Pizzeria Scotty

The stuffed pizza was totally worth the price.

Unfortunately, I cannot give an accurate review on the food because they closed before posted closing time without proper notice. I got there at 9:25pm on 1/11/24 after a nice evening run, looking forward to a good pizza, and the posted closing time on here was listed as 10pm. When I got there, the only potential indication of them being closed was one or two signs being off, but lights were on, doors were unlocked, there was no sign indicating early closure, etc. I stepped in and was informed they closed early to keep labor costs down. I can understand that to an extent, but I also went out of my way to get here based on the knowledge that this business was open until 10pm. It was a frustrating experience. So far this was my first and only visit. I hope to try again in the near future (perhaps not as close to closing time) and I hope for a more pleasant experience that can bring this review up to 4 or 5 stars.

This is one of the best pizza joints in the Milwaukee area. I ordered a deep dish and a thin crust. Both were outstanding.

We drove in from Sussex for their pizza.Never got a bad one yet.

Since we've been picking up our Sunday/Monday night pizza (depends on who's playing football those days) this pizzaria has been consistently delicious. The sauce has a hint of spicyness which as a base to the toppings stands out. We love the thin crust with black olives and pepperoni. If you're looking for something different they offer mouth watering options like Scotty sticks, or the Scotty extreme. It can take up to an hour to cook up your order because they are busy....so don't wait until you're hungry!!

Excellent pizza!!! Staff was so awesome!!!