Papa Johns Pizza Menu

452A Suffolk Ave Unit A, Brentwood, NY 11717
  • Papa's Starters

    • 10" Bacon Cheddar Sticks

      Original fresh dough covered with special garlic sauce, topped with hickory-smoked bacon, real cheese made from mozzarella and cheddar
      $6.00
  • Papa's Starters

    • Bacon Cheddar Stuffed Cheesesticks

      Fresh dough folded and stuffed with cheddar, Asiago, fontina, provolone and real cheese made from mozzarella, topped with garlic sauce, hickory-smoked bacon, and buttery Parmesan Romano cheese. Baked to a cheesy gooey goodness and served with sauce for dipping. Choose a sauce: Ranch, Barbeque, Blue Cheese, Pizza Dipping Sauce, Buffalo Sauce, Honey Mustard Sauce, Cheese Sauce, Special Garlic, No Sauce
      $6.00
  • Papa's Lighter Choices Thin Crust

    • Large 14" Mediterranean Veggie Thin Crust Pizza Light

      8 slices. Fresh-sliced Roma tomatoes and onions, banana peppers, crimini mushrooms, ripe black olives and real cheese made from mozzarella, all on our signature pizza sauce and hand-tossed original crust. Vegetarian. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
      $16.99
    • Large 14" Chicken And Veggie Original Crust Pizza Light

      8 slices. Grilled all-white chicken, fresh-sliced onions, Roma tomatoes and green peppers, plus crimini mushrooms, ripe black olives and real cheese made from mozzarella, all layered on our signature pizza sauce and hand-tossed original crust. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
      $16.99
  • Papa's Lighter Choices

    • Mediterranean Veggie Original Crust Pizza Light

      Fresh-sliced Roma tomatoes and onions, banana peppers, crimini mushrooms, ripe black olives and real cheese made from mozzarella, all on our signature pizza sauce and hand-tossed original crust. Vegetarian. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
    • Chicken And Veggie Original Crust Pizza Light

      Grilled all-white chicken, fresh-sliced onions, Roma tomatoes and green peppers, plus crimini mushrooms, ripe black olives and real cheese made from mozzarella, all layered on our signature pizza sauce and hand-tossed original crust. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
  • Local Flavors Thin Crust

    • Large 14" Buffalo Chicken Thin Crust Pizza

      8 slices. Tangy ranch sauce and real cheese made from mozzarella on our hand-tossed original crust topped with breaded chicken poppers, fresh-sliced onions, bacon and a spicy Buffalo swirl. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
      $16.99
    • Large 14" Double Bacon Six Cheese Thin Crust Pizza

      8 slices. Our fresh, never frozen hand-tossed original crust is layered with signature pizza sauce, julienne-cut Canadian bacon, bacon and an authentic blend of Parmesan, Romano, Asiago, fontina, provolone and real cheese made from mozzarella. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
      $16.99
  • Local Flavors

    • Buffalo Chicken Original Crust Pizza

      Tangy ranch sauce and real cheese made from mozzarella on our hand-tossed original crust topped with breaded chicken poppers, fresh-sliced onions, bacon and a spicy Buffalo swirl. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
    • Double Bacon 6 Cheese Original Crust Pizza

      Our fresh, never frozen hand-tossed original crust is layered with signature pizza sauce, julienne-cut Canadian bacon, bacon and an authentic blend of Parmesan, Romano, Asiago, fontina, provolone and real cheese made from mozzarella. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms