Lb Angus beef patty, bleu cheese crumbles, lettuce, tomatoes and red onions. Served with fries
  $13.50
- Cheddar Bacon Burger
  1/2 Lb Angus beef patty, aged cheddar cheese, applewood bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and red onions. Served with fries.
  $12.50
- Classic Burger
  1/2 Lb Angus beef patty, American cheese, lettuce, red onions and tomatoes. Served with fries.
  $11.50
- Cubana Burger
  1/2 Lb Angus beef patty, mojo onions, salami, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomatoes. Served with fries
  $12.50
Breakfast
- Breakfast Special Platter
  Two eggs, your choice of meat, your choice of side, choice of pancakes or Belgium waffle and some seasonal fruit.
  $13.25
- Breakfast tacos
  Corn or flour tortilla filled with traditional Latin-American breakfast ingredients.
  $12.50
- Key West Breakfast
  Two eggs choice of bacon, ham, sausage, choice of grits, fries or hash brown,
  $10.00
- Make Your Own Omelette
  Three eggs omelette, served with Hashbrown and toast
  $6.00
Starters
- Buffalo Shrimp
  Served with Bleu Cheese
  $15.00
- Calamari
  Served with Chipotle Aioli
  $14.00
- Conch Fritters
  6 pcs Served with Cocktail Sauce
  $12.00
- Key west Shrimp Peel & Eat
  Served with Cocktail Sauce
  $17.00
- Seasoned Fries
  Crispy fries tossed in a savory blend of spices and herbs.
  $5.00
- Shrimp Cocktail
  Shrimp cocktail with zing zang sauce, pico de Gallo, cucumber and avocado. served with crackers
  $16.00
- Sweet Potato Fries
  Crispy and flavorful fries made from sweet potatoes, a delightful twist on a classic favorite.
  $5.00
Coffee
- Buchi
  4 oz Espresso
  $3.00
- Colada
  8 oz Espresso
  $4.50
- Cortadito
  8 oz Cup
  $3.75
- Iced Cafe con Leche
  16 oz cup
  $4.95
- Large Con Leche
  16 oz
  $4.75
- Medium Con Leche
  Steamed milk blended with a balanced shot of espresso, typically sweetened to enhance the flavor.
  $4.00
- Small Con Leche
  A smaller serving of espresso mixed with steamed milk, typically sweetened.
  $3.50
Breakfast Sandwich
- Bacon Egg & Cheese
  Served with hash browns and slice of seasonal fruit
  $9.00
- Chicken Egg & Cheese
  Served with hash browns and slice of seasonal fruit
  $10.00
- Egg & Cheese
  Served with hash browns and slice of seasonal fruit
  $8.00
- Ham Egg & Cheese
  Ham, egg, and cheese served on toasted bread, typically accompanied by mayonnaise.
  $9.00
- Pork Egg & Cheese
  Served with hash browns and slice of seasonal fruit
  $10.00
- Sausage Egg & Cheese
  Sausage, egg, and cheese served on a toasted bread, typically includes a Latin-American twist to the classic breakfast sandwich ingredients.
  $9.00
- Steak Egg & Cheese
  Served with hash browns and slice of seasonal fruit
  $10.00
- Turkey Egg & Cheese
  Served with hash browns and slice of seasonal fruit
  $10.00
Sides
- Belgium waffle
  A light and crispy waffle, typically accompanied by maple syrup and a dollop of whipped cream, with an option for fresh berries.
  $8.25
- Cheese Bread
  Soft, Latin-American style bread, typically filled with a blend of cheeses.
  $3.50
- Chipotle
  Chicken sautéed with a smoky and slightly spicy chipotle sauce.
  $1.00
- Chipotle 2oz
  A smoky and slightly spicy sauce made with chipotle peppers, typically used to add flavor to dishes.
  $1.00
- Cocktail Sauce
  A tangy blend of tomatoes, horseradish, Worcestershire sauce, and spices, cocktail sauce is a classic accompaniment designed to enhance seafood dishes.
  $1.00
- Cuban bread with butter
  Cuban bread, lightly buttered and served as a simple yet satisfying side.
  $2.75
- Grilled Chicken Breast side order
  Grilled chicken breast, simply seasoned and cooked to perfection, often accompanied by Latin American spices.
  $8.00
- Guacamole 2 oz
  Mashed avocados mixed with lime juice, onions, tomatoes, and cilantro.
  $1.50
- Guava & Cheese Bread
  Baked bread infused with sweet guava paste and melted cheese, offering a unique blend of flavors.
  $4.50
- Hash-brown
  Crispy golden shredded potatoes, lightly seasoned and fried to perfection
  $1.25
- Homemade Habanero spicy sauce
  A fiery blend of habanero peppers, typically combined with garlic, onions, and a hint of citrus to create a bold and spicy sauce.
  $1.00
- Honey Mustard
  A blend of honey and mustard, this side sauce is commonly paired with Latin American dishes for added sweetness and tang.
  $1.00
- Jalapeños 2oz
  Two ounces of sliced jalapeños, typically served as a tangy and spicy accompaniment.
  $1.00
- Pancakes
  Fluffy, golden-brown pancakes
  $7.25
- Pico de Gallo 2 oz
  Diced tomatoes, onions, and cilantro, mixed with lime juice and a hint of jalapeño for a refreshing salsa.
  $1.50
- Ranch
  A Latin American inspired dressing, typically includes a blend of herbs, garlic, and tangy buttermilk.
  $1.00
- Roasted Pork side order
  Marinated roasted pork, typically includes a blend of Latin American spices, slowly oven-cooked to enhance its flavors.
  $6.00
- Side of Bacon
  Crispy, savory strips of cured pork.
  $3.95
- Side of Ham
  Sliced pork leg, typically served as a complement to main dishes.
  $3.95
- Side of sausage links
  Served as a side, these Latin-American sausage links are typically grilled or sautéed, offering a savory complement to any meal.
  $3.95
- Single Egg
  Egg cooked to preference: over easy, hard, medium, scrambled, or sunny side up.
  $1.50
- Skirt steak side order
  Skirt steak, typically marinated and grilled, often accompanied by traditional Latin American condiments or sauces.
  $8.00
- Small Grits
  Coarsely ground corn, simmered until creamy, often accompanied by butter and seasoning for added flavor.
  $2.00
- Tartar Sauce
  A classic condiment made with finely chopped pickles, mayonnaise, and typically includes hints of fresh herbs and lemon juice.
  $1.00
Sandwich
- Cuban Mix
  Ham, pork, salami, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, mustard and mayo. Served with French Fries on the side.
  $13.50
- Fried Lobster Sandwich
  Panko breaded lobster, lettuce, tomatoes and red onions. Served with French fries
  $18.50
- Fried Shrimp Sandwich
  Panko breaded Key West pink shrimp, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions. Served with French Fries
  $16.50
- Sandito's Sandwich
  Ham, pork, salami, Swiss cheese, American cheese, bacon, Turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, mayo and mustard. Served with fries
  $13.50
- Spicy Fried Chicken Sandwich
  Spicy breaded chicken breast, lettuce, tomatoes and red onions.
  $12.50
Tostones
- Cuban Roasted Pork Tostones
  Fried green plantains stuffed with roasted pork, topped with onion, mojo, cotija cheese and cilantro
  $14.50
- Lobster Tostones
  Fried green plantains stuffed with grilled lobster, topped with spicy cilantro lime slaw and cotija cheese
  $19.50
- Mahi Tostones
  Fried green plantains stuffed with grilled mahi , peppers and onions, topped with chipotle aioli, cotija cheese and cilantro
  $17.50
- Shrimp Tostones
  Fried green plantains stuffed with grilled shrimp, peppers and onions, topped with chihuahua cheese and cilantro.
  $17.50
- Skirt Steak Tostones
  Fried green Plantains stuffed with Angus skirt steak and onions, topped with chimichurry, cotija cheese and cilantro
  $17.50