Proper Sandwich Company Menu

4.7

(250+ Reviews)

$Sandwich shop

Customer Favorites Sandwiches Sides and Salads Banh Mi Drinks Specials Select your catering sandwiches

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Italian Hoagie
  french ham, coppa, salami calabrese, mortadella w/pistachio, aged provolone, house made giardiniera, shredduce, red onion, oregano, red wine vinegar, and Duke's mayo
  $15.25
- Turkey Club
  Smoked turkey breast, applewood smoked bacon, swiss, fresh tomatoes, shredduce, chipotle mayo on a hoagie roll
  $15.25
- Hot Prime Beef & Cheddar
  house-roasted prime beef, tipperary irish cheddar, crispy fried onions, 1000 horsey sauce, house-made 'arby' sauce on a potato roll
  $15.95
- Kyle's Chimichurri Beef
  house made roast beef, chimichurri, french fries, sautéed mushrooms, chimichurri aioli on ciabatta
  $16.75
- Cookie
  Freshly baked cookies!
  $4.00
- Chicken Bánh Mì
  grilled char siu chicken, pickled carrot & daikon, jalapeno, cucumber, cilantro herb mix, scallion, and Duke's mayo on classic bread
  $14.25
- Pastrami "Rachel"
  applewood smoked pastrami, melted swiss, russian dressing with horseradish, creamy coleslaw on toasted marble rye
  $15.75
- Caprese Sandwich
  burrata, fresh tomatoes, basil, pesto, and balsamic glaze, on ciabatta
  $14.00
- Italian Beef
  house-roasted beef, giardiniera, on french bread served with au jus
  $15.95
- Hawaiian Spam & Macaroni Salad
  pan seared spam, cavatappi pasta, mayonnaise, carrots, green onion
  $6.50
Sandwiches
- Pork Bánh Mì
  lemongrass pork (contains fish sauce), pickled carrot & daikon, jalapeno, cucumber, cilantro herb mix, scallion, and Duke's mayo on classic bread
  $15.25
- Primanti Brothers
  french ham, spicy capicola, genoa salami, provolone, french fries, amish coleslaw, fresh tomato, mayo on toasted sourdough
  $15.50
- Blackened Chicken
  blackened chicken, swiss cheese, fresh tomatoes, red onion, arugula, crispy chicken skin, black garlic aioli on marble rye
  $15.50
- Caprese Sandwich
  burrata, fresh tomatoes, basil, pesto, and balsamic glaze, on ciabatta
  $14.00
- Hot Prime Beef & Cheddar
  house-roasted prime beef, tipperary irish cheddar, crispy fried onions, 1000 horsey sauce, house-made 'arby' sauce on a potato roll
  $15.95
- Italian Beef
  house-roasted beef, giardiniera, on french bread served with au jus
  $15.95
- Italian Hoagie
  french ham, coppa, salami calabrese, mortadella w/pistachio, aged provolone, house made giardiniera, shredduce, red onion, oregano, red wine vinegar, and Duke's mayo
  $15.25
- Kid's Ham
  ham and american cheese
  $6.00
- Kid's PB&J
  peanut butter and either grape or strawberry jam
  $4.00
- Kid's Turkey
  turkey and american cheese
  $6.00
- Kyle's Chimichurri Beef
  house made roast beef, chimichurri, french fries, sautéed mushrooms, chimichurri aioli on ciabatta
  $16.75
- Pastrami "Rachel"
  applewood smoked pastrami, melted swiss, russian dressing with horseradish, creamy coleslaw on toasted marble rye
  $15.75
- Tuna Salad
  tuna & giardiniera salad, radish sprouts, pepperoncini, red onion, crunchy house made potato chips on a potato roll
  $14.00
- Turkey Club
  Smoked turkey breast, applewood smoked bacon, swiss, fresh tomatoes, shredduce, chipotle mayo on a hoagie roll
  $15.25
Sides and Salads
- Arugula Salad
  arugula, freshly-grated parmigiano reggiano, toasted pecans, lemon & honey vinaigrette
  $6.00
- Bacon Dill Potato Salad
  potatoes, bacon, dill
  $6.50
- Chips
  Original Sea Salt, tangy Sea Salt & Vinegar, and smoky BBQ.
  $3.00
- Cookie
  Freshly baked cookies!
  $4.00
- Fries
  Crispy fries cooked fresh
  $3.00
- Giardiniera
  House-made, Chicago-style. Take some home today!
  $2.00
- Hawaiian Spam & Macaroni Salad
  pan seared spam, cavatappi pasta, mayonnaise, carrots, green onion
  $6.50
- House-made Potato Chips
  our very own house-made chips. You're gonna love 'em!
  $3.00
- Meal Combo
  Choice of Chips, Fries, or House Made Chips.
  $5.50
Banh Mi
- Chicken Bánh Mì
  grilled char siu chicken, pickled carrot & daikon, jalapeno, cucumber, cilantro herb mix, scallion, and Duke's mayo on classic bread
  $14.25
- Veggie Bánh Mì with Tofu
  Crispy tofu, pickled carrot & daikon, jalapeno, cucumber, cilantro herb mix, scallion, and Duke's mayo on classic bread
  $14.25
Drinks
- Bottle Water
  Refreshing still or sparkling bottled water, 16.9oz or 12oz options.
  $2.00
- Can Soda
  Coke Zero, Diet Coke, Dr. Brown's sodas, or Sprite.
  $2.50
- Fountain Drink
  Refreshing carbonated beverage available in various flavors.
  $3.00
Specials
- Shrimp Po'Boy
  fried shrimp, fresh tomato, shredduce, bread and butter pickles, with house made rémoulade on a hoagie roll
  $15.95
Select your catering sandwiches
- Pork Bánh Mì - Catering
  lemongrass pork (contains fish sauce), pickled carrot & daikon, jalapeno, cucumber, cilantro herb mix, scallion, mayo on a hoagie