South Street Creamery Menu

4.5

(375+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Salads Sandwiches & Paninis Kids Menu Crepes Menu Cafe Drinks - Hot & Iced Dinner - Chef's Specials Dinner - Teff Injera Appetizers Triangle Pizzettes Eritrean - Ethiopian Meals Homemade Pastries & Sweets Ice Cream - Scoops & Pints Ice Cream - Cakes

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Double Scoop of Ice Cream
  2 scoops of your favorite flavors, yay!!!!
  $7.45
- Chicken Salad Sandwich
  The best chicken salad you've ever had! Diced chicken breast (slow roasted in our oven) with mandarin oranges, grapes, crunchy celery, mayo, and lettuce in a wrap.
  $15.40
- Homemade Cookie
  Made fresh by our staff, our most popular are chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, ginger & molasses, and sugar.
  $4.00
- Brownies
  Decadent and rich, these brownies are a treat for any time of day!
  $4.00
- Turkey Club Sandwich
  Home-roasted Turkey, swiss cheese, bacon, mayonnaise, tomato, and lettuce on rye bread.
  $15.40
- Lentil Birsen
  Gluten free, vegan. Red split lentils slow cooked with tomato, onions, garlic, and our Berbere seasoning. Served with your choice of injera or seasoned rice.
  $26.25
- Grilled Chicken Panini
  Slow-roasted chicken breast, fresh mozzarella, and roasted peppers with house-made pesto and house-made balsamic, all grilled on our homemade focaccia.
  $15.40
- Pint of Ice Cream
  We've been making ice cream at the creamery since 1999! Take home a pint (as A Gift or for yourself) of your favorite deliciously creamy flavor to enjoy.
  $10.85
- Cloud Coffee / Dalgona
  Frothed espresso and sugar gently layered over iced cold milk!
  $6.30
- Himbasha Sweet Bread
  Vegetarian. Our homemade Eritrean sweet bread flavored with cardamom and black nigella seed.
  $4.00
Salads
- Caesar Salad
  Romaine, arugula, shaved Parmesan, and homemade croutons with our custom Caesar dressing.
  $14.00
- Greek Salad
  Mixed field greens, tomato, cucumber, feta cheese and kalamata olives with our house vinaigrette.
  $14.00
- House Salad
  Mixed field greens, tomatoes, cucumbers and our house vinaigrette.
  $14.00
- Spinach Salad
  Baby spinach, feta, red onions, dried cranberries with an orange balsamic vinaigrette.
  $14.00
Sandwiches & Paninis
- Albacore Tuna Salad Sandwich
  A creamery original blend of white albacore tuna, pecans, celery, scallions, apples, mayo, and lettuce on rye bread.
  $15.40
- Caprese Panini
  Fresh tomato, mozzarella, and basil with herbed dressing and house-made balsamic grilled on our homemade focaccia.
  $15.40
- Chicken Salad Sandwich
  The best chicken salad you've ever had! Diced chicken breast (slow roasted in our oven) with mandarin oranges, grapes, crunchy celery, mayo, and lettuce in a wrap.
  $15.40
- Eggplant Panini
  Oven-roasted eggplant with tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and house-made balsamic, all served on a rustic roll.
  $15.40
- Grilled Chicken Panini
  Slow-roasted chicken breast, fresh mozzarella, and roasted peppers with house-made pesto and house-made balsamic, all grilled on our homemade focaccia.
  $15.40
- Italian Hoagie
  Our house-roasted Turkey with ham, provolone, herbed seasoning, lettuce, and tomato on a rustic roll.
  $15.40
- Monsieur Panini
  Black forest ham, swiss cheese, dijon mustard, and house-made balsamic grilled on a rustic roll.
  $15.40
- Roast Beef & Cheddar Sandwich
  Slow-cooked roast beef with cheddar cheese, lettuce, and horseradish mayo, all served in a rustic roll.
  $15.40
- Roast Beef Panini
  Fresh tomato, mozzarella, and basil with herbed dressing and house-made balsamic grilled on our homemade focaccia.
  $15.40
- Turkey Club Sandwich
  Home-roasted Turkey, swiss cheese, bacon, mayonnaise, tomato, and lettuce on rye bread.
  $15.40
- Turkey Cranberry Sandwich
  Thanksgiving in a sandwich! Home-roasted Turkey, cream cheese, and our house-made cranberry chutney with lettuce on a rustic roll.
  $15.40
Kids Menu
- Kids Drink
  Choose a kids-size of any soda, juice, milk, lemonade, or tea!
  $2.30
- Kids Grilled Cheese
  Made with American cheese! Includes chips and a kids milk, juice, or soda.
  $11.70
- Kids Ham & Cheese on White Bread
  $11.70
- Kids Mac & Cheese
  A House blend of cream and cheese slow-cooked with macaroni. Includes chips and a kids milk, juice, or soda.
  $11.70
- Kids Pizza
  Flatbread topped with our homemade tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. Comes with chips and a kids milk, juice, or soda!
  $11.70
- Kids Turkey & Cheese on White Bread
  $11.70
Crepes Menu
- Apple Chutney Crepe
  A warm crepe layered with slow-roasted apples, raisins, and cinnamon.
  $12.00
- Banana Nutella Crepe
  Banana and Nutella layered together in a warm, homemade crepe!
  $12.00
- Caramel Banana Foster Crepe!
  You don't have to fly all the way To France for this crepe! Caramel and bananas layered with wet walnuts.
  $12.00
- S'mores Crepe
  Campfire favorite! Our crepe stuffed with marshmallows and chocolate chips!
  $12.00
- Sugar Crepe
  So simple, so good! A 'lil sugar in a warm crepe, dusted with powdered sugar.
  $10.30
- Strawberry Banana Crepe
  A classic For a Reason! Strawberries and bananas packed together for this delightful treat.
  $12.00
Cafe Drinks - Hot & Iced
- Arnold Palmer
  Half fresh-squeezed lemonade with your choice of half unsweetened black or unsweetened (and decaf) herbal berry iced tea!
  $5.15
- Cappuccino
  A froth-rich blend of milk and espresso!
  $5.15
- Chiller
  Ice cream, espresso, ice, and your choice of flavoring blended together in this frappuccino-inspired blend!
  $9.70
- Espresso
  A Single Shot of our roasted espresso.
  $4.00
- Fountain Soda
  Coke, Diet Coke, Ginger Ale, Root Beer, Sprite, Seltzer.
  $3.45
- Homebrew Iced Tea
  Our homemade blend of sweetened iced tea!
  $5.15
- Chai Latte
  Always made with David rio chai, try our tiger spice or elephant vanilla today!
  $5.15
- Coffee
  Made with a medium-dark roast blend!
  $4.00
- Matcha Latte
  Try our custom matcha blend today!
  $5.15
- Iced Black Tea
  Made fresh daily!
  $5.15
- Iced Decaf Herbal Berry Tea
  Our fresh, loose-leaf blend of herbal berry tea! Unsweetened and decaf.
  $5.15
- Latte
  Made with our roasted espresso beans!
  $5.15
- Lemonade
  Our homemade blend of fresh-squeezed lemonade, made fresh daily!
  $5.15
- Milkshake
  Our classic milkshake is packed with three scoops of your favorite flavor, perfectly blended in our stainless-steel tumblers.
  $9.70
- Mocha Latte
  Made with our 100% Dutch cocoa blend!
  $6.00
- Smoothie
  Made with real frozen fruit, juice and ice cream or Dole Whip!!! Strawberry banana, mixed berry, mango, or pina Colada!
  $9.70
- Italian Ice Spritzer
  A refreshing combo of our homemade water ice blended with sprite!
  $9.70
- Cloud Coffee / Dalgona
  Frothed espresso and sugar gently layered over iced cold milk!
  $6.30
- Ice Cream Float
  A One scoop of ice cream in the soda of your choice!
  $9.70
- Americano
  Espresso and water, giving the appearance of drip coffee but provides the coffee lover with a stronger more intense flavor.
  $4.00
- Lime Spritzer
  Fresh-squeezed lime juice and sugar blended with bubbly seltzer!
  $6.30
- Orange Spritzer
  Orange juice, sugar, and bubbly seltzer!
  $6.30
Dinner - Chef's Specials
- Chicken Doro Tsebhi
  2 chicken legs and 1 hard-boiled egg simmered in our specialty sauce of Berbere seasoning and t’Esmi butter.
  $31.95
- Katenya with Cheese
  Toasted injera flavored with red pepper seasoning and clarified butter, topped with crumbled cow’s cheese.
  $20.55
- Tomato Basil Soup
  A classic the whole family will enjoy!!! Take some home for dinner tonight!
  $8.30
Dinner - Teff Injera Appetizers
- Chickpea Shiro Dip
  Gluten free, vegan, vegetarian. Roasted chicken, chipotle sauce, sweet onions, and cheddar cheese. .
  $17.10
- Cranberry Chutney Dip
  Gluten free, vegetarian. Toasted injera chips with a dip of whipped cream cheese & homemade cranberry chutney. .
  $17.10
- Sweet Apple Dip
  Gluten free, vegetarian. Toasted injera chips with cinnamon, sugar & apple chutney.
  $17.10
- Tomato Salsa Dip
  Gluten free, vegetarian. Toasted injera chips with a dip of roasted tomatoes, garlic, onion, and red pepper seasoning. .
  $17.10
Triangle Pizzettes
- Chicken Pesto Pizzette
  Homemade pesto, fresh tomatoes, Mozzarella cheese, and roasted chicken all baked on our homemade flatbread.
  $18.85
- Cranberry & Feta Pizzette
  Vegetarian. Homemade cranberry chutney, Feta cheese, red onions, and arugula.
  $18.85
- Margarita Pizzette
  Vegetarian. Mozzarella cheese, basil, fresh tomatoes, and our homemade tomato sauce.
  $18.85
- Spicy Chicken Pizzette
  Spicy. Roasted chicken, chipotle sauce, sweet onions, and cheddar cheese.
  $18.85
- Turkey Apple Pizzette
  Shredded turkey, homemade apple chutney, and Cheddar cheese.
  $18.85
Eritrean - Ethiopian Meals
- Berbere Spice Seasoning
  An authentic blend of Berbere that includes ginger, garlic, basil, ajwain seeds, cardamom, and a variety of other seasonings and flavors!
  $15.95
- Himbasha Sweet Bread
  Vegetarian. Our homemade Eritrean sweet bread flavored with cardamom and black nigella seed.
  $4.00
- Beef Shiro
  Gluten free. Beef, onions, tomatoes, and pepper simmered in our specialty sauce of roasted chickpeas. Served with your choice of injera or seasoned rice.
  $26.25
- Beef Siga
  Gluten free. Beef, onions, tomatoes, and garlic simmered in our specialty sauce of red pepper seasoning and clarified butter. Served with your choice of injera or seasoned rice.
  $26.25
- Chicken Qulwa
  Gluten free. Chicken breast prepared with fresh tomatoes, bell peppers, onions, and our red pepper seasoning of Berbere, all blended. Served with your choice of injera or seasoned rice.
  $26.25
- Eggplant Melanzane
  Gluten free, vegan. Roasted eggplants, garlic, onions, tomato, bell peppers, and red pepper seasoning sautéed in olive oil. Served with your choice of injera or seasoned rice.
  $26.25
- Lentil Birsen
  Gluten free, vegan. Red split lentils slow cooked with tomato, onions, garlic, and our Berbere seasoning. Served with your choice of injera or seasoned rice.
  $26.25
- Mushroom Kanti Shah
  Gluten free, vegan. Mushrooms slow-cooked in a blend of fresh tomatoes, onions, garlic, bell peppers, and our red pepper seasoning of Berbere. Served with your choice of injera or seasoned rice.
  $26.25
Homemade Pastries & Sweets
- Roasted Nuts
  A 3 oz package of our candied and house-roasted pecans or almonds. .
  $6.30
- Baked Breads
  Pick up a slice of our chef's homemade banana chip or carrot bread, both are delicious!!! (Ps. They go fast!!).
  $4.00
- Brownies
  Decadent and rich, these brownies are a treat for any time of day!
  $4.00
- Granola
  12 oz bag. Take home a package of our famous slow-baked granola; available in cranberry almond, chocolate, or plain original! .
  $14.00
- Homemade Cookie
  Made fresh by our staff, our most popular are chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, ginger & molasses, and sugar.
  $4.00
Ice Cream - Scoops & Pints
- Banana Split
  For the true ice cream lover, our banana split comes with three scoops and three toppings packed between a split banana and all topped with Hot Fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry!
  $10.55
- Double Scoop of Ice Cream
  2 scoops of your favorite flavors, yay!!!!
  $7.45
- Kids Scoop of Ice Cream
  A great size for the kids!
  $5.15
- Pint of Ice Cream
  We've been making ice cream at the creamery since 1999! Take home a pint (as A Gift or for yourself) of your favorite deliciously creamy flavor to enjoy.
  $10.85
- Saturdae
  The one-scoop version of our classic sundae, the saturdae comes with Hot Fudge, whipped cream, a cherry, and 1 topping of your choice.
  $8.30
- Single Scoop of Ice Cream
  Our ice cream is homemade In-house! Selection is always changing, enjoy them all!!!
  $5.45
- Sundae
  Our classic sundae combo, featuring two scoops of your favorite two flavors with Hot Fudge and 2 toppings of your choice! Topped with whipped cream and a cherry.
  $9.45
- Triple Scoop of Ice Cream
  Hip, hip, hooray for 3 scoops!!!
  $8.30
- Weekdae
  The junior version of our classic sundae, the weekdae features a kids scoop of your favorite flavor with Hot Fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry!
  $7.15
- Affogato
  An Italian dessert consisting of a shot of espresso poured over A One scoop of vanilla ice cream!
  $8.55
Ice Cream - Cakes
- Candles
  Homemade at our shop and ready for last-minute pickups, this ice cream cake serves 4-6 people and comes in either vanilla & chocolate or Oreo cookies & cream (for other flavors, please call us directly!).
  $3.75
- Ice Cream Cake
  Homemade at our shop and ready for last-minute pickups, this ice cream cake serves 4-6 people and comes in either vanilla & chocolate or Oreo cookies & cream (for other flavors, please call us directly!).
  $33.10