Appetizers
- Jumbo WingsHot, Mild, BBQ, Lemon Herb
- Breaded CalamariServed with cocktail sauce and lemon
- Bread Sticksw/ Marinara Sauce
- Cheezy Bread Sticksw/ Marinara Sauce
- Chicken Tenders
- Jumbo Buffalo Chicken Tenders
- Jumbo Panzarotti
- Meatball PlateIncludes Green Peppers & Bread
- Garlic Bread
- Cheezy Garlic Bread
- Pizza Bread
- Spinach Breadtopped w/ Mozzarella
- French Fries
- Cheezy Fries
- Jalapeno PoppersCheddar, Cream Cheese or Mixed
- Mozzarella Sticks
- Breaded Mushrooms Or Cauliflower
- Cole Slaw
Sandwiches
- Papa Joe's Beefw/ Red Sauce, Green Peppers & Mozzarella
- Italian Beef
- Cheezy BeefMozzarella or Cheddar
- Italian Meatball
- Italian SausageSauce or Gravy
- ComboBeef & Sausage
- Chicken Parmigiana
Soups & Salads
- Bowl Of SoupIncludes Crackers
- Garden Salad
- Caesar Salad
Pizzas
- Thin CrustOur most popular topped with our flavorful tomato sauce, your choice of the finest quality toppings and topped with a generous amount of 100% mozzarella cheese
- Double CrustTwice as thick as our thin crust with a rolled edge
- Chicago Style Thin CrustA lighter version of our popular Chicago style pan
- PanPrepared in a pan and baked to a light and tender golden brown crust
- Chicago Style PanTopped with our specially seasoned plum tomato sauce
- StuffedA layer of crust on top of your choice of toppings and cheese topped with our specially seasoned plum tomato sauce
- Each Additional Topping
- Papa Joe's FavoriteSausage, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions
Specialty Pizzas
- VeggieSpinach, Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Green Peppers
- Meat LoversSausage, Pepperoni, Bacon, Ground Beef
- Fantastic FourSausage, Mushrooms, Pepperoni, Black Olives
- HawaiianPineapple and Canadian Bacon
- Italian StyleRoast Beef, Hot Giardiniera, Garlic
- WesternSausage, Bacon, Onions, BBQ Sauce
- Sicilian StyleTomatoes, Garlic w/ Olive Oil
- Bacon BurgerGround Beef, Bacon, Tomatoes
- PopeyeSpinach and Ricotta
- MediterraneanArtichokes, Black Olives, Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, Garlic w/ Olive Oil
- South Of The BorderGround Beef, Tomatoes, Jalapeno w/ Pizza Sauce or Olive Oil
Pastas
- Spaghetti
- Mostaccioli
- Stuffed ShellsRicotta Cheese
- Lasagna Meat
Pastas - Add Ons
- Meatballs Or Sausage
- Meat Sauce
- Baked With Mozzarella Cheese
- Extra Marinara Sauce
Dinners
- Fried Chicken
- BBQ Chicken
- Baked Chicken
- Jumbo Shrimp
- Buffalo Shrimp
- Chicken Parmigianaw/ Spaghetti
- Baby Back Ribs
- Chicken Tenders
- Side Of Spaghetti Or Mostaccioli
Kid's Corner
- Personal Cheese Pizza
- Chicken Tenders & Fries
- Pasta & Meatball
Beverages
- Coke
- Sprite
- Diet Coke
Desserts
- Cannoli
- Eli's CheesecakePlain or Strawberry$2.95
- Pastry Nuggets
Daily Specials
- Monday - Baked, Fried Or BBQ Chickenwith fries, cole slaw and garlic bread
- Tuesday - Baby Back Ribswith fries, cole slaw and garlic bread
- Wednesday - Spaghetti Or Mostaccioliwith garlic bread and grated cheese
- Thursday - Lasagnawith garlic bread
- Friday - Jumbo Shrimpwith fries, cole slaw and garlic bread
- Saturday - Stuffed Shellswith garlic bread and grated cheese
- Sunday - Chicken Parmigianawith spaghetti, garlic bread and cole slaw
Coupon Specials
- 18" Cheese Pizza, 12" Jumbo Wings, Plus 2 Liter SodaAdditional Toppings Extra
- $5 Off Any Two 18" Pizzasw/ One or more Toppings
- Free 2 Liter Soda(Coke, Sprite or Diet Coke) w/ 18" Papa Joe's Favorite Pizza
- $1 Off Any 10" 12" 14" 16" Pizza
- $2 Off Any 18" Pizzaw/ One or more Toppings
