Pelly's Fish Market & Cafe Menu

4.6
(825+ Reviews)
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Fish and Chips

      English Style Fish & Chips (Cod). Served with French Fries .
      $19.40
    • Combo Platter

      Fish, Shrimp & Crab Cake. Served with French Fries
      $25.29
    • White Clam Chowder

      Boston 'White' or Manhattan 'Red'. Serving choices: cup, bowl, quart, bread bowl.
      $6.89
    • Atlantic Salmon Plates

      Atlantic Salmon with choice of Cajun, lemon butter, dill, house marinade, or teriyaki glaze. Options: medium, well, rare, seared, Pelly's style. Sides: salad, fries, rice, slaw.
      $25.29
    • Hula Halibut Plates

      $29.89
    • Sashimi Plate Appetizer

      Piece of fish.
      $28.74
    • One Fish Taco Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $12.64
    • Fish Burrito

      Grilled Mahi, Salsa Fresca, Yogurt Sauce, Fresh Made Guacamole, Sour Cream, Green Cabbage and Cheese
      $21.84
    • Two Fish Tacos Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $19.54
    • Two Shrimp Taco Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $19.54
    • Local Halibut Plates

      Local halibut, your choice of Cajun, lemon flavors, house marinade, or teriyaki glaze. Prepared your way, accompanied by salad, fries, Spanish rice, or cole slaw.
      $25.29
    • Shrimp Burrito

      Grilled Shrimp, Salsa Fresca, Yogurt Sauce, Fresh Made Guacamole, Sour Cream, Green Cabbage and Cheese
      $22.99
  • Fresh From The Fryer

    • Combo Platter

      Fish, Shrimp & Crab Cake. Served with French Fries
      $25.29
    • Jumbo Coconut Shrimp Platter

      Served with French Fries
      $25.29
    • Fish and Chips

      English Style Fish & Chips (Cod). Served with French Fries .
      $19.40
    • Shrimp & Chips

      Served with French Fries
      $19.54
  • Grilled Seafood Tacos

    Your choice of: soft corn or flour tortillas, topped with fresh made salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage. Served with your choice of two: Spanish Rice, Mexican Cabbage Slaw, Black Beans & Tortilla Chips.
    • Two Shrimp Taco Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $19.54
    • Two Fish Tacos Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $19.54
    • One Fish Taco Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $12.64
    • Two Calamari Taco Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $17.24
    • One Langostino Taco Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $17.24
    • One Shrimp Taco Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $13.79
    • One Calamari Taco Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $11.49
    • Combo One Fish & One Shrimp Tacos Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $19.40
    • Two Langostino Taco Plate

      Fresh made Salsa, yogurt sauce and shredded green cabbage
      $22.99
  • Seafood Burritos

    • Fish Burrito

      Grilled Mahi, Salsa Fresca, Yogurt Sauce, Fresh Made Guacamole, Sour Cream, Green Cabbage and Cheese
      $21.84
    • Shrimp Burrito

      Grilled Shrimp, Salsa Fresca, Yogurt Sauce, Fresh Made Guacamole, Sour Cream, Green Cabbage and Cheese
      $22.99
  • Seafood Cocktails & Appetizers

    Pelly's cocktail sauce, and lemon & saltiness.
    • Sashimi Plate Appetizer

      Piece of fish.
      $28.74
    • Crab Cakes Appetizer (2)

      Two crab cakes, typically consisting of minced crab meat and a blend of seasonings, lightly breaded and pan-fried. Often served with a side of tangy remoulade sauce.
      $21.84
    • Medium Shrimp Appetizer

      $21.84
    • Calamari Strips Appetizer

      Fried or grilled.
      $19.54
    • Jumbo Coconut Shrimp Appetizer (5 Pieces)

      Fried shrimp that has been rolled in coconut.
      $22.99
    • Steamed Shellfish Appetizer

      A medley of shellfish steamed and served with a blend of pico de gallo, avocado, and a hint of lime, typically accompanied by a savory broth.
      $21.84
    • Bay Shrimp & Crab Appetizer

      Bay shrimp and crab mixed with pico de gallo, avocado, and cilantro, typically served in a tangy tomato-based sauce.
      $20.69
    • Shrimp Scampi Appetizer

      Jumbo shrimp sautéed with garlic and olive oil, typically includes a hint of white wine and fresh herbs.
      $22.99
    • Bay Shrimp Appetizer

      Bay shrimp mixed with a special cocktail sauce, typically includes pico de gallo and avocado. Garnished with cilantro.
      $17.24
    • Smoked Fish Plate Appetizer

      Grilled fish fillet served with seasoned rice, fresh garden salad, tomato slices, and a lemon wedge.
      $20.69
    • Crab Appetizer

      Crab meat served with a mix of cucumber, pico de gallo, cilantro, onions, and avocado in a light cocktail sauce.
      $21.84
    • Ceviche Appetizer (8 Oz)

      Raw fish that has been marinated in citrus juice.
      $16.09
    • Medium Shrimp & Stone Crab Appetizer

      Medium shrimp and stone crab served with a blend of pico de gallo, avocado, and a special Mexican cocktail sauce.
      $21.84
  • Fresh Spring Mix Salads

    Served on a bed of fresh chopped romaine lettuce and spring mix, tomato wedges & lemon. Choice of house dressings: bleu cheese, 1000 island, italian, ranch, or balsamic vinegar.
    • Grilled Salmon Salad

      With mixed greens, and cranberry vinaigrette.
      $24.14
    • Smoked Fish Salad

      Choice of salmon or albacore.
      $22.99
    • Bay Shrimp Salad

      Shellfish salad.
      $20.69
    • Medium Shrimp & Crab Salad

      Shellfish salad.
      $20.99
    • Crab Salad

      Fresh spring mix, lump crab meat, choice of ranch, balsamic, bleu cheese, Italian, 1000 island, cranberry vinaigrette, or undressed.
      $24.14
    • Garden Salad

      Green salad with mixed vegetables.
      $9.19
    • Medium Shrimp Salad

      Shellfish salad.
      $19.99
    • Fresh Pacific Albacore Salad

      Salad with white tuna.
      $16.74
    • Pelly's Special Salad

      Bay shrimp, stone crab and smoked fish.
      $22.99
    • Baby Shrimp & Crab Salad

      Fresh spring mix topped with baby shrimp and crab. Choose from Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Balsamic Vinegar, 1000 Island, Italian, or Cranberry Vinaigrette dressing, or opt for no dressing.
      $21.84
  • Char-Grilled Seafood Plates

    Served with garden salad and Spanish rice. Seasoning choices: teriyaki, lemon butter, lemon dill, cajun, or our house marinade.
    • Atlantic Salmon Plates

      Atlantic Salmon with choice of Cajun, lemon butter, dill, house marinade, or teriyaki glaze. Options: medium, well, rare, seared, Pelly's style. Sides: salad, fries, rice, slaw.
      $25.29
    • Local Halibut Plates

      Local halibut, your choice of Cajun, lemon flavors, house marinade, or teriyaki glaze. Prepared your way, accompanied by salad, fries, Spanish rice, or cole slaw.
      $25.29
    • Northern Halibut Plates

      Northern Halibut Plates: Fried fish in choice of Cajun rub, lemon butter, lemon dill, house marinade, or teriyaki glaze. Options: cooked to preference, served with salad, fries, Spanish rice, or coleslaw.
      $28.74
    • Pacific Red Snapper Plates

      Pacific red snapper with choice of cajun, lemon butter/dill, house marinade, teriyaki glaze. Prepared to preference including 'Pelly's way'. Served with salad (six dressings), fries, Spanish rice, or cole slaw.
      $22.99
    • Mahi-Mahi Plates

      Mahi-mahi with choice of cajun, lemon butter, dill, house marinade, or teriyaki glaze. Prepared to preference. Served with salad, fries, rice, or slaw.
      $24.14
    • Crab Cake Plates

      Crab cake plates: Succulent crab seasoned with five options including Cajun and teriyaki. Choose your cooking style and pair with a side like Spanish rice or fries.
      $26.44
    • Ahi Plates

      Ahi tuna, choice of Cajun, lemon butter/dill, house marinade, or teriyaki. Prepared medium to rare, Pelly's style. Served with salad, fries, rice, or slaw.
      $28.74
    • Calamari Steak Plates

      Calamari steak with seasoning options including Cajun, lemon butter, dill, house marinade, teriyaki. Cooked to preference. Served with salad, fries, Spanish rice, or coleslaw.
      $21.84
    • Fresh Pacific Albacore Plates

      Albacore: Seasoned with your choice of Cajun, lemon butter, dill, house marinade, or teriyaki. Prepared to preference. Paired with balsamic, ranch, Italian, 1000 island, bleu cheese, or cranberry vinaigrette salad. Choice of salad, fries, Spanish rice, or cole slaw as a side.
      $21.84
    • Sea Bass Plates

      Sea bass with options for Cajun, lemon, teriyaki, or house marinade. Cooked to preference from rare to medium well, Pelly's way available. Accompanied by choice of salad, fries, rice, or slaw; varied dressings.
      $24.14
    • Grilled Shrimp Plates

      $25.29
    • Hula Halibut Plates

      $29.89
    • Jumbo Sea Scallops Plates

      Jumbo sea scallops, choice of Cajun, lemon butter/dill, house marinade, teriyaki. Preparation varies. Sides: salad, fries, rice, or slaw.
      $37.94
    • Swordfish Plates

      Swordfish, choice of Cajun, lemon butter/dill, house marinade, or teriyaki. Prepared medium to rare, Pelly's way optional. Served with salad, fries, Spanish rice, or coleslaw.
      $25.29
    • Fresh Yellowtail Plates

      Yellowtail options: medium to Pelly's way. Seasoning: cajun, lemon butter, more. Sides: salad, fries, rice, slaw. Dressing: Italian to cranberry vinaigrette.
      $22.99
  • Pelly's Cioppino

    • Pelly's Cioppino

      Clams, crabmeat, scallops, squid, mussels, and shrimp in a zesty tomato base.
      $33.99
  • Pelly's Clam Chowder

    • Bowl of Pelly's Original Loco-Moco

      Our chowder topped with Spanish rice & green onions.
      $11.03
    • Cup of Pelly's Original Loco-Moco

      Our chowder topped with Spanish rice & green onions.
      $7.58
    • White Clam Chowder

      Boston 'White' or Manhattan 'Red'. Serving choices: cup, bowl, quart, bread bowl.
      $6.89
    • Red Clam Chowder

      Red clam chowder with Manhattan 'Red' or Boston 'White' option. Available in cup, bowl, quart, or bread bowl.
      $6.89
  • Pelly's Poke Bowl

    Avocado, green onions, sesame seeds & Teriyaki Glaze. Served with rice, salad, or combo.
    • Poke Rice Bowl

      Fresh tuna chunks, avocado slices, scallions, and sesame seeds over rice with a light soy-based sauce.
      $22.99
    • Pole Salad Bowl

      Fresh greens in a bowl with a choice of dressing: 1000 island, ranch, balsamic, bleu cheese, Italian, cranberry vinaigrette, or undressed.
      $22.99
    • Poke Rice and Salad Bowl

      Poke bowl with rice, salad. Choice of dressing: 1000 island, Italian, ranch, balsamic, bleu cheese, cranberry vinaigrette, or no dressing.
      $22.99
  • Char-Grilled Fresh Fish Sandwiches (Hot)

    Choose from our fresh fish with your choice of lemon butter, cajun rub, teriyaki glaze, lemon dill or our house marinade
    • Local Halibut

      Halibut fish sandwich with choice of Cajun rub, lemon butter, lemon dill, house marinade, or teriyaki glaze. Served with coleslaw or fries. Regular or toasted bun.
      $22.99
    • Swordfish

      $22.99
    • Salmon Burger

      Fresh handmade Salmon Burger comes on a bun, With Thousand Island And Tartar Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato And red onion. Serves with Seasoned Fries
      $22.99
    • Pacific Red Snapper

      Pacific red snapper char-grilled, options for Cajun rub, lemon butter, dill, house marinade, teriyaki. Sides: coleslaw or fries. Bread: regular or toasted.
      $21.84
    • Atlantic Salmon

      Atlantic Salmon on char-grilled bread, choices of Cajun, lemon butter, dill, house marinade, or teriyaki. Served with coleslaw or fries. Bread can be regular or toasted.
      $22.99
    • Fried Alaskan Halibut

      Fried Alaskan halibut, options of Cajun rub, lemon butter, lemon dill, house marinade, teriyaki glaze. Served with coleslaw or fries. Choice of regular or toasted bun.
      $22.99
    • Yellowtail

      $21.84
    • Calamari

      Char-grilled calamari sandwich, choice of Cajun, lemon butter, lemon dill, house marinade, teriyaki. Served with coleslaw or fries. Available regular or toasted.
      $20.69
    • Crab Cake

      Crab Cake Sandwich: Char-grilled, choice of Cajun, lemon butter, dill, house marinade, or teriyaki. Served with coleslaw or fries. Regular or toasted bun.
      $24.14
    • Fresh Pacific Albacore

      Pacific albacore, char-grilled, with options of Cajun rub, lemon butter, lemon dill, house marinade, or teriyaki glaze. Served on regular or toasted bread with fries.
      $20.69
    • Ahi

      Ahi fish sandwich with choice of cajun rub, lemon butter, dill, house marinade, teriyaki glaze. Served with coleslaw or fries. Regular or toasted.
      $24.14
    • Mahi Mahi

      Char-grilled mahi mahi, options of Cajun rub, lemon butter, dill, house marinade, teriyaki glaze. Served with fries, choice of regular or toasted bun.
      $21.84
  • Cold Seafood Sandwiches

    With your choice of a side of Mexican cole slaw or Spanish rice. All sandwiches on sourdough with our special sandwich spread, romaine lettuce, and sliced tomatoes. Served with a side of Mexican cabbage slaw. Toasted upon request.
    • Crab Sandwich

      $22.99
    • Bay Shrimp Sandwich

      Bay shrimp on choice of regular or toasted bread. Served with coleslaw or fries.
      $21.84
    • Bay Shrimp & Crab Sandwich

      Bay shrimp & crab blend, choice of coleslaw or fries, served regular or toasted.
      $21.84
    • Crab & Medium Shrimp Sandwich

      $22.99
    • Medium Shrimp Sandwich

      $22.99
    • Ono Salad

      Ono fish mixed with fresh veggies and creamy dressing. Comes with a side of coleslaw or fries. Available regular or toasted.
      $19.54
    • Smoked Fish

      Choice of Salmon or Albacore or Both
      $21.84
  • Beverages

    • 16.9 Oz Coke (BOTTLE)

      The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
      $3.50
    • Gatorade

      A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
      $2.99
    • 16.9 Oz S.Pellegrino Water (BOTTLE)

      S.Pellegrino water, served in a 16.9 oz bottle, offers a sparkling and mineral-rich hydration experience, sourced from the Italian Alps.
      $3.49
    • 12 Oz Kombucha (Can)

      Fermented beverage, typically includes a blend of tea and natural flavors, packaged in a 12 oz can for convenience.
      $4.59
    • PureLeaf ICE TEA

      Real brewed tea served chilled, offering a refreshing and smooth taste.
      $3.99
    • 16.9 Oz Diet Coke (BOTTLE)

      A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
      $3.50
    • Mexican Coke

      The same great taste made with only pure cane sugar and served in a bottle.
      $4.50
  • Wine

    • Pinot Noir

      Six Degrees / 750ml13.5% ALC.by VOL
      $27.99
    • Sauvignon Blanc

      Bousquet / 750ml12.5% ALC. by VOL
      $27.99
    • Cabernet Sauvignon

      Lake Sonoma / 750ml 14.5% ALC.by VOL
      $27.99
    • Chardonnay

      Columbia Valley / 750ml13.5% ALC.by VOL
      $27.99
    • Pinot Grigio

      Balletto / 750 ml13.6% ALC.by VOL
      $27.99

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Old School Shave Ice
Old School Shave Ice
3.8
(9 Reviews)
Ice cream shop, Dessert shop
Ironsmith Coffee Roasters
Ironsmith Coffee Roasters
4.6
(219 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Bakery, Cafe
Modern Times Far West Lounge
Modern Times Far West Lounge
4.6
(469 Reviews)
Brewery, Lounge, Restaurant
Raul's Shack Mexican Food
Raul's Shack Mexican Food
4.5
(255 Reviews)
Mexican
Gelato 101 Encinitas
Gelato 101 Encinitas
4.9
(760 Reviews)
Ice cream shop, Bubble tea store, Coffee shop
SAGO
SAGO
4.3
(75 Reviews)
Asian fusion, Bar, Lounge
Aloha Cowboy
Aloha Cowboy
5.0
(6 Reviews)
Bar
Herb & Sea
Herb & Sea
4.4
(541 Reviews)
Seafood, American, Pizza
Maurizio's Trattoria Italiana
Maurizio's Trattoria Italiana
4.6
(459 Reviews)
Italian, Cocktail bar, Pasta shop
The Roxy Encinitas
The Roxy Encinitas
4.4
(815 Reviews)
American, Bar, Bar & grill

(760) 431-8454

7110 Avenida Encinas #101, Carlsbad, CA 92011


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms