PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO Menu

4.7

(325+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Individual Pizza (12)Sharing Pizza (16)Party Pizza (24)Sides Soft Drinks Sweet Corner Holiday Special

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- 5. Pepperoni (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pepperoni, sesame seeds.
  $19.00
- 9. Proper Pizza (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, smoked beef prosciutto, smoked beef sausage, mushrooms, and sesame seeds.
  $23.00
- Garlic Bread & Cheeses
  A cross between garlic bread and pizza, cheesy bread is a quick, easy, and delicious party snack, with macho sauce.
  $8.00
- 5. Pepperoni (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pepperoni, sesame seeds.
  $28.00
- 1. Margherita (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sesame seeds.
  $22.00
- 1. Margherita (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sesame seeds.
  $16.00
- Chicken Wings
  Fresh jumbo wings seasoned with our spices, served plain or tossed in buffalo or BBQ sauce with a choice of dressing
  $9.90+
- 0. Cheese Pizza (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sesame seeds.
  $20.00
- 0. Cheese Pizza (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sesame seeds.
  $14.00
- Build Your Own Pizza (16)
  Choose your sauce: classic red or creamy white.
  $25.00
Individual Pizza (12)
- 0. Cheese Pizza (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sesame seeds.
  $14.00
- 1. Margherita (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sesame seeds.
  $16.00
- 10. Blues Brother (12)
  Tomato sauce, 5 ingredients of your choice, sesame seeds.
  $25.00
- 11. Sausage Pizza (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper chees, sausage, sesame seeds
  $23.00
- 12. 4 Cheese (12)
  White sauce, special proper chees, gorgonzola, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, sesame seeds,
  $24.00
- 13. Hawaiian (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pineapple, ham, and sesame seeds.
  $24.00
- 14. Crudo Parmezan (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, rucola, parma ham prosciutto, sliced parmesan, cherry tomato, and sesame seeds.
  $25.00
- 15. American Gangster (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, ham, sliced black olives, onions, mixed peppers, mushrooms, loca sauce, sesame seeds.
  $25.00
- 16. Macho (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken meatballs, macho sauce, chives, sesame seeds.
  $21.00
- 17. Truffle (12)
  White sauce, truffle paste, truffle oil, mushrooms, pecorino cheese, pine nuts, sesame seeds.
  $25.00
- 18. Cheeseburger (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, meatballs, iceberg lettuce, burger sauce, ketchup, chives, and sesame seeds.
  $24.00
- 19. Buffalo Chicken (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, buffalo chicken, and sesame seeds.
  $20.00
- 2. Mushroom Pizza (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mushrooms, sesame seeds.
  $18.00
- 3. OMG Vegetarian (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mixed peppers, zucchini, caramelized onions, eggplants, onions, sesame seeds.
  $19.00
- 4. BBQ Chicken (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken, bbq sauce, and sesame seeds.
  $20.00
- 5. Pepperoni (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pepperoni, sesame seeds.
  $19.00
- 6. Tuna (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, tuna fish, sesame seeds.
  $22.00
- 8. Anchovies (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, anchovies, olives, sesame seeds.
  $22.00
- 9. Proper Pizza (12)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, smoked beef prosciutto, smoked beef sausage, mushrooms, and sesame seeds.
  $23.00
Sharing Pizza (16)
- 0. Cheese Pizza (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sesame seeds.
  $20.00
- 1. Margherita (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sesame seeds.
  $22.00
- 10. Blues Brother (16)
  Tomato sauce, 5 ingredients of your choice, sesame seeds.
  $35.00
- 11. Sausage Pizza (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper chees, sausage, sesame seeds
  $29.00
- 12. 4 Cheese (16)
  White sauce, special proper chees, gorgonzola, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, sesame seeds,
  $29.00
- 13. Hawaiian (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pineapple, ham, and sesame seeds.
  $29.00
- 14. Crudo Parmezan (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, rucola, parma ham prosciutto, sliced parmesan, cherry tomato, and sesame seeds.
  $29.00
- 15. American Gangster (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, ham, sliced black olives, onions, mixed peppers, mushrooms, loca sauce, sesame seeds.
  $32.00
- 16. Macho (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken meatballs, macho sauce, chives, and sesame seeds.
  $28.00
- 17. Truffle (16)
  White sauce, truffle paste, truffle oil, mushrooms, pecorino cheese, pine nuts, sesame seeds.
  $35.00
- 18. Cheeseburger (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, meatballs, iceberg lettuce, burger sauce, ketchup, chives, and sesame seeds.
  $34.00
- 19. Buffalo Chicken (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, buffalo chicken, and sesame seeds.
  $28.00
- 2. Mushroom Pizza (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mushrooms, sesame seeds.
  $25.00
- 3. OMG Vegetarian (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mixed peppers, zucchini, caramelized onions, eggplants, onions, sesame seeds. .
  $26.00
- 4. BBQ Chicken (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken, bbq sauce, and sesame seeds.
  $28.00
- 5. Pepperoni (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pepperoni, sesame seeds.
  $28.00
- 6. Tuna (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, tuna fish, sesame seeds.
  $32.00
- 8. Anchovies (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, anchovies, olives, sesame seeds.
  $32.00
- 9. Proper Pizza (16)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, smoked beef prosciutto, smoked beef sausage, mushrooms, and sesame seeds.
  $34.00
- Build Your Own Pizza (16)
  Choose your sauce: classic red or creamy white.
  $25.00
- Free Nutella
  Get 2 Sharing Cheese Pizzas and get Free Nutella
  $49.99
Party Pizza (24)
- 0. Cheese Pizza (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, sesame seeds.
  $38.00
- 1. Margherita (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sesame seeds.
  $40.00
- 10. Blues Brother (24)
  Tomato sauce, 5 ingredients of your choice, sesame seeds.
  $48.00
- 11. Sausage Pizza (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper chees, sausage, sesame seeds
  $42.00
- 12. 4 Cheese (24)
  White sauce, special proper chees, gorgonzola, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, sesame seeds,
  $43.00
- 13. Hawaiian (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pineapple, ham, and sesame seeds.
  $45.00
- 14. Crudo Parmezan (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, rucola, parma ham prosciutto, sliced parmesan, cherry tomato, and sesame seeds.
  $48.00
- 15. American Gangster (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, ham, sliced black olives, onions, mixed peppers, mushrooms, loca sauce, sesame seeds.
  $48.00
- 16. Macho (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken meatballs, macho sauce, chives, and sesame seeds.
  $43.00
- 17. Truffle (24)
  White sauce, truffle paste, truffle oil, mushrooms, pecorino cheese, pine nuts, sesame seeds.
  $46.00
- 18. Cheeseburger (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, meatballs, iceberg lettuce, burger sauce, ketchup, chives, and sesame seeds.
  $48.00
- 19. Buffalo Chicken (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, buffalo chicken, and sesame seeds.
  $45.00
- 2. Mushroom Pizza (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mushrooms, sesame seeds.
  $42.00
- 3. OMG Vegetarian (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, mixed peppers, zucchini, caramelized onions, eggplants, onions, sesame seeds.
  $44.00
- 4. BBQ Chicken (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, chicken, bbq sauce, and sesame seeds.
  $45.00
- 5. Pepperoni (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, pepperoni, sesame seeds.
  $46.00
- 6. Tuna (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, tuna fish, sesame seeds.
  $45.00
- 8. Anchovies (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, anchovies, olives, sesame seeds.
  $48.00
- 9. Proper Pizza (24)
  Tomato sauce, special proper cheese, smoked beef prosciutto, smoked beef sausage, mushrooms, and sesame seeds.
  $48.00
- Build Your Own Pizza (24)
  24" party pizza with customizable sauce options: choose between red sauce or white sauce. Ideal for group gatherings.
  $42.00
Sides
- Baby Arugula Salad
  Arugula Salad with Extra virgin olive oil, Balsamic vinegar, Sweet Balsamic, Cherry tomato, Pine nuts, and shaved Parmesan Cheese
  $12.99
- Cesar Salad
  Crisp romaine tossed with croutons, Caesar dressing, and grated cheese
  $12.99
- Cesar Salad with Chicken
  Crisp romaine tossed with croutons, Caesar dressing, grated cheese, and Chicken
  $14.99
- Cesar Sauce
  A traditional blend of anchovies, garlic, parmesan cheese, and egg yolks, emulsified with olive oil to create a rich and creamy dressing.
  $1.00
- Chicken Tenders
  6 Fresh Chicken tenders with a choice of flavor and dressing sauce
  $8.90
- Chicken Wings
  Fresh jumbo wings seasoned with our spices, served plain or tossed in buffalo or BBQ sauce with a choice of dressing
  $9.90+
- Garlic Bread & Cheeses
  A cross between garlic bread and pizza, cheesy bread is a quick, easy, and delicious party snack, with macho sauce.
  $8.00
- Loca Sauce
  A zesty and bold takeout favorite, often combining a mix of spices and ingredients for a unique flavor profile.
  $1.00
- Macho Sauce
  A bold blend, often incorporating spices and perhaps a creamy or tomato base, designed to complement a variety of takeout dishes.
  $1.00
- Ranch Sauce
  Our homemade ranch sauce, a creamy blend with herbs and spices.
  $1.00
Soft Drinks
- 2L Soda
  Carbonated beverage in a 2-liter bottle.
  $4.00
- Coca Cola
  The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
  $2.00+
- Coca Cola Zero
  The same great taste but with zero calories.
  $2.00
- Diet Coke
  A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
  $2.00
- Natural Water
  Pure, refreshing natural water.
  $2.00
- Sparkling Water
  Effervescent natural mineral water with a crisp, refreshing taste.
  $2.99
- Sprite
  The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
  $2.00
Sweet Corner
- Crunchy Nutella
  Nutella, Caramel, Granulated Peanuts, Graham Cracker Crumbs, and a pinch of Love
  $18.00
Holiday Special
- Free Nutella
  Get 2 Sharing Cheese Pizzas and get Free Nutella
  $49.99
- Free Nutella and 2L Coke
  Get 2 Party Size Cheese Pizzas 24'' to get Free Nutella and 2L Coke
  $80.00