Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
Chocolate Cream Slice
Deep rich chocolate, made from egg custard and cocoa, topped with whipped cream.
$6.29
Boysenberry Slice
Luscious boysenberries, chock full of tangy flavor.
$7.69
Chicken Pie Dinner
Polly’s pie crust with light meat chicken, signature gravy,broccoli, celery, cauliflower, carrots, peas, sweet onions,and diced potatoes. Served with red skin smashedpotatoes, and our cranberry sauce.
$18.89
2-3-1 Combo
Served with two large eggs, three Jones DairyFarms smoked sausage links or three cherrywoodsmoked bacon strips, and your choice of breakfastpotatoes.
$16.59
Giant Cinnamon Rolls 2ct
$10.69
Apple Crisp Slice
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices, covered with a sweet crumbly topping!
$7.09
Chicken Fried Steak
Country chicken fried steak with country gravy, red skinsmashed potatoes, and green beans*.
$18.89
Banana Cream Slice
Plump fresh bananas lavished in creamy vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream and almonds.
$6.29
Mini Pancakes & Egg
Served with butter & syrup. Add some extra love to your pancakes! Add Chocolate Chips, Blueberries, or Sliced Bananas 1.00 each. Served with choice of one sausage link, one bacon strip, fresh fruit cup, or hashbrowns.
$7.09
Ms. Polly's Triple Breakfast Surprise
Three sweet buttermilk pancakes served withbutter, syrup, three large eggs, a choice of threeJones Dairy Farms smoked sausage links or threecherrywood smoked bacon strips, and your choiceof breakfast potatoes.
$20.09
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Polly’s famous cookies baked fresh every day in our Big Red Oven.
$2.19+
French Toast Dippers & Egg
Served with syrup for dipping. Served with choice of one sausage link, one bacon strip, fresh fruit cup, or hashbrowns.
$7.09
Seasonal Specials
Reuben Fritters
Tender corned beef with sauerkraut, three cheeses, and spices hand breaded and fried golden brown. Served with house-made Guinness cheese sauce for dipping.
$12.99
Reuben Sandwich
Thinly sliced corned beef, fresh sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and house-made thousand island dressing on toasted, freshly baked rye bread. Served with fries.
$20.09
Corned Beef & Cabbage
Tender slices of corned beef with baby carrots, red potatoes, and a wedge of braised cabbage. Served with pub mustard sauce and our freshly baked dinner rolls.
$22.99
Pi Day Apple Pie
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices.
$21.29
Corned Beef & Cabbage Meal
Tender slices of corned beef, steamed cabbage, carrots, petite potatoes, O’Polly’s Special Sauce, and freshly baked rye or regular dinner rolls.
$93.29
Irish Skillet
Corned beef and chopped bacon layered with our breakfast potatoes, Guinness cheese sauce, farm fresh eggs, and sliced green onions.
$20.79
Starters
Mozzarella Sticks
With marinara sauce.
$10.69
Beer-Battered Onion Rings
With Ms. Polly’s Special Dressing.
$10.09
Southern Pimento Cheese Dip
House-made chilled dip w/ sliced baguette
$9.49
Polly's Jumbo Crispy Chicken Wings (6)
Choose a sauce or dry-rub! Dry rubs: Charred Lemon Pepper or Original Root Beer. Sauces: Citrus Mango BBQ, Traditional BBQ, or Buffalo.
$14.19
Polly's Jumbo Crispy Chicken Wings (9)
Choose a sauce or dry-rub! Dry rubs: Charred Lemon Pepper or Original Root Beer. Sauces: Citrus Mango BBQ, Traditional BBQ, or Buffalo.
$17.69
Soups & Salads
Turkey Cobb
Oven roasted turkey, tomatoes, green onions, bluecheese crumbles, and cherrywood smoked bacontossed with Polly’s mixed greens and blue cheesedressing. Topped with avocado and sliced egg.
$18.29
Creamy Tomato Basil Soup
Our comforting creamy tomato basil soup, made with a unique blend of red ripe tomatoes, rich cream, garlic, and basil, topped with shredded parmesan and a hand cut seasoned crouton (vegetarian)
$5.89+
Caesar Salad
Crisp mixed greens, house-made croutons, and Parmesan cheese tossed in a zesty Caesar dressing. Served with our garlic Parmesan crostini.
$11.79
House Salad
Sliced cucumber, tomato, carrots, red onion, and our own croutons.
$7.09
Backburner Soup
A Polly’s Classic – steam kettle slow-cooked with bacon, ham, pinto and black beans, garden vegetables, and small pasta shells.
$5.89+
Grilled Shrimp Salad
Grilled shrimp, shredded lettuce, and baby arugula tossed in our creamy garlic dressing with shredded carrots, marinated artichoke hearts, red onion, cucumber, grape tomatoes, fresh basil, and our house-made croutons.
$18.89
Asian Chicken Salad
Mixed greens and Napa cabbage, tossed with our pulled roasted chicken, mango, almonds, red bell pepper, cucumber, carrots, red onions, cilantro, and crispy wontons tossed in a zesty Asian dressing.
$17.69
Bleu Cheese Wedge
Iceberg wedge with cherrywood smoked bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, house-made bleu cheese dressing, caramelized walnuts, green onions, and dried cranberries.
$8.29
Sandwiches
Prime Rib French Dip
Slow-roasted prime rib piled on a baguette with creamy horseradish aioli and served with au jus for dipping.
$20.09
Old Fashioned Chicken Salad
Hand pulled roasted chicken, walnuts, celery, sweetonions and mayo on our toasted raisin walnut bread.
$14.19
Mega Grilled Cheese
Jack, Cheddar, Swiss, and American on our sourdoughbread grilled with Ms. Polly’s special garlic Parmesanspread.
$12.99
Half Sandwich Combo
Half sandwich with your choice of a cup of soup or a dinner salad. Choose from: Chicken Salad, Garlic Aioli Turkey, Tuna Salad, Mega Grilled Cheese, Avocado & Friends
$12.99
Famous Tuna Salad
White albacore tuna, chopped eggs, sweet onions,Ms. Polly’s Special recipe seasonings, relish, celery,and mayo on our white bread.
$14.19
Avocado & Friends
Sliced avocado, tomatoes, cucumber, sweet onions,green leaf lettuce, Jack or vegan Gouda cheese andgarlic aioli on our kracked wheat bread.
$12.99
Comeback Chicken Sandwich
Buttermilk fried chicken breast on our made fresh daily bun with our spicy 'Comeback Sauce', lettuce and pickles.
$15.39
BBQ Prime Rib Sandwich
Sliced warm prime rib, Sriracha-Ale mustard, BBQ sauce, caramelized onions, Monterey Jack cheese, and crisp arugula on a freshly baked bun.
$22.49
California Tuna Melt
Chilled white albacore tuna salad**, fresh avocado, tomato, lettuce, mayo, and melted Cheddar on our grilled sourdough bread. **contains eggs
$16.59
Garlic Aioli Roasted Turkey
Slices of oven roasted Foster Farms® turkey breast,garlic aioli, tomatoes, lettuce, and Jack Cheese servedon our sourdough bread.
$16.59
Burgers
Pollymelt
Our signature patty smothered in grilled sweetonions and your choice of melted Swiss or Cheddarcheese. Served on our rye bread.
$16.59
Create Your Own Burger
Craft your ideal burger by selecting your preferred protein, bun, and sauce. You can also enhance it with extras like arugula or caramelized onions for only 59 cents. And don’t forget the cheese! Each burger includes pickles and lettuce, served with either fries or coleslaw. For an upgrade, enjoy sweet potato fries or onion rings for an additional $1.99.
$14.79
Pollyburger
Our signature beef patty atop fresh lettuce, pickles,and sweet onions. Served on our freshly baked bun ofyour choice spread with Ms. Polly’s Special Dressing.
$14.79
Polly Cheeseburger
Our signature beef patty covered in your choice of melted cheese atop fresh lettuce, pickles, and sweet onion. Served on our freshly baked bun of your choice spread with Ms. Polly’s Special Dressing.
$16.59
Grilled Sourdough Burger
Our sourdough bread grilled with garlic Parmesanbutter, grilled onions, Cheddar cheese, lettuce,tomato, pickles and Ms. Polly’s Special Dressing.
$16.59
Homestyle Meals
Chicken Pie Dinner
Polly’s pie crust with light meat chicken, signature gravy,broccoli, celery, cauliflower, carrots, peas, sweet onions,and diced potatoes. Served with red skin smashedpotatoes, and our cranberry sauce.
$18.89
Classic Meatloaf
House-made meatloaf blended with Jack cheese, bell peppers, and sweet onions with tomato ketchup glaze. Served with market vegetables and red skin smashed potatoes with beef gravy.
$21.29
Salisbury Steak
Polly’s housemade steak with freshly grilled mushrooms,rich demi-glace, red skin smashed potatoes, and greenbeans*.
$18.89
Chicken Caliente Penne
Our signature oven-roasted pulled chicken sautéed with onion, bell pepper, fire-roasted corn, and garlic then tossed with penne pasta in chipotle cream sauce.
$20.09
Creamy Shrimp Pasta
Sautéed shrimp tossed with penne pasta in a garlic Parmesan cream sauce. Served with garlic Parmesan sourdough toast.
$20.09
Grilled Norwegian Salmon
Atlantic salmon filet served with market vegetables and herb rice. Prepared with your choice of: garlic butter and lemon or Cajun seasoning with chipotle butter.
$23.59+
Chicken Fried Steak
Country chicken fried steak with country gravy, red skinsmashed potatoes, and green beans*.
$18.89
Tenders Platter
Crispy breaded chicken tenders served with fries and coleslaw.
$14.19
Pasta Primavera
Cavatappi pasta in a light butter sauce with market vegetables, grape tomato, onion, garlic, fresh basil, and sundried tomato. Topped with shredded parmesan.
$16.59
Beer-Battered Fish & Chips
Hand-dipped Alaskan cod filets served with fries, coleslaw, and tartar sauce.
$20.09
Skillets & Omelettes
Vegetarian Skillet
Scrambled eggs with fresh seasonal vegetables, plant-based chorizo, and sliced avocado on a bed of our signature breakfast potatoes.
$18.89
Create Your Own Omelette
Create your perfect omelette by choosing two of your favorite vegetables. For an upgrade, consider adding meat and cheese. This delicious meal also includes a selection of breakfast potatoes and a bakery item of your choice.
Slow-roasted prime rib, mushrooms, bell peppers, caramelized onions, and grape tomatoes on a bed of our signature breakfast potatoes. Topped with two eggs any style, horseradish cream, green onions, and Cheddar cheese.
$21.89
Polly's Jr
Polly's Jr Grilled Cheese
On our freshly baked grilled sourdough bread. Includes choice of one Jr. side.
$7.69
French Toast Dippers & Egg
Served with syrup for dipping. Served with choice of one sausage link, one bacon strip, fresh fruit cup, or hashbrowns.
$7.09
Mini Pancakes & Egg
Served with butter & syrup. Add some extra love to your pancakes! Add Chocolate Chips, Blueberries, or Sliced Bananas 1.00 each. Served with choice of one sausage link, one bacon strip, fresh fruit cup, or hashbrowns.
$7.09
Jr Chicken Tenders
With your choice of dipping sauce. Includes choice of one Jr. side.
$7.09
Mini Corn Dogs
The perfect finger food! Served with ketchup for dipping. Includes choice of one Jr. side.
$7.69
Egg & Toast
With our own tasty Bumbleberry Jam. Served with choice of one sausage link, one bacon strip, fresh fruit cup, or hashbrowns.
$7.09
Silly Face Pancake
Use our fresh fruit to make your own silly face' pancake.
$5.89
Butter Noodles
Served plain or with butter & parmesan. Includes choice of one Jr. side.
$7.69
Pollyburger Jr
Our mini fresh never frozen beef patty served on a freshly baked roll. Includes choice of one Jr. side.
$7.69
Jr Mac & Cheese
Hot and cheesy! Includes choice of one Jr. side.
$7.69
Polly Cheeseburger Jr
Our mini fresh never frozen beef patty served on a freshly baked roll. Includes choice of one Jr. side.
$8.29
Polly's Famous Cookie
$1.79
Jr Pasta with Red Sauce
Cavatappi pasta with red sauce topped with parmesan cheese. Includes choice of one Jr. side.
$7.69
Breakfast All Day
Ms. Polly's Triple Breakfast Surprise
Three sweet buttermilk pancakes served withbutter, syrup, three large eggs, a choice of threeJones Dairy Farms smoked sausage links or threecherrywood smoked bacon strips, and your choiceof breakfast potatoes.
$20.09
French Toast Combo
Two slices of Ms. Polly's freshly baked breaddrenched in our special egg batter and grilled untilgolden brown.
$15.39
2-3-1 Combo
Served with two large eggs, three Jones DairyFarms smoked sausage links or three cherrywoodsmoked bacon strips, and your choice of breakfastpotatoes.
$16.59
Double Buttermilk Pancakes
Two sweet buttermilk pancakes served with butter& syrup.
$15.99
A.B.C. Omelette
Avocado, cherrywood smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, mushrooms and green onions
$18.89
Avocado Toast w/ Egg
Our freshly baked toasted sourdough bread with smashed avocado, sliced tomato, two eggs, and a side of salsa.
$15.39
Breakfast All Day - Sides
Bacon (3)
$6.49
Sausage (3)
$6.49
Cottage Cheese
$2.99
Breakfast Potatoes
$4.79
Fresh Fruit
$3.59
Pie Slices & Shakes
Boysenberry Slice
Luscious boysenberries, chock full of tangy flavor.
$7.69
Cherry Slice
Red, tart and juicy cherries from Utah or Michigan, captured in one of Polly's original pies.
$6.29
Banana Cream Slice
Plump fresh bananas lavished in creamy vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream and almonds.
$6.29
Coconut Cream Slice
The finest shredded Hawaiian Coconut is drenched in rich old-fashioned custard topped with whipped cream.
$6.29
Apple Slice
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices.
$6.29
Chocolate Cream Slice
Deep rich chocolate, made from egg custard and cocoa, topped with whipped cream.
$6.29
Apple Slice - No Sugar Added
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices. Made with equal sugar substitute.
$6.49
Apple Crisp Slice
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices, covered with a sweet crumbly topping!
$7.09
Lemon Meringue Slice
Lots of tasty lemon filling with a mountain of toasted meringue.
$6.29
Banberry Slice
Ms. Polly's delicious banana cream filling, topped with fresh sweet strawberries and a ring of real whipped cream.
$7.09
Sides
Red Skin Smashed Potatoes
$4.19
Macaroni & Cheese
$3.59
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.89
Market Vegetables
$3.59
Green Beans
$3.29
French Fries
$4.19
Polly's Coleslaw
$3.29
Fruit Cup
$3.59
Whole Pies
Order up to 6 pies. For larger orders, please visit our Catering Menu on pollypies.com. Questions about large orders? Email catering@pollyspies.com.
Banberry
Ms. Polly's delicious banana cream filling, topped with fresh sweet strawberries and a ring of real whipped cream.
$23.59
Banana Cream
Plump fresh bananas lavished in creamy vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream and almonds.
$21.29
Boysenberry
Luscious boysenberries, chock full of tangy flavor.
$27.19
Lemon Meringue
Lots of tasty lemon filling with a mountain of toasted meringue.
$20.09
Cherry
Red, tart and juicy cherries from Utah or Michigan, captured in one of Polly's original pies.
$21.29
Chocolate Cream
Deep rich chocolate, made from egg custard and cocoa, topped with whipped cream.
$21.29
Cheesecake
Classic cream cheese baked on a graham cracker crust.
$31.89
Fruit Cheesecake
Our classic cheesecake with a sweet strawberry topping.
$35.39
Famous Apple
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices.
$21.29
Apple Crisp
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices, covered with a sweet crumbly topping!
$23.59
Coconut Cream
The finest shredded Hawaiian Coconut is drenched in rich old-fashioned custard topped with whipped cream.
$21.29
POTM Strawberry Rhubarb
Tart rhubarb combined with sweet strawberries baked in Polly’s famous buttery & flaky pie crust.
$16.59
Bake at Home Peach
Old fashioned country-kitchen flavor enhanced with a touch of cinnamon.
$20.09
Bake at Home Apricot
A famous recipe of sun-ripened apricots, flavored to perfection and bursting with golden goodness.
$20.09
Bake at Home Rhubarb
Only the finest Northwestern rhubarb. Polly's has created a unique pie with a tangy sweet-sour taste.
$20.09
Bake at Home Blueberry
Mounds of wild mountain and cultivated blueberries for old time flavor.
$20.09
Chocolate Silk
Silky chocolate baked in our famous pie crust and topped with real whipped cream and chocolate shavings.
$28.39
Famous Apple - No Sugar Added
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices. Made with Splenda sugar substitute.
$22.49
Bakery and Marketplace
Giant Cinnamon Rolls 2ct
$10.69
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Polly’s famous cookies baked fresh every day in our Big Red Oven.
$2.19+
Muffin 4ct
$12.99+
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
Polly’s famous cookies baked fresh every day in our Big Red Oven.*** contains nuts
$2.19+
Snickerdoodle Cookies
Polly’s famous cookies baked fresh every day in our Big Red Oven.
$2.19+
Cornbread pan
$8.29
Dinner Rolls 12ct
$8.29
Gourmet Brownie
Indulge your sweet cravings with our delectable Double Chocolate Chip Brownie. This rich and fudgy brownie is a chocolate lover's dream come true, taken to the next level with extra chocolate chips.
$2.99+
Biscuits 6ct
$7.09
White Loaf
$5.89
Kracked Wheat Loaf
$8.29
Sourdough Loaf
$7.09
Raisin Walnut Loaf
$9.49
French Baguette
$3.59
1lb Polly's Coffee Bag
$16.59+
Strawberry Jam
Each jam jar comes with a tag for Teacher Appreciation Week!Our Fresh strawberries are made into the perfect sweet jam. Best served with our baked fresh daily biscuits or on toast!
$10.69
White Buns, 6 pack
Freshly baked white burger buns, perfect for BBQs, sloppy joes, and beyond, adding a touch of softness and flavor to take your grilling game to the next level!
$7.09
Wheat Buns, 6 Pack
Freshly baked kracked wheat burger buns, perfect for BBQs, sloppy joes, and beyond, adding a touch of softness and flavor to take your grilling game to the next level!
$7.09
Oatmeal Cookies
Polly’s famous cookies baked fresh every day in our Big Red Oven.*** contains nuts
$2.19+
Bumbleberry Jam
Each jam jar comes with a tag for Teacher Appreciation Week!The perfect mix of blueberries, strawberries, and blackberries in a sweet and tart jam. Best served with our baked fresh daily biscuits or on toast!
$11.19
Drinks
Soda
$4.49+
Orange Juice
$5.09
Freshly Brewed Ice Tea
$4.49
Freshly Brewed Mango Iced Tea
$4.49
Strawberry Lemonade
This pie is light and airy perfection, featuring an irresistible cream cheese base with a zesty lemon filling. it's set on polly’s classic flakey crust and topped with fresh sweet strawberries crowned with freshly whipped cream and garnished with a lemon wheel.
$5.09
Polly Palmer
A new take on the classic with a blend of fresh fruit strawberry lemonade and freshly brewed iced tea.
$5.09
Polly's Gourmet Coffee
$4.79+
Arnold Palmer
Freshly brewed iced tea and lemonade stirred together and served over ice.
$5.09
Apple Juice
$4.79
Hot Chocolate
$4.49
Cranberry Juice
$4.79
Vanilla Cream Cold Brew Coffee
$6.29
Lemonade
$4.49
Utensils
In an effort to be green, we will only provide utensils when requested. So if you would like utensils included with your order, please add this item to your cart!