Over The Moon Creamery Menu

4.4

(375+ Reviews)

$$Ice cream shop, Bakery, Frozen yogurt shop

Customer Favorites Cookies Beverages Frozen Treats Hand Packed Pints Extra Toppings

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- 6 cookies
  $12.00
- Milkshake
  $10.00
- Frozen ice cream sandwiches
  1 scoop of ice cream sandwiched between 2 FROZEN cookies. please note cookies will be delivered frozen, not soft.
  $8.00
- Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie
  $2.75
- Frozen Cookie Cups
  1 scoop in a FROZEN Over The Moon Cookie Cup
  $7.00
- Cookies & Cream Pint
  Vanilla ice cream with Oreo pieces
  $10.00
- Snickerdoodle Cookie
  $2.75
- 12 Cookies
  $24.00
- Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie
  $2.75
- 2 Cookies & Milk
  2 cookies with 16 oz Milk
  $6.50
Cookies
- Cookies & Cream Cookie
  $2.75
- Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie
  $2.75
- Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
  $2.75
- Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie
  $2.75
- 6 cookies
  $12.00
- 12 Cookies
  $24.00
- 2 Cookies
  Two cookies. Options: Sea Salt Chocolate Chip, Cookies & Cream, Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin.
  $5.00
- 2 Cookies & Milk
  2 cookies with 16 oz Milk
  $6.50
- Snickerdoodle Cookie
  $2.75
Beverages
- Craft Root Beer
  12 oz glass bottle
  $3.00
- Spring Still Water
  16 oz plastic bottle
  $2.00
- Mexican Coke
  12 oz glass bottle
  $3.75
- Diet Coke
  20 oz plastic bottle.
  $3.00
- Cucumber Soda
  Lightly carbonated beverage typically featuring fresh cucumber essence.
  $3.00
- Orange Crush
  A refreshing drink typically featuring the vibrant, tangy flavors of orange soda.
  $3.00
- Strawberry Crush
  Effervescent strawberry soda with a sweet, fruity flavor and vibrant red hue.
  $3.00
- Grape Crush
  Effervescent grape-flavored soda with a sweet and fruity taste.
  $3.00
- Sparkling Water
  Effervescent sparkling water with a crisp, clean taste, perfect for a refreshing beverage option.
  $3.00
- Whole Milk
  16 oz glass of whole milk
  $2.50
Frozen Treats
- Float
  Choose your ice cream and soda
  $8.00
- Frozen Cookie Cups
  1 scoop in a FROZEN Over The Moon Cookie Cup
  $7.00
- Frozen ice cream sandwiches
  1 scoop of ice cream sandwiched between 2 FROZEN cookies. please note cookies will be delivered frozen, not soft.
  $8.00
- Milkshake
  $10.00
Hand Packed Pints
- Pineapple Sorbet (dairy free)
  Rotating flavors; dairy free
  $10.00
- Cookies & Cream Pint
  Vanilla ice cream with Oreo pieces
  $10.00
- Mint Chip Pint
  Mint ice cream with chocolate chips
  $10.00
- Mint Oreo Pint
  Mint ice cream with Oreo pieces
  $11.50
- Vanilla Bean Pint
  $10.00
- Chocolate Pint
  $10.00
- Rocky Road Pint
  Chocolate ice cream with marshmallows and almonds
  $10.00
- Strawberry Pint
  $10.00
- Espresso Oreo Pint
  Espresso ice cream with Oreo pieces
  $10.00
- Caramel Cookie Dough Pint
  Caramel ice cream with cookie dough pieces
  $10.00
- Funfetti Pint
  Cake batter ice cream with rainbow sprinkles
  $10.00
- Salted Butterscotch Pint
  Butterscotch ice cream with a dash of salt
  $10.00
- Honey Lavender Pint
  Honey ice cream with lavender buds
  $10.00
- Nutella Banana Pint
  $10.00
- Cookie Monster Pint
  Vanilla ice cream with assorted baked cookie pieces
  $11.50
- Lemon Cookie Pint
  Vanilla ice cream with cookie pieces
  $11.50
- Snickerdoodle Pint
  Cinnamon ice cream
  $10.00
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Pint
  $10.00
- Drumstick Pint
  Vanilla ice cream with peanuts, waffle cone pieces, and chocolate
  $10.00
- Oreo Swirl Pint
  Oreo ice cream with cream filling swirl
  $11.50
- Stracciatella Pint
  Vanilla ice cream with chocolate chips
  $10.00
- Earl Grey Pint
  $11.50
- Ginger Pint
  Ground ginger
  $11.50
- Peanut Butter & Jelly Pint
  $10.00
- Raspberry Sorbet (Dairy Free)
  Rotating flavors; dairy free
  $10.00
- Butterfinger
  Vanilla ice cream with Butterfinger Pieces
  $11.50
- Cherry Mascarpone
  Creamy mascarpone ice cream typically blended with sweet cherries.
  $11.50
- Peach Crumble
  Peach ice cream with vanilla sandwich cookie pieces
  $11.50
- Cinnamon Kiwi
  Cinnamon kiwi pint: Cinnamon-infused ice cream typically includes fresh kiwi pieces.
  $11.50
Extra Toppings
- Almond Topping
  1 oz
  $1.00
- Chocolate Sprinkles Topping
  1 oz
  $1.00
- Cookie Pieces Topping
  3.25 oz
  $1.00
- Fruity Pebble Topping
  2 oz
  $1.00
- Gummy Bear Topping
  2 oz
  $1.00
- Marshmallow Topping
  3.25 oz
  $1.00
- Mini Chocolate Chips Topping
  1 oz
  $1.00
- Mini M&M Topping
  1 oz
  $1.00
- Oreo Pieces Topping
  1 oz
  $1.00
- Peanut Topping
  1 oz
  $1.00
- Rainbow Nonpareils Topping
  1 oz
  $1.00
- Rainbow Sprinkles Topping
  1 oz
  $1.00
- Shredded Coconut Topping
  1 oz
  $1.00
- Waffle Cone Pieces Topping
  3.25 oz
  $1.00
- Hot Fudge
  Rich and smooth, our hot fudge typically includes a blend of chocolate, cream, and sugar, making it an ideal topping for any dessert.
  $1.50