Pizzarito NY Pizza By The Slice Menu

4.8

(650+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites NY Thin Crust Pizzas Sicilian Deep Dish Crust Pizza Cold Salads Salad Trays Gourmet Pizza Hot Pasta Dishes Calzones, Stromboli & Pinwheels New York Subs Sides Desserts Beverages

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- NY Thin Crust Topping Slice
  Dough made fresh daily Quality ingredients
  $4.85
- 1-Topping NY Thin Crust Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily, fresh mozzarella cheeses, homemade pizza sauce. Choice of toppings
  $27.00
- 3-Toppings NY Thin Crust Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily, fresh mozzarella cheeses, homemade pizza sauce. Choose your toppings
  $31.00
- 2-Toppings NY Thin Crust Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily, fresh mozzarella cheeses, homemade pizza sauce Choice of toppings
  $29.00
- Slice of Sicilian Cheese
  Slice of Sicilian Pizza
  $4.85
- NY Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily ,fresh mozzarella cheese, homemade pizza sauce
  $25.00
- NY Thin Crust Cheese Slice
  Dough made fresh daily Quality ingredients
  $4.60
- One Dozen Garlic Knots
  Drizzled with olive oil, garlic and Italian parsley served with a side of homemade marinara sauce. Most popular!
  $11.75
- Bottled Mexican coke
  Made with cane sugar
  $3.75
- Slice of Sicilian Pepperoni
  Generously topped with pepperoni slices, melted mozzarella cheese, and a rich tomato sauce on a thick, airy Sicilian deep dish crust.
  $5.10
NY Thin Crust Pizzas
- NY Thin Crust Cheese Slice
  Dough made fresh daily Quality ingredients
  $4.60
- NY Thin Crust Topping Slice
  Dough made fresh daily Quality ingredients
  $4.85
- NY Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily ,fresh mozzarella cheese, homemade pizza sauce
  $25.00
- 1-Topping NY Thin Crust Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily, fresh mozzarella cheeses, homemade pizza sauce. Choice of toppings
  $27.00
- 2-Toppings NY Thin Crust Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily, fresh mozzarella cheeses, homemade pizza sauce Choice of toppings
  $29.00
- 3-Toppings NY Thin Crust Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily, fresh mozzarella cheeses, homemade pizza sauce. Choose your toppings
  $31.00
- 4-Toppings NY Thin Crust Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily, fresh mozzarella cheeses, homemade pizza sauce. Choose your toppings
  $33.00
Sicilian Deep Dish Crust Pizza
- Slice of Sicilian Cheese
  Slice of Sicilian Pizza
  $4.85
- Slice of Sicilian Pepperoni
  Generously topped with pepperoni slices, melted mozzarella cheese, and a rich tomato sauce on a thick, airy Sicilian deep dish crust.
  $5.10
- 17" Sicilian Cheese Pizza
  Deep dish crust Dough made fresh daily Fresh mozzarella cheeses Homemade pizza sauce, Splash of Oregano
  $31.00
- 17" Sicilian 1-Topping Pizza
  Deep dish crust, Choice of Topping
  $33.50
- 17" Sicilian 2-Toppings Pizza
  Deep dish crust Dough made fresh daily Fresh mozzarella cheeses Homemade pizza sauce Choose your toppings
  $36.00
- 17" Sicilian 3-Toppings Pizza
  Deep dish crust Dough made fresh daily Fresh mozzarella cheeses Homemade pizza sauce Choose your toppings
  $38.50
- 17" Sicilian 4-Toppings Pizza
  Deep dish crust Dough made fresh daily Fresh mozzarella cheese Homemade pizza sauce Choose your toppings
  $41.00
Cold Salads
- Italian Green Salad
  Crisp Romaine and Iceberg lettuce, garbanzo beans, black olives, grape tomatoes and red cabbage. Choice of homemade Italian dressing or creamy ranch
  $13.25
- Antipasto Salad
  Crisp Romaine & Iceberg lettuce, garbanzo beans, black olives, grape tomatoes, red cabbage, mozzarella cheeses and Premium Italian meats. Choice of homemade Italian dressing or creamy ranch
  $15.25
Salad Trays
- Green Salad Tray
  Crispy Romaine & Iceberg lettuce, garbanzo beans, black olives ,grape tomatoes and red cabbage. Choice of homemade Italian dressing or creamy ranch
  $30.00
- Antipasto Salad Tray
  Crispy Romaine & Iceberg lettuce, garbanzo beans, black olives, grape tomatoes, red cabbage, mozzarella cheeses and Premium meats. Served with homemade Italian dressing
  $40.00
Gourmet Pizza
- Spinach, Garlic & Ricotta Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily Fresh mozzarella and ricotta cheeses
  $31.00
- Fresh Tomato, Garlic & Basil Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily Fresh mozzarella cheeses , homemade pizza sauce
  $31.00
- BBQ Chicken, Red Onion & Cilantro Pizza
  Dough made fresh daily. Fresh mozzarella cheeses, Special BBQ sauce
  $31.00
Hot Pasta Dishes
- Cheese Manicotti
  Homemade and baked to order. Made with fresh pasta, ricotta, Parmesan, Romano and Mozzarella cheeses. Served with garlic bread.
  $18.75
- Meat Lasagna
  Made with fresh pasta, ricotta, Parmesan, Romano and mozzarella cheeses. Homemade and baked to order. Served with garlic bread. House Favorite !
  $19.75
Calzones, Stromboli & Pinwheels
- Cheese Calzone
  Homemade and baked to order. Filled with ricotta, Parmesan cheeses and served with a side of marinara sauce. Choose any of your favorite toppings
  $16.75
- Stromboli
  Homemade with fresh dough. Premium Italian meats and Mozzarella cheeses. Baked to perfection, served with a side of homemade marinara sauce.
  $14.75
- Pinwheels
  Homemade Pinwheels are layered and rolled into spirals with Mozzarella cheese and your choice of spinach ricotta, sausage or pepperoni. served with a side of homemade marinara sauce.
  $13.25
New York Subs
- Meatball Parmesan Sub
  Fresh Italian bread, homemade Italian meatballs, homemade marinara sauce and Mozzarella cheese.
  $19.25
- Chicken Parmesan Sub
  Fresh Italian bread, lightly breaded chicken, homemade marinara sauce and Mozzarella cheese.
  $19.25
Sides
- 6" Garlic Bread
  Two pieces.
  $5.75
- 2 Garlic Knots
  Garlic knots drizzled in olive oil, garlic and Italian parsley served with a side of homemade marinara sauce.
  $2.00
- One Dozen Garlic Knots
  Drizzled with olive oil, garlic and Italian parsley served with a side of homemade marinara sauce. Most popular!
  $11.75
- Italian Meatballs Side of 2
  Homemade Italian meatballs served with homemade marinara. Baked to perfection !
  $8.50
- Homemade Italian Dressing
  Olive oil, red wine vinegar and Italian herbs.
  $7.50
- Homemade Ranch Dressing
  Creamy dressing.
  $7.50
- Side Homemade Ranch Side
  Creamy dressing.
  $2.00
- Side Homemade Italian Dressing
  Olive oil, red wine vinegar & Italian herbs.
  $2.00
- Dough
  Made fresh daily
  $9.75
- Marinara
  Secret Recipe
  $7.50
- Side of Marinara
  Secret Recipe
  $2.00
Desserts
- Tiramisu Cup
  Layers of imported mascarpone cream, lady fingers delicately soaked in espresso and finished with a dusting of cocoa.
  $6.50
- Limoncello Mascarpone Cup
  Luscious cake, a combination of Sicilian lemon infused sponge cake and Italian mascarpone topped with European chocolate curls.
  $6.50
- New York Cheesecake
  N.Y. style deli all natural, rich and creamy.
  $6.50
- Black & White Cookie
  Soft cake-like cookie with both vanilla and chocolate icing. Straight From New York!
  $4.75
- Raspberry Linzer Tart Cookie
  A soft buttery shortbread style cookie with imported raspberry preserves and a sprinkle of powdered sugar.
  $4.75
- Macaroon Cookie
  A moist chewy tropical coconut macaroon that is dunked in luscious chocolate... Simply irresistible!!
  $4.75
- Cakebites
  Tri-colored Italian rainbow cake layered between raspberry jelly and dipped in premium dark chocolate.
  $4.75
- TORRES Potato chips
  Black Truffle
  $4.75
Beverages
- Fountain Soda
  No Delivery See bottles & cans
  $3.25
- Canned Soda
  Your choice of classic coke, diet coke or coke zero
  $3.00
- Bottled Mexican coke
  Made with cane sugar
  $3.75
- Yoo-Hoo
  Refreshing beverage for the chocolate lover
  $3.75
- Panna Water
  Italian bottled water
  $3.75
- San Pellegrino Water
  The finest sparkling natural mineral water
  $3.75
- Snapple
  It all started in Brooklyn
  $3.75
- Stewart's Soda
  Nostalgic "old fashioned" sodas
  $3.75
- Illy Cold Brew Coffee
  Awaken your senses with the pure pleasure of illy ready to drink Cold Brew
  $3.75
- Blood Orange Soda
  Made in Italy
  $3.75
- Manhattan Special
  Premium Espresso Coffee Drink Since 1895 Made in Brooklyn NY.
  $3.75

Menu Photos

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Pizzarito NY Pizza By The Slice Menu

Customer Favorites

NY Thin Crust Topping Slice

1-Topping NY Thin Crust Pizza

3-Toppings NY Thin Crust Pizza

2-Toppings NY Thin Crust Pizza

Slice of Sicilian Cheese

NY Thin Crust Cheese Pizza

NY Thin Crust Cheese Slice

One Dozen Garlic Knots

Bottled Mexican coke

Slice of Sicilian Pepperoni

NY Thin Crust Pizzas

NY Thin Crust Cheese Slice

NY Thin Crust Topping Slice

NY Thin Crust Cheese Pizza

1-Topping NY Thin Crust Pizza

2-Toppings NY Thin Crust Pizza

3-Toppings NY Thin Crust Pizza

4-Toppings NY Thin Crust Pizza

Sicilian Deep Dish Crust Pizza

Slice of Sicilian Cheese

Slice of Sicilian Pepperoni

17" Sicilian Cheese Pizza

17" Sicilian 1-Topping Pizza

17" Sicilian 2-Toppings Pizza

17" Sicilian 3-Toppings Pizza

17" Sicilian 4-Toppings Pizza

Cold Salads

Italian Green Salad

Antipasto Salad

Salad Trays

Green Salad Tray

Antipasto Salad Tray

Gourmet Pizza

Spinach, Garlic & Ricotta Pizza

Fresh Tomato, Garlic & Basil Pizza

BBQ Chicken, Red Onion & Cilantro Pizza

Hot Pasta Dishes

Cheese Manicotti

Meat Lasagna

Calzones, Stromboli & Pinwheels

Cheese Calzone

Stromboli

Pinwheels

New York Subs

Meatball Parmesan Sub

Chicken Parmesan Sub

Sides

6" Garlic Bread

2 Garlic Knots

One Dozen Garlic Knots

Italian Meatballs Side of 2

Homemade Italian Dressing

Homemade Ranch Dressing

Side Homemade Ranch Side

Side Homemade Italian Dressing

Dough

Marinara

Side of Marinara

Desserts

Tiramisu Cup

Limoncello Mascarpone Cup

New York Cheesecake

Black & White Cookie

Raspberry Linzer Tart Cookie

Macaroon Cookie

Cakebites

TORRES Potato chips

Beverages

Fountain Soda

Canned Soda

Bottled Mexican coke

Yoo-Hoo

Panna Water

San Pellegrino Water

Snapple

Stewart's Soda

Illy Cold Brew Coffee

Blood Orange Soda