Pizza Supreme, Inc. Menu

4.5

(200+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites BBQ Smoked Meats Handcrafted Pizzas Handcrafted Pizzas ( Gluten-Free)"Create" a Handcrafted Pizza Mega Meat Sandwiches Appetizers (Starters)Sauces and Salsa (locally made and crafted)Salads Soups & Chili (house made award winning recipes)Breakfast Pizzas Personal Pizzas Desserts Beverages

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Cheese Pizza (14" Large)
  Build your own Personal Pizza and choose from any of our many ingredients.
  $20.99
- Cheese Pizza (16" Family Size)
  Build your own Personal Pizza and choose from any of our many ingredients.
  $22.99
- Avalanche (Mashed Potato)
  Our famous mashed potato pizza! Garlic butter, mashed potatoes, crispy bacon, chives, and cheddar cheese.
  $23.99
- Cheese Pizza (12" Medium)
  Build your own Personal Pizza and choose from any of our many ingredients.
  $19.99
- Cheesy Garlic Bread
  Five pieces. Great on the grill or in your oven!
  $9.55
- Cheese
  Build your own Personal Pizza and choose from any of our many ingredients.
  $8.55
- Pizza Fries
  Garlic sauce with our three cheese blend piled high comes with marinara sauce. Great for dippin’!
  $18.99
- Supreme Breaded Wings
  Supreme breaded chicken wings. Choose: take n' bake or baked & boxed. Sizes: 8 or 16 pieces. Sauce options include teriyaki, garlic parmesan, mango-habanero, siracha, sweet red chili, BBQ, buffalo.
  $14.55
- Supreme
  Red sauce, pepperoni, Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, onion medley, green peppers, mushrooms, green olives, and black olives.
  $24.99
- Grizzly Bear (5 Meat)
  Red sauce, Canadian bacon, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, and crispy bacon.
  $25.99
BBQ Smoked Meats
10 hour slowly cooked smoked meats, hint of smoke flavor with special seasonings, and featuring Mr. B's legendary BBQ sauce
- 1 Pound-BBQ Smoked Rib Tips
  Bone-in, 10 hours slowly cooked, lightly seasoned, hint of smoke flavor, drenched in BBQ sauce!
  $21.99
- 1 Pound-BBQ Smoked Pulled Pork
  10 hours slowly cooked, lightly seasoned, hint of smoke flavor, drenched in BBQ sauce!
  $17.99
- 1 Pound-BBQ Smoked Pulled Beef
  10 hours slowly cooked, lightly seasoned, hint of smoke flavor, drenched in BBQ sauce!
  $26.99
- 1 Pound-BBQ Smoked Pulled Chicken
  10 hours slowly cooked, lightly seasoned, hint of smoke flavor, drenched in BBQ sauce!
  $20.99
- BBQ Smoked Pulled Pork Sandwich Meal
  Slow cooked, lightly seasoned, hint of smoke flavor, covered in BBQ sauce! Served on a Hogie Bun with Coleslaw, and Pickels.
  $13.99
- BBQ Smoked Pulled Beef Sandwich Meal
  Slow cooked, lightly seasoned, hint of smoke flavor, covered in BBQ sauce! Served on a Hogie Bun with Coleslaw, and Pickels.
  $15.99
- BBQ Smoked Pulled Chicken Sandwich Meal
  Slow cooked, lightly seasoned, hint of smoke flavor, covered in BBQ sauce! Served on a Hogie Bun with Coleslaw, and Pickels.
  $14.99
Handcrafted Pizzas
All of our gourmet pizzas start with your choice of hand-tossed, or crispy flatbread, mozzarella cheese with sauce and toppings per item description!
- Acropolis (Mediteranian)
  Olive oil and spice blend, garlic chicken, Roma tomatoes, kalamata olives, minced garlic, red onions, and Feta cheese.
  $23.99
- Avalanche (Mashed Potato)
  Our famous mashed potato pizza! Garlic butter, mashed potatoes, crispy bacon, chives, and cheddar cheese.
  $23.99
- Barn Burner
  For those who dare. Buffalo sauce, jalapeño bacon, buffalo chicken, banana pepper rings, jalapeño peppers and Topped with pepper jack cheese.
  $23.99
- Brotherly Love (Philly Steak)
  Alfredo sauce, seasoned steak, green peppers and onion medley, topped with pepper jack cheese.
  $23.99
- Cheese Burger (Up Nort')
  Red sauce, ground beef, yellow onions, crispy bacon, sliced dill pickles and cheddar cheese.
  $23.99
- Denali or Yellowstone
  Creamy white garlic sauce, garlic chicken, red onions, rosemary sprig, minced garlic, and Gorgonzola cheese.
  $23.99
- Everglades
  Creamy white garlic sauce, artichoke hearts, minced garlic, spinach, and Asiago cheese.
  $23.99
- Forest Fire
  Red sauce, buffalo chicken, jalapeño, bacon, and italian sausage.
  $23.99
- Garden
  Red sauce, black olives, mushrooms, onion medley, green peppers, and Roma tomatoes.
  $23.99
- Grand Teton
  Creamy white garlic sauce, garlic chicken, red onions, fresh spinach, minced garlic, Roma tomatoes, rosemary sprig, and Asiago cheese.
  $23.99
- Great Smoky Mountain
  Creamy white garlic sauce, crispy bacon, fresh spinach, and Roma tomatoes.
  $23.99
- Grizzly Bear (5 Meat)
  Red sauce, Canadian bacon, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, and crispy bacon.
  $25.99
- Isle Royale
  Creamy white garlic sauce, artichoke hearts, black olives, mushrooms, green peppers, onion medley, and Roma tomatoes.
  $23.99
- Jackpine Savage
  Alfredo sauce, garlic chicken, jalapeño bacon, roasted onions or roasted peppers with pepper jack cheese.
  $23.99
- Kodiak (5 Meat Plus Veggies)
  Red sauce, pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, ground beef, crispy bacon, mushrooms, onion medley, and jalapeno peppers!
  $26.99
- Lumberjack (BBQ Chicken)
  Bbq sauce, bbq chicken, red onions, banana pepper rings, crispy bacon, Roma tomatoes, and pineapple.
  $23.99
- Margarita
  Red sauce (light) olive oil, fresh mozzarella, basil, Roma tomatoes, Parmesan, and olive oil drizzle.
  $23.99
- Meatball
  Red sauce, italian meatballs.
  $23.99
- Mighty Oak
  Red sauce, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onion medley, and green peppers.
  $23.99
- Mt. Olympus (Gyro)
  Our gyro pizza! Tzatziki (creamy cucumber sauce), gyro meat, onion medley, Roma tomatoes, and kalamata olives, topped with both feta and asiago cheese.
  $23.99
- Oktoberfest
  Red sauce, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, crispy bacon, sauerkraut, and yellow onions.
  $23.99
- Polar Bear
  Creamy white garlic sauce, pepperoni, andouille sausage, jalapeño bacon, and hot banana pepper rings.
  $23.99
- Pulled Pork
  Bbq sauce, pulled pork, red onions, yellow onions, and mozzarella cheese.
  $23.99
- Spartan
  Olive oil spice blend sauce, spinach, pepperoni, artichoke hearts, crispy bacon, topped with Asiago cheese.
  $23.99
- Sunset
  Red sauce, crispy bacon, Italian sausage, onion medley, green peppers, Roma tomatoes, and cheddar cheese.
  $23.99
- Supreme
  Red sauce, pepperoni, Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, onion medley, green peppers, mushrooms, green olives, and black olives.
  $24.99
- Swiss Alps
  Alfredo sauce, mash potatoes, garlic chicken, onion medley, crispy bacon, and cheddar cheese.
  $23.99
- Taco Pizza (Feisty Burro)
  Taco sauce, taco beef, yellow onions, black olives, Roma tomatoes, and cheddar cheese.
  $23.99
- Toxic Waste (Dill Pickle)
  White sauce, dill pickles, banana peppers.
  $23.99
- Voyageurs
  Creamy white garlic sauce, artichoke hearts, minced garlic, fresh spinach, onion medley, kalamata olives, Roma tomatoes, with feta cheese.
  $23.99
- Wild Buffalo (Spicy Chicken)
  Spicy buffalo sauce, buffalo chicken, gorgonzola cheese, and celery.
  $23.99
- Yosemite
  Creamy white garlic sauce, artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, onion medley, and kalamata olives.
  $23.99
- Pizza Fries
  Garlic sauce with our three cheese blend piled high comes with marinara sauce. Great for dippin’!
  $18.99
Handcrafted Pizzas ( Gluten-Free)
All of our gourmet pizzas (Gluten - free) start with your choice of hand-tossed, or crispy flatbread, mozzarella cheese with sauce and toppings per item description!
- Acropolis (Mediterranean) ( Gluten-Free)
  Olive oil and spice blend, garlic chicken, Roma tomatoes, kalamata olives, minced garlic, red onions, and Feta cheese.
  $23.99
- Avalanche (Mashed Potato) ( Gluten-Free)
  Our famous mashed potato pizza! Garlic butter, mashed potatoes, crispy bacon, chives, and cheddar cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Barn Burner ( Gluten-Free)
  For those who dare. Buffalo sauce, jalapeño bacon, buffalo chicken, banana pepper rings, jalapeño peppers and Topped with pepper jack cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Brotherly Love (Philly Steak) ( Gluten-Free)
  Alfredo sauce, seasoned steak, green peppers and onion medley, topped with pepper jack cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Cheese Burger (Up Nort') ( Gluten-Free)
  Red sauce, ground beef, yellow onions, crispy bacon, sliced dill pickles and cheddar cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Denali or Yellowstone ( Gluten-Free)
  Creamy white garlic sauce, garlic chicken, red onions, rosemary sprig, minced garlic, and Gorgonzola cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Everglades ( Gluten-Free)
  Creamy white garlic sauce, artichoke hearts, minced garlic, spinach, and Asiago cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Forest Fire ( Gluten-Free)
  Red sauce, buffalo chicken, jalapeño, bacon, and italian sausage. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Garden ( Gluten-Free)
  Red sauce, black olives, mushrooms, onion medley, green peppers, and Roma tomatoes. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Grand Teton ( Gluten-Free)
  Creamy white garlic sauce, garlic chicken, red onions, fresh spinach, minced garlic, Roma tomatoes, rosemary sprig, and Asiago cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Great Smoky Mountain ( Gluten-Free)
  Creamy white garlic sauce, crispy bacon, fresh spinach, and Roma tomatoes. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Grizzly Bear (5 Meat) ( Gluten-Free)
  Red sauce, Canadian bacon, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, and crispy bacon. ( Gluten-Free)
  $25.99
- Isle Royale ( Gluten-Free)
  Creamy white garlic sauce, artichoke hearts, black olives, mushrooms, green peppers, onion medley, and Roma tomatoes. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Jackpine Savage ( Gluten-Free)
  Alfredo sauce, garlic chicken, jalapeño bacon, roasted onions or roasted peppers with pepper jack cheese.
  $23.99
- Kodiak (5 Meat Plus Veggies) ( Gluten-Free)
  Red sauce, pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, ground beef, crispy bacon, mushrooms, onion medley, and jalapeno peppers! ( Gluten-Free)
  $26.99
- Lumberjack (BBQ Chicken) ( Gluten-Free)
  Bbq sauce, bbq chicken, red onions, banana pepper rings, crispy bacon, Roma tomatoes, and pineapple. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Margarita ( Gluten-Free)
  Red sauce (light) olive oil, mozzarella, basil, Roma tomatoes, Parmesan, and olive oil drizzle. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Meatball ( Gluten-Free)
  Red sauce, Italian meatballs. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Mighty Oak ( Gluten-Free)
  Red sauce, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onion medley, and green peppers. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Mt. Olympus (Gyro) ( Gluten-Free)
  Our gyro pizza! Tzatziki (creamy cucumber sauce), gyro meat, onion medley, Roma tomatoes, and kalamata olives, topped with both feta and asiago cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Oktoberfest ( Gluten-Free)
  Red sauce, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, crispy bacon, sauerkraut, and yellow onions. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Polar Bear ( Gluten-Free)
  Creamy white garlic sauce, pepperoni, andouille sausage, jalapeño bacon, and hot banana pepper rings. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Pulled Pork ( Gluten-Free)
  Bbq sauce, pulled pork, red onions, yellow onions, and mozzarella cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Spartan ( Gluten-Free)
  Olive oil spice blend sauce, spinach, pepperoni, artichoke hearts, crispy bacon, topped with Asiago cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Sunset ( Gluten-Free)
  Red sauce, crispy bacon, Italian sausage, onion medley, green peppers, Roma tomatoes, and cheddar cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Supreme ( Gluten-Free)
  Red sauce, pepperoni, Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, onion medley, green peppers, mushrooms, green olives, and black olives. ( Gluten-Free)
  $24.99
- Swiss Alps ( Gluten-Free)
  Alfredo sauce, mash potatoes, garlic chicken, onion medley, crispy bacon, and cheddar cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Taco Pizza (Feisty Burro) ( Gluten-Free)
  Taco sauce, taco beef, yellow onions, black olives, Roma tomatoes, and cheddar cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Toxic Waste (Dill Pickle) ( Gluten-Free)
  White sauce, dill pickles, banana peppers. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Voyageurs ( Gluten-Free)
  Creamy white garlic sauce, artichoke hearts, minced garlic, fresh spinach, onion medley, kalamata olives, Roma tomatoes, with feta cheese. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Wild Buffalo (Spicy Chicken) ( Gluten-Free)
  Spicy buffalo sauce, buffalo chicken, gorgonzola cheese, and celery. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Yosemite ( Gluten-Free)
  Creamy white garlic sauce, artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, onion medley, and kalamata olives. ( Gluten-Free)
  $23.99
- Pizza Fries ( Gluten-Free)
  Garlic sauce with our three cheese blend piled high comes with marinara sauce. Great for dippin’! ( Gluten-Free)
  $18.99
"Create" a Handcrafted Pizza
All of our pizzas, be it our creation or yours, will be handcrafted with our own fresh, hand-tossed or crispy flat bread crust, any of our 9 sauces and with our mozzarella cheese. Add toppings as you like! Feel free to do 1/2 sauces & 1/2 toppings…equal substitutions are ok too.
- Cheese Pizza (12" Medium)
  Build your own Personal Pizza and choose from any of our many ingredients.
  $19.99
- Cheese Pizza (14" Large)
  Build your own Personal Pizza and choose from any of our many ingredients.
  $20.99
- Cheese Pizza (16" Family Size)
  Build your own Personal Pizza and choose from any of our many ingredients.
  $22.99
- Cheese Pizza (10" Gluten-Free)
  Build your own Personal Pizza and choose from any of our many ingredients.
  $19.99
- Cheese Pizza (12" Gluten Free)
  Cheese Pizza (12" gluten-free) Customized with choice of baking style. Select from a variety of sauces like traditional red, vegan marinara, Alfredo, BBQ, and more. Available for non-celiac and celiac needs.
  $23.99
- Cheese Pizza (14" Gluten Free)
  14" gluten-free crust. Choose baking option, sauce selection from 10 varieties including traditional pizza sauce, vegan marinara, BBQ, Alfredo. Options for celiac safety.
  $26.99
Mega Meat Sandwiches
All of our sandwiches come on a 7” toasted ciabatta multigrain roll! We call them Grinders!
- BLT Sandwich
  Crispy bacon, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese.
  $9.55
- Brotherly Love Sandwich
  Alfredo sauce, seasoned steak, onion medley, green peppers, and pepper jack cheese.
  $10.55
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich
  Grilled chicken, crispy bacon, mayo, onion medley, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, Roma tomatoes, and creamy ranch dressing.
  $10.55
- Grand Teton Sandwich
  White garlic sauce, grilled chicken, red onions, Roma tomatoes, spinach, and asiago cheese.
  $10.55
- Grizzly Bear Sandwich
  Canadian bacon, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, crispy bacon, mayo, and mozzarella cheese.
  $12.55
- Gyro Sandwich
  Gyro meat, tzatziki sauce, lettuce, onion medley and Roma tomatoes on a 7” pita bread.
  $8.55
- Gyros (2) Sandwichs
  Gyro meat, tzatziki sauce, lettuce, onion medley and Roma tomatoes on a 7” pita bread.
  $16.55
- Jackpine Savage Sandwich
  Alfredo sauce, grilled chicken, jalapeno bacon, roasted peppers and onions with pepper jack cheese.
  $10.55
- Meatball Sandwich
  Red Sauce, 3 Italian meatballs cut in 1/2, smothered with mozzarella cheese.
  $10.55
- Pizza Sandwich
  Pizza sauce, pepperoni, and sausage smothered with mozzarella cheese.
  $10.55
- Pulled Pork Sandwich
  Pulled pork, BBQ sauce with our mozzarella cheese.
  $10.55
- Reuben Sandwich
  Piled high Corn Beef, Sauerkraut, Whole Milk Mazzarella and 1000 Island Dressing. Add your choice of Dill Pickels, Banana Peppers or Jalapeno Peppers @ n/c
  $10.55
- Supreme Club Sandwich
  Roasted turkey, pepperoni, crispy bacon, mayo, lettuce, onion medley, Roma tomatoes and mozzarella cheese.
  $10.55
- Toasted buttery PB&J Sandwich
  Peanut butter and jelly on a toasted bun.
  $7.25
- Turkey Club Sandwich
  Roasted turkey, mayo, onion medley, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, and Roma tomatoes.
  $10.55
- Voyagers Sandwich
  White garlic sauce, onion medley, artichoke hearts, kalamata olives, spinach, Roma tomatoes and feta cheese.
  $10.55
- Build Your Own Sandwich
  Choose toppings from any of our huge ingredients list.
  $8.55
Appetizers (Starters)
- Cheesy Garlic Bread
  Five pieces. Great on the grill or in your oven!
  $9.55
- Pizza Garlic Bread
  Same great garlic bread with our Mozzarella cheese, traditional pizza sauce, and your choice of any one of our proteins!
  $11.55
- Supreme Breaded Wings
  Supreme breaded chicken wings. Choose: take n' bake or baked & boxed. Sizes: 8 or 16 pieces. Sauce options include teriyaki, garlic parmesan, mango-habanero, siracha, sweet red chili, BBQ, buffalo.
  $14.55
- Supreme Meatballs (6)
  Italian meatballs with sauce, and mozzarella cheese!
  $14.55
- Wing Nuggets (8)
  CHICKEN BREAST NUGGET, TEMPURA BATTERED
  $4.55
Sauces and Salsa (locally made and crafted)
So tasty you can eat it right out of the jar!
- Salsa Salsa Salsa
  Don't run out of JoMomma's salsa! This is not your average condiment, it's a sensory experience - a vibrant medley of textures and tastes that takes your taste buds on a crazy carpet ride.
  $6.95
- BBQ Sauce
  This Ain’t Just Another Sauce!
  $6.95
- Spaghetti Sauce
  Serving size is listed as 4 but realistically it tastes so good it typically serves 2. Awesome taste you can eat it right out of the jar! O yes, keep the jar on us and thank you for being a customer!
  $6.95
Salads
Built with iceberg lettuce and spinach. Choose toppings from any of our huge ingredients lists!
- Build Your Own Salad (Small) (24 Oz.)
  Choose toppings from any of our huge pizza ingredients list. Pick your first 3 veggies from our veggie ingredients list at n/c.
  $7.55
- Build Your Own Salad (Large) (48 Oz.)
  Choose toppings from any of our huge pizza ingredients list. Pick your first 3 veggies from our veggie ingredients list at n/c.
  $10.55
Soups & Chili (house made award winning recipes)
12 ounces bowl., award winning, supreme soup and chili
- Chicken Chili
  Chicken chili with options for 'take n bake' or 'heated ready to enjoy'.
  $6.55
- Chili 5 Alarm
  Spicy chili with a variety of beans. Options for take n bake or heated, ready to enjoy.
  $6.55
- Chili-Mild
  Mild chili with option for 'take n bake' or served hot and ready.
  $6.55
- Navy Bean Soup
  Navy bean soup with options for take n bake or heated, ready to enjoy.
  $6.55
- Chicken Noodle Mash
  Chicken noodle soup with options for take n bake or heated ready to enjoy.
  $6.55
- T's Wild Turkey Chili
  Turkey chili with a choice of "take n bake" or "heated ready to enjoy."
  $6.55
Breakfast Pizzas
- Pizzomelette
  Cheese sauce, eggs, onion medley and includes one choice of crispy bacon, Canadian bacon, sausage, diced spam or spinach.
  $23.99
- Pizzomelette Supreme
  Cheese sauce, eggs, onion medley, mushrooms, crispy bacon, sausage, and diced spam.
  $24.99
Personal Pizzas
Yes, we can cook them just for you! Dine-in, take out or take-n-bake for your convenience.
- Cheese
  Build your own Personal Pizza and choose from any of our many ingredients.
  $8.55
- Personal Specialty Pizza
  Choose your baking and crust preferences for a 7" pizza. Options range from traditional flavors like Supreme and Margarita to unique tastes such as Yosemite, Polar Bear, and Isle Royale.
  $11.55
- 3 Topping Special
  Choose your pizza with two baking options, hand-tossed or flatbread crust, and a wide variety of sauce choices including traditional, vegan, alfredo, and more. Select any three toppings from meats, vegetables, cheeses, and seasonings.
  $9.55
- Personal Dessert Pizza
  Apple or cheery topping with icing to drizzle.
  $8.55
Desserts
Chocolate chip cookie dough. Ready to bake when you want’ em!
- Dessert Pizza (12 " med)
  With icing.
  $18.55
- Giant Cookie (12 Inch)
  Chocolate chip... Enough to satisfy any sweet tooth.
  $12.55
- Fresh Cookie Dough (14 Oz.)
  Chocolate chip... ready to bake when you want'em.
  $10.55
Beverages
We proudly serve coke products-many varieties.
- 20oz Bottle
  We proudly serve coke products-many varieties.
  $2.50
- 2 Liter
  We proudly serve coke products-many varieties.
  $3.95
- Minute Maid
  100% Pure squeezed pasteurized orange juice. A delicious orange juice with a taste that’s the next best thing to fresh squeezed.
  $2.55
- Bottled Water
  Pure, refreshing bottled water to quench your thirst.
  $2.55