Pies
- Mozzarella & Tomato Sauce PieMade with sally's tomato sauce and mozzarella
- Tomato Sauce PieMade with sally's tomato sauce and parmesan (without mozzarella)
- White PieMade with mozzarella and parmesan(without tomato sauce)
Speciality Pies
- Potato & Rosemary SpecialPotato,onion,mozzarella parmesan and roasemary
- The Garden SpecialFresh tomato,mozzarella,onion,zucchini,fresh garlic,parmesan and basil
- Fresh Tomato White PieFresh tomato,mozzarella garlic and basil
- New Haven Original Clam PieMozzarella,fresh clams fresh garlic and parmesan cheese
Toppings
- Extra Mozzarella
- Pepperoni,Sausage,Meatball,Bacon(Each)
- Roasted Peppers,Hot Peppers,Broccoli(Each)
- Onions,Mushrooms,Olives(Each)
- Anchovies,Tuna(Each)
- Fresh Clams
- Gulf Shrimp
- Oven Roasted Chicken
- Fresh Garlic,Basil(Each)
Salads
- House SaladMixed greens,tomatoes,red onions house italian dressing
- Caesar SaladRomaine,parmesan,caesar dressing and croutons
Dessert
- Cannoli PiePer slice$5.95
Specialty Cocktails
- The Gin GenieGin, lime, ginger, mint$12.00
- Wooster St. SpecialBourbon, rye, pineapple, lemon, pomegranate$12.00
- Nine Point TwoDark rum, aperol, lime, orange$12.00
- Song Remains The SameCampari, old forester, cocchi di torino$12.00
- The Secret NumberBlanco tequila, mezcal, sweet vermouth, cucumber, lime, agave, hellfire bitters$12.00
- The Italian CookieAmaretto, campari, orange, lemon$12.00
- Start Me UpMezcal, montenegro, aperol, lemon$12.00
- FireBlanco tequila, cassis, lime, ginger, hellfire bitters$12.00
- The 1938Gin, lemon, cucumber, mint$12.00
- Summer St. SwizzleVodka, st. Germaine, blanc vermouth, pineapple, lemon, honey$12.00
Frozen Drinks
- Aperol Spritz$9.00
- Lemonade(Non-alcoholic)$6.00
Beers
- Sallys ApilzBy nebco
- Miller Lite
- Peroni
- Allagash White
- Nebco Sea Hag
- Beer'd Dogs & Boats
Drinks
- Foxon Park Spring Water$1.95
- Topo Chico Sparkling Water$2.95
- Spindrift Sparkling WaterAssorted flavors$2.95
- Flow Natural Alkaline Spring WaterAssorted flavors$2.95
- House Brewed Iced Tea$2.95
- Fresh Squeezed Lemonade$3.75
- Rise Nitro Cold Brew Coffee$3.95
- Fountain SodaCoke diet coke sprite foxon rootbeer foxon white birch foxon diet white birch foxon cream soda boylan ginger ale boylan black cherry boylan orange$2.95
- Specialty Bottled SodasMexican coca-cola mexican sprite$3.25
- Abita Root Beer$3.50
- Sprecher Root Beer$3.25
- Hank's Crafted SodaPremium grape vanilla cream$3.95
Wine & Seltzer
- Sally's Red
- Sally's White
- Il Nido Rose Veneto
- Parolvini Prosecco
- Fishers Island Lemonade$8.95
- White ClawAssorted flavors$6.95
- SangriaSally's red, pineapple, rum, brandy$8795.00
