Prime Steakhouse Menu

3.9

(75+ Reviews)

$$Steak house

Call

(716) 665-6837

(Pale Ales) Light and Smooth-Bodied
- #9 Magic Hat, Vermont, American Pale Ale ABV 5.1%
  $4.50
- Fire Rock, Kona, Hawaii, American Pale Ale ABV 6%
  $4.50
- Hop Sun, Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American Pale Wheat ABV 5.1%
  $4.50
- Little Sumpin' Sumpin' Ale, Lagunitas, California, American Pale Wheat Ale ABV 7.5%
  $5.00
- Live, Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American Pale Ale ABV 5.5%
  $4.50
- PMX (Phin & Matt's), Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American Pale Ale ABV 5.7%
  $4.50
- Prima Pils, Victory, Pennsylvania, German Pilsener ABV 5.3%
  $4.50
(Belgians) Complex Flavor Profiles with Lawless Beginnings
- Abbey Ale, Ommegang, Cooperstown, NY, Belgain Dubbel ABV 8.2%
  $6.00
- Blue Moon, Blue Moon, Denver, Belgian Witbier ABV 5.4%
  $4.00
- Duvel, Duvel, Belgium, Belgian Strong Pale Ale ABV 8.5%
  $7.00
- Hennepin, Ommegang, Cooperstown, NY, Farmhouse Saison ABV 7.7%
  $6.00
- Kellerweis, Sierra Nevada, California, Hefweizen ABV 4.8%
  $4.00
- La Chouffe, Houblon Chouffe, Belgium, Belgain Strong Pale Ale ABV 8%
  $7.00
- Matilda, Goose Island, Chicago, Belgain, Strong Pale Ale ABV 7%*
  $6.00
- Maudite, Unibroue, Quebec, Canada, Belgian Strong Dark Ale ABV 8%
  $6.00
- Pepe Nero, Goose Island, Chicago, Farmhouse Saison, ABV 6.4%*
  $5.00
- Pere Jaques, Goose Island, Chicago, Belgain Dubbel ABV 8.7%*
  $5.00
- Rare Vos, Ommegang, Cooperstown, NY, Belgain Pale Ale ABV 6.5%
  $6.00
- Sofie, Goose Island, Chicago, Saison / Farmhouse Ale ABV 6.5%**
  $10.00
- Three Philosophers, Ommegang, Cooperstown, NY, Belgain Quadrupel ABV 9.7%
  $7.00
- Trappist Tripel, Westmalle, Belgium, Belgain Tripel ABV 9.5%
  $8.00
(IPAs and Double IPAs) Flavorful and Hoppy
- 2XIPA Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, Double IPA, ABV 8.2%
  $4.50
- Centennial IPA Founders, Michigan, American IPA, ABV 7.2%
  $5.00
- Dirt Wolf, Victory, Pennsylvania, Double IPA, ABV 8.7%
  $5.00
- Grapefruit Sculpin IPA Ballast Point, Pennsylvania, American IPA, ABV 7%
  $5.50
- Hercules Double IPA Great Divide, Colorado, American Double IPA, ABV 10%
  $7.50
- Hop Devil, Victory, Pennsylvania, American IPA, ABV 6.7%
  $4.50
- IPA Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American IPA, ABV 7.3%
  $4.50
- Tangier, Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American IPA, ABV 5%
  $4.50
- Titan IPA Great Divide, Colorado, American IPA, ABV 7.1%
  $5.50
- Torpedo, Sierra Nevada, California, Double IPA, ABV 7.2%
  $4.50
(Dark Ales) Not Your Typical Middle Child
- Arrogant Bastard Ale, Stone Brewing, California American Strong Ale ABV 7.2%**
  $10.00
- Big Foot, Sierra Nevada, California, American Barleywine ABV 9.6%
  $5.00
- Dead Guy Ale, Rogue Ales, Oregon, Maibock / Helles Bock ABV 6.5%
  $5.00
- Dirty Bastard, Founders, Michigan, Scotch Ale ABV 8.5%
  $5.50
- Indian Brown Ale, Dogish Head, Delaware, American Brown Ale ABV 7.2%
  $5.00
- Nut Brown Ale, Samuel Smith, United Kingdom, English Brown Ale ABV 5%
  $5.50
- Old Ruffian, Great Divide, Colorado, American Barleywine ABV 10.2%
  $7.50
- Ruedrich's Red Seal Ale, North Coast, California, American Amber / Red Ale ABV 5.4%
  $5.00
- Tröegs Troegenator Double Bock, Tröegs Brewing Company, Pennsylvania, Doppelbock ABV 8.2%
  $5.00
- Wookey Jack, Firestone, California, American Black Ale ABV 8.3%
  $6.50
- Yuengling Traditional Lager, Yuengling, Pennsylvania, American Amber / Red Lager ABV 4.4%
  $4.50
(Porters and Stouts) Dark and Delicious
- Bourbon County Stout, Goose Island, Chicago Imperial Stout ABV 14.2%
  $12.00
- Breakfast Stout, Founders, Michigan, Imperial Stout ABV 8.3%
  $6.00
- Coffee Porter, Wolavers, Vermont, American Porter ABV 5%
  $4.50
- Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald Porter, Great Lakes, Ohio, American Porter 5.8%
  $4.50
- Old Rasputin Russian Imperial Stout, North Coast, California Russian Imperial Stout ABV 9%
  $6.00
- Porter, Founders, Michigan, American Porter ABV 6.5%
  $4.50
- Porter, Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American Porter ABV 5.8%
  $4.50
- Smuttynose Robust Porter, Smuttynose Brewing, New Hampshire, American Porter ABV 6.2%
  $4.50
- Taddy Porter, Samuel Smith, United Kingdom, English Porter ABV 5%
  $5.50
- Victory At Sea Coffee Vanilla Imperial Porter, Ballast Point, California, American Porter ABV 10%
  $6.00
(Fermented Fruits) beyond Hops and Barley
- Apple Ale, Redds, Wisconsin, Fruit Beer ABV 5%
  $4.50
- Amber, Woodchuck, Vermont, Hard Cider ABV 5.8%
  $4.50
Steaks and Chop
- Grilled Prime Rib
  Slow Roasted with Traditional Seasonings. Then Grilled to Your Taste
  $23.00
- Delmonico
  Hand Cut Delmonico
  $30.00
- NY Strip
  $27.00
- Filet Mignon
  $22.00
- Marinated Sirloin
  With Cabernet Demi and Rosemary Potato Hash
  $20.00
- Pork Chop
  With Apple Chutney
  $18.00
Seafood and Chicken
- Pan Seared Scallops
  With Sautéed Spinach, Tomatoes and Mushrooms Over a Bed of Pasta
  $29.00
- Lobster Tail
  8-10 oz. Cold Water Lobster, Broiled, Seasoned
- Shrimp Scampi
  With Sauteed Garlic and Tomatoes Served over Linguini
  $8.00
- Chicken Marsala
  Sauteed with Mushrooms, Garlic, Rice and Marsala Wine
  $16.00
Starters
- Crab Cakes
  With Roasted Red Pepper Rémoulade
  $9.00
- French Onion Soup
  Caramelized Onions, Croutons, Provolone, Swiss
  $7.00
- Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
  Baby Bella Mushroom Caps Stuffed With Our Homemade Crab Stuffing
  $9.00
- Steakhouse Shrimp Cocktail
  With house made Cocktail Sauce
  $8.00
- Sausage Stuffed Peppers
  With Gorgonzola Tomato Sauce and Balsamic Reduction
  $8.00
- Soup of the Day
Salad
- Classic Caesar Salad
  With Romaine Lettuce, House-made Caesar, Parmesan Cheese, and Croutons
  $9.00
- Buffalo Chicken Salad
  With Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Carrots, Onions & Peppers, Croutons: Hot, Medium, Mild; Choice of Dressing
  $13.00
- Prime Salad
  With Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Carrots, Onions & Peppers, Croutons and Cabernet Vinaigrette Dressing
  $9.00
Pasta
- Alfredo
  Linguini in a White Wine and Garlic Cream Sauce. Also available with Blackened or Pesto
  $15.00
- Rigatoni con Filet
  With Rigatoni, Filet Mignon Medallions, Asparagus, Gorgonzola Cream Sauce, Roasted Red Peppers, Scallions, Parmesan Cheese
  $26.00
- Wild Rice and Veggies
  Wild Rice With Seasonal Vegetable Medley, Mushrooms, Spinach and Lightly Seasoned to Perfection
  $14.00
Reds Wines
- Cabernet
- Merlot
- Lambrusco
- Malbec
- Pinot Noir
- Bella Rosa
White Wines
- Chardonnay
- Pinot Grigio
- Riesling
- Sauvignon Blanc
- White Zinfandel
- Moscato
Monday
- Steak & Beer Night
  Buy any steak and any beer, take $5 off. Or 8 oz. Marinated Sirloin with one side and a beer for $15 (some exclusions apply)
Tuesday
- Date Night
  Buy one entrée, take $5 off second entrée
Wednesday
- Craft Beer Night
  $1 Off All Beers
Thursday
- Pasta Night
  All you can eat Spaghetti for | $13 Or $2 Off Any other pasta dish
Friday
- By The Sea
  Catch of the Day
Sides
- Rosemary Potato Hash
- Baked Potatoes
- Garlic Mashed
- Ginger Cilantro Rice
- Seasonal Vegetables
Desserts
- Coconut Carrot Cake
  $7.00
- Ice Cream Lasagna
  $7.00
- Chocolate Peanut Ice Cream Pie
  $7.00
- Bistro Salted Caramel Brownie w/ Ice Cream
  $7.00
- Italian Almond Cream Cake
  $7.00
- Sorbet
  $5.00

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Prime Steakhouse Menu

(Pale Ales) Light and Smooth-Bodied

#9 Magic Hat, Vermont, American Pale Ale ABV 5.1%

Fire Rock, Kona, Hawaii, American Pale Ale ABV 6%

Hop Sun, Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American Pale Wheat ABV 5.1%

Little Sumpin' Sumpin' Ale, Lagunitas, California, American Pale Wheat Ale ABV 7.5%

Live, Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American Pale Ale ABV 5.5%

PMX (Phin & Matt's), Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American Pale Ale ABV 5.7%

Prima Pils, Victory, Pennsylvania, German Pilsener ABV 5.3%

(Belgians) Complex Flavor Profiles with Lawless Beginnings

Abbey Ale, Ommegang, Cooperstown, NY, Belgain Dubbel ABV 8.2%

Blue Moon, Blue Moon, Denver, Belgian Witbier ABV 5.4%

Duvel, Duvel, Belgium, Belgian Strong Pale Ale ABV 8.5%

Hennepin, Ommegang, Cooperstown, NY, Farmhouse Saison ABV 7.7%

Kellerweis, Sierra Nevada, California, Hefweizen ABV 4.8%

La Chouffe, Houblon Chouffe, Belgium, Belgain Strong Pale Ale ABV 8%

Matilda, Goose Island, Chicago, Belgain, Strong Pale Ale ABV 7%*

Maudite, Unibroue, Quebec, Canada, Belgian Strong Dark Ale ABV 8%

Pepe Nero, Goose Island, Chicago, Farmhouse Saison, ABV 6.4%*

Pere Jaques, Goose Island, Chicago, Belgain Dubbel ABV 8.7%*

Rare Vos, Ommegang, Cooperstown, NY, Belgain Pale Ale ABV 6.5%

Sofie, Goose Island, Chicago, Saison / Farmhouse Ale ABV 6.5%**

Three Philosophers, Ommegang, Cooperstown, NY, Belgain Quadrupel ABV 9.7%

Trappist Tripel, Westmalle, Belgium, Belgain Tripel ABV 9.5%

(IPAs and Double IPAs) Flavorful and Hoppy

2XIPA Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, Double IPA, ABV 8.2%

Centennial IPA Founders, Michigan, American IPA, ABV 7.2%

Dirt Wolf, Victory, Pennsylvania, Double IPA, ABV 8.7%

Grapefruit Sculpin IPA Ballast Point, Pennsylvania, American IPA, ABV 7%

Hercules Double IPA Great Divide, Colorado, American Double IPA, ABV 10%

Hop Devil, Victory, Pennsylvania, American IPA, ABV 6.7%

IPA Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American IPA, ABV 7.3%

Tangier, Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American IPA, ABV 5%

Titan IPA Great Divide, Colorado, American IPA, ABV 7.1%

Torpedo, Sierra Nevada, California, Double IPA, ABV 7.2%

(Dark Ales) Not Your Typical Middle Child

Arrogant Bastard Ale, Stone Brewing, California American Strong Ale ABV 7.2%**

Big Foot, Sierra Nevada, California, American Barleywine ABV 9.6%

Dead Guy Ale, Rogue Ales, Oregon, Maibock / Helles Bock ABV 6.5%

Dirty Bastard, Founders, Michigan, Scotch Ale ABV 8.5%

Indian Brown Ale, Dogish Head, Delaware, American Brown Ale ABV 7.2%

Nut Brown Ale, Samuel Smith, United Kingdom, English Brown Ale ABV 5%

Old Ruffian, Great Divide, Colorado, American Barleywine ABV 10.2%

Ruedrich's Red Seal Ale, North Coast, California, American Amber / Red Ale ABV 5.4%

Tröegs Troegenator Double Bock, Tröegs Brewing Company, Pennsylvania, Doppelbock ABV 8.2%

Wookey Jack, Firestone, California, American Black Ale ABV 8.3%

Yuengling Traditional Lager, Yuengling, Pennsylvania, American Amber / Red Lager ABV 4.4%

(Porters and Stouts) Dark and Delicious

Bourbon County Stout, Goose Island, Chicago Imperial Stout ABV 14.2%

Breakfast Stout, Founders, Michigan, Imperial Stout ABV 8.3%

Coffee Porter, Wolavers, Vermont, American Porter ABV 5%

Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald Porter, Great Lakes, Ohio, American Porter 5.8%

Old Rasputin Russian Imperial Stout, North Coast, California Russian Imperial Stout ABV 9%

Porter, Founders, Michigan, American Porter ABV 6.5%

Porter, Southern Tier, Lakewood, NY, American Porter ABV 5.8%

Smuttynose Robust Porter, Smuttynose Brewing, New Hampshire, American Porter ABV 6.2%

Taddy Porter, Samuel Smith, United Kingdom, English Porter ABV 5%

Victory At Sea Coffee Vanilla Imperial Porter, Ballast Point, California, American Porter ABV 10%

(Fermented Fruits) beyond Hops and Barley

Apple Ale, Redds, Wisconsin, Fruit Beer ABV 5%

Amber, Woodchuck, Vermont, Hard Cider ABV 5.8%

Steaks and Chop

Grilled Prime Rib

Delmonico

NY Strip

Filet Mignon

Marinated Sirloin

Pork Chop

Seafood and Chicken

Pan Seared Scallops

Lobster Tail

Shrimp Scampi

Chicken Marsala

Starters

Crab Cakes

French Onion Soup

Crab Stuffed Mushrooms

Steakhouse Shrimp Cocktail

Sausage Stuffed Peppers

Soup of the Day