Paulie's Pub & Eatery Menu

4.3

(1,600+ Reviews)

$Restaurant, Bar, Pizza

SHAREABLES
- BONE-IN WINGS
  1 lb of wings. Choice of traditional or breaded. Choice of wing sauce. Served with ranch or bleu cheese and celery
  $12.00
- BONELESS WINGS
  1/2 lb. of boneless. Choice of wing sauce. Served with ranch or bleu cheese and celery
  $12.00
- CHEESE CURDS
  Battered white Cheddar cheese with marinara sauce or ranch
  $9.50
- GARLIC BREAD
  A great side to our awesome pizza
  $6.00
- GARLIC BREAD-CHEESE
  $7.00
- GARLIC BREAD-CHEESE/PEP
  Our garlic bread with cheese and pepperoni and mararina on the side
  $8.50
- MOZZARELLA STICKS
  3 house-made wonton rolled mozzarella sticks with marinara or ranch
  $8.00
- NACHOS
  Select of chicken verde +2, pork carnitas +2, or ground beef. Tortilla chips, topped with beer cheese sauce, pico de gallo, cotija, and cilantro lime sour cream
  $13.50
- ONIONS PETALS
  Served with boom-boom sauce or ranch
  $8.50
- POTATO BASKET
  Choice of tater tots, house-made fries, or seasoned chips
  $7.00
- PRETZEL STICKS
  3 soft bavarian pretzels with beer cheese sauce
  $8.50
- TACO DIP
  Taco dip, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, black olives, shredded Monterey Jack cheese & tortilla chips
  $15.00
GRILLED CHEESE
- CHEESEHEAD GRILLED CHEESE
  American, swiss, and mozzarella on multi-grain
  $11.25
- SOME LIKE IT HOT GRILLED CHEESE
  American, ghost pepper, and fresh jalapeños on multi-grain
  $12.25
- PAULIE'S GRILLED CHEESE
  American, bacon, tomato, and avocado on sourdough
  $12.25
- ALL-AMERICAN GRILLED CHEESE
  $9.50
FROM THE GRILL
- BACON BLEU
  Bleu cheese crumbles, bacon, harvest greens, and sliced red onion
  $15.50
- BARNYARD
  Cheddar, bacon, and fried egg
  $16.75
- CLASSIC
  American cheese, harvest greens, tomato, and onion
  $15.25
- FIRECRACKER
  Boom-boom sauce, bacon, fresh jalapeños, and ghost pepper cheese
  $16.75
- MUSHROOM SWISS
  Sautéed mushrooms and swiss
  $16.75
- PAULIE'S PATTY MELT
  1/3 lb Angus beef burger, sautéed onions, American cheese on grilled marble rye
  $14.25
- SO CAL
  Brie, garlic aioli, fire-roasted tomato, avocado, and harvest greens
  $18.00
- WESTERN
  Cheddar, bacon, sweet baby Ray's BBQ, and onion petals
  $17.25
- PAULIE'S HALF CHICKEN DINNER (4-PIECE)
  HENNY PENNY 4 PIECE WITH PAULIE'S SECRET BLEND OF BREADING! SERVED WITH COLESLAW AND FRIES
  $15.00
MAC & CHEESE
- P.A.C. MAC
  Fat tire beer cheese sauce, pico de gallo, avocado, and cilantro
  $15.75
- 4 CHEESE MAC
  Fat tire beer cheese sauce, brie, Cheddar, and Monterey Jack
  $12.50
- GHOST MAC
  Fat tire beer cheese sauce, ghost pepper cheese, and fresh jalapeño
  $13.50
- BACON BLEU MAC
  Fat tire beer cheese sauce, bacon, bleu cheese, and onion petals
  $15.50
SOUP & SALAD
- SOUP OF THE DAY-CUP
  $4.00
- SOUP OF THE DAY-BOWL
  $5.00
- SIDE SALAD
  Harvest greens, tomato, cucumber, red onion, and croutons
  $4.00
- TZATZIKI CHICKEN SALAD
  Grilled chicken, romaine hearts, kalamata olives, diced red onion, grape tomatoes, sliced pepperoncini, feta tzatziki & Greek vinaigrette on the side
  $16.00
- CHILI BOWL-PLAIN
  $5.50
- CHILI BOWL-WORKS
  Bowl. Cheddar, sour cream, and onion
  $6.50
- COTTAGE CHEESE CUP
  $3.50
- COLESLAW CUP
  $3.00
SPECIALTY SANDWICHES
- PHILLY CHEESESTEAK
  Italian beef, mozzarella, sautéed mushrooms, green peppers and onions on a toasted hoagie bun, side of au jus. Add giardiniera for an additional charge
  $16.50
- THE ULTIMATE BLT
  Bacon, harvest greens, tomato, garlic aioli on lightly toasted sourdough
  $12.00
- ITALIAN BEEF DELUXE
  $16.50
- GRILLED REUBEN SANDWICH
  Slow-roasted corned beef brisket, kraut, swiss cheese and 1000 island dressing, and marble rye
  $16.00
- MEATBALL SUB
  $15.00
- BLT WRAP
  $15.00
BYO PIZZA (14")
- BYO Pizza
  Traditional crust
  $14.50
SPECIALTY PIZZA (14")
- NAKED PIE STRIPS
  Garlic butter, mozzarella-provolone cheese blend with ranch or marinara for dipping
  $17.00
- BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA
  Traditional crust. Chicken, Cheddar, mozzarella, red onion, and sweet baby Ray's BBQ
  $23.00
- BLT RANCH PIZZA
  Traditional crust. Mozzarella, bacon, lettuce, tomato and ranch sauce
  $19.00
- PAULIE'S HOUSE PIZZA
  Traditional crust. Sausage, fresh mushroom, and onion
  $20.00
- SPICY MEAT PIZZA
  Traditional crust. Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and jalapeño
  $22.00
- HAWAIIAN PIZZA
  Traditional crust. Canadian bacon, pineapple
  $20.00
DESSERTS
- BEIGNETS
  Fluffy deep-fried donuts, powdered sugar, and chocolate sauce
  $7.00
- COOKIE BATTER CHEESECAKE
  $10.00
EXTRAS
- RANCH
  $0.50
- BLEU CHEESE
  $0.50
- MARINARA
  $0.50
- MAYO
  $0.50
- 1000 ISLAND
  $0.50
- TARTAR SIDE
  $0.50
- ADD AVOCADO
  $1.00
- ADD BACON
  $2.00
- ADD CHEESE
- ADD EGG
  $1.00
- ADD JALAPENOS
  $1.00
- BOOM BOOM SAUCE
  $1.00
- CILANTRO SOUR CREAM
  $0.50
- DRUNKEN CHERRY
  $1.00
- FRENCH
  $0.50
- GIARDINERA
  $1.00
- HONEY BBQ
  $1.00
- HONEY MUSTARD
  $1.00
- HOT HONEY GARLIC
  $1.00
- ITALIAN
  $0.50
- LL BUFFALO
  $1.00
- LL GARLIC PARM
  $1.00
- LL HOT GARLIC
  $1.00
- LL RASP HABANERO
  $1.00
- LL SCARY LARRY
  $1.00
- LL SPICY BACON BBQ
  $1.00
- LL THAI CHILI
  $1.00
- PICO DE GALLO
  $0.50
- SOUR CREAM
  $0.50
- SWEET BABY RAY'S BBQ
  $1.00
BREWER TRIPS
- BREWERS OPENING DAY!!!
  IMPORTANT - Select TODAY'S DATE to order a spot on shuttle, NOT the date of the event you are going to. ENJOY OPENING DAY WITH PAULIE'S, INCLUDES TICKET IN SECTION 235! TALL BOY COOZIE! INDOOR TAILGATE BUFFET FEATURING BRATS, BURGERS DOGS, AND CHIPS AND PASTA SALAD! 2 TALL BOYS OF LITE, COORS LITE, PABST OR HIGH LIFE AND OF COURSE A SHUTTLE WRISTBAND! GAME AT 1:10 PAULIE'S OPEN AT 9:30AM. MUST BE 21 TO PURCHASE. NO ONE UNDER THE AGE OF 21 ALLOWED TO DRINK ANY ALCOHOL AND NOT ALLOWED TO BE ON PREMISE WITHOUT THEIR PARENT. IMPORTANT USE TODAY'S DATE FOR THE ORDER PLEASE!!! ALL SALES FINAL. NO REFUNDS.
  $80.00
FRIDAY FISH FRY
- BLUE GILL
  $20.00
- WALLEYE
  Lightly floured and deep-fried
  $23.00
- LAKE PERCH
  Lightly floured and deep-fried
  $26.00
- BREADED COD FISH FRY
  Three cod loins, lightly floured with our special breading fried to a light golden brown
  $16.00
- BEER BATTERED COD
  3 cod loins- beer batter
  $16.00
- BAKED COD
  3 cod loins-lightly buttered and seasoned to your liking with drawn butter or tarter sauce. Choose seasoning lemon pepper and paprika, cajun or zesty blend
  $16.00
- FISH TACOS
  3 flour tortillas-lightly breaded cod pieces, cilantro sour cream, side or tortilla chips, and pico de gallo
  $16.00
- CLAM CUP
  Perfect compliment to Paulie's fish fry
  $4.50
- CLAM BOWL
  Perfect compliment to Paulie's fish fry
  $6.00
BYO PIZZA (14") (Copy)
- BYO Pizza
  Traditional crust
  $14.50
WINGS
- BONELESS WINGS
  1/2 lb. of boneless. Choice of wing sauce. Served with ranch or bleu cheese and celery
  $12.00
- BONE-IN WINGS
  1 lb of wings. Choice of traditional or breaded. Choice of wing sauce. Served with ranch or bleu cheese and celery
  $12.00
SHAREABLES (Copy)
- BONE-IN WINGS
  1 lb of wings. Choice of traditional or breaded. Choice of wing sauce. Served with ranch or bleu cheese and celery
  $12.00
- BONELESS WINGS
  1/2 lb. of boneless. Choice of wing sauce. Served with ranch or bleu cheese and celery
  $12.00
- CHEESE CURDS
  Battered white Cheddar cheese with marinara sauce or ranch
  $9.50
- GARLIC BREAD
  A great side to our awesome pizza
  $6.00
- GARLIC BREAD-CHEESE
  $7.00
- GARLIC BREAD-CHEESE/PEP
  Our garlic bread with cheese and pepperoni and mararina on the side
  $8.50
- MOZZARELLA STICKS
  3 house-made wonton rolled mozzarella sticks with marinara or ranch
  $8.00
- NACHOS
  Select of chicken verde +2, pork carnitas +2, or ground beef. Tortilla chips, topped with beer cheese sauce, pico de gallo, cotija, and cilantro lime sour cream
  $13.50
- ONIONS PETALS
  Served with boom-boom sauce or ranch
  $8.50
- POTATO BASKET
  Choice of tater tots, house-made fries, or seasoned chips
  $7.00
- PRETZEL STICKS
  3 soft bavarian pretzels with beer cheese sauce
  $8.50
- TACO DIP
  Taco dip, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, black olives, shredded Monterey Jack cheese & tortilla chips
  $15.00
BYO PIZZA (14") (Copy)
- BYO Pizza
  Traditional crust
  $14.50
SPECIALTY PIZZA (14") (Copy)
- NAKED PIE STRIPS
  Garlic butter, mozzarella-provolone cheese blend with ranch or marinara for dipping
  $17.00
- BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA
  Traditional crust. Chicken, Cheddar, mozzarella, red onion, and sweet baby Ray's BBQ
  $23.00
- BLT RANCH PIZZA
  Traditional crust. Mozzarella, bacon, lettuce, tomato and ranch sauce
  $19.00
- PAULIE'S HOUSE PIZZA
  Traditional crust. Sausage, fresh mushroom, and onion
  $20.00
- SPICY MEAT PIZZA
  Traditional crust. Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and jalapeño
  $22.00
- HAWAIIAN PIZZA
  Traditional crust. Canadian bacon, pineapple
  $20.00
EXTRAS (Copy)
- RANCH
  $0.50
- BLEU CHEESE
  $0.50
- MARINARA
  $0.50
- MAYO
  $0.50
- 1000 ISLAND
  $0.50
- ADD AVOCADO
  $1.00
- ADD BACON
  $2.00
- ADD CHEESE
- ADD EGG
  $1.00
- ADD JALAPENOS
  $1.00
- BOOM BOOM SAUCE
  $1.00
- CILANTRO SOUR CREAM
  $0.50
- DRUNKEN CHERRY
  $1.00
- FRENCH
  $0.50
- GIARDINERA
  $1.00
- HONEY BBQ
  $1.00
- HONEY MUSTARD
  $1.00
- HOT HONEY GARLIC
  $1.00
- ITALIAN
  $0.50
- LL BUFFALO
  $1.00
- LL GARLIC PARM
  $1.00
- LL HOT GARLIC
  $1.00
- LL RASP HABANERO
  $1.00
- LL SCARY LARRY
  $1.00
- LL SPICY BACON BBQ
  $1.00
- LL THAI CHILI
  $1.00
- PICO DE GALLO
  $0.50
- SOUR CREAM
  $0.50
- SWEET BABY RAY'S BBQ
  $1.00
COUNTRY IN THE BURG TRIPS
- 08/22/25 COUNTRY IN THE BURG FRIDAY
  IMPORTANT - Select TODAY'S DATE to order a spot on shuttle, NOT the date of the event you are going to. MUST BE 21 TO RIDE. NO REFUNDS ALL SALES FINAL. $5 each spot *Transportation only* to Country in the BURG Cedarburg, WI Friday 8/22/2025. Shuttles leave Paulie's 3PM Sharp. Shuttle leaves appx 1/2 hr after end of show. Spots limited. Thank you for choosing Paulie's Pub for your concert and event needs!!
  $5.00
- 08/23/25 COUNTRY IN THE BURG SATURDAY
  IMPORTANT - Select TODAY'S DATE to order a spot on shuttle, NOT the date of the event you are going to. MUST BE 21 TO RIDE. NO REFUNDS ALL SALES FINAL. $5 each spot *Transportation only* to Country in the BURG Cedarburg, WI Saturday 8/23/2025 Shuttles leave Paulie's 3PM Sharp. Shuttle leaves appx 1/2 hr after end of show. Spots limited. Thank you for choosing Paulie's Pub for your concert and event needs!!
  $5.00
MARCH 2025 FOOD FEATURES
- REUBEN WRAP
  Corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and 1000 island dressing in a tomato basil wrap, served with fries or parmesan ranch chips
  $15.00
- COD PO BOY
  Two lightly breaded cod loins, shredded iceberg lettuce, 2 slices American cheese & remoulade sauce on a French roll, served with fries or parmesan ranch chips
  $14.50
- SWEET & SPICY CHILI LIME SHRIMP BOWL
  Six chili & lime grilled shrimp, white rice, & mango salsa
  $15.00
WEDNESDAY FISH FRY
- BLUE GILL
  $20.00
- WALLEYE
  Lightly floured and deep-fried
  $23.00
- LAKE PERCH
  Lightly floured and deep-fried
  $26.00
- BREADED COD FISH FRY
  Three cod loins, lightly floured with our special breading fried to a light golden brown
  $16.00
- BEER BATTERED COD
  3 cod loins- beer batter
  $16.00
- BAKED COD
  3 cod loins-lightly buttered and seasoned to your liking with drawn butter or tarter sauce. Choose seasoning lemon pepper and paprika, cajun or zesty blend
  $16.00
- FISH TACOS
  3 flour tortillas-lightly breaded cod pieces, cilantro sour cream, side or tortilla chips, and pico de gallo
  $16.00
- CLAM CUP
  Perfect compliment to Paulie's fish fry
  $4.50
- CLAM BOWL
  Perfect compliment to Paulie's fish fry
  $6.00