Sarah’s Handmade Ice Cream Wildwood Menu

Create your own pint! Mix up to 3 flavors.

Can't decide? Try Sarah's Signature 6-flavor Ice Cream Flight! Perfect to indulge, share, and explore!

Award Winning: Best of Bethesda! Our signature doggie ice creams are made with all-natural, human-grade ingredients with no added sugar. Ingredients: organic peanut butter, organic pure pumpkin, organic Greek yogurt, organic local honey, and dried beef liver. Pup cups come very frozen, so that dogs can take their time enjoying them, which also makes it easy to portion-control.

Need a larger amount of ice cream for a group? Our 1.5 gallon tub is custom made for your order and kept in our blast freezer (-30 degrees) for easy transport. Tub deposit is $15, which is fully refundable upon return of the tub/lid.

Classic sundae with a chocolate chip cookie to satisfy your cravings!

2 kiddie scoops of ice cream (or 1 full scoop), Sarah's brownie, hot fudge, whipped cream, and cherry.

Sliced banana, 3 scoops of ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, peanuts, and cherry.

6 mini ice cream sandwiches made with Tate's cookies with custom flavors. Please pre-order at least 1-2 hours in advance so that the sandwiches can freeze properly. While we are able to make the item within 10 minutes, we do not recommend that you take them home without letting it freeze for some time.

Cold brew coffee with a scoop of ice cream

Perfect to quench your thirst on a hot summer day! Sparkling soda with your choice of sorbet flavor. Vegan friendly.

Sarah's homemade fudge brownie.

Customize your own 9 inch ice cream cake for 8-12 people!Please note that our custom cakes only include choice of cake option, ice cream flavors, special messaging on top, and SIMPLE decorations only. Unfortunately, we aren't able to cater to special themes or complicated designs.If you choose 2 flavors, we assume that the ice creams are side by side, not layered. If you'd like the flavors to be layered, please let us know in the box below.All custom cake orders must be placed at least 3 days in advance. During slow season, we may be able to expedite your order; please call us to confirm.All sales are final. Please note: Photo is for reference purpose only, and actual items will vary.

Pre-made 9 inch ice cream pie (either Oreo or graham cracker crust). Call the scoop shop you'd like to pick up from to see what we have in store today! With more than 24 hours notice, we may be able to write on top of the pie. Please note: Photo is for reference purpose only, and actual items will vary.

Create your own 9 Inch ice cream pie for 6-8 people!Choice of Ice cream with either Oreo or Graham Cracker crust. Please note: Photo is for reference purpose only, and actual items will vary.All orders must be placed at least 2 days in advanced. However, during our slow season, we are able to expedite pie orders. If you are in a hurry, please call the shop, as we may have pre-made pies available for you. All sales are final.

Choose fun toppings to share with the whole family.

Cute crop top and a complimentary scoop with purchase.

If you prefer a physical gift card to be sent to your loved ones, we now offer the option! We will mail or deliver the physical giftcard in our giftcard holder.Please select this item as "pick up" not for delivery, as we will mail out the giftcard. Disregard the message saying your item is ready for pickup.