Pagliai's Pizza & Italian Restaurant Menu

3.9

(425+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Pastas Lasagna Family Meals Garden Fresh Salads Build Your Own Specialty Pizza Wraps Sandwiches Beverages Side Dishes Kid's Menu

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- 12" Cheese & Build Your Own
  12" customizable pizza with cheese. Choice of crust: Chicago style thick crust, cauliflower, or New York style thin.
  $16.14
- 10" Cheese & Build Your Own
  10" pizza with cheese. Options include Chicago style thick crust, gluten-free, or New York style thin crust.
  $10.80
- 8" Cheese & Build Your Own
  8" pizza with customizable options. Choose from Chicago-style thick crust, crustless, or New York-style thin crust.
  $8.40
- Pagliai's Special
  Sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, and green peppers.
  $8.56
- Spaghetti with Meat Sauce (Medium)
  Tender spaghetti topped with a rich and hearty meat sauce, crafted from ground beef and tomatoes.
  $10.44
- Leroy Special
  Sausage, pepperoni, beef, ham, and mushroom.
  $8.95
- 14" Cheese & Build Your Own
  14" Cheese Pizza with options for Chicago style thick crust or New York style thin crust.
  $18.54
- Chips & Ranch Dressing
  Crispy chips paired with our house-made ranch dressing, typically served as a light accompaniment.
  $5.28
- Chicken Tenders
  Served with potato chips.
  $1.99
- Dessert Pizza
  Pagliai's special dessert topping with chocolate and crumb topping.
  $10.16
Pastas
- Spaghetti with Meat Sauce (Medium)
  Tender spaghetti topped with a rich and hearty meat sauce, crafted from ground beef and tomatoes.
  $10.44
- Baked Spaghetti with Marinara (Medium)
  Oven-baked spaghetti enveloped in a classic marinara sauce, typically includes a blend of herbs and spices.
  $9.78
- Baked Spaghetti with Meat Sauce (Medium)
  Tender spaghetti topped with hearty meat sauce, baked to perfection.
  $12.92
- Spaghetti with Marinara (Medium)
  Spaghetti served with a classic marinara sauce, often featuring tomatoes, basil, and garlic.
  $9.78
- Spaghetti with Marinara (Large)
  Spaghetti served with a classic marinara sauce made from tomatoes, garlic, and basil, often garnished with parmesan cheese.
  $11.70
- Baked Spaghetti with Marinara (Large)
  Baked spaghetti enveloped in a classic marinara sauce, typically includes a generous topping of melted cheese.
  $13.02
Lasagna
Originating from a recipe that came over from the old country.
- Medium Baked Lasagna
  Layers of ricotta and mozzarella, pasta and spices with Pagliai's famous meat sauce, served with garlic bread.
  $12.89
- Large Baked Lasagna
  Layers of ricotta and mozzarella, pasta and spices with Pagliai's famous meat sauce, served with garlic bread.
  $15.53
Family Meals
- Family Meal Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
  Serves 7-9 people, served with 20 pieces of garlic bread.
  $50.93
- Family Meal Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce
  Serves 7-9 people, served with 20 pieces of garlic bread.
  $47.70
- Family Meal Baked Lasagna
  Serves 8-12 people, served with 20 pieces of garlic bread.
  $63.55
- Family Salad
  Serves 10-12 people.
  $22.26
Garden Fresh Salads
- Small Pagliai's Chef Salad
  Chopped ham and shredded 2% fat Wisconsin mozzarella on a crisp salad mix with red cabbage, carrots and grape tomatoes.
  $8.99
- Large Pagliai's Chef Salad
  Chopped ham and shredded 2% fat Wisconsin mozzarella on a crisp salad mix with red cabbage, carrots and grape tomatoes.
  $10.69
- Dinner Salad
  Garden fresh lettuce with carrots, red cabbage and grape tomatoes.
  $6.35
- Meat Lovers Salad
  Fresh ham and chicken breast, shredded Monterey jack and Cheddar, sprinkles of real bacon on a crisp salad mix, red cabbage, carrots and grape tomatoes.
  $15.23
- Chicken Breast Bacon Salad
  Grilled chicken breast and crispy bacon served over a mix of fresh greens, typically includes tomatoes, onions, and a blend of cheeses, tossed with a house dressing.
  $15.23
- Chicken Breast Salad
  Served with a salad mix, red cabbage, carrots, sliced red onions, grape tomatoes, Monterey jack and Cheddar.
  $13.94
Build Your Own
New York style, thin crust Chicago style, thick crust new! We have gluten free 10" crust for an additional price.
- 8" Cheese & Build Your Own
  8" pizza with customizable options. Choose from Chicago-style thick crust, crustless, or New York-style thin crust.
  $8.40
- 10" Cheese & Build Your Own
  10" pizza with cheese. Options include Chicago style thick crust, gluten-free, or New York style thin crust.
  $10.80
- 12" Cheese & Build Your Own
  12" customizable pizza with cheese. Choice of crust: Chicago style thick crust, cauliflower, or New York style thin.
  $16.14
- 14" Cheese & Build Your Own
  14" Cheese Pizza with options for Chicago style thick crust or New York style thin crust.
  $18.54
- 16" Cheese & Build Your Own
  Family size.
  $24.30
Specialty Pizza
New York style, thin crust Chicago style and thick crust 16". Family size is not available in Chicago style.
- House Special
  Sausage, onion and green pepper.
  $8.35
- Hawaiian Special
  Ham, pineapple and mushroom.
  $8.35
- Pagliai's Special
  Sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, and green peppers.
  $8.56
- Leroy Special
  Sausage, pepperoni, beef, ham, and mushroom.
  $8.95
- Everything
  Everything - except hot peppers, pineapples and chicken.
  $10.93
- Chuck's Veggie Supreme
  Green and red bell peppers, mushrooms, onions, banana peppers, tomatoes and green olives.
  $8.95
- Dessert Pizza
  Pagliai's special dessert topping with chocolate and crumb topping.
  $10.16
- Meat Lover's Special
  Sausage, beef, ham, pepperoni and bacon.
  $8.95
Wraps
Our exciting and tasty wraps are honey wheat and include a dinner salad.
- Laker Chicken Wrap
  Boldly seasoned chicken breast, crisp lettuce, ripe green olives, green peppers, fresh tomatoes, banana peppers, shredded Cheddar and Monterey jack cheese with Italian dressing.
  $14.35
- Racer Chicken Wrap
  Ham, chicken breast, fresh tomatoes, crisp lettuce, onions green ripe olives, shredded Cheddar and Monterey jack cheese with our honey mustard dressing.
  $14.35
- Tiger Wrap
  Fresh bacon, chicken breast, crisp lettuce, onions, shredded Cheddar and Monterey jack cheese with our famous ranch dressing.
  $14.35
Sandwiches
Served with potato chips.
- 6" Nanette's Hot Ham & Bacon
  Served with our ranch dressing, tomato tidbits and mozzarella on a hoagie bun.
  $9.20
- 12" Nanette's Hot Ham & Bacon
  Served with our ranch dressing, tomato tidbits and mozzarella on a hoagie bun.
  $16.38
- 6" Poorboy
  Ham, cotto salami and mozzarella served hot on a hoagie bun, garnished with lettuce and seasoned with out spicy pizza sauce and honey French dressing.
  $10.40
- 12" Poorboy
  Ham, cotto salami and mozzarella served hot on a hoagie bun, garnished with lettuce and seasoned with our spicy pizza sauce and honey French dressing.
  $16.38
- Grilled Cheese
  Served on fresh toasted bread.
  $6.42
- 6" Ham & Cheese
  Served hot on a hoagie bun, garnished with lettuce and seasoned with our spicy pizza sauce and honey French dressing.
  $10.40
- 12" Ham & Cheese
  Served hot on a hoagie bun, garnished with lettuce and seasoned with our spicy pizza sauce and honey French dressing.
  $16.38
- 6" Meatball
  With mozzarella and our famous meat spaghetti.
  $10.40
- 12" Meatball
  With mozzarella and our famous meat spaghetti.
  $16.38
- Reuben (Med)
  Corned beef, swiss cheese and kraut served hot on rye.
  $10.40
- Reuben (Lg)
  Corned beef, swiss cheese and kraut served hot on rye.
  $16.38
Beverages
- Coke Classic
  The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
  $2.76
- Diet Coke
  A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
  $2.76
- Fanta Orange
  Change up your routine with the bright, bubbly, fruity orange flavor.
  $2.76
- Hi-C Lemonade
  Explosive fruit flavors and 100% of the vitamin C your body needs.
  $2.76
- Dr Pepper
  Unique blend of 23 flavors, carbonated soft drink.
  $2.76
- Mountain Dew
  Exhilarate and quench your thirst with a one of a kind taste.
  $2.76
- Arabica Gold Coffee
  A premium brew made from 100% Arabica beans, known for their smooth and rich flavor profile.
  $1.31
- 2% Milk (8 Oz Carton)
  No reffils.
  $1.14
- Sprite
  The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
  $2.76
- Barq's Root Beer
  A sweet, spiced favorite that’s stood the test of time.
  $2.76
- House Recipe Iced Tea
  A refreshing blend of tea, brewed in-house following our unique recipe, and typically served over ice.
  $2.39
- Diet Dr Pepper
  Crisp, Sugar-Free Dr. Pepper with a Unique Blend of 23 Flavors
  $2.76
- Pepsi Cola
  The bold, refreshing, robust cola
  $2.76
- Diet Mountain Dew
  Exhilarate and quench your thirst with a one of a kind taste.
  $2.76
Side Dishes
- Chips & Ranch Dressing
  Crispy chips paired with our house-made ranch dressing, typically served as a light accompaniment.
  $5.28
- 4 Oz Cup of Ranch Dressing
  $0.92
- 16 Oz Lays Potato Chips
  A 16 oz serving of classic Lay's potato chips, thinly sliced and crisped to a golden perfection.
  $5.12
- Bread Sticks
  Breadsticks made from fresh dough, typically brushed with garlic butter and sprinkled with Parmesan cheese.
  $4.79
- Cheese Bread
  Freshly baked bread infused with garlic butter, generously topped with a blend of melted cheeses and a hint of herbs.
  $9.74
- Cheese Sticks
  Golden-baked breadsticks topped with melted mozzarella cheese, served in eight pieces.
  $9.74
- Small Bag of Potato Chips
  A small bag of classic Italian-style potato chips, lightly seasoned to complement any dish.
  $1.26
- Crisp Dill Pickles
  Crisp dill pickles are typically served as a tangy and crunchy accompaniment, often including a light batter and herbs for enhanced flavor.
  $1.64
- Garlic Bread
  Crisp, buttery toasted bread infused with aromatic garlic and herbs.
  $2.23
- Pepperoncini Peppers
  Pepperoncini peppers, typically served as a tangy and mildly spicy accompaniment, dressed with olive oil.
  $1.19
- Chili
  Italian-style chili, available in small (12 oz), medium (16 oz), and large (20 oz) sizes.
  $3.90
- Chili with Grilled Cheese
  Spicy Italian chili paired with melted cheese on grilled bread. Sizes available: small 12 oz, medium 16 oz, large 20 oz.
  $6.10
Kid's Menu
- Spaghetti Kids
  Served with garlic bread.
  $6.60
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich
  Served with potato chips.
  $2.51
- Lasagna Kids
  Served with garlic bread.
  $6.06
- Soft Drinks
  12 oz.
  $1.31
- Chicken Tenders
  Served with potato chips.
  $1.99