Checkle
Search
For Businesses
Primi Italian Steakhouse
Menu
Primi Italian Steakhouse Menu
$
·
Steak house
999 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
Appetizers
Salads
Pastas
House Specialties
Prime 28 Day Dry-Aged
Steaks and Chops - Add-Ons
Steaks and Chops - Sauces
Sides
Sparkling
Rosé Wine
Italian White
California Chardonnay
Other White
Italian Red
California Cabernet
Other Red
Large Format
Sparkling
White
Red
Bottled Beer
Tap Beer
Cocktails
Spritz
Soft Drinks
Appetizers
Pizza Margherita
tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil
$19.00
Pizza Amalfi
goat cheese, mission fig, crispy bacon, caramelized onion
$21.00
Primi Pizza
ricotta, fontina, mozzarella, wild mushroom, prosciutto, truffle oil
$21.00
Pizza Diavola
chorizo, mozzarella, basil
$21.00
Burrata Pizza
fresh mozzarella, arugula, tomato, prosciutto, burrata
$21.00
Mussels
choice of white wine & garlic or fra diavolo
$17.00
Crispy Artichokes
salmoriglio, parmesan, herb crema
$17.00
Calamari
crispy cherry peppers, lemon, marinara
$20.00
Clams Oreganata
lemon burre blanc, white wine, seasoned breadcrumbs
$14.00
Eggplant Parmesan
seasoned breadcrumb, eggplant, san marzano tomato, mozzarella, parmesan
$14.00
Meatballs
braised in tomato sugo, creamy polenta
$17.00
Burrata
prosciutto, cherry tomato, aged balsamic, evoo
$19.00
Beef Carpaccio
filet mignon, arugula, pecorino romano
$23.00
Bruschetta
tomato, red onion, basil, balsamic, crostini
$14.00
Salads
Mixed Greens
cucumber, tomato, red onion, balsamic vinaigrette
$12.00
Caesar
romaine, croutons, shaved parmigian
$13.00
Wedge Salad
iceberg lettuce, roquefort blue cheese, crumbled bacon, cherry tomato
$13.00
Arugula
olive, ceci bean, cherry tomato, roasted pepper, herb vinaigrette, shaved parmesan
$14.00
Summer Salad
arugula, endive, apple, walnuts, goat cheese, lemon vinaigrette
$14.00
Pastas
Spaghetti
cacio e pepe, pecorino, black pepper
$21.00
Cavatelli
bolognese ragu, touch of cream, whipped ricotta
$28.00
Gnocchi
san marzano tomato, burrata, basil
$23.00
Rigatoni
sweet and spicy sausage, vodka sauce, pecorino romano
$22.00
Fusilli
mascarpone, wild mushrooms, blistering cherry tomatoes, truffle oil
$26.00
Bucatini
egg yolk, pecorino, panchetta
$25.00
House Specialties
Scottish Salmon
spinach, cherry tomato, artichoke, salmoriglio
$36.00
Shrimp Scampi
scampi style, creamy polenta, sauteed spinach, lemon
$46.00
Cod Oreganata
seasoned breadcrumbs, sauteed spinach, lemon caper burre blanc
$32.00
Whole Main Lobster
1 1/2lb lobster, sweet corn, roasted potato
Chicken Breast
franchese, parmigiana, piccata or milanese style
$28.00
Veal
marsala, parmigiana, piccata or milanese style
$40.00
Chicken Scarpariello
organic free-range half chicken, sausage, potato, onion, cherry pepper
$32.00
Primi Burger
butcher's blend, fontina, arugula, beef steak, tomato, bacon, spicy mayo, brioche bun, tuscan fries
$26.00
Prime 28 Day Dry-Aged
Filet Mignon
$40.00
Australian Rack Of Lamb
$47.00
New York Strip
$47.00
Bone-In Rib Eye
$62.00
Porterhouse For Two
$98.00
Steaks and Chops - Add-Ons
Jumbo Grilled Shrimp
$14.00
Lobster Tail
$22.00
Steaks and Chops - Sauces
Peppercorn
Chianti Demi
Gorgonzola
Truffle Butter
Sides
Crispy Fried Onions
$9.00
Sautéed Spinach
$10.00
Tuscan Fries
truffle oil, parmigiana, herbs
$10.00
Asparagus
$12.00
Creamed Spinach
$12.00
Creamy Polenta
$10.00
French Fries
$10.00
Mixed Wild Mushrooms
$10.00
Roasted Potato
$10.00
Sparkling
Prosecco, Mille NV
$45.00
Franciacorta, Barone Pizzini NV
$70.00
Franciacorta Rose, Brolese NV
$75.00
Champagne, Rose, Veuve-Clicquot NV 375ml
$60.00
Champagne, Laurent Perrier NV
$95.00
Champagne, Yellow Label, Veuve Cliquot
$115.00
Dom Perignon, Reims France 2006
$320.00
Prosecco Brut, Zardetto 3L
$240.00
Rosé Wine
Rose, Ferrari NV 375ml
$45.00
Tomaresca Antinori, Calafuria, Italy 2014
$45.00
Cotes De Provence, Whispering Angel 2015
$70.00
Billette, Cote De Provence 2014
$50.00
Italian White
Arneis, Cacina Chicco 2014
$55.00
Chardonnay, Jermann 2013
$75.00
Falanghina, I Pentri 2014
$70.00
Fiano Cometa, Planeta 2011
$80.00
Gavi Di Gavi, La Scolca, Black Label 2013
$90.00
Orvieto Classico Castagnolo, Barberino 2014
$50.00
Pinot Grigio, Sant'Elana 2014
$45.00
Pinot Bianco, Tramin 2014
$50.00
Sauvignon Blanc, Sant'Elena 2014
$55.00
Trebbiano D'Abruzzo, Contesa 2015
$45.00
Vernacciadi San Gimignano, Mormaraio 2014
$45.00
Vermentino, Pelissero 2014
$55.00
Vermentino, Tenuta Guado Al Tasso 2014
$65.00
Verdicchio, Bonci 2012
$40.00
California Chardonnay
Cakebread, Napa 2012
$90.00
Sonoma Cutrer 2014
$58.00
Jordan, Russian River Valley 2012
$80.00
Nickel & Nickel, Napa 2012
$110.00
Rodney Strong, Sonoma 2012
$55.00
Rombauer, Carneros 2012
$75.00
Other White
Chablis, Louis Jadot 2014
$55.00
Fume Blanc, Ferrari Carano 2014
$50.00
Sancerre, Domaine Jean-Paul Balland 2012
$58.00
Sauvignon Blanc, Charles Krug, CA 2013
$45.00
Sauvignon Blanc, Duckhorn CA 2012
$65.00
Italian Red
Aglianico, Cantine Del Notaio 2013
$60.00
Aglianico, 'Bocca Di Luppo' Tormaresca 2010
$100.00
Aglianico, Taurasi, Mastroberardino 2009
$125.00
Amarone Della Valpolicella, Gabriella 2010
$105.00
Amarone Della Valpolicella, Brigaldara 2008
$140.00
Barbaresco 'Nubiola', Pelissero 2011
$95.00
Barbera Di Alba, Marchesi Di Barolo 2014
$60.00
Barbera D'Alba, Castello Di Neive 2013
$50.00
Barolo, Cascina Chicco 2012
$140.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Simonetti 2014
$58.00
Cannanau, Argiolas 2013
$40.00
Chianti Classico, Fontodi 2012
$80.00
Brunello Di Montalcino, Col D'Orcia 2011
$100.00
Brunello Di Montalcino, Colle Del Prete 2011
$95.00
Brunello Di Montalcino, Valdicava 2009
$250.00
Chianti Classico, San Guisto A Rentannano, 2013
$60.00
Chianti Classico, Castellare 2014
$85.00
Chianti Classico Riserva, Quercetto 2009
$60.00
Chianti Classico Riserva Antinori 2011
$75.00
Dolcetto, Briccolero Chianetti 2012
$65.00
Nebbiolo, Cascina Chicco 2014
$60.00
Nebbiolo, Gattinara, Travaglini 2010
$70.00
Primitivo, Tormaresca 2013
$45.00
Ripasso, Zenato 2012
$65.00
Ripasso Classico, Villa Fulvia 2011
$52.00
Rosso Di Montalcino, Col D'Orcia 2012
$60.00
Rosso, Planeta, Le Segreta 2013
$50.00
Super Tuscan, Guisti + Zanga 2005
$85.00
Super Tuscan, Ottone 2012
$54.00
Super Tuscan, Flaccianello, Fontodi 2012
$225.00
Super Tuscan, Bruciato, Guado Al Tasso 2014
$75.00
Super Tuscan, Guado Al Tasso, Antinori 2011
$185.00
Super Tuscan, Tignanello, Antinori 2012
$170.00
Valpolicella Ripasso, Bertani 2012
$60.00
California Cabernet
Beringer, Knights Valley 2013
$70.00
Caymus, Napa 2014
$160.00
Cakebread, Napa Valley 2013
$125.00
Dominus, Napa 2011
$285.00
Franciscan, Napa 2013
$80.00
Freemark Abbey, Napa Valley 2012
$105.00
Girard, Artistry, Napa 2012
$105.00
Joseph Phelps, Napa 2013
$130.00
Jordan, Sonoma 2012
$115.00
Nickel & Nickel, Oakville 2013
$190.00
Groth, Oakville 2012
$125.00
Sequoia Grove, Napa Valley 2012
$85.00
Silver Oak, Alexander 2011
$180.00
Stag's Leap, Artemis 2013
$125.00
The Calling, Alexander 2012
$70.00
Other Red
Insignia, Joseph Phelps, Napa 2011
$320.00
Merlot, Robert Mondavi, P. Selection 2014
$45.00
Merlot, Markham, Napa 2013
$60.00
Merlot, Duckhorn, Napa 2012
$115.00
Opus One, Napa 2012
$395.00
Petit Syrah, Stag's Leap, Napa 2013
$90.00
Petite Syrah, Earthquake, 2013
$70.00
Pinot Noir, Cambria, Santa Maria Valley 2013
$60.00
Pinot Noir, La Crema, Carneros 2013
$80.00
Red Zinfandel, Earthquake 2013
$65.00
Red Zinfandel, Ravenswood, Sonoma 2013
$50.00
Red Blend, Col Solare, US 2012
$120.00
Red Blend, Quintessa, Napa 2012
$350.00
Red Blend, Charles Krug, Napa 2012
$120.00
Red Blend, "Bergan Road" 2013
$95.00
Large Format
Cabernet, Artemis, Stag's Leap 2012, 1.5L
$250.00
Amarone Della Valpolicella, Brigaldara 2010, 3L
$375.00
Chianti Classico, Castello Di Sevole 2003, 3L
$210.00
Merlot, Sant'Elena 2011, 3L
$215.00
Montepulciano, Contessa 3L 2013
$195.00
Red Blend, Bergen Road, Macari 2010, 1.5L
$200.00
Sparkling
Prosecco, Mille
$10.00
Ferrari Rose
$12.00
Champagne, Laurent Perrier
$16.00
White
Pinot Grigio, Bertani
$9.00
Gavi, Vila Ile
$10.00
Sauvignon Blanc, Brancott
$11.00
Chardonnay, Josh Cellars
$12.00
Reisling, Konig Johann "AMARUS"
$12.00
Moscato, Le Cantine
$12.00
Toscano Bianco, Villa Antinori
$13.00
Red
Malbec, Ruta 22
$9.00
Valpolicella, Brigaldara
$10.00
Nero D'Avola, Caruso E Minini
$10.00
Montepulciano, Selva De'Canonici
$11.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Josh Cellars
$12.00
Chianti Classico, Castello Di Bossi
$13.00
Pinot Noir, Meiomi
$14.00
Super Tuscan, Villa Antinori
$15.00
Bottled Beer
Budweiser / Bud Light
$6.00
Heineken / Heineken Light
$7.00
Michelob Ultra
$7.00
Stella
$7.00
Duvel
$9.00
Tap Beer
Peroni
$7.50
Brooklyn Seasonal
$8.00
Dogfish 60 IPA
$8.50
Cocktails
Il Bastardo
Makers Mark, vanilla bean, Amaro Montenegro
Fellini
Basil Hayden's Bourbon, Carpano Antica, Campari, St. Germain, citrus
Mexicana
Patron Silver, Aperol, Pamplemusse, rose, citrus
Amalfi
Hendricks Gin, fresh lime, soda water, citrus
Baci
Solerno blood orange, Stoli O, ginger beer, citrus
Sicilian Temper
Hendricks Gin, Antica sweet vermouth, Campari, Solerno blood orange
Spritz
Classic
prosecco, Aperol, club soda, orange
$12.00
Portofino
rose, Antica sweet vermouth, lemon juice, prosecco
$12.00
Le Parisiene
prosecco, St. Germain, lemon
$12.00
Soft Drinks
Coke
Diet Coke
Sprite
Ginger Ale
Unsweetened Iced Tea
Cranberry Juice
Orange Juice
Menus may not be up to date.
Suggest Edit
Know a great happy hour or special for this location?
Add Happy Hour
People Also Viewed
Sugar Island Bake Shop
5.0
(8 Reviews)
Bakery
Seabreeze Cafe
4.2
(106 Reviews)
Bar
Babylon Fish & Clam Restaurant
4.1
(443 Reviews)
Seafood, American, Bar
Tres Palms
4.1
(899 Reviews)
New American, Bar, Seafood
The Delica Sea
4.7
(65 Reviews)
Deli
Starbucks
4.0
(541 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Breakfast, Cafe
Izumi Sushi and Hibachi Steak house
4.5
(388 Reviews)
Japanese steakhouse, Grill, Bar
South Swell
4.5
(22 Reviews)
Restaurant
VERN Restaurant and Bar
4.4
(119 Reviews)
Seafood
seagull restaurant
4.2
(469 Reviews)
Seafood, Bar, Brunch
© 2025 Checkle, Inc
·
Privacy
·
Terms