Sherrill New York Pizzeria Menu

4.3
(300+ Reviews)
  • Specials

    • Medium Pizza & 10 Wings Special

      $29.55
    • Large Pizza & 20 Wings Special

      $43.50
    • Large Pizza & 50 Wings Special

      $73.50
    • Large Pizza & Boneless Wings Special

      $26.70
  • Pizza

    • Large 16 Inch

      $17.85
      Large 16 Inch
    • Medium 14 Inch

      $16.10
    • Small 12 Inch

      $13.40
    • Personal 10 Inch

      $10.00
    • Cauliflower 12 Inch

      $14.75
      Cauliflower 12 Inch
    • Slice Pie 18 Inch

      $20.75
    • Sicilian 11x13

      $22.25
      Sicilian 11x13
    • Calzone

      $12.25
      Calzone
    • Stromboli

      11x13
      $26.50
      Stromboli
    • Pizza Dough

      $2.75
  • Appetizers

    • Mac & Cheese Bites

      $10.00
      Mac & Cheese Bites
    • Arancini

      $10.00
      Arancini
    • Boneless Wings

      $10.85
      Boneless Wings
    • Chicken Tenders

      $10.00
      Chicken Tenders
    • Chicken Tenders W/ Fries

      $11.25
      Chicken Tenders W/ Fries
    • Fried Dough

      $9.00
    • Fried Mushrooms

      $10.00
      Fried Mushrooms
    • Small French Fries

      $4.75
      Small French Fries
    • Large French Fries

      $5.50
      Large French Fries
    • Bacon Cheese Fries

      $10.15
      Bacon Cheese Fries
    • Garlic Bread

      $4.25
    • Garlic Bread W/ Cheese

      $4.75
    • Garlic Knots

      $6.25
      Garlic Knots
    • Mozzarella Stix

      $10.00
      Mozzarella Stix
    • Mozzarella Stix W/ Fries

      $11.25
      Mozzarella Stix W/ Fries
    • Onion Rings

      $10.00
      Onion Rings
    • Onion Rings W/ Fries

      $11.25
    • Poppers

      $10.00
      Poppers
    • Poppers W/ Fries

      $11.25
      Poppers W/ Fries
    • Fried Meatballs

      $10.00
      Fried Meatballs
    • Fried Cauliflower

      $10.00
    • Butterfly Shrimp W/ Fries

      $11.00
      Butterfly Shrimp W/ Fries
  • Chicken Wings

    • 10 Wings

      $14.95
      10 Wings
    • 20 Wings

      $27.40
    • 30 Wings

      $38.40
    • 40 Wings

      $49.40
    • 50 Wings

      $60.40
    • Boneless Wings

      $10.85
      Boneless Wings
    • Celery & Blue Cheese

      $1.30
  • Cold Subs

    • Turkey Sub

      $9.00
      Turkey Sub
    • Roast Beef Sub

      $9.00
      Roast Beef Sub
    • Italian Mixed Sub

      $9.00
    • Tuna Fish Sub

      $9.00
    • Ham Sub

      $9.00
      Ham Sub
    • Salami Sub

      $9.00
    • Veggie Sub

      $9.00
  • Hot Tunnels

    • Chicken Parm Tunnel

      $9.50
      Chicken Parm Tunnel
    • Chicken Tender Tunnel

      $9.50
      Chicken Tender Tunnel
    • Eggplant Parm Tunnel

      $9.50
    • Meatball Tunnel

      $9.50
      Meatball Tunnel
    • Pepperoni Tunnel

      $9.50
    • Sausage Tunnel

      $9.50
    • Steak Tunnel

      $9.50
      Steak Tunnel
  • Salads

    • Small Anitpasto

      $8.35
      Small Anitpasto
    • Large Antipasto

      $11.25
      Large Antipasto
  • Sauces

    • 2oz Sauce

      $0.65
    • 4oz Sauce

      $1.25
    • 8oz Sauce

      $1.85
  • Wheat Wraps

    • Chicken Wheat Wrap

      $9.00
    • Ham Wheat Wrap

      $9.00
    • Roast Beef Wheat Wrap

      $9.00
    • Turkey Wheat Wrap

      $9.00
  • Beverage

    • Can

      $1.35
      Can
    • 16oz Bottle

      $2.35
      16oz Bottle
    • 2 Liter

      $3.50
      2 Liter
    • Bottled Water

      $1.35
      Bottled Water
    • Bottle Water-Large

      $2.35
      Bottle Water-Large
    • Gatorade

      $2.60
      Gatorade
    • Snapple

      $2.60
      Snapple
    • Milk

      $2.50
      Milk

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Corner Diner Too
Corner Diner Too
4.7
(341 Reviews)
Diner, Breakfast, Lunch
Italian Sizzle Shack
Italian Sizzle Shack
4.2
(23 Reviews)
Italian
Joe's Jerky, Pizza, Deli & Corner Market
Joe's Jerky, Pizza, Deli & Corner Market
4.5
(193 Reviews)
Chicken wings
Dickey's Barbecue Pit
Dickey's Barbecue Pit
3.1
(11 Reviews)
Barbecue
The Coffee Tree
The Coffee Tree
4.6
(94 Reviews)
Coffee shop
Sweet Life of a Baker
Sweet Life of a Baker
4.9
(72 Reviews)
Bakery, Breakfast, Cafe
East Sushi
East Sushi
4.5
(80 Reviews)
Sushi
Ebeneezer's Cafe & Creamery
Ebeneezer's Cafe & Creamery
4.7
(162 Reviews)
Restaurant
Sweet Basil's Diner and Catering LLC
Sweet Basil's Diner and Catering LLC
5.0
(4 Reviews)
Restaurant

+1 315-363-2189

125 E Seneca St, Sherrill, NY 13461


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms