Prohibition Port Jefferson Menu

115 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777
  • Dessert Skillets

    • Super Duper S'mores

      our warm fudge brownie topped with vanilla gelato, hot fudge, torched marshmallow cream and a sprinkle of buttery graham crackers. Finished with a drizzle of fudge sauce
    • Ultra Mega Peanut Butter Cup Spectacular

      our brown butter blondie with peanut butter cups, vanilla or chocolate ice cream, crushed peanut butter cups and a double drizzle of peanut butter sauce and hot fudge
    • Apple Crisp Explosion

      cinnamon spiced gala apples topped with dirty crumb, Maldon sea salt, vanilla gelato, finished with a drizzle of caramel sauce
    • Blue Ribbon Skillet

      Thick chocolate chip cookie served warm with a chocolate ganache center topped with vanilla or chocolate gelato and a drizzle of fudge sauce
  • Desserts on Plates

    • Mike's Hot Honey Chip Ala Mode

      house made, hand cut yukon gold potato chips, mikes hot honey, vanilla ice cream, cinnamon drizzle topped with a little extra honey sauce…think of cornflakes in ice cream, a totally unique experience
    • Maple Flap Jack Cake

      blueberry layer cake with fresh maple cream layers, topped with whipped cream and blueberry compote…just like a breakfast!
    • East Main & Main Donut Bread Pudding

      At the end of the day, your favorite donuts become our amazing donut bread pudding! Topped with sprinkles and a drizzle of vanilla frosting, this is so worthy of the calories!
  • Thick Shakes-Hand Spun & Over the Top

    • Dirty Elvis

      Peanut butter, banana, a slice of our cold smoked bacon…and some great dance moves
    • The Captains Cinnamon Toast Crunch

      Cinnamon ice cream, crushed captain crunch, salted caramel drizzle topped with cinnamon toast crunch crumbles and salted caramel crisp pearls
    • Johnny Appleseed

      the wanderer-Vanilla ice cream, gala apple, salted caramel crispy pearls, whipped cream and a caramel stroopwaffle
  • Distillates

    • Smokey Williamsburg

      Pelaton de Muerte Mezcal, Fresh Lime, Ginger Simple Syrup, Greenport Juicy IPA
      $12.00
    • Second Breakfast

      Rough Rider Bourbon, Fresh Lemon, Crown Smoked Maple Syrup, Ginger Beer, Fresh Blueberry
      $12.00
    • Justin's Deadly Daiquiri

      Bly Silver Rum, Simple Syrup, Fresh Lime Juice
      $12.00
    • New Old Fashioned

      Hillrock Rye, Simple Syrup, Ango, Raft Orange Bitters
      $12.00
    • Backyard Martini

      Deepwells Gin, Backyard Brine Brine, Dill Death Do us Part Dill Pickle
      $12.00
    • Paloma

      Pueblo Viejo Tequilla, Fresh Grapefruit, Mikes Hot Honey
      $12.00
    • Dark Side Absinthe Cocktail

      Liepold Brothers Absinthe, Demerara Sugar Cube, Saratoga Water
      $12.00
    • Ferments From The East

      Representing the best Wine of Long Island
  • From the Tap

    • Bridge Lane White Merlot

    • Bridge Lane Steel Chardonnay

  • Bridge Lane Red Blend

    • Classic Carriers

  • Paumonok Cellars

    • Oak Fermented Chardonnay

      Toasty, Oaky, Tasty
    • Sauvignon Blanc

      Crisp, Light, Bright
    • Cabernet Franc

      Dark Cherry, Black Pepper, Tom's Fav
    • Cabernet Sauvignon

      Fruit Forward, Long Finish, Big Plums
  • Macari Vineyards

    • Early Wine

      Super tasty, Light and Sweet, Fresh Fruit
    • Dos Aguas White Blend

      Bright, Clean, Light Acidity
    • Dos Aguas Red Blend

      Mellow Finish, Light fruit, Coffee, Jamesport Vineyards
    • Dry Reisling

      Crisp, Vibrant, Clean
    • Syrah

      Smoked, Cherry, Anise
  • Pindar

    • Pythagoris Blend

      Mineral Start, Jammy Blackberry, Light Tannin
  • Wolffer Vineyards

    • Summer In A Bottle

      Hamptons Gatorade, Clean, Super Drinkablity
    • Finca Rose

      Bright Peach, Raspberry, Strawberry
  • Crack of Dawn

    • Avocado Toast

      Big Boy Cut Sourdough, Avocado Crema, Poached Egg, Backyard Brine Bloody Seasoning
      $13.00
    • Chicken And Waffle

      Coleman Organic/Antibiotic Free Chicken Breast, Quinoa and Kale Waffle, Bourbon Barrel Aged Maple Syrup
      $15.00
    • Superman Steel Cut Oats

      Verjus Poached Pear, Grape, Dried Grape, Granola, Honey
      $11.00
    • Corned Beef Jack Benny

      Thick Chop corned beef Hash, Poach Egg, Hollandaise, British Muffin
      $13.00
    • On A Hot Tin Roof

      Ham and Cheese Stuffed biscuits smothered in Chorizo white gravy
      $14.00
    • Prohibition Skillet

      Quinoa, Potato Kale Hash. White cheddar Sauce, Poached Egg
      $13.00
    • Southern Scramble

      Jumbo Shrimp, Smoked Cheddar Chorizo Gravy, Crispy Grit, Scramble
      $19.00
    • Big Daddy

      Cinnamon Chipotle Braised Pork Shoulder, Onion Tanglers, Egg, Poblano Chile sauce Roasted Sprouts
      $16.00
    • Sloppy Scramble

      Green Chile Aioli, Burnt Ends, Peppered Bacon, Super Sloppy Eggs
      $15.00
    • Hot Buttered Russ

      Lemon Poppy Pound Cake, French Toast Batter, Lemon Blueberry Compote
      $14.00
    • Hot Tub Time Machine

      Big HOT Waffle, Vanilla Maple Glaze, Pearl Sugar
      $16.00
  • Swanky Shares & Sides

    • O'Canada

      Porter Infused Gravy, Short Rib, Poutine Queso, Garlic Donut Holes
      $13.00
    • Twilight Zone

      Creamy Cheese Sauce, Shells, Cracker Crumb, Bacon, Franks Red Hot
      $11.00
    • 'Mozz Squad

      Burrata Mozzarella, Fire Roasted Tomato, Hemp Pesto, Roasted Garlic Donut
      $14.00
    • Big Boy Giant Pretzel

      Hatch Chile infused Beer Queso, Grain Mustard
      $12.00
    • Daddy-O

      Thick Cut House Cut onion Rings, Ginger Habanero Chile Sauce
      $10.00
    • Big Wedge

      Artisan Romaine Lettuce, Roasted Heirloom Tomato, Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing, Bacon, Everything Bagel Seasoning
      $15.00
    • Snazzy Sprouts

      Braised Brussel Sprouts, Bourbon Barrel Aged Maple Syrup, Wildflower Honey, Local Sea Salt
      $12.00
    • Chip And Dip

      Yukon Gold Potato Chips, Smoked Pork and Gorgonzola Dip, Green Onion, Cracker Crumb
      $13.00
    • Pbj Wings

      Roasted Organic Chicken Wing, Crushed Peanut Satay, Thai Chili Jelly
      $14.00
    • Frito Pie

      Certified Angus Beef Chili, Queso Fresco, Chile Lime Crema, Cold Cheese, Fritos
      $12.00
    • Thinking About Gym

      Sweet Potato Hummus, Crispy Sprouts, EVOO, Ras El Hanout
      $14.00
    • Flat Foot Falaffel

      Baby Kale, Beets, Hemp Seed, Avocado, Toasted Chick Pea, Watermelon Radish, English Cucumber, Quinoa Salad, Crispy Pita
      $18.00
    • Prohibition Poutine

      Wedge Monster Fries, Poutine Gravy
      $12.00
    • The G.O.A.T

      Fried Green Tomato, Local Goat Cheese, BYB Sriracha Slaw, Micro Daikon
      $15.00
    • Prohibition Provisions And Baby Cheeses

      A smattering of our favorite local Charcuterie, Cheese, Jam, and Stuff
      $24.00
    • Locavore

      East end Tomato, Local Goat Cheese, Wildflower Honey, Local Sea Salt, Non Local Olive Oil
      $16.00
    • Edamame Dumplings

      Blood Orange Braised King Oyster Mushrooms
      $13.00
  • Sammies & Smashers

    • Dirty Mother Clucker

      Southern Fried Chicken, Sweet Glazed Donut
      $14.00
    • The G Man

      Cinnamon/Chipotle Pork shoulder, Onion Tanglers, Lime Crema, Prohibition Slaw
      $15.00
    • What's Your Beef?

      Certified Angus Beef Smash Burger, Roasted Serrano Chile Queso, LTOP, Swell Sauce
      $15.00
    • Hotsie Totsie

      Coleman Organic/Antibiotic Free Chicken, I put that S*it on everything Sauce, Fromage Blue Cheese Dressing
      $16.00
    • 8 Slice Death Punch

      Big Boy Cut Sourdough, Grueyre, American, Burrata, Tomato, Bacon
      $14.00
    • Kobayashi Dog

      Duo of Certified Angus Beef Hot Dogs, Backyard Brine Sriracha Slaw, Kewpie Mayo, Nori, Other Green Stuff
      $13.00
    • Puttin On The Ritz

      Crispy #1 Sushi Grade Tuna, Mango, Avo, Pickled Shishito Pepper, Firecracker Mizuna, Chipotle Mango Crema
      $19.00
    • The Fruit Of The Sea

      Pan Seared Right coast Shrimp, Avocado, Hemp seed, LI Tomato, Crispy Grit, RRP
      $16.00
    • Captain Midnight

      Certified Angus Beef Smash Burger, All American Cheese, All American Bacon, All American Coleslaw, Super Swell Sauce
      $17.00

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms