Search
Prime + Proper Menu
4.4
(2,275+ Reviews)
Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.- Classic Vanilla Cheesecakegraham crust / fresh berries / raspberry whipped cream$16.80+
- Double Cut Pork Chopstwo 20 ounce chops / heritage berkshire pork$52.50+
- Mac + Cheesegruyere / reserve cheddar / torchio pasta$47.25
- Brussels Sproutshoneycrisp apple / bacon / honey mustard$47.25
- Bone-In Ribeyetwo 20 ounce steaks / USDA prime / dry-aged$99.75+
- Lobster Rollpoached lobster / scallops / lemon aioli / potato roll / fine herbs / caviar$36.75+
- Jumbo Shrimp Cocktaileight jumbo shrimp / cocktail sauce / lemon$47.25+
- Chicken Fried Lobsterbuttermilk / green chili aioli / chesapeake seasoning$60.90+
- Bone-In NY Striptwo 18 ounce steaks / USDA prime / dry-aged$89.25+
- Cokeglass bottled$6.30
Prime + Proper Large Format Dinners
Dinner at home for groups large and small. All packed in reusable oven safe containers and thermal bags. Order from our butcher shop delivered to your door or leave dinner to us!- Add Utensils
Large Format Starters
All designed to serve groups of four or larger.- Jumbo Shrimp Cocktaileight jumbo shrimp / cocktail sauce / lemon$47.25+
- Roasted Bone Marrowshort rib / tabbouleh / whipped garlic / grilled semolina bread$26.25+
- Octopushummus / olive oil / capers / sweet peppers / charred lemon / pita$52.50
- Chicken Fried Lobsterbuttermilk / green chili aioli / chesapeake seasoning$60.90+
Large Format Salads
All designed to serve groups of four or larger. Packaged in thermal containers with dressing served on the side.- Wedgeiceberg / tomato / bacon / red onion / roth blue cheese / buttermilk dressing$63.00
- P+P Louieblue crab / butter bibb lettuce / cured yolk / tomato / asparagus / avocado / poppy seed dressing$94.50
- Caesarromaine / pecorino frico / white anchovy / caesar$63.00
- Proper Choppedwinter greens / smoked chèvre / ginger miso / citrus / sesame tuile$63.00
Prime Meat + Chops
All designed to serve groups of four or larger. USDA Prime - Dry Aged In-House (28 Days) Packaged in oven safe containers and in a thermal reusable bag. Available for groups of four and larger. Steaks are recommended cooked Rare to Medium. We do not guarantee quality of steaks cooked medium well or above.- Porterhouse Steaktwo 32 ounce steaks / USDA prime / dry-aged$157.50+
- Bone-In NY Striptwo 18 ounce steaks / USDA prime / dry-aged$89.25+
- Center Cut Filet Mignonfour 8 ounce steaks / USDA prime / wet aged$68.25+
- Bone-In Ribeyetwo 20 ounce steaks / USDA prime / dry-aged$99.75+
- Double Cut Pork Chopstwo 20 ounce chops / heritage berkshire pork$52.50+
- Prime Lamb Chopssix double chops / prime colorado lamb$79.80+
- Dry-Aged Burgerfour burgers / house baked buns / french onions / pickled mustard seed / reserve cheddar$26.25+
Seafood
All designed to serve groups of four or larger. Flown in Fresh Daily to Prime + Proper Packaged in oven safe containers and in a thermal reusable bag.- Ora King Salmonfour six ounce portions$37.80+
- Jumbo Scallopstwelve U10 scallops / pan seared / maitake mushrooms / tomato raisins$42.00+
- Lobster Rollpoached lobster / scallops / lemon aioli / potato roll / fine herbs / caviar$36.75+
Large Format Sides
All designed to serve groups of four or larger. Packaged in oven safe thermal containers.- Pomme Puréede robuchon / chive$47.25
- Marble Potatoesbuttermilk vinaigrette / chervil / bottarga$47.25
- Cauliflower Gratincomté / garlic breadcrumbs$47.25
- Carrotspistachio / chermoula$47.25
- Mac + Cheesegruyere / reserve cheddar / torchio pasta$47.25
- Ricotta Gnocchimushroom conserva / caraway mustard / pecorino / horseradish$47.25
- Brussels Sproutshoneycrisp apple / bacon / honey mustard$47.25
Sauces
House made accompaniments for your dinner selections.- Proper Steak Saucefour ounces / served warm$10.50
- Whipped Horseradishfour ounces / served cool$10.50
- Roasted Garlic Ash Butterfour ounces / served cool$10.50
Desserts
All designed to serve groups of four or larger.- Chocolate Cakejivara milk chocolate mousse / dark chocolate mousse / chocolate glaze / white chocolate chantilly$16.80+
- Classic Vanilla Cheesecakegraham crust / fresh berries / raspberry whipped cream$16.80+
Butcher Shop
Raw Steaks + Chops from our Butcher Team. Vacuum packed and served fresh in thermal packaging.- Burger + Links Grilling Kitfour 8 oz burgers / four 8 oz wagu hot dogs / eight house baked buns / 8 oz dry aged cheddar / 4 oz french onions / 4 oz zip mayo / jacobson's salt$105.00
- Steak Grilling Kittwo 8 oz filets / two 20 oz bone-in ribeyes / two 18 oz bone-in dry aged NY strips / 8 oz tallow / jacobson's salt$262.50
- Fill the Iceboxeight 8oz dry aged burgers / eight 8oz wagyu hot dogs / four 8oz USDA prime filets / four 20oz bone-in dry aged ribeyes / four 18 oz bone In dry aged NY strips / 16 house baked buns / 16 oz aged cheddar / 8oz of french onions / 8 oz zip mayo / jacobson's salt$630.00
- Large Format Steak Grilling Kitone 40 oz bone-in dry aged tomahawk ribeye / one 32 oz bone-in dry aged porterhouse / 4 oz of tallow / jacobson's salt$262.50
- World of Wagyuone 6 oz block cut miyazaki GYU A-5 / 6 oz block cut australian 9+ BMS / one 6 oz block cut japanese craft selection / jacobson's salt$420.00
Beverages
- Cokeglass bottled$6.30
- Diet Cokeglass bottled$6.30
- Spriteglass bottled$6.30
Menu Photos
Menu Photos
Loading...
