Seasonal Items
- Red Velvet Heart Shaped Whoopie PieShow your love with our Heart-Shaped Red Velvet Whoopie Pie! Soft, moist red velvet cakes are lovingly sandwiched with a smooth, creamy filling, creating the perfect balance of rich flavor and sweetness. Whether you're celebrating or just craving something special, this delightful treat is sure to melt hearts with every bite!$3.53
- Chocolate Covered Cherry DonutExperience the perfect blend of sweetness with our Chocolate Covered Cherry Donut! This fluffy donut is filled with a luscious cherry filling, then topped with a smooth, rich chocolate icing. A heavenly combination of fruity and chocolaty goodness in every bite. Treat yourself to a deliciously indulgent moment!$3.25
- Red Velvet Whoopie PieDelight in the classic flavors of our Red Velvet Whoopie Pie! Two soft, moist red velvet cakes are filled with a rich, creamy filling, creating the perfect balance of sweet and velvety goodness. A deliciously indulgent treat that’s perfect for any occasion!$3.53
- Red Velvet Frosted Sugar CookiesTreat yourself to our irresistible Red Velvet Cookies with Cream Cheese Frosting! These soft, chewy cookies are made with rich red velvet flavor and topped with a luscious layer of smooth cream cheese frosting. A perfect balance of sweetness and tanginess in every bite—ideal for satisfying your dessert cravings!$2.99
Fry Pies
- Fry PieA delightful, crispy pastry filled with sweet, flavorful fruit filling. Made fresh at our Amish bakery in Middlebury, Indiana.$4.29
Donuts
- America’s Favorite Donut - Cinnamon Caramel RingAmish crack Cinnamon Caramel donuts$2.09
- Ring DonutFreshly made Amish donuts$2.09
- Premium DonutFreshly made Premium Amish donuts$2.39
- 6-Count Mixed DonutsChoose your own or let us pick for you!$11.75
- 12- Count Mixed DonutsChoose your own or let us pick for you!$21.99
- Donut HolesFamous Amish crack donut holes$4.99
Crunch Candy
- Nutty Crunch$9.59
- Chocolate Covered Nutty Crunch$9.59
- Pecan Crunch$9.59
- Chocolate Covered Pecan Crunch$9.59
- Cashew Crunch$9.59
- Chocolate Covered Cashew Crunch$9.59
Rolls, Danish, Buns, & Muffins
- Cinnamon RollsGiant, Amish-made Cinnamon Rolls smothered in cream cheese icing.$3.59
- Pecan Sticky BunsAmish-made Cinnamon Roll smothered in Indiana maple syrup and pecans$4.05
- Apple FritterClassic apple fritter sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.$2.79
- DanishDelight in our freshly baked danishes, featuring a variety of sweet and savory fillings wrapped in flaky, golden pastry$2.99
- MuffinsEnjoy our freshly baked muffins, bursting with rich flavors and textures, made with the finest ingredients for a perfect treat.$3.50
Cookies and Pies
- Box Of Cookies (6)Fresh-baked, Amish-made box of cookies$10.60
- Box Of Cookies (12)Freshly Baked, Amish-made cookies$19.51
- 4-Count Chocolate Whoopie PiesAmish-made chocolate Whoopie pies$11.59
- Fresh Amish Pie (7 Inch)Freshly baked, Amish pie (7 inch)$10.86
- Fresh Amish Pie (9 Inch)Freshly baked, Amish pie (9 inch)$28.68
Sweet Breads
- Apple BreadFreshly baked, Amish-made Apple Bread$6.39
- Banana BreadAmish-made, freshly baked Banana Bread$6.39
- Pumpkin BreadAmish-made, freshly baked Pumpkin Bread$6.39
- Zucchini BreadAmish-made, freshly baked Zucchini Bread$6.39
Beverages
- Signature CoffeeFresh brewed hot coffee$2.49
- Bottled DrinksAn assortment of Pepsi fan favorites!$3.73
- Hot ChocolateIndulge in our velvety hot chocolate, made with premium cocoa and topped with fluffy whipped cream. Each sip delivers a perfect blend of sweetness and warmth, making it the ultimate treat for chocolate lovers.$3.45
Grocery Items
- Pint Jars$9.73
- Theresa's Homemade CheeseballExperience the ultimate snacking delight with Theresa’s homemade cheeseballs! Each cheeseball is expertly blended with premium cheeses and flavorful ingredients, resulting in a creamy, irresistible treat. Perfect for parties, gatherings, or a cozy night in, these cheeseballs are best enjoyed with your favorite crackers or veggies.\n\nElevate your appetizer game and savor the taste of homemade goodness with every bite!\n\n$13.99
