Poppy's Ice Cream & Coffee House Menu

4.6

(475+ Reviews)

$Ice cream shop, Coffee shop, Dessert shop

Customer Favorites Signature Specialty Sundaes Regular Sundaes Scoops Hand-Rolled Waffle Cone Shakes Floats extra stuff

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Double Scoop
  Two scoops of ice cream served in a cup with your choice of flavors. Toppings including sprinkles, gummy worms & Oreos. Options include vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cake batter, mint chip, gianduja, and cookie dough.
  $9.25
- True Banana Split
  One size only. Vanilla, chocolate & strawberry ice creams topped with chocolate syrup, strawberries, pineapple, pecans & whipped cream & cherry.
  $9.50
- The Unicorn Sundae
  Two scoops of cake batter ice cream topped with unicorn chocolate, rainbow sprinkles & strawberries.
  $8.85
- One Scoop
  A single scoop served in a cup. Offering options like vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cake batter, mint chip, gianduja, or cookie dough ice cream, with optional rainbow sprinkles, gummy worms & oreos.
  $5.00
- Gianduja Espresso Shake
  Gianduja ice cream blended with double espresso shots.
  $8.50
- Strawberry
  Creamy blend of strawberries & vanilla ice cream. Choose between regular or large.
  $6.75
- Slow Sundae
  Vanilla ice cream topped with hot fudge, caramel & pecans.
  $6.75
- Salty Brownie
  Vanilla ice cream with salted brownie topped with hot fudge.
  $6.75
- Strawberry
  Vanilla ice cream topped with strawberries, optional whipped cream, and a cherry on top. Available with one or two scoops.
  $5.90
- Banana
  Creamy banana shake with a rich banana flavor. Available in regular or large.
  $6.75
- Gianduja Sundae
  Two brownies and two scoops of gianduja ice cream topped with chocolate shell.
  $8.85
- Hot Fudge
  Rich hot fudge with creamy vanilla ice cream. Choose from 1 scoop or 2 scoop.
  $5.90
Signature
- The Unicorn Sundae
  Two scoops of cake batter ice cream topped with unicorn chocolate, rainbow sprinkles & strawberries.
  $8.85
- Espresso Bean Shake
  Vanilla ice cream blended with Broadway Café espresso beans & magic chocolate.
  $8.50
- Gianduja Espresso Shake
  Gianduja ice cream blended with double espresso shots.
  $8.50
- Gianduja Sundae
  Two brownies and two scoops of gianduja ice cream topped with chocolate shell.
  $8.85
Specialty Sundaes
- True Banana Split
  One size only. Vanilla, chocolate & strawberry ice creams topped with chocolate syrup, strawberries, pineapple, pecans & whipped cream & cherry.
  $9.50
- Slow Sundae
  Vanilla ice cream topped with hot fudge, caramel & pecans.
  $6.75
- Black Out
  Chocolate ice cream with hot fudge & magic chocolate.
  $6.75
- Salty Brownie
  Vanilla ice cream with salted brownie topped with hot fudge.
  $6.75
- Poppy's Peanut
  Vanilla ice cream with hot fudge & peanuts.
  $6.75
Regular Sundaes
Vanilla ice cream.
- Strawberry
  Vanilla ice cream topped with strawberries, optional whipped cream, and a cherry on top. Available with one or two scoops.
  $5.90
- Chocolate Syrup
  Rich chocolate syrup over creamy vanilla ice cream, with choices of one or two scoops.
  $5.90
- Pineapple
  Vanilla ice cream topped with pineapple.
  $5.90
- Hot Fudge
  Rich hot fudge with creamy vanilla ice cream. Choose from 1 scoop or 2 scoop.
  $5.90
- Caramel
  Creamy vanilla ice cream topped with rich caramel sauce. Available in 1 scoop or 2 scoop.
  $5.90
Scoops
- Double Scoop
  Two scoops of ice cream served in a cup with your choice of flavors. Toppings including sprinkles, gummy worms & Oreos. Options include vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cake batter, mint chip, gianduja, and cookie dough.
  $9.25
- One Scoop
  A single scoop served in a cup. Offering options like vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cake batter, mint chip, gianduja, or cookie dough ice cream, with optional rainbow sprinkles, gummy worms & oreos.
  $5.00
Hand-Rolled Waffle Cone
- Rainbow Sprinkle with Chocolate
  Hand-rolled waffle cone with rainbow sprinkles and chocolate drizzle.
  $2.00
- Plain
  Hand-rolled waffle cone made from a simple batter, offering a crisp and light texture.
  $1.25
- Chocolate
  Hand-rolled waffle cone dipped in rich chocolate.
  $1.50
Shakes
Make it a malt for an additional charge.
- Banana
  Creamy banana shake with a rich banana flavor. Available in regular or large.
  $6.75
- Peanut Butter
  Creamy shake with rich peanut butter flavor, available in regular or large sizes.
  $6.75
- Vanilla
  Creamy vanilla shake available in regular or large size.
  $6.75
- Cherry
  cherries and vanilla ice cream. Available in regular or large size.
  $6.75
- Strawberry
  Creamy blend of strawberries & vanilla ice cream. Choose between regular or large.
  $6.75
- Chocolate
  Rich chocolate shake, available in regular or large size.
  $6.75
Floats
Double of vanilla and bottle of soda.
- Cola
  Classic chilled cola, the perfect refreshing companion to any meal.
  $8.50
- Black Cherry
  Vanilla ice cream floating in a glass of fizzy black cherry soda.
  $8.50
- Root Beer
  Smooth, classic root beer with a rich, frothy head. Perfectly sweet and endlessly refreshing.
  $8.50
- Orange
  Orange Ice Cream Float: Sunkist orange soda with a scoop of premium vanilla ice cream.
  $8.50
extra stuff
- cake cone
  Crispy cone typically filled with a rich and creamy cake mixture.
  $0.75
- Cup
  Choice of cup, sugar cone, or cake cone.
  $0.75
- sugar cone
  A crisp, sweet cone typically used for holding your favorite ice cream or dessert.
  $0.75