Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Shinnecock Lobster Factory Menu

$Seafood
42 Montauk Hwy, Southampton, NY 11968
Order Online

  • Lobster Rolls

    • Classic Lobster Roll (Guppy)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $32.24

    • Classic Lobster Roll (Shark)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $36.40

    • Classic Lobster Roll (Whale)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $40.56

    • Hamptons Lobster Roll (Guppy)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $32.24

    • Hamptons Lobster Roll (Shark)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $36.40

    • Hamptons Lobster Roll (Whale)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $40.56

    • BLT Lobster Roll (Guppy)

      Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $32.24

    • BLT Lobster Roll (Shark)

      Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $36.40

    • BLT Lobster Roll (Whale)

      Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $40.56

    • BLT Roll (No Lobster)

      $12.48

    • Cajun Lobster Roll (Guppy)

      Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $32.24

    • Cajun Lobster Roll (Shark)

      Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $36.40

    • Cajun Lobster Roll (Whale)

      Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $40.56

    • Diavolo Lobster Roll (Guppy)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $32.24

    • Diavolo Lobster Roll (Shark)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $36.40

    • Diavolo Lobster Roll (Whale)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $40.56

    • Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Guppy)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $32.24

    • Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Shark)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $36.40

    • Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Whale)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $40.56

  • Lobster Salad

    • Lobster Salad (Guppy)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette
      $32.24

    • Lobster Salad (Shark)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette
      $36.40

    • Lobster Salad (Whale)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette
      $40.56

  • Seafood

    • Lobster Fritters

      (6) Tempura battered fried lobster bites / side of chipotle aioli dipping sauce
      $20.80

    • Lobster Melt

      Fresh poached Lobster meat with slaw, sauce and cheese / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $26.00

    • Lobster Tacos

      Fresh poached Lobster tossed with warm marinated mixed peppers on two grilled tortillas with arugula, guacamole and tomatoes
      $26.00

    • Fried Fish Platter

      $18.72

  • Soups

    • Lobster Bisque

      “The Best” bisque you can find! Fresh poached lobster in broth transformed into deliseaous soup (touch of cream)
      $21.84

    • Shinnecock Clam Chowder

      Hearty local clam soup with classic vegetables (tomato base) + toasted bread
      $14.56

  • Burgers

    • Crab Cake Burger

      House-made Jumbo Lump crab cake burger / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $18.72

    • Salmon Burger

      Signature house-made Atlantic Salmon patty Grilled to perfection / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $18.72

    • Tuna Burger

      Signature house-made local yellowfin tuna burger (local catch)/ Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $18.72

    • Fish Burger

      $16.64

  • Sides

    • Local Sweet Corn

      $4.16

    • Mexi Corn

      $5.20

    • Regular Fries

      $5.20

    • 1/2 Pan Of Chips

      $20.80

  • Pasta Dinner

    • Lobster Mac & Cheese

      Our famous chef’s lobster mac has fresh poached lobster with 4 cheese blend + elbow pasta / toasted penko crust
      $22.88

    • Mac & Cheese (No Lobster)

      $12.48

    • Lobster Fra Diavolo Pasta

      An unforgettable pasta dish with fresh poached lobster meat tossed with spicy fra diavolo sauce (roasted tomatoes) + spaghetti
      $36.40

    • Lobster Ravioli

      Decadent + Deliseaous! Fresh poached lobster filling enveloped in thin pasta dough and tossed with a roasted tomato cream sauce (hint of spicy heat) + blended with more lobster meat
      $33.28

  • Kids Menu

    • Kids Chicken Fingers

      $14.56

    • Kids Side Of Fries

      $3.12

  • Whole Lobster

    • 1 1/4 Lbs Whole Lobster

      Whole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat)
      $54.07

    • 1 1/2 Whole Lobster Dinner

      Whole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat) / served with baked potato + cole slaw + corn on cob
      $68.63

    • 2 Lbs Whole Lobster

      Whole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat)
      $90.47

  • Tea

    • Montauk Pink Lemonade

      $4.68

    • Montauk Lemon Tea

      $4.68

    • Montauk Raspberry

      $4.68

    • Montauk Southern Sweet Tea

      $4.68

    • Montauk White Tea

      $4.68

    • Montauk Green Tea

      $4.68

    • Montauk Lemonade

      $4.68

    • Montauk Half & Half

      $4.68

    • Montauk Mango Green Tea

      $4.68

    • Montauk Orange Clementine

      $4.68

    • Montauk Diet Sweet Tea

      $4.68

  • Soda

    • Coke Can

      $2.08

    • Sprite Can

      $2.08

    • Diet Coke

      $2.08

  • Water

    • Water

      $3.35

  • San Pellegrino

    • San Pellegrino Aranciata Rossa

      $3.12

    • San Pellegrino Limonata

      $3.12

    • San Pellegrino Arancia & Fico D'India

      $3.12

    • San Pellegrino Melograno & Arancia

      $3.12

  • Food Truck Race

    • Coke Can

      $2.08

  • Food Truck - Gas Station (Highway)

    • Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Guppy)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $32.24

    • Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Shark)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $36.40

    • Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Whale)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $40.56

    • Lobster Fritters

      (6) Tempura battered fried lobster bites / side of chipotle aioli dipping sauce
      $20.80

    • Lobster Mac & Cheese

      Our famous chef’s lobster mac has fresh poached lobster with 4 cheese blend + elbow pasta / toasted penko crust
      $22.88

    • Mexi Corn

      $5.20

    • Hamptons Lobster Roll (Guppy)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $32.24

    • Hamptons Lobster Roll (Shark)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $36.40

    • Hamptons Lobster Roll (Whale)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $40.56

    • Lobster Bisque

      “The Best” bisque you can find! Fresh poached lobster in broth transformed into deliseaous soup (touch of cream)
      $21.84

    • Classic Lobster Roll (Guppy)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $32.24

    • Classic Lobster Roll (Shark)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $36.40

    • Classic Lobster Roll (Whale)

      Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
      $40.56

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms