Papa Johns Pizza Menu

452A Suffolk Ave Unit A, Brentwood, NY 11717
  • Papa's Starters

    • 10" Bacon Cheddar Sticks

      Original fresh dough covered with special garlic sauce, topped with hickory-smoked bacon, real cheese made from mozzarella and cheddar
      $6.00
  • Papa's Starters

    • Bacon Cheddar Stuffed Cheesesticks

      Fresh dough folded and stuffed with cheddar, Asiago, fontina, provolone and real cheese made from mozzarella, topped with garlic sauce, hickory-smoked bacon, and buttery Parmesan Romano cheese. Baked to a cheesy gooey goodness and served with sauce for dipping. Choose a sauce: Ranch, Barbeque, Blue Cheese, Pizza Dipping Sauce, Buffalo Sauce, Honey Mustard Sauce, Cheese Sauce, Special Garlic, No Sauce
      $6.00
  • Papa's Lighter Choices Thin Crust

    • Large 14" Mediterranean Veggie Thin Crust Pizza Light

      8 slices. Fresh-sliced Roma tomatoes and onions, banana peppers, crimini mushrooms, ripe black olives and real cheese made from mozzarella, all on our signature pizza sauce and hand-tossed original crust. Vegetarian. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
      $16.99
    • Large 14" Chicken And Veggie Original Crust Pizza Light

      8 slices. Grilled all-white chicken, fresh-sliced onions, Roma tomatoes and green peppers, plus crimini mushrooms, ripe black olives and real cheese made from mozzarella, all layered on our signature pizza sauce and hand-tossed original crust. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
      $16.99
  • Papa's Lighter Choices

    • Mediterranean Veggie Original Crust Pizza Light

      Fresh-sliced Roma tomatoes and onions, banana peppers, crimini mushrooms, ripe black olives and real cheese made from mozzarella, all on our signature pizza sauce and hand-tossed original crust. Vegetarian. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
    • Chicken And Veggie Original Crust Pizza Light

      Grilled all-white chicken, fresh-sliced onions, Roma tomatoes and green peppers, plus crimini mushrooms, ripe black olives and real cheese made from mozzarella, all layered on our signature pizza sauce and hand-tossed original crust. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
  • Local Flavors Thin Crust

    • Large 14" Buffalo Chicken Thin Crust Pizza

      8 slices. Tangy ranch sauce and real cheese made from mozzarella on our hand-tossed original crust topped with breaded chicken poppers, fresh-sliced onions, bacon and a spicy Buffalo swirl. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
      $16.99
    • Large 14" Double Bacon Six Cheese Thin Crust Pizza

      8 slices. Our fresh, never frozen hand-tossed original crust is layered with signature pizza sauce, julienne-cut Canadian bacon, bacon and an authentic blend of Parmesan, Romano, Asiago, fontina, provolone and real cheese made from mozzarella. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
      $16.99
  • Local Flavors

    • Buffalo Chicken Original Crust Pizza

      Tangy ranch sauce and real cheese made from mozzarella on our hand-tossed original crust topped with breaded chicken poppers, fresh-sliced onions, bacon and a spicy Buffalo swirl. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)
    • Double Bacon 6 Cheese Original Crust Pizza

      Our fresh, never frozen hand-tossed original crust is layered with signature pizza sauce, julienne-cut Canadian bacon, bacon and an authentic blend of Parmesan, Romano, Asiago, fontina, provolone and real cheese made from mozzarella. Choose a style: Normal Bake, Well Done. Choose a cut: Normal Cut, Square Cut. Choose a sauce: Original (Normal Sauce), Original (Light Sauce), Original (Extra Sauce), BBQ (Normal Sauce), BBQ (Light Sauce), BBQ (Extra Sauce), Ranch (Normal Sauce), Ranch (Light Sauce), Ranch (Extra Sauce)

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille
Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille
4.3
(729 Reviews)
Restaurant, Bar
Goody Two Shoes
Goody Two Shoes
4.5
(76 Reviews)
Restaurant
T.J. Finley's
T.J. Finley's
4.4
(380 Reviews)
Pub
Kismet Coffee Company - Bay Shore
Kismet Coffee Company - Bay Shore
4.9
(40 Reviews)
Coffee shop
Tullulah's
Tullulah's
4.4
(558 Reviews)
American, Bar, Beer garden
JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ
JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ
4.5
(690 Reviews)
Restaurant, Barbecue, Hot pot
North Fork Doughnut Co. Bay Shore
North Fork Doughnut Co. Bay Shore
4.4
(226 Reviews)
Donut shop, Restaurant
Rock City Dogs
Rock City Dogs
4.4
(411 Reviews)
Restaurant, American, Bar
Roadtrip
Roadtrip
4.7
(187 Reviews)
Restaurant
Milano Bean Cafe
Milano Bean Cafe
4.7
(208 Reviews)
Coffee shop

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms