Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli Menu

$$$Deli

6125 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis, WI 53214

Order Online

Suggest Edit

Sandwiches Treats Drinks

Sandwiches
- Build Your Own PBJ
  Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli's freshly ground Natural or Honey Roasted peanut butter spread across your choice of our hearty, locally made breads. Top it off with your choice of one of our 95+ flavors of Jams and Jellies. Plain, toasted, or grilled. Substitute our Almond or Cashew butter.
  $6.25
- Strawberry Lovers
  A thick layer of our fresh, crunchy, honey roasted peanut butter, spread with a layer of strawberry jam and topped with fresh sliced strawberries.
  $6.95
- The King
  Elvis himself was said to have this sandwich everyday. A grilled sandwich with a layer of our all natural or honey roasted Peanut Butter combined with sliced bananas and honey. Treat yourself and try it with bacon. This one will have you all shook up!
  $5.95
- PB Banana
  All natural peanut butter with a layer of Nutella & topped with sliced bananas.
  $6.95
- Grilled Cheese & Jelly
  Your choice of American or sharp cheddar cheese and any of our craft jams or jellies, all melted between your choice of bread. We suggest our thick Texas Toast!
  $6.75
- Big Apple
  The PBJD's own honey roasted peanut butter smothered with our chunky Apple Jam, and layered with diced apples.
  $6.75
- Double Decker
  Two layers of fresh Peanut Butter, and two layers of jelly or jam between THREE layers of our traditional bread. Plain or toasted.
  $7.75
- Crunch & Punch
  PBJD's crunchy, natural, peanut butter paired with a zesty layer of raspberry jalapeño jam.
  $6.50
- Almond Delight
  PBJD's freshly ground almond butter served with a jam, jelly or fruit spread of your choice.
  $7.75
- Bagel PB
  A plain, sliced, toasted bagel topped with Peanut Butter, drizzled with honey, and sprinkled with cinnamon.
  $5.95
- Yummy Cashew
  Our freshly ground cashew butter served with a jam, jelly, or fruit spread of your choice.
  $7.75
- Peanut Butter & Yeli
  A 1/4 lb hot dog on a hoagie bun, with natural peanut butter, jalapeño jelly, jalapeño relish and bacon.
  $7.95
- You're Killing' Me Smalls
  Dark chocolate peanut butter, crushed Graham Crackers, and drizzled with mallow creme.
  $6.95
- Peanut Butter Oreo
  Dark chocolate peanut butter, crumbled Oreo® cookies, and mallow creme fused together on the grill.
  $6.95
Treats
- Chips
  $2.00
Drinks
- PBJ DELI Soda Pop
  $2.50
- Milkshakes
  Signature Milkshakes
  $4.95
- PBJ Milkshake
  Peanut Butter & Jelly Milkshake with your choice of Jam (Strawberry, Grape, or Raspberry)
  $5.50
- Coke Products
  Your Choice Coke, Diet Coke, or Sprite
  $2.25
- Peanut Butter Cup Milkshake
  Milkshake with Peanut Butter & Chocolate! It's Delicious!!
  $5.50
- Milk
  Bottled.
  $2.50