Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Ritter's Frozen Custard Menu

$Ice cream shop
4949 E Stop 11 Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46237
Order Online

  • Signature Sundaes

    • Strawberry Delight

      Strawberries & sugar wafers
      $4.94

    • Mud Sundae

      Chocolate frozen custard, chocolate syrup, marshmallow creme & Oreo® cookies
      $4.94

    • Strawberry Shortcake

      Vanilla frozen custard, fresh strawberries & strawberry sauce on cake
      $4.94

    • Brownie Sundae

      Chocolate brownie & hot fudge
      $4.94

    • Grizzly Cub Special

      Hot fudge & Spanish peanuts
      $4.94

    • Turtle Sundae

      Hot fudge, hot caramel & toasted pecans
      $4.94

    • Peanut Butter Mountain

      Peanut butter sauce & Reese's® peanut butter cups
      $4.94

    • Banana Split

      Chocolate syrup, strawberries, pineapple & toasted pecans
      $5.54

  • Create Your Own

    • Sundaes

      $3.29

    • Shakes & Malts

      $3.64

  • Italian Ice

    • Italian Slush Sippable

      $2.54

    • Gelati

      $3.99

    • Gelati Blend

      $3.84

  • Glaciers

    • Glaciers

      $3.84

  • Glaciers Mix-In

    • Cake Batter

    • Strawberry

    • Banana

    • Wild Cherry

    • Peach

    • Marshmallow

    • Pineapple

    • Oreo

    • Heath

    • M & Ms

    • Butterfinger

    • Reese's

    • Snickers

    • Sprinkles

    • Coconut

    • Peanut Butter

    • Black Raspberry

    • Red Raspberry

    • Chocolate Chips

    • Cookie Dough

  • Kids Favorites

    • Worms 'N Dirt Sundae

      $2.14

    • Kid's Crunch Sundae

      $2.14

    • Monkey In The Middle Sundae

      $2.14

    • Cookie Dough Rockslide Sundae

      $2.14

  • Cones & Dishes

    • Waffle Cone

      $3.34

    • Cake Cone

      $2.56

    • Dipped Waffle Cone

      $4.64

    • Dishes

      $2.50

  • Take Some Home!

    • By The Tub

      $4.49

    • Cubby Paw

      $1.99

  • Cakes & Pies

    • Sheet Cakes

      It's our famous party cake with corners. We give you lots of size options and one constant: Whether you're serving twenty or two, our sheet cake makes it an occasion to remember. Size / Serving: Full sheet - 25 to 30, Half sheet 12 to 15, Quarter sheet: 4 to 6, Cake for 2

    • Oreo® Cookie Cake

      (Serves 10 to 12). Yes, it's just as delicious as it looks. Moist chocolate cake and creamy vanilla frozen custard separated by layers of crumbled Oreos®. Lavishly Covered with whipped icing and more oreos®

    • Reese's Cake

      (Served 10 to 12). Rich chocolate cake layered with our homemade vanilla frozen custard and crumbled Reese's® cups. Then topped with real peanut butter sauce. Utter Perfection

    • Party Cakes

      (Serves 10 to 12). Let the party begin. Moist chocolate or white cake, topped with creamy chocolate or vanilla frozen custard, completely covered with whipped icing. A true cause for celebration

    • Banana Split Cake

      (Serves 10 to 12). How do you improve upon a classic? Well, we start with fresh White and chocolate cake. Then we layer it with fresh banana frozen custard, strawberries, and pineapple, chocolate syrup, butter toasted pecans, and cherries for real a-peel

    • Heath® Bar Cake

      (Serves 10 to 12). Rich chocolate cake layered with our homemade vanilla frozen custard and crumbled Reese's cups. Then topped with real peanut batter sauce. Utter perfection

    • Snickers Pie

      (Serves 10 to 12). It's like a frozen Snickers® bar. Only a thousand times better. An Oreo® cookie crust, brimming with fresh vanilla frozen custard, smothered with fudge, caramel topping, and ground snickers®

    • Mud Pie

      (Serves 10 to 12). Here's the dirt on one of our most popular pies: It's an Oreo® cookie crust filled with creamy chocolate frozen custard, topped with chocolate syrup, marshmallow crème, and Oreos

    • Peanut Butter Mountain Pie

      (Serves 10 to 12). Think ginormous. Think an Oreo® cookie crust, piled high with vanilla frozen custard, covered with ground Reese's® cups, topped with real peanut butter sauce, and chocolate syrup

    • Mint Chocolate Chip Pie

      (Serves 10 to 12). It's enough to make other pies green with envy. An Oreo® cookie crust filled with cool, crisp mint chocolate chip frozen custard, then smothered in rich fudge, drizzled with gooey marshmallow crème, and topped with chocolate carts

    • Turtle Pie

      (Serves 10 to 12). Slow down and enjoy. An Oreo® cookie crust chock-full of our legendary vanilla frozen custard, topped with rich, thick fudge & caramel toppings, and crunchy butter toasted pecans

  • Featured Items

    • Red Velvet

    • Cookie Dough

    • Mint Oreo Torte

    • Pumpkin Nut Pie

      Available seasonally, upon request

    • Strawberry Delight

    • Chocolate Kiss Bliss

  • Create Your Own

    • Create Your Own Cake Or Pie

      (Serves 10-12). Additional for an extra charge. Gummy Worms, Sprinkles, Chocolate Chip, Cookie Dough, Hot Caramel, M & Ms, Heath, Oreo, Chocolate Syrup, Hot Fudge, Marshmallow, Butter Scotch, Peanut Butter, Reese's, Snickers, Butterfinger, Banana, Peach, Strawberry, Pineapple, Toasted Pecan, Spanish Peanut, Blueberry, Black Raspberry, Toasted Almonds, Coconut

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms