Checkle
Search
For Businesses
O'Toole's Way
Menu
O'Toole's Way Menu
$
·
Irish
,
American
,
Bar & grill
518 W 30th St, New York, NY 10001
Order Online
Small Plates
Devils On Horseback Plate
Goat cheese, port reduction.
$12.00
House Chips Plate
Irish cheddar, onion dip.
$14.00
Irish Cheese Board Plate
Irish cheddar, cashel blue, gubbeen crackers, quince, fig, pear.
$24.00
House Made Soda Bread
whipped marmite butter
$12.00
Red Pepper Hummus
market vegetable crudités
$16.00
Espresso Rubbed Chicken Wings
choice of buffalo or bourbon bbq, blue cheese dressing, crudités
$15.00
Irish Nachos
house chips, cheese sauce, bacon, pickled fresnos chili pepper, sour cream, scallions
$15.00
Sausage Roll
hand rolled spiced Irish Sausage, puff pastry, hp sauce
$16.00
Soups & Salads
Traditional Cobb Salad
Blue cheese, egg, avocado, bacon market greens, red wine vinaigrette.
$18.00
Kale Caesar Salad
Parmesan, croutons, charred lime, Caesar dressing.
$19.00
Pub Salad
Seasonal vegetable, house dressing.
$16.00
The High Line Salad
Quinoa, hummus, broccoli, dried cranberry, carrot, toasted almonds, maple dressing.
$18.00
Potato Leek Soup
Bar Pies
Prosciutto
Goat cheese, arugula, hot honey.
$22.00
Margherita
Tomato, mozzarella, basil.
$18.00
Garden Squash
mozzarella, pumpkin seed pesto, parmesan
$20.00
Sandwiches & Burgers
O'Toole's Burger
American, caramalized onions, burger sauce, b+b pickles, brioche bun.
$25.00
Chicken Sandwich
Pickled fresno, hot honey slaw, remoulade, brioche bun.
$22.00
Bagel & Lox
everything or plain bagel, cream cheese, capers, cucumber, pickled red onion
$22.00
"Dangerous Dave's" Dublin Dip
shaved prime rib, irish cheddar, caramelized onions, horseradish, served on ciabatta, "with its own gravy"
$32.00
Ham & Cheese Toasties
House cured & carved ham, coleslaw, irish cheddar, toasted brioche.
$23.00
Brunch Mains
2 Eggs Any Style
2 eggs any style, home fries, toasted sourdough, bacon
$18.00
Eggs Blackstone
poached eggs, hollandaise, bacon, grilled tomato, toasted sourdough
$14.00
Chicken + Waffles
berry butter, hot honey
$22.00
The "Sand Hog Breakfast"
espresso rubbed grilled skirt steak, breakfast potatoes, grilled tomato, fried eggs, spicy steak sauce
$32.00
Avocado Toast
smashed avocado, grilled sourdough, charred lime
$14.00
Brioche French Toast
$18.00
Roasted Mushroom Toast
Marsala, whipped goat cheese, sourdough
$17.00
Large Plates
Fillet Of Salmon Plate
Salsa rosa, arugula salad, charred lime.
$30.00
Proper Fish And Chips Plate
Guinness battered cod, crushed peas, tartar, salt and vinager.
$30.00
Mussels And Fries Plate
Irish cider, garlic, cream, lemon, parsley.
$28.00
Butternut Squash Ravioli
burnt butter, crispy sage, toasted hazelnuts
$24.00
Berkshire Pork Chop Plate
charred carrots, carrot top chimichurri, apple cider, bourbon reduction
$32.00
Steak Frites
14oz Espresso Rub Prime NY Strip, truffle butter, watercress, roasted garlic, fries
$48.00
Brick Chicken
buttermilk caesar slaw, charred lemon, fries
$28.00
Charred Cauliflower Steak
cauliflower and quinoa cous cous, spinach & cherry tomato, nigella seeds
$26.00
Grilled Ahi Tuna
Roasted tomato, Black olive dressing
$30.00
Sides
Side Fries
$10.00
Fries With Parmesan & Truffle Oil
$12.00
Grilled Asparagus
$15.00
Colcannon
Irish mashed potatoes.
$10.00
Dirty Fries Plate
Short rib gravy, Irish cheddar, scallions.
$16.00
Zucchini
lemon, parmeson
$10.00
Breakfast Potatoes
peppers, salt, pepper
$9.00
Side Bacon
$9.00
Breakfast Sausage
chicken, apple, maple
$9.00
Black Pudding
Blood Sausage from Ireland
$9.00
Baked Beans
$8.00
Toasted Bagel
Cream cheese or butter
$8.00
Puddings (Irish Dessert)
Dangerous Dave's Key Lime Pie
toasted coconut, chantilly cream
$10.00
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet
Vanilla ice cream, Jamason whiskey salted caramel
$13.00
Menu Gallery
Menu Gallery
Menus may not be up to date.
Suggest Edit
Know a great happy hour or special for this location?
Add Happy Hour
© 2025 Checkle, Inc
·
Privacy
·
Terms