Sarah's Cake Shop Menu

A smaller version of our classic or specialty cupcakes. (Minimum of a dozen on most flavors)

Chocolate cake topped with a dollop of chocolate frosting and a swirl of our signature buttercream and a sprinkle of chocolate curls.

Caramel cake brushed with caramel, topped with caramel buttercream and a sprinkle of sea salt.

Chocolate or yellow cake topped with sweet frosting.

Buttermilk cake topped with our sweet cream cheese frosting. (Available Saturday & Sunday)

Spiced cake baked with carrots, pineapple, coconut and pecans, topped with sweet cream cheese frosting.

Our buttery yellow cake topped with our sweet frosting and a seasonal design.

Check for weekly creations!

Ask about our cupcake of the month.

3-layer round yellow, chocolate, white or almond cake filled with sweet decorators frosting and iced in buttercream, covered in rainbow or solid white nonpareils and topped with a fondant banner. Available banner colors: Black, White, Hot Pink, S...

3-layer 8” round cakes available in 5 popular shop flavors, including carrot, chocolate birthday, everyday wedding cake, vanilla birthday, and very vanilla cake. They can be personalized with a message. Available in vegan yellow and vegan chocola...

2-layer 9” round yellow, chocolate, red velvet or almond cake filled and iced in either traditional or vanilla buttercream. Red Velvet cakes are filled with cream cheese frosting. Standard cakes are topped with a fondant banner with a custom mess...

2 layers of yellow, chocolate, white or almond cake; filled & iced with buttercream. Add your color choice for borders, message and sprinkles. Add an Edible Image for additional upcharge.

Your choices are yellow and chocolate cake, filled and iced with a vanilla buttercream, choice of one color for border icing dots and message Vegan chocolate or yellow option $19.99

3-layer round chocolate, yellow, white or almond cake filled and iced in your single-color choice of buttercream rosettes and topped with a plaque from our catalog. Specialty fillings and icing available for an additional charge.

A St. Louis favorite with a rosette of cream cheese frosting

If you LOVE chocolate this cake is for you! 3 layers of chocolate cake, filled with chocolate ganache, chocolate frosting and chocolate milk crumb, iced in our signature chocolate buttercream.

Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chewy Goodness, Confetti, and Everyday Wedding Cake

Please ask for selection

2-layer, 6” round cakes that can be customized with a message and sprinkles. Celebration cakes are available in-store every day and can be ordered with at least 24-hour notice. (Serves 6-8 people) While Supplies Last

2 layers of cake filled with vanilla buttercream, dipped in chocolate and rolled in sanding sugar.

3 layers of almond cake with your choice of strawberry champagne or double chocolate covered in chocolate ganache

Cake mixed into a truffle consistency, rolled, dipped in chocolate and topped with rainbow sprinkles. Available in chocolate or vanilla.

Our rich decadent gluten free brownie is topped with ganache and a rosette of our signature chocolate buttercream. This brownie is a must try!