Search
Otto's Market Menu
4.5
(100+ Reviews)
Prepared - Lunch Sandwich
- Broccoli ReubenBroccoli with Caraway Seeds, Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese and Thousand Island Dressing served on grilled Rye Bread$11.00
- Lox Bagel SpecialToasted Bread Alone Bagel, Lox, Capers, Red Onion, Tomato, and Cream Cheese$14.00
- Tuna MeltTuna salad, Cheddar Cheese, Choice of Bread, Grilled to Perfection$11.00
- Cheese SandwichYour choice of bread and cheese$6.00
- Classic BLTBacon, lettuce, tomato, and Plane Meadow basil mayo on toasted bread$10.00
- DIY SandwichMain and Cheese on your choice of Bread with Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo$11.00
- QuesadillaA flour tortilla filled with mozzarella and cheddar. Add chicken and/or avocado for extra yum!$7.00
- Roast Beef SpecialRoast Beef, Provolone Cheese, Horseradish Mayo, Pickled Onions and Parsley on a Formisano roll$13.00
- Italian SandwichHam, Salami, Pepperoni, Mortadella, Provolone, Marinated Peppers, Tomato, Lettuce, Mayo, Oil & Vinegar$15.00
- Grilled CheeseToasty, gooey grilled cheese sandwich.$7.00
- Turkey Club$14.00
- Turkey SpecialTurkey, bacon, pepper jack cheese and chipotle mayo on a ciabatta$14.50
- Grab N' GoDaily Grab N' Go option*pre-made, no customization*$10.00
- House Smoked Pulled PorkHouse Smoked Pulled Pork, BBQ Sauce, Chipotle Lime Crema, Tangy Slaw, on a Seeded Bun$11.00
- Diego SpecialBacon, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo on a plain toasted Bread Alone bagel*In support of Diego's Fight Against Leukemia we will be donating $2 from every sandwich sold. Additional donations can be given in store or https://gofund.me/7cc93c81Thank you for any support towards this amazing 6 year old and his family$11.00
- Chicken Cutlet SandwichFried chicken cutlet on a Formisano roll with lettuce, onion, and mayo.$12.00
Prepared - Deli
- Small SoupHomemade soup of the day. 12oz$5.00
- Large SoupHomemade soup of the day. 16oz$6.50
- House smoked Turkey Chili with Tortilla chipsSmall$6.00Large$7.00
- House Made Macaroni SaladCelery, Onion, Elbow Pasta, Mayo, Vinegar, Spicy MustardQuarter Pound$2.15Half Pound$4.25Per Pound$8.49
- House Made Potato SaladPotatoes, Mayo, Garlic Powder, Onion Powder, Celery Seed, Onion, Celery, Bell PeppersQuarter Pound$1.75Half Pound$3.50Per Pound$6.99
- Caesar SaladFresh Romaine, Home Made Caesar Dressing, Pecorino, and House Made Croutons$10.00
- Tuna SaladTuna, Celery, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Dill, LemonQuarter Pound$4.50Half Pound$8.99Pound$17.99
- French FriesSo crispy, so delicious!$4.50
- House Made Egg SaladHard-boiled Eggs, Dill, Kewpie Mayo, Rice VinegarQuarter Pound$3.25Half Pound$6.50Per Pound$12.99
Prepared - Cafe
- Cold Brew CoffeeMade from our very own JB Peel roasted Germantown Blend coffee beans16oz$4.00
- Tea8oz, 12oz, 16ozHarney & Sons:Cinnamon, Chai, Egyptian Chamomile, English Breakfast, Peppermint, Japanese Sencha, Tropical Green, Earl Grey SupremePG TipsTea Drops$2.00
- Small Drip CoffeeMade from our very own JB Peel roasted Germantown Blend coffee beans8oz$1.39
- Large Drip CoffeeMade from our very own JB Peel roasted Germantown Blend coffee beans16oz$2.78
- Medium Drip CoffeeMade from our very own JB Peel roasted Germantown Blend coffee beans12oz$2.08
- Hot Cider12 oz cider steamed with a stick of cinnamon$5.25
Prepared - Lunch Sandwich
- Turkey SpecialTurkey, bacon, pepper jack cheese and chipotle mayo on a ciabatta$14.50
- Italian SandwichHam, Salami, Pepperoni, Mortadella, Provolone, Marinated Peppers, Tomato, Lettuce, Mayo, Oil & Vinegar$15.00
- Grilled CheeseToasty, gooey grilled cheese sandwich.$7.00
- Turkey Club$14.00
- DIY SandwichMain and Cheese on your choice of Bread with Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo$11.00
- Meatball ParmHouse Made Meatballs with Marinara, Mozzarella, and Pesto on a toasted Hard Roll.$14.00
- QuesadillaA flour tortilla filled with mozzarella and cheddar. Add chicken and/or avocado for extra yum!$7.00
- Reuben SpecialPremium Sliced Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese and Thousand Island Dressing served on grilled Rye Bread$15.00
- Roast Beef SpecialRoast Beef, Provolone Cheese, Horseradish Mayo, Pickled Onions and Parsley on a Formisano roll$13.00
- Broccoli ReubenBroccoli with Caraway Seeds, Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese and Thousand Island Dressing served on grilled Rye Bread$11.00
- Cheese SandwichYour choice of bread and cheese$6.00
- Buffalo Cauliflower SandwichCauliflower with buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, and blue cheese on a grilled Bread Alone ciabatta.$10.00
- Caprese SandwichLioni Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers, Pesto, Balsamic, Tomato Jam, on Ciabatta*veg$13.00
- Tuna MeltTuna salad, Cheddar Cheese, Choice of Bread, Grilled to Perfection$11.00
- Chicken Cutlet SandwichFried chicken cutlet on a Formisano roll with lettuce, onion, and mayo.$12.00
- Classic BLTBacon, lettuce, tomato, and Plane Meadow basil mayo on toasted bread$10.00
- Otto's Hot DogSplit-griddled natural casing hot dog served on butter-toasted bun with chopped white onion, sweet relish and yellow mustard.$6.00
- Diego SpecialBacon, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo on a plain toasted Bread Alone bagel*In support of Diego's Fight Against Leukemia we will be donating $2 from every sandwich sold. Additional donations can be given in store or https://gofund.me/7cc93c81Thank you for any support towards this amazing 6 year old and his family$11.00
Prepared - Bakery
- Nancy's MuffinBaked fresh daily in-houseBlackberry Walnut Streusel$3.50Cinnamon Coffee Cake$3.50
- Nancy's CookieBaked fresh daily in-houseChocolate Chip$3.00Peanut Butter$3.00Oatmeal Raisin$3.00Pecan Shortbread$3.00Cranberry Molasses Pecan$3.00
- Nancy's Raspberry Thumbprint CookieBaked fresh daily in-house$3.50
- BagelBread Alone Bagel. Plain or EverythingPlain$2.00Everything$2.00
- Nancy's SconeBaked fresh daily in-housePepper Jack$3.50Chocolate Almond$3.50
Meat
- Northwind Small Individual HamNorthwind Farm Mini Ham w/ Brown Sugar Glaze $21/lb3-4lb rangePlease select how many pounds you would prefer. Most hams will be in the 3-4lb range.$21.00
Home Goods
- A La Maison de Provence Hand & Body Bar Soap Milk Bars (100 g)$8.99
Grocery - Candy
- Tony's Chocolonely Milk Chocolate6.35oz$6.39
- Tony's Chocolonely 70% Dark Chocolate6.35oz$6.39
- Tony's Chocolonely Milk Chocolate Caramel Sea Salt6.35oz$6.39
- Tony's Chocolonely Dark Chocolate Almond$6.39
Grocery - Cookies
- Tate's Gingersnap$7.69
Grocery - Baking Needs
- FD Baking Powder 12oz$4.99
Grocery - Coffee/Tea/Cocoa
- JB Peel Germantown Blend$15.99
- JB Peel Decaf Germantown Blend$16.99
- JB Peel Tivoli Bread Co Blend$15.99
- JB Peel Colombian Supremo$15.99
- JB Peel French Roast$15.99
- JB Peel Organic Flying Pig$15.99
- JB Peel Espresso Roast$14.99
Grocery - Pasta/Sauces/Sides
- Basil Pesto alla Genovese$5.29
- Better Than Gravy Roasted Turkey Gravy$6.59
- Tomato Sauce with Cheese & Vodka Sauce$11.99
Grocery - Nut Butters/Jams/Honey
- Ray Tousey Raw Honey 16 Oz16 oz$11.00
- Ray Tousey Raw Honey 12 Oz BEAR$10.00
- Ray Tousey Honey 2#$20.00
Grocery - Dessert
- Bobos Maple Pecan$3.99
Grocery - International
- Frontier Natural Products Coop - Star Anise Hand Select$4.99
- Annie Chun's Pad Thai Rice Noodles, Non GMO, Vegan, Gluten Free$4.99
Self-Care
- Toothbrush Adult Med$4.79
Grocery - Snacks/Chips
- Kettle Brand Salt & Vinegar Chips 1.5oz1.5oz single serving bag$1.99
- Kettle Brand Sea Salt Chips 1.5oz1.5oz single serving bag$1.99
- Kettle Brand BBQ Chips 1.5oz1.5oz single serving bag$1.99
- Food Should Taste Good Multigrain Tortilla Chips5.5oz$5.49
- Kettle Brand Cheddar Chips 1.51.5oz single serving bag$1.89
- Quinn Pretzel Sticks Classic Sea Salt5.6oz$5.29
- Good Crisp Aged White Cheddar5.6oz$4.99
- Kettle Brand BBQ Chips 5oz5oz bag$5.49
- Kettle Brand Salt & Vinegar Chips 5oz5oz bag$5.49
- Quinn Whole Grain Sea Salt Pretzel Twists5.6oz$5.49
- Quinn Peanut Butter Pretzel Nuggets7oz$7.19
- Kettle Brand Sea Salt Chips 5oz5oz bag$5.49
- Good Crisp Original5.6oz$4.99
- North Fork Sour Cream & Onion Chips$1.99
- North Fork Salt & Vinegar Chips 2oz$1.99
- Quinn Maple Almond Butter Pretzel Nuggets5oz$7.19
- Good Crisp Salt + Vinegar5.6oz$5.29
- Good Crisp Sour Cream + Onion5.6oz$4.99
Beverages - Juice/Water
- Natalie's Orange Juice 16 Oz16oz$4.25
- Spring Saratoga Water$1.79
- Spindrift Sparkling Water Grapefruit Single12fz$1.99
- Saratoga Sparkling Water$1.79
- San Pellegrino Sparking Water 25.3oz$2.59
- Spindrift Tea And Lemon Sparkling Water Single12fz$1.99
- Spindrift Raspberry Lime Single12fz$1.99
- Natalie's Strawberry Lemonade 16oz$4.25
- Red Jacket 12oz Apple Cider$3.89
- Red Jacket Strawberry Apple Juice$3.89
- Natalie's Natural Lemonade 16 Oz$4.25
Beverages - Soda
- Mexican Coca-Cola$2.25
- La Croix CoconutSingle 12fz$1.79
- Mexican Sprite$2.25
- Diet Coke Cans12oz$2.00
- Coca-Cola12fz$2.00
- GuS Cola12fz$2.00
- GuS Blackberry12fz$2.00
Beverages - Coffee/Tea
- Harney + Sons Unsweetened Black16oz$2.29
- Harney & Son Unsweetened Green Tea$2.29
- Stumptown Original Cold Brew10.5fz$5.19
- Harney & Sons Butterfly Flower Lemonade16oz$2.29
- Harney & Sons Organic Black$2.29
Dairy - Eggs
- TITUSVILLE FARM EGGS$8.50
Grocery - Unsliced Breads
- Catskill Bread Co. FocacciaAvailable Thursday thru Sunday$6.00
- Sparrowbush TableIngredients: organic stone milled wheat flour, water, sea saltDelivered on Friday afternoon$11.00
- Sparrowbush SesameIngredients: organic stone milled wheat flour, organic sesame seeds, water, sea saltDelivered on Friday afternoon$11.00
- Sparrowbush SpeltIngredients: organic stone milled spelt flour, water, sea saltDelivered on Friday afternoon$10.00
- Sparrowbush Raisin OatIngredients: organic stone milled spelt flour, organic rolled oats, organic raisins, water, sea saltDelivered on Friday afternoon$10.00
- Sparrowbush CompanionIngredients: organic stone ground wheat flour, organic stone ground einkorn flour, water, sea salt, yeastDelivered on Friday afternoon$6.00
- Catskill Bread Co. EarlWholegrain, Multigrain with Sesame Seeds Available Thursday thru Sunday$8.00
- Catskill Bread Co EmpireSourdough with Molasses, Apple Cider Vinegar (Salt on Top) Available Thursday thru Sunday$8.00
- Catskill Bread Co SwedeDark Rye with Salt and Caraway Available Thursday thru Sunday$8.00
- Catskill Bread Co. BaguetteAvailable Thursday thru Sunday$5.00
Seasonal
- Plainville Farm Turkey (Raw)14-18 lbFamily farm raised, all-natural vegetarian diet.Antibiotic, hormone, GMO, and steroid free~ $5.99/lb ~ There is a non-refundable $50 deposit for all Plainville birds; final pricing will be based on actual weight and will be adjusted and charged at time of pick upPlease select your preferred weight but note that actual weights may vary.12lb $71.88$50.0013lb $77.87$50.0014lb $83.86$50.0015lbs $89.85$50.0016lbs $95.84$50.0017lbs $101.83$50.0018lbs $107.82$50.00
Menu Photos
Menu Photos
Loading...
